User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > General Discussion > Politics and Religion > Something about the Bible I honestly want to know
Page:
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by edwardzachary
Originally posted by Krunchy
Originally posted by edwardzachary
#3 Isaac was his first born, his only at the time of that writing. Just like my dad only had 1 kid then he had for more.

Genesis 16:15 "And Hagar bare Abraham a son: and Abram called his son's name, which Hagar bare, Ishmael. "
Genesis 22:2 "Take now thy son, thine only son Isaac, ... and offer him there for a burnt offering. "
So in Genesis 16 he has two sons, but later in Genesis 22 he only has one? Fail.

The Bible doesn't go in chronological order


true... but since isaac was the second son, his mock-sacrifice obviously came after ishmael's birth.

but we also know that ishmael had already been disinherited by that time, so there's absolutely no contradiction here... and that's before dipping into the biblical hebrew to adjudge the word "only" (cf. H3173, יחיד.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
^
stupid smilies.
 
Sureal
offline
Link
 
Captobvious,

Please give me a reference of the objective definition of a Christian that "we" have.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by edwardzachary
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by Krunchy
Originally posted by Catullus 16
you realize there are centuries-old theological counter-arguments to all of those, right?

Ok, so give me them.

you seriously want me to list the reams and reams of almost two millennia worth of theological disputation? far be it from me to say "go do some research", but it doesn't work for you to commit the impossible burden of proof fallacy. start with augustine and work your way down.

Originally posted by Krunchy
The point is that anyone who debates that the Bible is without contradictions and falsehoods is a fool.

except that most christians interpret the bible figuratively... it's only their detractors that presume that a literal reading means anything.

Um...actaully, no. Apparently neither of us knows anything about the other. Did you read my response to the seven "contradictions"?


are you talking to me or krunchy?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by edwardzachary

Originally posted by Krunchy

Originally posted by edwardzachary

#3 Isaac was his first born, his only at the time of that writing. Just like my dad only had 1 kid then he had for more.

Genesis 16:15 "And Hagar bare Abraham a son: and Abram called his son's name, which Hagar bare, Ishmael. "
Genesis 22:2 "Take now thy son, thine only son Isaac, ... and offer him there for a burnt offering. "
So in Genesis 16 he has two sons, but later in Genesis 22 he only has one? Fail.

The Bible doesn't go in chronological order


true... but since isaac was the second son, his mock-sacrifice obviously came after ishmael's birth.

but we also know that ishmael had already been disinherited by that time, so there's absolutely no contradiction here... and that's before dipping into the biblical hebrew to adjudge the word "only" (cf. H3173, יחיד.


Isaac was the first, after his mock sacrifice as you call it, God promised to deliver more to Abraham. As I said, the Bible doesn't go in chronological order
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by edwardzachary

Originally posted by Catullus 16

Originally posted by Krunchy

Originally posted by Catullus 16

you realize there are centuries-old theological counter-arguments to all of those, right?

Ok, so give me them.

you seriously want me to list the reams and reams of almost two millennia worth of theological disputation? far be it from me to say "go do some research", but it doesn't work for you to commit the impossible burden of proof fallacy. start with augustine and work your way down.

Originally posted by Krunchy

The point is that anyone who debates that the Bible is without contradictions and falsehoods is a fool.

except that most christians interpret the bible figuratively... it's only their detractors that presume that a literal reading means anything.

Um...actaully, no. Apparently neither of us knows anything about the other. Did you read my response to the seven "contradictions"?


are you talking to me or krunchy?


You. What makes you think we take everything figuritively?
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by captobvious
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by captobvious
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by captobvious
Originally posted by Sureal
- You used the No True Scotsman fallacy

false.
please read what i wrote to you a few posts back.

False. We do have an objective definition of Christian. A Christian is one who believes in the divinity of Jesus Christ.

so you're saying that non-trinitarians are heretics?
this is exactly my point, you realize.

Non sequiter. Whether Jesus is seen as part of the Trinity, the son of God, or an embodiment of God, he remains divine.


not a non sequitur.

also, i'm quite obviously speaking of the general non-trinitarian position (would you prefer "arianism" instead?) that jesus was not divine.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by edwardzachary
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by edwardzachary
Originally posted by Catullus 16
except that most christians interpret the bible figuratively... it's only their detractors that presume that a literal reading means anything.

Um...actaully, no. Apparently neither of us knows anything about the other. Did you read my response to the seven "contradictions"?

are you talking to me or krunchy?

You. What makes you think we take everything figuritively?


hence the word "most".

and yes, i realize there's a large difference between constructivism and literalism... and i'm aware that biblical literalism isn't technically raw literalism, blahblahblah.
 
corporeal
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by captobvious
Originally posted by Catullus 16

Originally posted by captobvious


Originally posted by Catullus 16


Originally posted by captobvious


Originally posted by Sureal


- You used the No True Scotsman fallacy

false.
please read what i wrote to you a few posts back.

False. We do have an objective definition of Christian. A Christian is one who believes in the divinity of Jesus Christ.


so you're saying that non-trinitarians are heretics?

this is exactly my point, you realize.


Non sequiter. Whether Jesus is seen as part of the Trinity, the son of God, or an embodiment of God, he remains divine.


There were some early sects that ran with the Jesus as man view, but I think the church declared them heretical.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by edwardzachary
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by edwardzachary
Originally posted by Krunchy
Originally posted by edwardzachary
#3 Isaac was his first born, his only at the time of that writing. Just like my dad only had 1 kid then he had for more.

Genesis 16:15 "And Hagar bare Abraham a son: and Abram called his son's name, which Hagar bare, Ishmael. "
Genesis 22:2 "Take now thy son, thine only son Isaac, ... and offer him there for a burnt offering. "
So in Genesis 16 he has two sons, but later in Genesis 22 he only has one? Fail.

The Bible doesn't go in chronological order

true... but since isaac was the second son, his mock-sacrifice obviously came after ishmael's birth.
but we also know that ishmael had already been disinherited by that time, so there's absolutely no contradiction here... and that's before dipping into the biblical hebrew to adjudge the word "only" (cf. H3173, יחיד.

Isaac was the first, after his mock sacrifice as you call it, God promised to deliver more to Abraham. As I said, the Bible doesn't go in chronological order


well now, this is certainly a minority teaching that i've never encountered before.

not only does this fly in the face of the "younger son" trope (jacob/joseph/etc), i'm not sure how it lines up with most of the other surrounding verses. for starters, how do you account for sarah's comments pre-ishmael?

for the record, i'm not challenging you here -- i'm just curious how this interpretation operates.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by edwardzachary

Originally posted by Catullus 16

Originally posted by edwardzachary

Originally posted by Catullus 16

except that most christians interpret the bible figuratively... it's only their detractors that presume that a literal reading means anything.

Um...actaully, no. Apparently neither of us knows anything about the other. Did you read my response to the seven "contradictions"?

are you talking to me or krunchy?

You. What makes you think we take everything figuritively?


hence the word "most".

and yes, i realize there's a large difference between constructivism and literalism... and i'm aware that biblical literalism isn't technically raw literalism, blahblahblah.


What I mean is aside from the parables we take it pretty literal
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by edwardzachary

Originally posted by Catullus 16

Originally posted by edwardzachary

Originally posted by Krunchy

Originally posted by edwardzachary

#3 Isaac was his first born, his only at the time of that writing. Just like my dad only had 1 kid then he had for more.

Genesis 16:15 "And Hagar bare Abraham a son: and Abram called his son's name, which Hagar bare, Ishmael. "
Genesis 22:2 "Take now thy son, thine only son Isaac, ... and offer him there for a burnt offering. "
So in Genesis 16 he has two sons, but later in Genesis 22 he only has one? Fail.

The Bible doesn't go in chronological order

true... but since isaac was the second son, his mock-sacrifice obviously came after ishmael's birth.
but we also know that ishmael had already been disinherited by that time, so there's absolutely no contradiction here... and that's before dipping into the biblical hebrew to adjudge the word "only" (cf. H3173, יחיד.

Isaac was the first, after his mock sacrifice as you call it, God promised to deliver more to Abraham. As I said, the Bible doesn't go in chronological order


well now, this is certainly a minority teaching that i've never encountered before.

not only does this fly in the face of the "younger son" trope (jacob/joseph/etc), i'm not sure how it lines up with most of the other surrounding verses. for starters, how do you account for sarah's comments pre-ishmael?

for the record, i'm not challenging you here -- i'm just curious how this interpretation operates.


What verse(s), chapter, book were her comments?
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by corporeal
Originally posted by captobvious
Non sequiter. Whether Jesus is seen as part of the Trinity, the son of God, or an embodiment of God, he remains divine.

There were some early sects that ran with the Jesus as man view, but I think the church declared them heretical.


after a series of highly politicized councils, yes.

but arianism was still alive and well in the germanic north... and survived in various other forms elsewhere in christendom. following the reformation, it became a mainline in the protestant movement.

it's still a minority position, but it's as old as trinitarianism and has never gone away.
Edited by Catullus 16 on Jun 9, 2009 14:19:48
 
captobvious
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by captobvious

Non sequiter. Whether Jesus is seen as part of the Trinity, the son of God, or an embodiment of God, he remains divine.


not a non sequitur.

also, i'm quite obviously speaking of the general non-trinitarian position (would you prefer "arianism" instead?) that jesus was not divine.


Arianism is not the only non-trinitarian viewpoint, but:

Originally posted by
Arius had a simple formula for explaining how Jesus Christ could be divine—and therefore worthy of worship along with God the Father—even though there is only one God.

http://christianodyssey.com/god/jesusgod.htm
 
captobvious
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sureal
Captobvious,

Please give me a reference of the objective definition of a Christian that "we" have.


Sure. It's called a dictionary.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.