Originally posted by jlax34
Alabama has to forfeit 21 wins over the last 2 years (pending appeal) and thats it. No future scholarships or anything. Their probabtion just says don't do it again during this time or they are in trouble. Mind you that school is filled with a bunch of cheaters (3rd violation in 10 yrs if memory serves). Not even my SEC pride will allow me to root for those douchebags.
Keep in mind however that the offenders were all brought in during the pre-Saban era. I personally disagree with the forfeiture of the games. The University self policed itself and turned itself in once they got wind of what happened and they suspended the players themselves for 5 games that season while they investigated. All that happened was the book store was giving them books that they in turn gave to their friends to use. The books were all returned at the end of the semester. No money was made and no competitive advantage was gained. The only one's who got screwed was the University since they lost money on the book sales. This was just the NCAA overstepping their bounds yet again to prove they are the big bullies on campus.
What the kids did was wrong. I'll be the first one to admit that. However... punishing the school and the other athletes for something they had no involvement in is petty at best and criminal at worst. Had Bama not suspended the players themselves during the investigation then I could see the penalty but Bama not only suspended the players but even did all the self investigating and turned it into the NCAA itself. All this lame punishment does is show other schools that there is no reason to even police yourself. The NCAA has set a very bad precedent with it's decision in this case.
Alabama has to forfeit 21 wins over the last 2 years (pending appeal) and thats it. No future scholarships or anything. Their probabtion just says don't do it again during this time or they are in trouble. Mind you that school is filled with a bunch of cheaters (3rd violation in 10 yrs if memory serves). Not even my SEC pride will allow me to root for those douchebags.
Keep in mind however that the offenders were all brought in during the pre-Saban era. I personally disagree with the forfeiture of the games. The University self policed itself and turned itself in once they got wind of what happened and they suspended the players themselves for 5 games that season while they investigated. All that happened was the book store was giving them books that they in turn gave to their friends to use. The books were all returned at the end of the semester. No money was made and no competitive advantage was gained. The only one's who got screwed was the University since they lost money on the book sales. This was just the NCAA overstepping their bounds yet again to prove they are the big bullies on campus.
What the kids did was wrong. I'll be the first one to admit that. However... punishing the school and the other athletes for something they had no involvement in is petty at best and criminal at worst. Had Bama not suspended the players themselves during the investigation then I could see the penalty but Bama not only suspended the players but even did all the self investigating and turned it into the NCAA itself. All this lame punishment does is show other schools that there is no reason to even police yourself. The NCAA has set a very bad precedent with it's decision in this case.






























