I agree. I think the ST needs a tweak altogether because we had this report today, too:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3385107Basically the opposite of what you're reporting. Instead of returning to the Punter, they outrun the PR and let him free. Lol.
It is frustrating to see something not fixed for months at a time. The issue we have at hand is we don't get error logs or any type of access to any code -- so it's much harder to track Bugs. That's why we need as many examples as possible (which it's evident you have a lot here). Some things are just near impossible to track without having access to any type of code or logs -- like the AI not calling correct plays in some instances. I've got a forum of my own made for tracking those Bugs, but I can't even match anything in those. It's a pain to see them exist and have no idea what's causing them.
Anyway, enough rambling.

As I said, I'll give you an update as soon as I can. Does this happen all the time, most of the time, or only a few times vs. how often you punt/return?