User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Someone give me cliffs on the weight fix
Page:
 
Joe Buck
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Originally posted by PsychoMan

so why does the weight show up properly on the player profile page every time?


Probably because that's properly pulling the data whereas whatever is pulling data to be used in games is not.


Bort said the sim server is a different machine from the database server. So its using TCP/IP protocol to do that transfer. The database server / web server connection uses Http not Sql, so that's another variable in the mix. Perhaps HTTP reads whatever corruption better.
Edited by Joe Buck on Sep 2, 2009 08:17:49
 
PsychoMan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Probably because that's properly pulling the data whereas whatever is pulling data to be used in games is not.


thank you.

so if the issue lies in what is pulling the data, then it doesn't lie with where the data is actually stored!
 
GP1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Originally posted by ron2288

which bort said in the X-Factor testing thread (page 53ish)


Did he? OK, then I assumed correctly

Originally posted by PsychoMan

didn't bort say that he didn't know what the issue was (bad data in a weight table would be simple to find and fix), so he had to place some extra logic in the sim that would verify that the weights came over the tcp/ip uncorrupted?


That sounds correct, which is why I have said over and over, "assuming weight is the issue here..." or something like that.

Originally posted by hydrosmak

Just had a game in EEPro sim and I am not seeing anything glaring...

Couple of our "X-Factor" players are still doing the usual...


Can you please link me to what you're seeing? I'll get the info to Bort.

Originally posted by DaMayan

btw. Why is it only weight?
Is that stored in a different table or on a different server then the rest of the data?
Shouldnt all data be effected if it's a general transport issue?


I think Bort said he was seeing some potential errors going on there in testing completely separate from this issue.

Originally posted by Signalsgt

Care to explain how an error correcting protocol that requires a SYN and a SYN-ACK causes these problems?

I already had to explain how TCP traffic actually works once, don't have time to do it again.

Follow the arrows: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Tcp_state_diagram_fixed.svg


No because I have no fucking clue what you're talking about. Once again, reminder:

Originally posted by Jed

<-Not a developer


With all due respect, you shouldnt be commenting on "TCP/IP" errors if you're not a developer. You cant use it as a definitive answer and then hide behind that shield when someone questions the logic.

 
Joe Buck
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PsychoMan
Originally posted by Jed

Probably because that's properly pulling the data whereas whatever is pulling data to be used in games is not.


thank you.

so if the issue lies in what is pulling the data, then it doesn't lie with where the data is actually stored!


Not necessarily, it could be a corrupt database entry, just one that Error-checking on TCP/IP is hanging up on, that HTML just skips over and ignores.
 
jamz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
It's not so much that he couldn't fix them as much as it's not a guaranteed fix, so putting something like this in place will act like a fix right now if that is the problem so if it is, the problem will act fixed till a real fix is in place and work to show that it is indeed the problem at the same time


How much wood, would a woodchuck, chuck if a woodchuck could chuck wood?
 
Voltron
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jamz
How much wood, would a woodchuck, chuck if a woodchuck could chuck wood?


As much as wood as woodchuck could if a woodchuck could chuck wood.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Cliffs Notes: DB + PierreThomas prove once again that something is causing players to out-perform builds, Jed locks the thread and tells everyone to stop whining, the community tells Jed that he is being an asshole and he sheepishly backs down from his assholishness, then Bort posts something in the changelog about a data transmission issue supposedly causing the discrepancy.


As you can tell, I'm extremely skeptical about the last part. It's fishy that Bort suddenly and magically knows what the problem is when Bort previously blamed PT's player's performance on "Taco Bell." It's also fishy that weight recording corruption would supposedly only occur at creation, since players weren't being transformed to superstars randomly. The ones who had higher than expected speed, always had higher than expected speed. And as others have pointed out, the weight being listed correctly means that it must have the correct value in the database somewhere, which is why people have pointed to the "data transmission" angle, but it makes no sense that a corrected listed value would always be transmitted corruptly due to whatever excuses Bort made for the supposedly corrupt end-data.
 
taurran
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Cliffs Notes: DB + PierreThomas prove once again that something is causing players to out-perform builds, Jed locks the thread and tells everyone to stop whining, the community tells Jed that he is being an asshole and he sheepishly backs down from his assholishness, then Bort posts something in the changelog about a data transmission issue supposedly causing the discrepancy.


As you can tell, I'm extremely skeptical about the last part. It's fishy that Bort suddenly and magically knows what the problem is when Bort previously blamed PT's player's performance on "Taco Bell." It's also fishy that weight recording corruption would supposedly only occur at creation, since players weren't being transformed to superstars randomly. The ones who had higher than expected speed, always had higher than expected speed. And as others have pointed out, the weight being listed correctly means that it must have the correct value in the database somewhere, which is why people have pointed to the "data transmission" angle, but it makes no sense that a corrected listed value would always be transmitted corruptly due to whatever excuses Bort made for the supposedly corrupt end-data.


 
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer
Originally posted by PsychoMan

Originally posted by wombat killer


Does height impact anything?


omg can you imagine how elusive you'd be if you were 7.2 inches tall instead of 72? someone better check dooley's height value in the db quick!


Would a 72 foot dot be harder or easier to tackle?


Gulliver's Travels FTW.
 
GP1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by taurran
Originally posted by jdbolick

Cliffs Notes: DB + PierreThomas prove once again that something is causing players to out-perform builds, Jed locks the thread and tells everyone to stop whining, the community tells Jed that he is being an asshole and he sheepishly backs down from his assholishness, then Bort posts something in the changelog about a data transmission issue supposedly causing the discrepancy.


As you can tell, I'm extremely skeptical about the last part. It's fishy that Bort suddenly and magically knows what the problem is when Bort previously blamed PT's player's performance on "Taco Bell." It's also fishy that weight recording corruption would supposedly only occur at creation, since players weren't being transformed to superstars randomly. The ones who had higher than expected speed, always had higher than expected speed. And as others have pointed out, the weight being listed correctly means that it must have the correct value in the database somewhere, which is why people have pointed to the "data transmission" angle, but it makes no sense that a corrected listed value would always be transmitted corruptly due to whatever excuses Bort made for the supposedly corrupt end-data.




 
PsychoMan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Cliffs Notes: DB + PierreThomas prove once again that something is causing players to out-perform builds, Jed locks the thread and tells everyone to stop whining, the community tells Jed that he is being an asshole and he sheepishly backs down from his assholishness, then Bort posts something in the changelog about a data transmission issue supposedly causing the discrepancy.


As you can tell, I'm extremely skeptical about the last part. It's fishy that Bort suddenly and magically knows what the problem is when Bort previously blamed PT's player's performance on "Taco Bell." It's also fishy that weight recording corruption would supposedly only occur at creation, since players weren't being transformed to superstars randomly. The ones who had higher than expected speed, always had higher than expected speed. And as others have pointed out, the weight being listed correctly means that it must have the correct value in the database somewhere, which is why people have pointed to the "data transmission" angle, but it makes no sense that a corrected listed value would always be transmitted corruptly due to whatever excuses Bort made for the supposedly corrupt end-data.


this is well put
 
Krunchy
offline
Link
 
What I love is how PierreThomas continually gets vilified on these sorts of issues, when in fact he's doing GLB a great service. Maybe a thank you would be in order, or at very least maybe Bort could call off his pack of attack Mods?
 
Joe Buck
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Krunchy
What I love is how PierreThomas continually gets vilified on these sorts of issues, when in fact he's doing GLB a great service. Maybe a thank you would be in order, or at very least maybe Bort could call off his pack of attack Mods?


agree 100%.
 
taurran
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Krunchy
What I love is how PierreThomas continually gets vilified on these sorts of issues, when in fact he's doing GLB a great service. Maybe a thank you would be in order, or at very least maybe Bort could call off his pack of attack Mods?


I agree. I've talked with him on issues via PM's in the past, and he has sound reasoning behind the issues he brings up.

The problem is the bandwagon "fix your builds" and "stop whining" crowds. If it were up to them, nothing would ever get fixed in this beta game.
Edited by taurran on Sep 2, 2009 08:44:02
 
MikeJ
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Krunchy
What I love is how PierreThomas continually gets vilified on these sorts of issues, when in fact he's doing GLB a great service. Maybe a thank you would be in order, or at very least maybe Bort could call off his pack of attack Mods?


Absolutely.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.