Yes the Big 10.5 sucks right now, but don't think for a second that they don't have the potential to have a great conference. Now I'm not saying that they should be considered a BCS conference right now, but with the histories of Michigan, Ohio State, and Penn State in one conference, you better believe that they have the potential to make it back to the top.
What separates the SEC and Big 12 from everyone else is their recruiting base. In the SEC, you have Florida which puts about 300 NCAA prospects into the league every season. Then you have Georgia, Alabama, and the Carolina that aren't too shabby either. The Big 12 of course has Texas which is like 4 states in one and their high school football is just about as big as their college football. Of course USC has California. Almost no big recruits leave that state if USC wants them, not to mention the fact that you would have to be insane not to want to spend 4 of the best years of your life in Southern California.
But besides Ohio, Pennsylvania, and New Jersey, there really aren't that many big recruiting states up north. There just aren't enough recruits up north and therefore it's hard to fill a team with the talent that the South has. The article below mentions how cold weather plays a roll in recruiting skill position players. I think it's much bigger than that though. Kids from California, Florida, and Texas grow up playing outdoor sports 12 months a year, because they can. That is not the case for most of the kids from the Big 10, so really the difference could possibly be the weather.
http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2009/writers/andy_staples/01/20/recruiting/index.html
What separates the SEC and Big 12 from everyone else is their recruiting base. In the SEC, you have Florida which puts about 300 NCAA prospects into the league every season. Then you have Georgia, Alabama, and the Carolina that aren't too shabby either. The Big 12 of course has Texas which is like 4 states in one and their high school football is just about as big as their college football. Of course USC has California. Almost no big recruits leave that state if USC wants them, not to mention the fact that you would have to be insane not to want to spend 4 of the best years of your life in Southern California.
But besides Ohio, Pennsylvania, and New Jersey, there really aren't that many big recruiting states up north. There just aren't enough recruits up north and therefore it's hard to fill a team with the talent that the South has. The article below mentions how cold weather plays a roll in recruiting skill position players. I think it's much bigger than that though. Kids from California, Florida, and Texas grow up playing outdoor sports 12 months a year, because they can. That is not the case for most of the kids from the Big 10, so really the difference could possibly be the weather.
http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2009/writers/andy_staples/01/20/recruiting/index.html





. Big 10 is just the conference that everyone will always dog on. I would compare Big 10 to the Big 12 north division. Teams that have a lot of history, tradition and great fan followings but like Catcher says its just so hard to recruit skill positions to places where the tempatures are just so much colder than Florida and Cali and Texas. 























