User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Thoughts on Borts new post about XP changes in the announcements forum.
Page:
 
Unconquered
offline
Link
 
I know you're responding to a million requests but I have two questions Bort that unlike most will ask in a respectful way.

1) Is this being implemented due to the demand of stopping team gutting?

2) Parity is one thing. Do you think it's a good idea though to curb recruiting efforts of top teams in leagues because they are hardcore GLB players? Why should that 1-15 (wins) Owners be given parity when he spends 30 mins a week recruiting?
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 01:19:41
 
crawlins
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CroBot
Seriously, there goes everybody's recruiting efforts. There's such a thing as too much parity and this is it. Just because a player is in BBB and is level 19 DOES NOT mean that they're cheating, or that they're there to pad their stats. What's the fun in the game when all your recruiting work goes for naught and Bort is forcing everybody to be equal and boring?


OR...you could play against competitive competition. There is a reason they don't let High Schoolers play dodge ball with 1st graders...or are you saying thats fair too? Darn gym teachers forcing everyone to be equal!
 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Meryk
Is this going to be based off of starter levels, or all players on the team, to come up with the median?


Uh-oh, now I can see it: tons of high-level teams loading up on level 1's to skew the median.
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 01:18:56
 
Dudeamis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by seven7
i like the new rule and hope more fair rules for players and owners alike are put into the game soon.


thats right because having good teams is just a terrible idea.
 
Houndster
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MD
Originally posted by Houndster

Originally posted by MD


So if this is based on that average league player level list, our entire league will be penalized almost.


That doesn't make any sense. If your entire league is good your average will reflect your players.


Yes it does. Our league has an average of like 14.xx. But theres a ton of players around Level 17 and up. Do all the players higher than level 14 get penalized?


If there is a ton of players level 17 and up and the average is 14 then there would have to be an equal of number of players level 11 and below.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MD
Originally posted by Houndster

Originally posted by MD


So if this is based on that average league player level list, our entire league will be penalized almost.


That doesn't make any sense. If your entire league is good your average will reflect your players.


Yes it does. Our league has an average of like 14.xx. But theres a ton of players around Level 17 and up. Do all the players higher than level 14 get penalized?


I never said it was based on average level. It will be based on median level, which is quite a bit different. I also never said what the "fudge factor" would be. I said that if you are playing "within the spirit of the game" you will see zero to little effect on your player. Take that at its word.

This is not an update to punish teams who recruit well. We are not adding this willy-nilly with no thought to players who stick with teams for the long haul. Like I said, the formula will not be given, but all of these things will be taken into account.
 
Dudeamis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by crawlins
Originally posted by CroBot

Seriously, there goes everybody's recruiting efforts. There's such a thing as too much parity and this is it. Just because a player is in BBB and is level 19 DOES NOT mean that they're cheating, or that they're there to pad their stats. What's the fun in the game when all your recruiting work goes for naught and Bort is forcing everybody to be equal and boring?


OR...you could play against competitive competition. There is a reason they don't let High Schoolers play dodge ball with 1st graders...or are you saying thats fair too? Darn gym teachers forcing everyone to be equal!


So I shouldn't build the best team possible? I should just aim for middle of the road? What NFL team does that? What College team does that?
 
chad13
offline
Link
 
I feel sorry for teams that get promoted into Pro leagues. Even if a AAA team has Pro league level talent, their higher level players are gonna lose out on experience and when they get promoted, their talent will no longer be pro league caliber since their exp (which should have been the same as pro league) gets nerfed and makes the talent gap even larger.
 
vzone
offline
Link
 
This is a terrible rule!

As a new team I did not have the opportunity to choose what level team I would get. Our team's goal is to get to the pro league. Last time I checked the way to get better was to recruit better players. Now, I am being told that teams and players are being punished for setting high goals. I'm getting really sick of all these "rules" that keep getting implemented without any thought or any notice.
 
keedon
offline
Link
 
All i know is that I wish there was a warning before offseason started
 
seven7
offline
Link
 
stand firm bort , you are doing the right thing for fairness to the game .
 
Unconquered
offline
Link
 
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 01:21:59
 
keedon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vzone
This is a terrible rule!

As a new team I did not have the opportunity to choose what level team I would get. Our team's goal is to get to the pro league. Last time I checked the way to get better was to recruit better players. Now, I am being told that teams and players are being punished for setting high goals. I'm getting really sick of all these "rules" that keep getting implemented without any thought or any notice.


actually that does kinda suck if you just bought a team. then youre forced to have a shitty team compared to the rest of GLB.
 
MrMoose
offline
Link
 
I'm not going to get upset about this until I see just how big of a spread this makes. I know that, in Oceania AA #1 for example, we've had quite a few gutted teams this offseason, and our average level is probably down to about 11.5. problem is, 6 or 7 of the teams at the top sit around an average of 16, with most of them having a few 17s and maybe an 18.

I'm going to wait and see if those 16-18 players are punished, if it is big or not before getting upset. Since we've had most of these guys grow with the team from Season 2 on (and had to get them to compete with the top teams in the league) they are going to be higher level. So, provided the penalty takes leagues like Oceania AA #1 into account, I'll be ok with it.

Thankfully, Bort is using the median level and not the average level, which will be a benefit to leagues like Oceania AA #1. We won't have to worry about a few low level teams dragging us down or anything like that.
 
FBGProfessor
offline
Link
 
This new rule is a very positive step. I applaud Bort and DD on this one.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.