User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Anti-World League Thread
Page:
 
billsrule83
offline
Link
 
I thought this thread would be about making a league where you put the 4 worst teams in every Pro League together

So dissapointed
 
Nuge20
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DL24
Well, the main argument here seems to be that Regional rivalries will die because this World League, no? Well then why don't we add the World League as a bonus on top of the Pro Leagues for the top 32 teams(or however many)?

Take the top 32 teams and create this League as another League in addition to the Pro Leagues. Think of it as the Champions League, the way they do it in European soccer. Teams would play scrimmages at set times, just like the Pro Leagues, but against different competition.

Now the problem that my idea poses is will this gameplanning be too much to handle? I think it would be quite a task. But, to counter-act this, Bort could stiffen the requirements for participants and change the structure up. The top 4 in OPL and USAPL wouldn't get in. It would break down fairly, not necessarily evenly.

An idea for participants would be:

APL - 3
USAPL - 7
CPL - 4
EEPL - 4
WEPL - 4
OPL - 3
SEAPL - 4
SAPL - 5

(I'm not saying this would be how the structure would have to be, I'm just demonstrating the general idea that things wouldn't, and shouldn't be even)

As for the structure of the actual game scheduling, things would have to be a little different if teams also played in their regional Pro Leagues. So, Bort would have to decide on how to abbreviate the length of the season in this Pro League. The best option I see for this is, like international soccer tournaments, group stages. There would be 8 groups of 4 teams. These group stages would take place during preseason(?). By this time, the weaker half of the teams will be eliminated. That way, they will not have the burden of unnecessary extra gameplanning for the duration of the season.

The other 16 teams will then have weeks 1-16 to play league games(on top of regional Pro league games), determining seeding for the playoffs. The best 8 teams will advance to the playoffs. The playoff games will be played and a World League Champ will be named.

What do you guys all think? Probably would be too much gameplanning, and is a little all over the place. I just want your guys' thoughts on the general idea of having teams play in both a regional Pro League and the World Pro League.


I REALLY LIKE THIS A LOT
 
blln4lyf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
I agree, we don't need a World League. I was excited at first but the more I think about it, the more I think it wouldn't work.

1) it'll never be fair to everyone
2) it'll invalidate Pro leagues
3) It probably won't even encompass the best teams. If it's 4 of the best teams from every pro league, USA Pro could possibly be better.
4) We already have a tournament of champions, and the PWT which do a pretty good job of international play.


 
DL24
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nuge20
Originally posted by DL24

Well, the main argument here seems to be that Regional rivalries will die because this World League, no? Well then why don't we add the World League as a bonus on top of the Pro Leagues for the top 32 teams(or however many)?

Take the top 32 teams and create this League as another League in addition to the Pro Leagues. Think of it as the Champions League, the way they do it in European soccer. Teams would play scrimmages at set times, just like the Pro Leagues, but against different competition.

Now the problem that my idea poses is will this gameplanning be too much to handle? I think it would be quite a task. But, to counter-act this, Bort could stiffen the requirements for participants and change the structure up. The top 4 in OPL and USAPL wouldn't get in. It would break down fairly, not necessarily evenly.

An idea for participants would be:

APL - 3
USAPL - 7
CPL - 4
EEPL - 4
WEPL - 4
OPL - 3
SEAPL - 4
SAPL - 5

(I'm not saying this would be how the structure would have to be, I'm just demonstrating the general idea that things wouldn't, and shouldn't be even)

As for the structure of the actual game scheduling, things would have to be a little different if teams also played in their regional Pro Leagues. So, Bort would have to decide on how to abbreviate the length of the season in this Pro League. The best option I see for this is, like international soccer tournaments, group stages. There would be 8 groups of 4 teams. These group stages would take place during preseason(?). By this time, the weaker half of the teams will be eliminated. That way, they will not have the burden of unnecessary extra gameplanning for the duration of the season.

The other 16 teams will then have weeks 1-16 to play league games(on top of regional Pro league games), determining seeding for the playoffs. The best 8 teams will advance to the playoffs. The playoff games will be played and a World League Champ will be named.

What do you guys all think? Probably would be too much gameplanning, and is a little all over the place. I just want your guys' thoughts on the general idea of having teams play in both a regional Pro League and the World Pro League.


I REALLY LIKE THIS A LOT


Needs a little ironing out, but the general idea doesn't seem too bad, does it?
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
At first it sounds great! Yeah, World league. If you sit down and start to think about it what will this really accomplish? Its going to funnel teams into one large bracket and cause loss of league identities.

As a long time member of SAPL I love south america. I love the rivalries, the trash talk/banter. If you go with a World League you need to lose the Countries theme and go with one bracket, because that is all it will be. I would be sad to see the Monkeys and Benitos leave SAPL.

Instead of a World League why not just have one tournament that includes 32 teams (or another number) from the Pro leagues every season during your the "Down time". Have a game a day, with a bracket, and the team that wins is GLB's best team.

IMO, a "World League" is just a tricky way of Bort wording "League Restructure" because that is what it really is if it happens.


rivalries? what are you worried about? anyone qualifying for World League is just another loss off of your schedule.
 
Ravenwood
offline
Link
 
When you say "add the World League as a bonus on top of the Pro Leagues", are you suggesting these games be played concurrent with the regular season, and/or playoffs? Or after? If after, how long can you reasonably expect teams that didn't make the playoffs to wait before their next meaningful game? Put another way - how long would the off-season be?
 
blln4lyf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DL24
Originally posted by Nuge20

Originally posted by DL24


Well, the main argument here seems to be that Regional rivalries will die because this World League, no? Well then why don't we add the World League as a bonus on top of the Pro Leagues for the top 32 teams(or however many)?

Take the top 32 teams and create this League as another League in addition to the Pro Leagues. Think of it as the Champions League, the way they do it in European soccer. Teams would play scrimmages at set times, just like the Pro Leagues, but against different competition.

Now the problem that my idea poses is will this gameplanning be too much to handle? I think it would be quite a task. But, to counter-act this, Bort could stiffen the requirements for participants and change the structure up. The top 4 in OPL and USAPL wouldn't get in. It would break down fairly, not necessarily evenly.

An idea for participants would be:

APL - 3
USAPL - 7
CPL - 4
EEPL - 4
WEPL - 4
OPL - 3
SEAPL - 4
SAPL - 5

(I'm not saying this would be how the structure would have to be, I'm just demonstrating the general idea that things wouldn't, and shouldn't be even)

As for the structure of the actual game scheduling, things would have to be a little different if teams also played in their regional Pro Leagues. So, Bort would have to decide on how to abbreviate the length of the season in this Pro League. The best option I see for this is, like international soccer tournaments, group stages. There would be 8 groups of 4 teams. These group stages would take place during preseason(?). By this time, the weaker half of the teams will be eliminated. That way, they will not have the burden of unnecessary extra gameplanning for the duration of the season.

The other 16 teams will then have weeks 1-16 to play league games(on top of regional Pro league games), determining seeding for the playoffs. The best 8 teams will advance to the playoffs. The playoff games will be played and a World League Champ will be named.

What do you guys all think? Probably would be too much gameplanning, and is a little all over the place. I just want your guys' thoughts on the general idea of having teams play in both a regional Pro League and the World Pro League.


I REALLY LIKE THIS A LOT


Needs a little ironing out, but the general idea doesn't seem too bad, does it?


Would need to hire a every other day OC/DC imo. That is a lot of gameplanning.
Edited by blln4lyf on Jul 8, 2009 15:59:22
 
the man of doom
Miracles happen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by the man of doom
1 things that can be overlooked

it will wncourage people to play in leagues like OPL and SEAPL since it might b a little easier to sneakin that way rather than USA and Canada


 
DL24
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by blln4lyf
Would need to hire a every other day OC/DC imo. That is a lot of gameplanning.


Yep, that's the biggest problem. I'd just like to see any ideas that involve keeping teams in regional pro leagues in addition to competing in a world league. Because imo, a world league should be an added bonus.
 
Phantom_Opera
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by blln4lyf
Originally posted by DL24

Originally posted by Nuge20


Originally posted by DL24



Well, the main argument here seems to be that Regional rivalries will die because this World League, no? Well then why don't we add the World League as a bonus on top of the Pro Leagues for the top 32 teams(or however many)?

Take the top 32 teams and create this League as another League in addition to the Pro Leagues. Think of it as the Champions League, the way they do it in European soccer. Teams would play scrimmages at set times, just like the Pro Leagues, but against different competition.

Now the problem that my idea poses is will this gameplanning be too much to handle? I think it would be quite a task. But, to counter-act this, Bort could stiffen the requirements for participants and change the structure up. The top 4 in OPL and USAPL wouldn't get in. It would break down fairly, not necessarily evenly.

An idea for participants would be:

APL - 3
USAPL - 7
CPL - 4
EEPL - 4
WEPL - 4
OPL - 3
SEAPL - 4
SAPL - 5

(I'm not saying this would be how the structure would have to be, I'm just demonstrating the general idea that things wouldn't, and shouldn't be even)

As for the structure of the actual game scheduling, things would have to be a little different if teams also played in their regional Pro Leagues. So, Bort would have to decide on how to abbreviate the length of the season in this Pro League. The best option I see for this is, like international soccer tournaments, group stages. There would be 8 groups of 4 teams. These group stages would take place during preseason(?). By this time, the weaker half of the teams will be eliminated. That way, they will not have the burden of unnecessary extra gameplanning for the duration of the season.

The other 16 teams will then have weeks 1-16 to play league games(on top of regional Pro league games), determining seeding for the playoffs. The best 8 teams will advance to the playoffs. The playoff games will be played and a World League Champ will be named.

What do you guys all think? Probably would be too much gameplanning, and is a little all over the place. I just want your guys' thoughts on the general idea of having teams play in both a regional Pro League and the World Pro League.


I REALLY LIKE THIS A LOT


Needs a little ironing out, but the general idea doesn't seem too bad, does it?


Would need to hire a every other day OC/DC imo. That is a lot of gameplanning.


Too much of a load. My head would explode.
 
Ubasstards
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Phantom_Opera


Too much of a load. My head would explode.


o_O

 
Ubasstards
offline
Link
 
sorry Phantom

 
Link
 
I'm 100% against it. it really invalidates the Pro leagues. Having Pro leagues without their best teams makes them so much less interesting.

If this change happens, the Pro Leagues need to be renamed to just AAAA.

 
DL24
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
I'm 100% against it. it really invalidates the Pro leagues. Having Pro leagues without their best teams makes them so much less interesting.

If this change happens, the Pro Leagues need to be renamed to just AAAA.



Seriously?
 
Ravenwood
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
I'm 100% against it. it really invalidates the Pro leagues. Having Pro leagues without their best teams makes them so much less interesting.

If this change happens, the Pro Leagues need to be renamed to just AAAA.



I agree. Rename the Pros "AAA", and rename "AA" just "A".
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.