User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Add 10 season decline to the NEVER going to happen list
Page:
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Animalmother
I have no choice but to accept it so I do!

Now lets fix it...

Coaching is fine but why not let people just ROLL coaches to begin with?
If I wanted a coach I would download NFL head coach (worst selling game in the genre)


The retirement league is the best option ive heard so far but again how unrealstic is that? Players cant live forever or you QUIT! So it's ok if they do..eventhough its totaly unrealistic as long as others retire?
The logic is odd but ill take the old crappy player if thats my only option.


Ok now the dilema:
Do I boost next season because my guys will one day make it to the retirement league?
We dont know if there is one....
If there isnt one I will not boost...
If there is a retirement leage.. I may boost but not unless I know HOW MUCH the players will degrade.
Do they loose 30 stats...100...10? WTH is it? I need to know or I wont pay.

So if there is one do I miss a season of Boosts and how does that effect the retirement league?
Do only players boosted 3 times for 10 seasons make it in?

So you got your question answered maybe ...by the NEVER going to happen post.
the rest of us didnt...
I have no clue whats going on with my money and 30 boosted players.
Neither does anyone else with even 1 boosted player.
Do we boost again?
When will we know?



Don't let people roll coaches to begin with so there's something uniquely cool that you can do after you've played at least 10 seasons and decline has begun.

You're right that whether there will be a retirement league has not been decided.

And I like how you say I got my answer but "the rest of us" don't have them. The majority on this site seem fine with decline, especially if there's a Seniors' League.

If you want to stop pushing against decline and instead start pushing for a Seniors' League, then it's a different thing...although the extent and emotion to which you've pushed this is way, way out of proportion, regardless.
 
Animalmother
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by LoperK
Originally posted by imwatchingespn

Originally posted by LoperK


tpaterniti, why are we not allowed to make discussions on this?


because you're wrong


Wrong about what? They are ideas, 99% of them are not mine. I am not wrong about anything you moron.



tap said discuss it all you want...hold him to it.

go make a post that says ...GOOD idea 10 season Decline...

Keep it positive and only for progress TOWARDS FIXING DECLINE for everyone.

Decline in some form is a Fact now.... not a option were going to change.
Bort ended the debate with his post here.

If you like any posts from it...link the pages in your opening thread and they live forever. Or copy paste quotes...

Maybe its best you just try to collect ideas and opinions for moving foward.
I dont see them backing off of decline untill the market is so screwed from other football mmorpgs they just have to.

IDK just an idea...its been hours and its super easy to unlock a thread...I dont think they want some of it read with tons of new peeps joining either




The fight is in getting a good program to work along with decline for long term players.

.

We all had good ideas and im sure they talked it over so rehashing it at this point may be mute.... now that i think about it?
Last edited Jun 1, 2008 21:51:52
 
Animalmother
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by Animalmother

I have no choice but to accept it so I do!

Now lets fix it...

Coaching is fine but why not let people just ROLL coaches to begin with?
If I wanted a coach I would download NFL head coach (worst selling game in the genre)


The retirement league is the best option ive heard so far but again how unrealstic is that? Players cant live forever or you QUIT! So it's ok if they do..eventhough its totaly unrealistic as long as others retire?
The logic is odd but ill take the old crappy player if thats my only option.


Ok now the dilema:
Do I boost next season because my guys will one day make it to the retirement league?
We dont know if there is one....
If there isnt one I will not boost...
If there is a retirement leage.. I may boost but not unless I know HOW MUCH the players will degrade.
Do they loose 30 stats...100...10? WTH is it? I need to know or I wont pay.

So if there is one do I miss a season of Boosts and how does that effect the retirement league?
Do only players boosted 3 times for 10 seasons make it in?

So you got your question answered maybe ...by the NEVER going to happen post.
the rest of us didnt...
I have no clue whats going on with my money and 30 boosted players.
Neither does anyone else with even 1 boosted player.
Do we boost again?
When will we know?



Don't let people roll coaches to begin with so there's something uniquely cool that you can do after you've played at least 10 seasons and decline has begun.

You're right that whether there will be a retirement league has not been decided.

And I like how you say I got my answer but "the rest of us" don't have them. The majority on this site seem fine with decline, especially if there's a Seniors' League.

If you want to stop pushing against decline and instead start pushing for a Seniors' League, then it's a different thing...although the extent and emotion to which you've pushed this is way, way out of proportion, regardless.



Way out of proportion?
So this never comes up if I dont say anything?
Dude I have made 1 thread about this and that was to point out my situation and get opinions.
A few posts later I was linked to Lopers post and chimed in.
Dont forget your about 40 posts deep into defending lol.

I replied 100 times to guys like you and guys that agree for conversation and to make sure a noobie doesnt waste his money without knowing UPFRONT what the deal was.

I even made a deal with you..
They fix the FaQ I STFU...
You see the FaQ Fixed?

I also want to know what im BOOSTING (paying) TO BECOME...you make it seem like thats a odd question to ask in a MMORPG.

Sport sim guys telling me how a MMORPG should work is kinda funny
Last edited Jun 1, 2008 22:02:49
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Status:

Coaches with unique abilities, abilities to start related to their playing skills, from retired players: Bort has said he likes the idea and is likely to implement it.

Legacy program with children of players, in some form, starting above newly created players in level: Bort has said he would be very open to it.

Seniors' League so people can keep playing players at their peak, while still clearing out the main leagues for newer players, unrealistic but a way to allow people to keep players while keeping the main leagues' turnover: Bort has not given any signal on it, but has not closed it off.

So, the first two are very likely to happen. The last one is highly uncertain.
 
Animalmother
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Status:

Coaches with unique abilities, abilities to start related to their playing skills, from retired players: Bort has said he likes the idea and is likely to implement it.

Legacy program with children of players, in some form, starting above newly created players in level: Bort has said he would be very open to it.

Seniors' League so people can keep playing players at their peak, while still clearing out the main leagues for newer players, unrealistic but a way to allow people to keep players while keeping the main leagues' turnover: Bort has not given any signal on it, but has not closed it off.

So, the first two are very likely to happen. The last one is highly uncertain.


Nice lets move forward and help them work out the ruff stuff in the forums.
the ideas came from talk like this...
I think a good solid thread with ideas and less fighting will get us moving along faster from here?

I would like to see your last comment added as well..
I hope the door is very wide open on ATLEAST trying the seniors League or something like it before a core wipe.

we need to know before the end of next season what the plan is to some degree.
Last edited Jun 1, 2008 22:10:34
 
jbartle3
offline
Link
 
decline after 10 seasons is the same as gaining no exp after 10 seasons. you get 10 seasons to build your guy. THEN, some stats drop off, you continue to level up and train, thereby replacing the ones you lost. i think its a good idea. its kind of like a maximum level, but more like a maximum TIME to reach whatever level you can get to.
 
solidmatt
offline
Link
 
The "realistic" argument is terrible. I mean my player wears a fuckin doo rag and it makes him run faster.
 
codine22
offline
Link
 
I think its a BS idea mainly because theres no way I'd get another QB job if I had to start from scratch hell the D league teams are all 5-6 deep with QB's.

Maybe if they did the son thing whereby your new player would have decent starting attributes from level 1.

But the main flaw in this ideas that there is no end game, why pump money into a guy and spend time homing his abilities when in 10 months time he's gone forever with nothing to show for it.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by codine22
I think its a BS idea mainly because theres no way I'd get another QB job if I had to start from scratch hell the D league teams are all 5-6 deep with QB's.

Maybe if they did the son thing whereby your new player would have decent starting attributes from level 1.

But the main flaw in this ideas that there is no end game, why pump money into a guy and spend time homing his abilities when in 10 months time he's gone forever with nothing to show for it.


You realize that an MMO with an endgame doesn't exist right? MMOs are money sinks that keep moving the goalposts to keep players playing. It's not a complicated fomula. At least in GLB, an endgame shouldn't be expected (that's like asking, when is the last Super Bowl going to be).
 
JM
offline
Link
 
I created a player on day 22 of the first season. Is he gonna decline once the 11th season begins, or doesnt he start to decline before the 22th day of that season?

I also think it should be possible to retire a player without removing him from the database. So you can retire him and get 70 percent of the flex points back, but he will still be in the database as a former player you have had. And off cause, the stats he made should be availible even after he retires.
Last edited Jun 2, 2008 16:52:32
 
jwd100iii
offline
Link
 
There is already different costs for glamor positions and I feel the skill decline for certain positions should be different as well. As an example a QB's avg career length is longer then a RB's and WR's, per NFL standards. The reason being is the RB takes repeated poundings and health becomes an issue. I believe the numbers on avg career length in the NFL are something like 7yrs for QB's 3-4yrs WR's and just 2.5 for RBs. (Don't quote me exactly, this is from memory)

If we could incorporate the (type of position)X(the number of plays)X(the type of play activity) to determine when the players skills start to decline rather than just after the 10th season.

Or a simple method would be to have the glamor positions decline sooner then the "less glamor" and "non-glamor" positions.


Have not had time to read this entire thread so this may have already been suggested. I apologize if it has.
 
jeffgarcia
offline
Link
 
I understand the reason for doing the decline, but I'm gonna lose my motivation after I lose my player tbh.
 
Maddencoach
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
I think you could really bring in a lot of options.

My suggestions, quickly:
- First, have the decline come a little bit later, with a plateau and a decline that starts slow and speeds up exponentially.
- For those that would rather keep building like a MMORPG, they "retire" their players from the regular game (whatever records they have at that point for HOF) and rather than retire for 70% FP back, their player moves to a legacy league and keeps growing.
- For those that want to retire but not rebuild, they can become a coach in the regular game
- For those that want to retire and rebuild, 70% FP back when they choose to retire.
- For those that want to retire and rebuild a "son", less FP back and enhanced attributes to begin with as a son of a GLB veteran


love the idea. I think that your declind should be a cobination of season/days played and amout of plays. A buck up wit half the playing team should have a bit more longer period then a starter who beat himself up every game.
 
Nanobot
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jeffgarcia
I understand the reason for doing the decline, but I'm gonna lose my motivation after I lose my player tbh.


Personally, I can't wait to get a new set of players going. It will be much different for most people the second time around with the knowledge we've all gained.
 
Caledric
offline
Link
 
Without a decline, eventually the "Pro" leagues will just be a dice roll every game. Players will all have the exact same levels, exact same stats... it will be boring and pointless.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.