User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > XP bonus for playing at or above your level
Page:
 
Icespyder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Icespyder

Since Africa Pro was released 2 seasons after the first leagues, their "Pros" would be no better then an America BBB team.


That's what's happening anyway. The average level over there right now is around 10.


So why name it Pro and have them earn more money then a USA BBB team?
 
BartRock
offline
Link
 
I'm on your side, here. But you have to look at this particular idea. It would probably be a pretty decent sized range of players who would get normal points. If the average level in the league was 10, figure levels 6-14 or thereabouts would receive neither a bonus nor a penalty. When you consider all the other caps and signing restrictions and whatever, this is a pretty harmless, yet effective, idea.

It also has actual relevance to football. If you take your college player and play him in junior high school, he's going to rack up great stats, but he won't learn a damned thing, so he gains no experience. Conversely, let a junior high kid play in college and, despite the massive injuries that would surely result, he'd probably gain a ton of experience.

Originally posted by thunderdoozer

No, no, no. I think you are missing the point.

This kind of system will assure that every team in a league is IDENTICAL in talent. As the lower level teams grow by leaps and bounds and the higher level teams crawl forward, eventually they will level out and be the same.

So, why put any effort into finding talented players? Everyone in the league will be the same eventually anyway. What fun is a league with no variety whatsoever? It's about as fun as flipping a coin.


 
justafish2002
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
Originally posted by justafish2002

Originally posted by thunderdoozer


Originally posted by justafish2002



People are making this out to affect everything.

Most games will stay the same. Only a few teams will be affected majorly.


No, no, no. I think you are missing the point.

This kind of system will assure that every team in a league is IDENTICAL in talent. As the lower level teams grow by leaps and bounds and the higher level teams crawl forward, eventually they will level out and be the same.

So, why put any effort into finding talented players? Everyone in the league will be the same eventually anyway. What fun is a league with no variety whatsoever? It's about as fun as flipping a coin.


You win by finding smart players.

A good build will beat a player even if the lvl of the other player is higher.


LOL, so you agree that player level is overrated. Then why make rules based on something that is overrated (irrelevant)?


No, this rule will make compeitions better and closer. The teams that will win though are the ones who recruit the smart players.
 
Kaiserfarrow
offline
Link
 
Personally I don't see what all the fuss is about - yes, it sucks to go up against higher level players, but they level up quick enough. I started my team last season with a bunch of level 1s during the shortage, and everyone is up to at least 10 now, only a few levels different to the higher level players I signed. Seriously, the bigger level differences occur when people boost/don't boost - long term that will be the factor as to who has the better teams. If I have a team full of boosters, as do a couple of others in my league, znd we don't make it up to the next level, should we really be penalised for hanging around where we're easily better than 8-9 of the teams?

If we want to stratify more, move more people up and down through promotion/relegation - that will means the cream rises to the top quicker, and the lesser teams find their level.

Yes, I signed some higher level FAs to a friend's team in Africa, not because I want to own lower level players, but because I want to play on his team, wherever that may have been. When I boost, there'll be some awful mismatches next season in places, but hey, that's life. If I'm going to be penalised on XP, and hamper my players' development, then I wouldn't have made the move.

You want the talent, build bridges with other players, owners etc, and manage those relationships to yield higher level players on the team.

Rant over - fact is, someone has to win, and someone has to come last.
Last edited Jun 6, 2008 17:40:03
 
cbrown
offline
Link
 
yea im in a usa bbb league and the worst team last season just gutted there team and they have all level 1's, so they would get more xp?
 
big_n_rich
offline
Link
 
Look at Africa, a new pro league was just created as an expansion. To get this idea to really work a AAA USA league should have ben designated as the pro team and then a AA promoted, a A promoted and a new A created in that region. The players are somewhere all between 1-2 seasons old. Just not enough variety in levels yet of players to support a variety in leagues. Year 1 players clearly have a leg up on the rest of us and idealy would be almost all on Pro or AAA teams. Year 2 players should ideally be on AA, Year 3 would be on A. If you get on a team above your level you get extra exp. to help level up faster and become more competive. I think this is just a growing pain in the early stages of the game.
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
Originally posted by rbedgood

I realize that the point of this is to avoid having the lv15 player that wants to drop to BBB so he can XP up and dominate a league. I think 1-4 should pretty much handle this, especially if it is done on a sliding scale. The actual implementation of the program should not be revealed so as to reduce the loopholes...don't say what players are going to determine the average level of your team. It could be the entire roster, could be the starting line-up, could be 'best possible' line-up to remove advantage of dropping top players in the depth chart...

Additionally this helps the new owner of a gutted team recover. Or a team like ours (Ottawa Chiefs Canada AAA#2) that played all last season outmatched...we were 3-13...we beat the two teams that were relegated and our inter-conference matchup. So essentially every team that stayed beat us last season. This would give us hope of making up a bit of the 3-4 level deficit we face on average.

I think we'll be a bit more competitive than last season, but this gives us a bit more hope.



Instead of making the rest of the league play down to your level, how about dropping down to a lower level league. Do you realize that you are punishing the whole league to make your team "competitive"?


We've tried to move down...we missed out on relegation and haven't been able to find a trade partner that wants to move up...any suggestions, or do you just want to flame indiscriminately?
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

I think you're over-estimating the size of the bonus. I didn't say if you're level 2 and you play level 20's you go from lv 2 to lv 15 after one game. I'm talking about something like a 10-15% bonus for playing within the "spirit of the game."


Hey Bort, are there a lot of people doing this? If there is only a minority of people that are doing this, then the changes really should not have an effect on everyone. For my experience in the BBB league, everyone is trying to win and move up. No one is trying to stay around or move to a lower level so that they can keep "dominating". I'm just curious how many of the people in the GLB actually think this is a problem.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kaiserfarrow
Personally I don't see what all the fuss is about - yes, it sucks to go up against higher level players, but they level up quick enough. I started my team last season with a bunch of level 1s during the shortage, and everyone is up to at least 10 now, only a few levels different to the higher level players I signed. Seriously, the bigger level differences occur when people boost/don't boost - long term that will be the factor as to who has the better teams. If I have a team full of boosters, as do a couple of others in my league, znd we don't make it up to the next level, should we really be penalised for hanging around where we're easily better than 8-9 of the teams?

If we want to stratify more, move more people up and down through promotion/relegation - that will means the cream rises to the top quicker, and the lesser teams find their level.

Yes, I signed some higher level FAs to a friend's team in Africa, not because I want to own lower level players, but because I want to play on his team, wherever that may have been. When I boost, there'll be some awful mismatches next season in places, but hey, that's life.

You want the talent, build bridges with other players, owners etc, and manage those relationships to yield higher level players on the team.

Rant over - fact is, someone has to win, and someone has to come last.


I do agree for the most part. Some people just don't want to take the time to build up their team, or want to keep their lv 10 friends team together and not have it destroyed by somebody else's lv 20 friends team.

I know there will never be a happy medium because people just like to complain no matter what. Just throwing ideas out there.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
Hey Bort, are there a lot of people doing this? If there is only a minority of people that are doing this, then the changes really should not have an effect on everyone. For my experience in the BBB league, everyone is trying to win and move up. No one is trying to stay around or move to a lower level so that they can keep "dominating". I'm just curious how many of the people in the GLB actually think this is a problem.


It comes up at least once every couple of days with some sort of "cheating" accusation witch hunt.

This idea has been discussed before. I just thought I would bring it up again after all the recent complaining about Africa and "stacking" teams.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by justafish2002
Originally posted by datongw

Originally posted by justafish2002


Originally posted by thunderdoozer



Originally posted by justafish2002




People are making this out to affect everything.

Most games will stay the same. Only a few teams will be affected majorly.


No, no, no. I think you are missing the point.

This kind of system will assure that every team in a league is IDENTICAL in talent. As the lower level teams grow by leaps and bounds and the higher level teams crawl forward, eventually they will level out and be the same.

So, why put any effort into finding talented players? Everyone in the league will be the same eventually anyway. What fun is a league with no variety whatsoever? It's about as fun as flipping a coin.


You win by finding smart players.

A good build will beat a player even if the lvl of the other player is higher.


LOL, so you agree that player level is overrated. Then why make rules based on something that is overrated (irrelevant)?


No, this rule will make compeitions better and closer. The teams that will win though are the ones who recruit the smart players.


Competition is already getting better and closer at the top. All the leagues except BBB received 2 good teams and dropped 2 bad teams, I'd say their level of competition is already better than the last season. And next season after another round of promotion, it will get even better. Let the natural selection take its course, don't try to fix it, you can't.
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Good stuff Bort. Been waitin on this one. Proposed it back in April: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=63851&page=4

Originally posted by SAGA45

Originally posted by Doug_Plank

The only incentive it would give would be the incentive to play against lower competition to get more stats.


I think you can counter that with one or both of the following methods:

1) Higher the LVL = the lower morale/XP bonus for positive plays and the higher the morale/XP penalty for negative plays.

2) Add a "Level of Competition" modifier where:
--A lower lvl competing against higher lvl (positive plays) = higher morale/XP bonus rate for the low lvl and lower morale/XP bonus rate for the high lvl.

--A lower lvl competing against higher lvl (negative plays) = lower morale/XP penalty
rate for the low lvl and higher morale/XP penalty rate for high lvl.

--In both cases, The wider the difference in lvl, the larger the impact (whether accelerated/decelerated) on the morale/XP bonus and morale/XP penalty rates.

What I believe the above two methods would do is make it far more beneficial, from a progression standpoint, for players to compete against an equal or higher level of competition.


By the way, Bort, I prefer your option #2 - Avg League-Level weighted towards the top.
 
Kwill-bot
offline
Link
 
I like it.
 
justafish2002
offline
Link
 
The problem is teams like Utopia in USA Pro will get pounded because they sold their team. So the cycle takes even longer
 
MrMoose
offline
Link
 
I'm in favor of a 10% bonus or so for lower level teams playing against much higher level teams. Heck, I'd be in favor of a 10% penalty of sorts, too.

Maybe this code could come into play for the first two seasons of any league. It would let leagues get established, let friends play together, etc. After a couple of years of being established, remove the penalty from the league.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.