As the owner of a team almost entirely populated by level 35 players that boosted to 38 at the start of this season playing in an uncapped league, I completely concur that at this level, and those below it as well, teams rarely seem to pass the ball all that well.
I've tried a pretty good amount of experimenting with plays this season and the WR depth chart in seasons past with very little success. Our WRs have always been a joke, they've been around for 8 months doing practically nothing outside of inflating stats vs gutted teams. Even taking into account that we are one now of the lower level teams in our conference, the passing game is incredibly difficult to execute. Our line is sometimes porous, but even when we don't allow hurries and sacks, the passing game is still miserable. Admittedly we were built to be a run-first team from day 1 so our passing numbers would be kind of low no matter what, but the balance is WAY outside what I like to see. We're completely forced to run the ball as much as possible if we want to have anything resembling a consistent offense. If we were in a 38 cap instead we might be slightly less 1-dimensional, but not much. Here's what I'm working with, am I just completely screwing up the play calling/depth chart or are the builds in need? Or is the OP right and passing just insanely hard to pass until higher levels unless you have nearly perfect players and play selection.
The WRs have 95-102 speed and 74-80 agility, 51-58 catching, 46-48 vision, 49-54 carrying, 27-38 jumping. The stats on some of them could be a little bit higher if they weren't wearing slightly lower level AEQ to get SA bonuses.Two of them are 6'4", the others are 6'3" and 6'2"
One has 102 speed, 74 agility, 58 catching, 54 carrying, 48 vision, 37 jumping, and 20 strength with 6 in First Step and 3 in Quick Cut.
Another has 95 speed, 80 agility, 56 catching, 54 carrying, 48 vision, 38 jumping, 23 strength, 3 First Step, 2 Quick Cut, and 4 points (all from equipment) in Spin, I plan on getting carrying and strength up on him and making him a YAC threat.
The other 2 aren't my builds so I won't completely give them away, but they fall pretty much in the middle between those two players above with less carrying, jumping and strength but more stamina and confidence. One of them has a lot of route running and is consistently the fastest receiver. The other has his SAs spread out a little more on the possession tree.
The TE has 100 speed and 71 agility, 54 catching, 45 carrying, 39 vision, 38 strength with 6 ranks of route running and 3 in Stiff Arm from some AEQ. I am trying to eventually get him up to 8 Stiff Arm with equipment if I can find another decent piece, I assume Stiff arm isn't a bad skill to have if you constantly come to a dead stop catching the ball, could be hard to power through or lower the shoulder with no momentum.
The FB is not mine and I'd rather not talk about him, not sure just how good his build is so far, his points might be a little too spread out at this level. He's never targeted by the QB anyway (QB set to normal dump-offs, doesn't favor long) even when no one is covering him.
QB has 98 Throwing (was 100, but traded out +5 normal equipment for AEQ with only a +4 bonus), 70 vision, 66 strength (will be 68+ after next game), 53 confidence, 37 agility, 30 speed. 4 Pocket Presence, 7 Tight Spiral, 7 Field General +6% Pass Quality. The idea was Field General AEQ (and plenty of motivational speaker on other players on the sideline) would help with low confidence/stamina on our receivers. I'm not really sure that's working out too well. If I sold the Field General equipment, I'd have 102 Throwing, +12% Pass Quality, 7 Tight Spiral and 4 Field General with 13 Bonus tokens in the bank. I've played with the sliders and seen little impact.
Coincidentally, I am also scrimmaging the OP's team tomorrow, so I guess I just helped him do a little scouting.