User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
One more thing. If this was a simple failure of a vision check, then why does it happen when the offense is going "up" so much more than when the offense is going "down"? It's like a 95%/5% spread.
 
Gunner65
offline
Link
 
Ya'll need to pipe down ... getting FG posts & fat side lines is WAY more important then fixing important bugs like these ... come on ... get your priorities straight!
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Well could you at least do the "pass it on to Bort" thing so we know for sure if it's intended or not? Because you don't seem so sure yourself.


I'm gathering information.

Originally posted by Sik Wit It
One more thing. If this was a simple failure of a vision check, then why does it happen when the offense is going "up" so much more than when the offense is going "down"? It's like a 95%/5% spread.


Is it? the examples provided are weighted in one direction, but that possibly highlights the fact the step is easier to spot in certain replays than others.
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sixx
That's one of the dumbest things I've heard for an excuse.
So you are telling me that a decent CB is going to screw up within the first yard of a route everytime?

If it's not a bug then why are there so many threads about this problem? Hell this has been going on since I started in season 6, but yet it's not a bug.

As for everyone saying it's "pump fake", how many CBs playing m2m do you see getting pump faked irl?
They don't because they're not looking at the QB.

How bout trying to fix this and quit making excuses as to why it's not been fixed?


1 - No. But when it works that is what happens.

2 - Being "faked" is not a bug, even if it looks odd that he steps forward. If you disable the ability to be "faked forward" then I'm not sure what the actual effects would be for faking throughout the rest of the play (i.e. biting on a pass). If it shares the same mechanics as actually make a correct read then the chances are fixing the "step forward" issue might completely disable CB's from stepping forwards to make an interception.

Big picture > little picture.

3 - This has been going on since Day 1, not season 6. One of Borts original fixes was that prior to Season 4 all CB's were programmed to track at the same speed as the WR (which meant super slow WR's were wide open underneath).

4 - There have been a lot of threads about any number of issues. Similar symptoms are often representative of different effects so this isn't some blanket issue. It's something that has been approached in several different ways, each time fixing other issues that were suspected root causes.

5 - It'd be nice to have some quantifiable evidence rather than just a few replays? Without an understanding of what is exactly happening it's very easy to suggest a "fix" only to find it's wrong. I prefer to suggest fixes that don't need reversing - which is why when I get a bug fixed it stays fixed.

6 - And Pump Fake is actually less likely to be responsible than all the other forms of faking, apart from in Shotgun formations were the QB is already set in position to Pump from the off. And yes, I've seen it.

7 - I have better things to do than make excuses. Such as actually trying to work out what the problem is without jumping to conclusions and coming up with a fix that does more harm than good.
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
That is absolutely retarded. Something is almost always responsible for any "bug" happening. The idea that events have to be random to be considered bugs is absurd. What makes it a "bug" is that the catalyst is producing an unintended, destabilizing result.


If the CB was racing off and being caught way out of position, then you'd have a point. Being sent in the wrong direction on a random axis due to a fake is another matter entirely. It's unrealistic based on what we know IRL - but then so is a lot of GLB.

What is the bug:
- Stepping forward from the CB.

What are the reasons for him stepping forward:
- Fake
- Failed Vision check.
- X

Identify X and get back to me, or consider what happens if change any of the other 2 (and what exactly you would change).
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
Originally posted by Sik Wit It

Well could you at least do the "pass it on to Bort" thing so we know for sure if it's intended or not? Because you don't seem so sure yourself.


I'm gathering information.

Originally posted by Sik Wit It

One more thing. If this was a simple failure of a vision check, then why does it happen when the offense is going "up" so much more than when the offense is going "down"? It's like a 95%/5% spread.


Is it? the examples provided are weighted in one direction, but that possibly highlights the fact the step is easier to spot in certain replays than others.


Here's a team I had to gameplan for today. I saw their last game, and they were afflicted by the step forward bug...only on plays going up as far as I could see.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=720720&pbp_id=7834922
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=720720&pbp_id=7833125
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=720720&pbp_id=7837086

So what did I do? Knowing it would result in an automatic TD for half the game (the 2 quarters when we were going "up"), I put it in to the gameplan.

Sure enough...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=720708&pbp_id=8677571

Another example from our game:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=720708&pbp_id=8674633

All going "up".

Just in my experience, I always see it going up. Feel free to debunk this...I'm not entirely sure, but like I said, it seems to happen like 95% of the time going up. I don't see how the step would be easier to spot going up than down.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde

2 - Being "faked" is not a bug, even if it looks odd that he steps forward. If you disable the ability to be "faked forward" then I'm not sure what the actual effects would be for faking throughout the rest of the play (i.e. biting on a pass). If it shares the same mechanics as actually make a correct read then the chances are fixing the "step forward" issue might completely disable CB's from stepping forwards to make an interception.

Big picture > little picture.


Well ideally the CB would bite in the direction the fake was actually GOING in. No way did the WR head fake to his rear...or juke to his rear. I'm not even sure what that would look like. So while it probably would affect CB play throughout the play, it still doesn't change the fact that some of the mechanics behind it seem horribly broken. Again...ideally we could differentiate moves off the snap from moves during the route. WRs shimmy and shake off the line all the time...you'd have to be an idiot to fall for that. I don't see how the "big" picture is we can't fix it because it'll affect the CB throughout the route. That actually seems like a very limited picture to me. How about fixing the broken mechanics behind it so it won't affect the rest of the route. Biting on a route because you think the pass is being thrown is different...in that case it'd make sense to step forward. That'd never happen at the LOS though. Biting on a "backward" head fake or juke just makes no sense. What, are these WRs looking behind them to head fake? Lmao...Are they taking a step backward then jumping off the line to juke backward? Obviously not, because you'd see that. So IMO, the even BIGGER picture > Your "big" picture. The bigger picture being hey, let's actually fix this...not, we can't fix this completely unrealistic, unintentional, and counterintuitive action because it'd affect other things.
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It

Sure enough...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=720708&pbp_id=8677571

Another example from our game:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=720708&pbp_id=8674633

All going "up".

Just in my experience, I always see it going up. Feel free to debunk this...I'm not entirely sure, but like I said, it seems to happen like 95% of the time going up. I don't see how the step would be easier to spot going up than down.


I'm not sure who you're seeing in play 1, 1 CB is on a Blitz pattern. BBG is faked to the left, Running Scared to the right, but otherwise we're not seeing the "Step Forward". Replay 2 for my money shows CB1 Ricky The Glove struggling to turn a circle after being faked to the left.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
Identify X and get back to me, or consider what happens if change any of the other 2 (and what exactly you would change).

The "fix" is to code it so that CBs never step forward at the snap. This has already been explained to you, so until you can grasp that extremely simple concept, you should stop posting.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
Originally posted by Sik Wit It


Sure enough...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=720708&pbp_id=8677571

Another example from our game:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=720708&pbp_id=8674633

All going "up".

Just in my experience, I always see it going up. Feel free to debunk this...I'm not entirely sure, but like I said, it seems to happen like 95% of the time going up. I don't see how the step would be easier to spot going up than down.


I'm not sure who you're seeing in play 1, 1 CB is on a Blitz pattern. BBG is faked to the left, Running Scared to the right, but otherwise we're not seeing the "Step Forward". Replay 2 for my money shows CB1 Ricky The Glove struggling to turn a circle after being faked to the left.


I was talking about BBG. On second look, I guess he doesn't step forward.

On the 2nd one though, Ricky steps forward a yard. You can clearly see it.
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Well ideally the CB would bite in the direction the fake was actually GOING in. No way did the WR head fake to his rear...or juke to his rear. I'm not even sure what that would look like.


Assumption 1. What direction did he fake in?

Originally posted by Sik Wit It
] Again...ideally we could differentiate moves off the snap from moves during the route. WRs shimmy and shake off the line all the time...you'd have to be an idiot to fall for that.


Assumption 2. Not really. Even in the examples you provided the "fall for it" counts for a shift to the side, rather than a step forward. Considering every WR does all the time, sooner or later someone is going to fall for it, and it seems to me that they do.

Originally posted by Sik Wit It
I don't see how the "big" picture is we can't fix it because it'll affect the CB throughout the route.


No, the big picture is we can't just stop faking in 360 degrees in order to fix an occasional issue at the LOS because it'll muck up the rest of the game.

Identifying other ways of fixing the unrealistic nature of the fake itself is entirely fair game. Think of one.

Of course that requires actually identifying what happened first.

Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Biting on a route because you think the pass is being thrown is different...in that case it'd make sense to step forward. That'd never happen at the LOS though.


Do they think the pass is being thrown?

Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Biting on a "backward" head fake or juke just makes no sense. What, are these WRs looking behind them to head fake?


As above.

Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Are they taking a step backward then jumping off the line to juke backward? Obviously not, because you'd see that.


Would you see it? Only if there is an actual "animation" programmed for it.

Originally posted by Sik Wit It
So IMO, the even BIGGER picture > Your "big" picture. The bigger picture being hey, let's actually fix this...not, we can't fix this completely unrealistic, unintentional, and counterintuitive action because it'd affect other things.


The big picture isn't that we can't fix it. The big picture is that we can't fix it based on the 3/5ths of nothing that we know about it. Some of the suggestions of how to "fix it" don't actually correct anything because what actually is happening isn't exactly clear.
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick

The "fix" is to code it so that CBs never step forward at the snap. This has already been explained to you, so until you can grasp that extremely simple concept, you should stop posting.


That's not a "fix". That's something that would cause something of an issue on screen plays, or if the LB/SS/FS/DE/CB actually did read the play at the snap- because this is something that in theory effects more than just the CB. Just they're the most noticeable due to their proximity.
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
On the 2nd one though, Ricky steps forward a yard. You can clearly see it.


The problem with the Ricky exaple is that he reads a move to the left and moves towards it as if the WR is making a 90 degree turn. He closes the gap because he is set to cover to a short distance. The remainder of his motion is actually his turning circle to recover from the initial fake.

What is the correct movement for a CB if a WR runs 90 degrees to the sideline?
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
That's not a "fix". That's something that would cause something of an issue on screen plays, or if the LB/SS/FS/DE/CB actually did read the play at the snap- because this is something that in theory effects more than just the CB. Just they're the most noticeable due to their proximity.

Yes it is a "fix," and please don't waste any more of my time with your bullshit excuses. CBs don't come forward on the snap for screen plays already, so the idea that this "fix" would stop them from doing so is asinine. And unless you have evidence of this bug affecting any other position, then don't use the possibility of it affecting other positions as an excuse either.
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Yes it is a "fix," and please don't waste any more of my time with your bullshit excuses.


Grow up.

Originally posted by jdbolick
CBs don't come forward on the snap for screen plays already, so the idea that this "fix" would stop them from doing so is asinine.


Sorry to point it out, but my CB reads screens and has successfully PD's WR screen plays.

Originally posted by jdbolick
And unless you have evidence of this bug affecting any other position, then don't use the possibility of it affecting other positions as an excuse either.


Put a SS, FS, DE or LB into M2M against a man on the LOS and they'll all have the same issues if the player has the faking capabilities or if they fail their read.

Just check the changelog for the issues that were had with LB's and the number of times "fixes" were put in only to have to be removed because they had unintended side effects.

Simply preventing forward motion is not a fix.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.