User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
catcher_0_3
offline
Link
 
Yes the Big 10.5 sucks right now, but don't think for a second that they don't have the potential to have a great conference. Now I'm not saying that they should be considered a BCS conference right now, but with the histories of Michigan, Ohio State, and Penn State in one conference, you better believe that they have the potential to make it back to the top.

What separates the SEC and Big 12 from everyone else is their recruiting base. In the SEC, you have Florida which puts about 300 NCAA prospects into the league every season. Then you have Georgia, Alabama, and the Carolina that aren't too shabby either. The Big 12 of course has Texas which is like 4 states in one and their high school football is just about as big as their college football. Of course USC has California. Almost no big recruits leave that state if USC wants them, not to mention the fact that you would have to be insane not to want to spend 4 of the best years of your life in Southern California.

But besides Ohio, Pennsylvania, and New Jersey, there really aren't that many big recruiting states up north. There just aren't enough recruits up north and therefore it's hard to fill a team with the talent that the South has. The article below mentions how cold weather plays a roll in recruiting skill position players. I think it's much bigger than that though. Kids from California, Florida, and Texas grow up playing outdoor sports 12 months a year, because they can. That is not the case for most of the kids from the Big 10, so really the difference could possibly be the weather.

http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2009/writers/andy_staples/01/20/recruiting/index.html
 
flyinillini98
offline
Link
 
I think you've probably nailed it as close as anyone Catcher. I read somewhere a while back in regards to Pro players, that Florida, Texas, and California produce more by far than any other states so they've got naturally great recruitment areas. To go along with that, travel is becoming a whole lot easier than it used to be, say 20 or 30 years ago. It was a lot tougher for kids to go across the country and leave behind friends and family because you'd be totally out of touch. Now email, cell phones, internet, and driving or flying that far is a lot more common than it used to be. I'm sure it takes a far better salesman to sell a kid the -20 degree January weather of Illinois against the weather of southern California or some of the other southern states.

BCS conference though? They're still easily a BCS conference, if not, then SEC is the only BCS conference in college football.
 
Demario
offline
Link
 
Conferences # of ranked teams including others recieving votes:

SEC: 5
Big 12: 7
Big 10:5
Pac 10:5

Top 15:


SEC: 3
Big 12: 3
Big 10: 2
Pac 10: 2

Bowl Teams (W-L)

SEC: 8(6-2)
Big 12: 7(4-3)
Big 10: 6(1-5)
Pac 10: 5(5-0)

Number of times in the National title game under BCS:

SEC: 5
Big 12: 6
Big 10: 3-
Pac 10: 2


Really can't see your argument of how Big 10 is the best conference around now. Looks like they are the bottom feeders and don't say they beat themselves up during the season because same thing happenes to the other conferences plus you lost 3 bowl games alone to Big 12 opponents.
 
Motion15
offline
Link
 
Go Gators
 
Demario
offline
Link
 
Look at Texas recruiting this season alone they almost already have all their scholorships filled up and think like 90% are from Texas. If you want an easy job go be a recruiting coordinator for Texas lol
 
flyinillini98
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Demario
Really can't see your argument of how Big 10 is the best conference around now.


If you're talking to me, where have I made anything close to that statement or argument?

As far as most of your stats, they're from one season, if we're basing it entirely off last season then no, the Big 10 certainly wasn't one of the premier conferences. Are you satisfied now?
 
Demario
offline
Link
 
Ohio State is your only team who's had a shot at National title since the BCS. I figured it was pretty much inferred that we are discussing most recent success of the conferences. Yeah if we go back decades when it was ok to build offenses and defenses from slow fat people then yes Big 10 was very good. And trust me being a Nebraska fan I know how hard it is to see your team fall from grace and I'll definitely admit it now we still are only mediocre but when you stated that no conference is better than the Big 10 and made a poked about Big 12 I just pointed out the stats including losing all your bowl games to Big 12 opponents this past season.

 
flyinillini98
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Demario
Ohio State is your only team who's had a shot at National title since the BCS. I figured it was pretty much inferred that we are discussing most recent success of the conferences. Yeah if we go back decades when it was ok to build offenses and defenses from slow fat people then yes Big 10 was very good. And trust me being a Nebraska fan I know how hard it is to see your team fall from grace and I'll definitely admit it now we still are only mediocre but when you stated that no conference is better than the Big 10 and made a poked about Big 12 I just pointed out the stats including losing all your bowl games to Big 12 opponents this past season.



I think you're inferring things that aren't there, I've never said "no conference is better than the Big 10", in fact I said the SEC is better than the Big 10. What I said was that you could make a case that the Big 10 is right there with any of the other conferences.

You're being very selective about your stats, what's the Big 10 vs Big 12 bowl record for the last 20 years? Pull that up and then we'll talk.
 
Demario
offline
Link
 
well considering the Big 12 hasn't been around for 20 years that might be a bit difficult ha ha
 
Demario
offline
Link
 
The closest I could do is an all time thing and combining Big 8 and Big 12 since all big 8 teams joined big 12. This does leave out Texas, Texas Tech, Texas A&M and Baylor bowl games prior to the mid 90's so there is already a bonus to big 10

Big 8/Big 12 all time bowl record: Bowls 212 (104-107-1)

Big 10: Bowls 202 (96-105-1)


Hope that satisfies your curiosity.
 
flyinillini98
offline
Link
 
It does, I'm not trying to say Big 10 is better, all I'm trying to say is they're not as bad as people keep trying to make them out to be. Recently they've been on hard times, but hopefully that turns around in the next couple of years.
 
Demario
offline
Link
 
Yeah I mistook your earlier post out of context when I thought after you said SEC is top I took the next few sentences as Big 12 people have issues if they don't see the Big 10 as being better . Big 10 is just the conference that everyone will always dog on. I would compare Big 10 to the Big 12 north division. Teams that have a lot of history, tradition and great fan followings but like Catcher says its just so hard to recruit skill positions to places where the tempatures are just so much colder than Florida and Cali and Texas.
Edited by Demario on Jul 27, 2009 18:06:16
 
Demario
offline
Link
 
You know College football is getting close when the debates start popping up ha ha!!! Anyways good luck in the game here shortly hope its a good 1.
 
catcher_0_3
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Motion15
Go Gatas


Fixed.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KgbBP9Em00A
Edited by catcher_0_3 on Jul 27, 2009 21:02:50
 
dawgs1235
offline
Link
 
beat me to it.

corch urban meyer and percy harvey.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.