User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Lv 38 Minor Leagues > Lv 38 Minor League #4 > Whom is the most dominant player in our league?
Page:
 
Pwned
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Absolut Zero
http://i182.photobucket.com/albums/x156/dontcare555111/564868b8b0c790b63922f510110dfd19.png

http://farm1.static.flickr.com/24/56733884_8a9876603c.jpg

Lol, I couldn't resist.


ROFL, oh shit..
 
ChicagoTRS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Absolut Zero
Oops:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=748162&pbp_id=5007239


Speed wins games...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=748072&pbp_id=5872626
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=748072
 
Absolut Zero
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ChicagoTRS
Speed wins games...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=748072&pbp_id=5872626
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=748072


If it wasn't for that, the story of the game would have been a truly great defensive showing. I mean, 8 completions out of 21 attempts, 10 of the other 13 passing plays were sacks.

You had 74 yards of total offense.
 
ChicagoTRS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Absolut Zero
If it wasn't for that, the story of the game would have been a truly great defensive showing. I mean, 8 completions out of 21 attempts, 10 of the other 13 passing plays were sacks.

You had 74 yards of total offense.


Absolutely...we were dominated. and that is the point...speed iculous can score TDs in games that matter and turn a loss into a win...
 
Pwned
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ChicagoTRS
Absolutely...we were dominated. and that is the point...speed iculous can score TDs in games that matter and turn a loss into a win...


+1

BUT

I still don't think a Return man should be labeled most Dominate player in the League.

There are plenty of position players, that make sure their team wins, without return TD's..
 
ChicagoTRS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Pwned IRL
+1

BUT

I still don't think a Return man should be labeled most Dominate player in the League.

There are plenty of position players, that make sure their team wins, without return TD's..


Fair enough...

I would define most dominant player:

A) Needs to be statistically dominant to all other players at his same position or role...
B) Needs to consistently put up good numbers against good opponents...stats in losses are sometimes even more telling...
C) Stats vs gutted teams should be mostly ignored...
D) Player should likely be from a winning team...I think there could be exceptions to this but I give extra consideration to winners...
E) It is easier to judge when limiting it to a conference best player...because they play common opponents...conference strength makes a big difference in individual player statistics...if you are judging across conferences then you MUST remove stats from blowouts...
F) Player should be high up the MVP list...no doubt the MVP system on GLB is not perfect but it does generally identify the top players...
G) Player should be winning awards...goes along with statistical dominance...

I would not eliminate any position from the running...
 
Absolut Zero
offline
Link
 
Good criteria for measuring this. That definitely will give you very dominant players. But when accounting for THE most dominant player in the entire league, other criteria has to be included to compare it with their fellow dominant players.

I'd like to add to Point C. When I go through players game logs to find out where their production comes from. I immediately ignore any stats from 100+ victories. 70+ I usually ignore as well, unless I know the team they faced are credible and probably just got out-game-planned like crazy. 50-70 I'll usually halve. So 2 sacks, 2 FFs I'll drop down to 1 sack and 1 FF.
 
ChicagoTRS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 49ownbigtime
only has 10 less return tds than TRS


TRS now has 13 less...

speed iculous - 27 tds, scored in 4 of 5 games, more yards per k/p...
TRS - 14 tds, scored against a gutted team 1 of 5 games...

Can safely remove TRS from the contest...
 
stumanroo
blame stu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ChicagoTRS

I would define most dominant player:

A) Needs to be statistically dominant to all other players at his same position or role...
B) Needs to consistently put up good numbers against good opponents...stats in losses are sometimes even more telling...
C) Stats vs gutted teams should be mostly ignored...
D) Player should likely be from a winning team...I think there could be exceptions to this but I give extra consideration to winners...
E) It is easier to judge when limiting it to a conference best player...because they play common opponents...conference strength makes a big difference in individual player statistics...if you are judging across conferences then you MUST remove stats from blowouts...
F) Player should be high up the MVP list...no doubt the MVP system on GLB is not perfect but it does generally identify the top players...
G) Player should be winning awards...goes along with statistical dominance...

I would not eliminate any position from the running...


A) Not in Passing yards but better than any other QB rushing in the league...and better than almost all HB's in the league.
B) Has ran for over 6.7 ypc in every game this season...including BDS and Dayton. Also has over 100 yards in every game and has only once had 20 carries in a game.
C) Fine...ignore them!
D) On top of the Zeta
E) Hey Thanks! Now I am the leading rusher not 2nd place rusher!
F) 6th...let's see how the Dayton win adjusts it if it hasn't already.
G) He got a Gold and Silver last season.

Guess you may have the most Dominant player right here...Chase Herbstreit...Pee Wee QB extraordinaire!!!
 
Pwned
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stumanroo
A) Not in Passing yards but better than any other QB rushing in the league...and better than almost all HB's in the league.
B) Has ran for over 6.7 ypc in every game this season...including BDS and Dayton. Also has over 100 yards in every game and has only once had 20 carries in a game.
C) Fine...ignore them!
D) On top of the Zeta
E) Hey Thanks! Now I am the leading rusher not 2nd place rusher!
F) 6th...let's see how the Dayton win adjusts it if it hasn't already.
G) He got a Gold and Silver last season.

Guess you may have the most Dominant player right here...Chase Herbstreit...Pee Wee QB extraordinaire!!!


I take full fault for Dayton giving him over 40 yards rushing..

We will stop this Pee Wee QB when it counts most.
 
stumanroo
blame stu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Pwned IRL
Originally posted by stumanroo

A) Not in Passing yards but better than any other QB rushing in the league...and better than almost all HB's in the league.
B) Has ran for over 6.7 ypc in every game this season...including BDS and Dayton. Also has over 100 yards in every game and has only once had 20 carries in a game.
C) Fine...ignore them!
D) On top of the Zeta
E) Hey Thanks! Now I am the leading rusher not 2nd place rusher!
F) 6th...let's see how the Dayton win adjusts it if it hasn't already.
G) He got a Gold and Silver last season.

Guess you may have the most Dominant player right here...Chase Herbstreit...Pee Wee QB extraordinaire!!!


I take full fault for Dayton giving him over 40 yards rushing..

We will stop this Pee Wee QB when it counts most.


I will be very honest here...I am looking forward to the re-match! Always love playing in a good tight game with a great opponent!
 
Pwned
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stumanroo
I will be very honest here...I am looking forward to the re-match! Always love playing in a good tight game with a great opponent!


Indeed
 
ChicagoTRS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Pwned IRL
+1

BUT

I still don't think a Return man should be labeled most Dominate player in the League.

There are plenty of position players, that make sure their team wins, without return TD's..



Ready to let Speed Iculous at least be considered in the most dominant talk?

+2 games for Speed
 
dyrt mcgyrt
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ChicagoTRS

Ready to let Speed Iculous at least be considered in the most dominant talk?

+2 games for Speed


no commit
 
Absolut Zero
offline
Link
 
Speed Iculous is by far the best returner in this league. Not sure how much of that to attribute to special teams blocking or not. But he's got I think a little over 50% of his teams total yards.

To really see what happens next, is to find out how well BDS's offense performs normally. Like 1st, 2nd, 3rd down conversion rates etc. It's possible that the offense is good enough to where they don't even need Speed Iculous, but there's no doubt that BDS's special teams unit is the best in the league.

It's safe to say that Iculous and that unit is the most dominant in special teams.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.