I think ideas like clutch factors are fine, but because this is a game it would be nice to have them balanced by other things. Even to a point where you choose your player's disposition:
Clutch - player plays average or below except he sometimes comes through big in big situations and has occasional out of this world games.
Hard Worker - player gets the most out of training because he is always working hard
Natural Leader - player tends to make others better around him
Selfish player - player tends to perform better when getting more snaps/passes/runs/etc.
Consistent Player - has few highs and lows - plays the same level all the time
The trick would be to get these balanced so that one is not always better than the next., it depends what type of personality you want to give your player. Other types possible too. I am in a hurry.
I think physically freaky players are already built into the rolls system.
Another idea would be the notion of potential and living up to it. Maybe the better your roll and physical potential is, the more you have to add certain things like Hard Worker to live up to your potential.
As a general rule in video sims of sporting games though, the balance of the game depends almost entirely on the complexity of the mental and strategic aspects of it. The simpler a sports sim is strategically, the more it favors base attributes like speed and agility. I have a post about this on the test server which explains why a WR like Isaac Bruce who runs excellent routes and has a high football IQ, though he is a step slower than other WRs, is much better in real life than he is on most video games.
Clutch - player plays average or below except he sometimes comes through big in big situations and has occasional out of this world games.
Hard Worker - player gets the most out of training because he is always working hard
Natural Leader - player tends to make others better around him
Selfish player - player tends to perform better when getting more snaps/passes/runs/etc.
Consistent Player - has few highs and lows - plays the same level all the time
The trick would be to get these balanced so that one is not always better than the next., it depends what type of personality you want to give your player. Other types possible too. I am in a hurry.
I think physically freaky players are already built into the rolls system.
Another idea would be the notion of potential and living up to it. Maybe the better your roll and physical potential is, the more you have to add certain things like Hard Worker to live up to your potential.
As a general rule in video sims of sporting games though, the balance of the game depends almost entirely on the complexity of the mental and strategic aspects of it. The simpler a sports sim is strategically, the more it favors base attributes like speed and agility. I have a post about this on the test server which explains why a WR like Isaac Bruce who runs excellent routes and has a high football IQ, though he is a step slower than other WRs, is much better in real life than he is on most video games.






























