Originally posted by bigtony2tone
A team I DC for just lost the Conference Championship Game, in large part because the team we played has a running QB that's used in QB rollouts and draws. It's not the loss that pisses me off, it's the cheap way in which it happened.
This dynamic of the game renders defenses completely useless. Sure, it's rather easy to shut down the QB run plays in and of themselves. But because teams that use this also do everything else out of a given formation, it's impossible to run an effective defense. You have to pick your poison: either shut down the QB runs, or the rest of their offense.
Here are 3 plays that, when using the right personnel, are unstoppable unless selling out to stop them:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=800960&pbp_id=18062580
strong-side rollout
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=800960&pbp_id=18064214
up the gut
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=800960&pbp_id=18064955
weak-side rollout
And these are just out of the strong I. The singleback is just as bad. The problem here is not that these plays are unstoppable in and of themselves. It's that in order to stop them, you are giving up the power-run as well as any pass-rush on passing plays.
The bigger issue may be the fact that a big play or 2 against a defense completely demoralizes that defense, making them ineffective for the rest of the game. These players are making their way up the ranks, too. Eventually the Pros and even WL will be infiltrated. It'll be "if you can't beat 'em, join 'em" and soon enough this game will be the Dolphins offense. And no one wants to see that.
Some will inevitably say "you're just mad cuz you don't have a running QB, why don't you just sign one and run those plays yourself". Because it's cheap-ass shit, just like the SI Slam, and screen passes in higher leagues this year. If you have the right guy for the play, you're unstoppable. That's not real football. Give me the ability to recognize personnel in a given play so my defense can select the play for that personnel.
Bottom line is this: In REAL football, if a run-only QB lines up behind center, that defense knows what's going to happen. In dot-ball, the defense runs whatever comes up, regardless of personnel. Something must be done.
You're doing it wrong bud.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=784924http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=694924If you scouted the game we played against them for season 11, you would've seen the defense we used to stop Voltz. Voltz is an explosive player, but he can be stopped.