User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Uncapped Minors = Worst part of GLB / Fix = Top Season 12 Priority
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
The main problem I see is that there are two types of owners:

- Those who want to make it to the top as quickly as possible
- Those who don't care about making it to the top, and would rather keep riding the cap lines so they don't have to try

I have actually run into FAR more of #2 type owners, every offseason, requesting demotions or one-level promotions and complaining that their 20-0 team shouldn't have to move up at all because it's not fair, etc.

The thing is that these two types of owners are not compatible. Owner #1 wants as much competition as possible, doesn't mind losing against competitive teams, and wants to go to the world league. Owner #2 doesn't care about winning 200-0 because a W is W and it makes him feel good.

Now, if owner #2 would simply sack up and agree to play teams that are his equal, we wouldn't have a problem. Unfortunately, he wont, so he keeps riding those lines and claiming he wishes his league were more competitive.

How do you get these two types of owners to meet in the middle? Or do you? Should #2 types go play in the "vs CPU only" sandbox?


Bort man, please realize that there have been a lot of type #1 owners who had a lot of fun and success, and then your promotion scheme dumps them into leagues where they're too low level to compete.

Then the owner has to pick between:

1) Keep the roster intact and go 3-13. And hope that players don't want to leave their gutter team.
2) Gut the roster of people they know and like, and had a lot of fun/success with, and try to re-recruit a competitive roster for the new league level.

I've seen TONS of type #1 owners turn into type #2s after the promotion scheme failed them.
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury


Bort man, please realize that there have been a lot of type #1 owners who had a lot of fun and success, and then your promotion scheme dumps them into leagues where they're too low level to compete.

Then the owner has to pick between:

1) Keep the roster intact and go 3-13. And hope that players don't want to leave their gutter team.
2) Gut the roster of people they know and like, and had a lot of fun/success with, and try to re-recruit a competitive roster for the new league level.

I've seen TONS of type #1 owners turn into type #2s after the promotion scheme failed them.


The current system is a work around that. It is designed for 1s and at no point does your team go to "can't compete" mode in the cloud if you have good builds and tactics, along with decent depth.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Ignore the wishes of owner #2. He is most likely a child and will whine regardless. Force him to sack up. There are casual leagues for owner type #2.


... says the man with season #1 players, a venerable team, a network of farm teams to back him up, and an association with GLB admin.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by pottsman
The current system is a work around that. It is designed for 1s and at no point does your team go to "can't compete" mode in the cloud if you have good builds and tactics, along with decent depth.


You obviously have no clue how the cloud has played out. None.

Not to mention I was referring to seasons 1-11, not just right now.
Edited by fallingmercury on Aug 30, 2009 14:48:02
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Bort man, please realize that there have been a lot of type #1 owners who had a lot of fun and success, and then your promotion scheme dumps them into leagues where they're too low level to compete.

Then the owner has to pick between:

1) Keep the roster intact and go 3-13. And hope that players don't want to leave their gutter team.
2) Gut the roster of people they know and like, and had a lot of fun/success with, and try to re-recruit a competitive roster for the new league level.

I've seen TONS of type #1 owners turn into type #2s after the promotion scheme failed them.


If they are truly #1 type owners, they will not want to add more caps. More caps = never reaching the top, ever.

Seems like the problem is the #2 owners who want to beat up everyone else at any cost. They are the ones who have lv 60's in uncapped minors.

I guess there is a subset of the #3 owners as well - they decide they want to start at level 1, no matter where they are, no matter when it is, rest of the league be damned. These guys are a problem as well.
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by pottsman

The current system is a work around that. It is designed for 1s and at no point does your team go to "can't compete" mode in the cloud if you have good builds and tactics, along with decent depth.


You obviously have no clue how the cloud has played out. None.


You're right, I don't DC a team that went into a 31, 38 cap, and then an uncapped league with minimal recruiting needed each season.
 
r87
offline
Link
 
Even worse, type #4 who intentionally lose games so they can drop down / stay where they are.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by r87
Even worse, type #4 who intentionally lose games so they can drop down / stay where they are.


They are #2's. I like to call them "pussies."
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I guess there is a subset of the #3 owners as well - they decide they want to start at level 1, no matter where they are, no matter when it is, rest of the league be damned. These guys are a problem as well.


The problem with 3s is that they have nowhere else to go. Peewee is a seperate waiting list, meaning you need to line things up to get the teams in successive seasons. If you put a level 1 cap league at the bottom of the cloud, 100% auto-promoting to 13 every season, you'd have a lot less 3s.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
They are #2's. I like to call them "pussies."


Either that or they don't want to have to gut and re-recruit to stay competitive.

Bort, you gotta realize that being promoted into inappropriate leagues is enmeshed in the history of GLB. There have been countless threads on it over the seasons where anyone would be like "whoa dude you're screwed".

Nobody wants to go from champ to gutter team, and nobody wants to gut/re-recruit the roster full of players that they like hanging out with and that took them to great heights.

But you've made them choose.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pottsman
The problem with 3s is that they have nowhere else to go. Peewee is a seperate waiting list, meaning you need to line things up to get the teams in successive seasons. If you put a level 1 cap league at the bottom of the cloud, 100% auto-promoting to 13 every season, you'd have a lot less 3s.


I don't know. These guys decide they want to start over for whatever reason. They often don't bother to tell anyone about it or request a demotion, or they do it mid-season, and then their league is stuck playing them. The only thing that might stop it is putting minimum levels on EVERY league.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I don't know. These guys decide they want to start over for whatever reason. They often don't bother to tell anyone about it or request a demotion, or they do it mid-season, and then their league is stuck playing them. The only thing that might stop it is putting minimum levels on EVERY league.


Yeap that would stop them

And I agree that #3s are always a problem. They degrade everyone else's experience....
 
r87
offline
Link
 
fallingmercury, THIS is an example of a real type 1 team.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=5348

Season 5, went 11-5 in Africa A.
Season 6, got demolished in Africa AA.
Season 7, demolished again.
Season 8, demoted.
Season 9, won the title, back up to AA.
Season 10, 11-5 in AA.
Season 11, 6-1 in AA.

THAT is called taking your lumps and getting through it as a team.
 
Maddoc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by r87
fallingmercury, THIS is an example of a real type 1 team.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=5348

Season 5, went 11-5 in Africa A.
Season 6, got demolished in Africa AA.
Season 7, demolished again.
Season 8, demoted.
Season 9, won the title, back up to AA.
Season 10, 11-5 in AA.
Season 11, 6-1 in AA.

THAT is called taking your lumps and getting through it as a team.


Unfortunately, on many teams the entire team would have abandoned ship midway through season 6
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by pottsman

The problem with 3s is that they have nowhere else to go. Peewee is a seperate waiting list, meaning you need to line things up to get the teams in successive seasons. If you put a level 1 cap league at the bottom of the cloud, 100% auto-promoting to 13 every season, you'd have a lot less 3s.


I don't know. These guys decide they want to start over for whatever reason. They often don't bother to tell anyone about it or request a demotion, or they do it mid-season, and then their league is stuck playing them. The only thing that might stop it is putting minimum levels on EVERY league.


We're talking about different teams here, I think. Yes, those people suck, and minimums could help. I'm talking about some of my own teams, though, like http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=717 . Hazy wanted to start over, didn't have anybody to do it with, so he dropped down from USA Pro to 24 capped or somewhere, with 1s. Needed someplace to go to make a roster together.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.