User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > OL still not picking up blitzers who start far from the LOS
Page:
 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zoblefu
Well, if this gets fixed, I want to see the O-Line hold blocks for less time in general though

Almost no O-Line can hold a good D-Line back from a sack for more than a handful of seconds, and that happens all the time in GLB too. Something like every tick it should become easier for the D-Line to break free / harder for the O-Line to hold the block... or something.

Just saying, this change alone isn't all that's wrong with the O / D line interaction, but fixing the O without making a change to the D line to balance it probably isn't that great.


The sim is already set up that block will be broken with time. The addition of stun and rev.pancake are exactly there to make it easier for the DL to win the fight over time.
Saying that it is possible tat the numbers are off and one side (presumably the DL) is too weak. Easily tested by the way if anyone can define what are the expected values, and a mod is willing to put some test server games for that.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zoblefu


Against teams of similar skill level:
No extra blockers: Blocked 30-50%, Hurry 30-50%, sack 0-20%


You are way, way, way off.

In USA Pro between competitive teams, this blitz goes unblocked by the uncovered guard about 85% of the time. I've actually tallied it. And when it's blocked, it's due to LB pathing, and not anything the LG does.

It's a bug.
Edited by thunderdoozer on Sep 2, 2009 22:30:56
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tragula
The problem is not the blitz it is the guard reaction. Offensive linemen can see in real life, why can't they do the same in GLB ?


Bingo.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zoblefu
Well, if this gets fixed, I want to see the O-Line hold blocks for less time in general though

Almost no O-Line can hold a good D-Line back from a sack for more than a handful of seconds, and that happens all the time in GLB too.


Because players in real life get 7 sacks a game like all the time, amirite?

The game already makes it harder for OL to block as the play progresses, and in general the hold block time is way less than in real life.
 
Chop_Lobster
offline
Link
 
C'mon track, stop trolling thunderdoozer and admit it's a glitch blitz
 
Chop_Lobster
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by URL54MVP
Nooooo! This is the only way I can find to get pressure. Plox don't take it away from me and the other bad DCs plox plox plox.




 
Chop_Lobster
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zoblefu
Well, if this gets fixed, I want to see the O-Line hold blocks for less time in general though

Almost no O-Line can hold a good D-Line back from a sack for more than a handful of seconds, and that happens all the time in GLB too. Something like every tick it should become easier for the D-Line to break free / harder for the O-Line to hold the block... or something.

Just saying, this change alone isn't all that's wrong with the O / D line interaction, but fixing the O without making a change to the D line to balance it probably isn't that great.


No...

I don't disagree that it should be easier for the d-line to break free with every concurrent tick after x amount of ticks, that's realistic and actually a p good idea imo.

I do disagree that fixing a obvious flaw means you should nerf the counter balance in the game so you can keep ridiculous stats. Very, very bad idea imo and I'm sick of this exact bullshit logic being argued by the users all the time.
 
Track6Track7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Chop_Lobster
C'mon track, stop trolling thunderdoozer and admit it's a glitch blitz


It's not a glitch blitz, you can totally neutralize it if you know what you're doing. I'd say more, but I think I'm just gonna have fun for a while watching thunderdoozer diligently scout all our games searching for additional proof of our dastardly "exploit" that he just can't for the life of him figure out how to stop.
 
Chop_Lobster
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Track6Track7
It's not a glitch blitz, you can totally neutralize it if you know what you're doing. I'd say more, but I think I'm just gonna have fun for a while watching thunderdoozer diligently scout all our games searching for additional proof of our dastardly "exploit" that he just can't for the life of him figure out how to stop.


lol, ok man. I'm imagining you imagining thunder pulling his hair out while frantically watching all your team's replays, it's p amusing tbh.

But seriously, maybe it's not a glitch blitz but you can't tell me it's not a little ridiculous that the LG will try to help out on the C's assignment when even my dumb ass would see that coming if we were playing football irl. Take this play from my team out of 5 wide for example http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=720241&pbp_id=10688964. In a formation where you don't have a HB or FB to keep in against the blitz there's nothing you can do about it imho. With out line shifts or any kind of tactics outside of run/balanced/pass you're helpless so it's a exploit...

if you know something I don't please feel free to shoot me a pm
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Obviously, this thread isn't about something that is impossible to stop.

It's about a bug in the blocking script.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Chop_Lobster
Take this play from my team out of 5 wide for example http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=720241&pbp_id=10688964. In a formation where you don't have a HB or FB to keep in against the blitz there's nothing you can do about it imho. With out line shifts or any kind of tactics outside of run/balanced/pass you're helpless so it's a exploit...


Perfect example.
 
Track6Track7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Chop_Lobster
lol, ok man. I'm imagining you imagining thunder pulling his hair out while frantically watching all your team's replays, it's p amusing tbh.

But seriously, maybe it's not a glitch blitz but you can't tell me it's not a little ridiculous that the LG will try to help out on the C's assignment when even my dumb ass would see that coming if we were playing football irl. Take this play from my team out of 5 wide for example http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=720241&pbp_id=10688964. In a formation where you don't have a HB or FB to keep in against the blitz there's nothing you can do about it imho. With out line shifts or any kind of tactics outside of run/balanced/pass you're helpless so it's a exploit...

if you know something I don't please feel free to shoot me a pm


With 6 pass rushers and 5 blockers, somebody is getting a free shot at the QB, that's not a "exploit", that's math. Unless you're seriously suggesting a lineman should be able to block two guys at the same time every play, which would be way "buggier" than anything in this thread. If the other team does that, you have to just choose a shorter-developing play out of 5 wide, but someone should be open since they only have five guys in coverage. Complaining about that blitz is like using 2 defensive backs against three WRs, then saying it's an "exploit" that one of them gets open.
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
There is a simple fix to this..."exploit/bug".

Add code to do the following:

When an OL lines up and does not have a DL lined up against him, he gets a free near automatic blitz read. It's really simple. When an OL is blocking open space, he should be looking for other threats and spot them. It's what happens in real life and it should happen in GLB.

It will do nothing to stop any real blitzing, just these glitch plays that abuse OL pathing/coding by not giving them a DL to block.
 
Joe Buck
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Track6Track7
Originally posted by Chop_Lobster

lol, ok man. I'm imagining you imagining thunder pulling his hair out while frantically watching all your team's replays, it's p amusing tbh.

But seriously, maybe it's not a glitch blitz but you can't tell me it's not a little ridiculous that the LG will try to help out on the C's assignment when even my dumb ass would see that coming if we were playing football irl. Take this play from my team out of 5 wide for example http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=720241&pbp_id=10688964. In a formation where you don't have a HB or FB to keep in against the blitz there's nothing you can do about it imho. With out line shifts or any kind of tactics outside of run/balanced/pass you're helpless so it's a exploit...

if you know something I don't please feel free to shoot me a pm


With 6 pass rushers and 5 blockers, somebody is getting a free shot at the QB, that's not a "exploit", that's math. Unless you're seriously suggesting a lineman should be able to block two guys at the same time every play, which would be way "buggier" than anything in this thread. If the other team does that, you have to just choose a shorter-developing play out of 5 wide, but someone should be open since they only have five guys in coverage. Complaining about that blitz is like using 2 defensive backs against three WRs, then saying it's an "exploit" that one of them gets open.


No man, it's like using 2 defensive backs in zone against 3 WR's, having THAT part work, and on the other side of the field where it is 2 defensive backs on 2 WR's, having a special placement of the 2nd WR force the 2nd DB to double cover a WR instead of cover the 1st WR 1 on 1.


Did you even look at the replay?

Yeah its 6 on 5.......

► but on the right side of the line, the RT and RG picked up all 3 of the MLB, SS, and LE. There went your numbers argument. I would expect this to get blocked everytime because you have blitzers all trying to shoot the same gap. Not that hard to block IRL.

► The C picked up the NT in the middle.

► The LT picked up the RE.

Leaving the LG free to do whatever he wanted. Instead of picking up the FS blitzer coming right at him, he *STEPPED FORWARD*, *BLOCKED NOBODY* , and let the FS shoot thru unmolested.

That part looks "working as intended" to you?
 
wsdp
offline
Link
 
t6t7, i've been supporting you up to this point but joe buck just nailed it in the post above.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.