User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Canadian AA Leagues > Canada AA #1 > Calling out the Toronto Towers
Page:
 
Rawk02
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by anfiach
Originally posted by Rawk02

or could it be that on a random day a player or team just play like crap and loose to a team they shouldn't you know like what happens in real life? (see: Michigan vs App State)


That could very well be, but it isn't exactly a feature we were told about. I don't have an issue with it if I know to expect the possibility but we are led to believe that games are decided solely on player builds and tactics.


I don't know if I were creating the game it would be one of the first features I programmed and one of the last I told people about.

Now I agree that it is odd that it just so happened now
 
Lappdancer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by anfiach
That could very well be, but it isn't exactly a feature we were told about. I don't have an issue with it if I know to expect the possibility but we are led to believe that games are decided solely on player builds and tactics.


And stamina...and chemistry. If you seriously don't think there is any random factors associated with this game I'm sorry but you are an idiot.
 
Kenshiro
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cybershot
what mystifies me is the glaring difference in the likelihood of an upset during the reg season vs the playoffs.


Is this true after you account for late season boosting? It should be easy enough to check, if you have the stats.

Maybe just based on the scouting report at the time the game played. How many upsets have there been during the playoffs?

I would suspect at least a portion of this is because 1) people notice more in the playoffs 2) lots of teams boost right before the playoffs 3) you're playing better competition in the playoffs. The worst upset possible is 8 over 1, whereas in the regular season, you're also playing 9-16 seeds.
 
Kenshiro
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by anfiach

That could very well be, but it isn't exactly a feature we were told about. I don't have an issue with it if I know to expect the possibility but we are led to believe that games are decided solely on player builds and tactics.


Not true. All the special skills have a random element to them. Any halfway decent simulation will also have a random element to it. If you rerun the simulation 50,000 times, you'll have different results each time and you'll lose some of them.
 
Kenshiro
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by anfiach
I disagree, it just makes your decisions on point distribution more unpredictable in their affect on your game. Say everyone boosts at the end of the season, there's no advantage at all for anyone. Unless it widens the lvl gap between you and your opponent it still relies on your build to win games and teams that already know how their players will perform and can take advantage of that. Players boosting at the end of the season don't have that luxury. Yea you might run faster but maybe you needed more agility to be effective or maybe more strength. Boost at the beginning and you can use the points from levels you gain to correct performance issues. You could try to do that with your boost points at the end of the season but you have no way of knowing if you chose the right attributes to get the affect you wanted so it is more like gambling.


I disagree. There's more information available at the end of the season to make a good build than at the beginning. Even ignoring that, there are fairly sizeable advantages to boosting at the end of the season. It's worth at least a half a level to every player who waits, even more at the lower levels.
Last edited May 29, 2008 11:20:22
 
anfiach
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kenshiro
Originally posted by anfiach


That could very well be, but it isn't exactly a feature we were told about. I don't have an issue with it if I know to expect the possibility but we are led to believe that games are decided solely on player builds and tactics.


Not true. All the special skills have a random element to them. Any halfway decent simulation will also have a random element to it. If you rerun the simulation 50,000 times, you'll have different results each time and you'll lose some of them.


Special skills are part of the build and they are not all random in nature. Also you assume a good simulation will have randomness to it but we are talking about a random element that is not part of regular simulation but an outside element which causes extremes in behavior.
 
Avondell
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kenshiro
Originally posted by anfiach

I disagree, it just makes your decisions on point distribution more unpredictable in their affect on your game. Say everyone boosts at the end of the season, there's no advantage at all for anyone. Unless it widens the lvl gap between you and your opponent it still relies on your build to win games and teams that already know how their players will perform and can take advantage of that. Players boosting at the end of the season don't have that luxury. Yea you might run faster but maybe you needed more agility to be effective or maybe more strength. Boost at the beginning and you can use the points from levels you gain to correct performance issues. You could try to do that with your boost points at the end of the season but you have no way of knowing if you chose the right attributes to get the affect you wanted so it is more like gambling.


I disagree. There's more information available at the end of the season to make a good build than at the beginning. Even ignoring that, there are fairly sizeable advantages to boosting at the end of the season. It's worth at least a half a level to every player who waits, even more at the lower levels.


It makes no sense from an owner's standpoint. As an owner, I want home field for the playoffs so I can make money, build my stadium, and afford to pay my players when they reach higher levels.

It may be clever to wait to boost and try to surprise some teams in the playoffs, but not if it costs you a home field game. Going thru the playoffs as the away team every game isnt doing your team any long run good at all, especially when a single playoff game can be worth well over a million dollars in income to the home team.

So yay! You waited to boost and you won your playoff game. It only cost you a million plus, some stadium upgrades, and a contract when you turn 25.
 
anfiach
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kenshiro
Originally posted by anfiach

I disagree, it just makes your decisions on point distribution more unpredictable in their affect on your game. Say everyone boosts at the end of the season, there's no advantage at all for anyone. Unless it widens the lvl gap between you and your opponent it still relies on your build to win games and teams that already know how their players will perform and can take advantage of that. Players boosting at the end of the season don't have that luxury. Yea you might run faster but maybe you needed more agility to be effective or maybe more strength. Boost at the beginning and you can use the points from levels you gain to correct performance issues. You could try to do that with your boost points at the end of the season but you have no way of knowing if you chose the right attributes to get the affect you wanted so it is more like gambling.


I disagree. There's more information available at the end of the season to make a good build than at the beginning. Even ignoring that, there are fairly sizeable advantages to boosting at the end of the season. It's worth at least a half a level to every player who waits, even more at the lower levels.


Please explain because I don't see any real advantage. More info is available? You are talking about trying to compensate for numerous past failures instead of improving skills that are lagging. The only advantage I see is the perception that the boosted skills will allow you to win and it will be like a surprise victory and no, you won't be gaining more levels if you wait, the difference is negligible. The only real advantage you get is over a player that does not boost at all and that would take several seasons be be significant.
 
Kenshiro
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by anfiach

Please explain because I don't see any real advantage. More info is available? You are talking about trying to compensate for numerous past failures instead of improving skills that are lagging. The only advantage I see is the perception that the boosted skills will allow you to win and it will be like a surprise victory and no, you won't be gaining more levels if you wait, the difference is negligible. The only real advantage you get is over a player that does not boost at all and that would take several seasons be be significant.


Look at the numbers. If you think half to a full level is negligible, then I disagree.

More info is available because you can look at everybody else's builds and see what people are saying in the forums. There's not really enough data to just base decisions on your player.

Avondell has a point about earning home field games. This will be significant in a few seasons. Look at Toronto's stadium compared to the guys in the West...that's going to pay off in a few seasons when equipment costs 100k+ per player.
 
Cybershot
offline
Link
 
Late boosting is great in year one of a player; after that it's negligible. I won't accept that we lost because the late boosters of the acturials gained 450 more XP than my players.
My players still covered them in terms of overall points assigned at game time and overall average level.
The late boosting strategy is not as great as it seems.
 
Cybershot
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kenshiro
Originally posted by anfiach


Please explain because I don't see any real advantage. More info is available? You are talking about trying to compensate for numerous past failures instead of improving skills that are lagging. The only advantage I see is the perception that the boosted skills will allow you to win and it will be like a surprise victory and no, you won't be gaining more levels if you wait, the difference is negligible. The only real advantage you get is over a player that does not boost at all and that would take several seasons be be significant.


Look at the numbers. If you think half to a full level is negligible, then I disagree.

More info is available because you can look at everybody else's builds and see what people are saying in the forums. There's not really enough data to just base decisions on your player.

Avondell has a point about earning home field games. This will be significant in a few seasons. Look at Toronto's stadium compared to the guys in the West...that's going to pay off in a few seasons when equipment costs 100k+ per player.


few seasons? That's next year if you plan on having level 24 guys.
 
Kenshiro
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cybershot
Late boosting is great in year one of a player; after that it's negligible. I won't accept that we lost because the late boosters of the acturials gained 450 more XP than my players.
My players still covered them in terms of overall points assigned at game time and overall average level.
The late boosting strategy is not as great as it seems.


This is true, but you would have covered us by an average of half a level more if we hadn't boosted late. It can be mitigated, but there are also training point advantages to boosting late.

To be honest, I think the Rats and Towers are both better teams than we are, but if we replayed that game 10 times, we'd probably take at least 4. The large advantage both of you had earlier in the season disappeared when most of us boosted.

The Zebra's might actually be better too, but they've made some interesting roster/management decisions.
 
Kenshiro
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cybershot

few seasons? That's next year if you plan on having level 24 guys.


Shh. Don't warn them. I want those guys in the west to be surprised.
 
anfiach
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kenshiro
Originally posted by anfiach


Please explain because I don't see any real advantage. More info is available? You are talking about trying to compensate for numerous past failures instead of improving skills that are lagging. The only advantage I see is the perception that the boosted skills will allow you to win and it will be like a surprise victory and no, you won't be gaining more levels if you wait, the difference is negligible. The only real advantage you get is over a player that does not boost at all and that would take several seasons be be significant.


Look at the numbers. If you think half to a full level is negligible, then I disagree.

More info is available because you can look at everybody else's builds and see what people are saying in the forums. There's not really enough data to just base decisions on your player.

Avondell has a point about earning home field games. This will be significant in a few seasons. Look at Toronto's stadium compared to the guys in the West...that's going to pay off in a few seasons when equipment costs 100k+ per player.

You HAVE to base your decisions off of your player. You can have two players built exactly the same and they won't perform the same in this game because they are not the same they are 2 different guys. That's just an absurd way to look at things.
 
Kenshiro
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by anfiach

You HAVE to base your decisions off of your player. You can have two players built exactly the same and they won't perform the same in this game because they are not the same they are 2 different guys. That's just an absurd way to look at things.


There's not enough data in 3-4 games to credibly figure out if those 5 points of vision really helped you or if it was just randomness in the simulation. If you look at a season's worth of data on players who put 20 extra points into vision compared to guys who put 20 extra points into speed, you might be able to draw some reasonable conclusions.

And then half of it is just guessing and adjusting based on how your player is doing.

You don't think you have a better idea of what stats your players need to improve now than you did at the beginning of the season? You wouldn't change anything?
Last edited May 29, 2008 12:13:51
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.