User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Make Carrying Tactics Relevant To Fumble Chance
Page:
 
Link
 
Especially since the defense has been adjusting to catch up to the offensive sided sim for about 3 seasons. After three seasons of training and boosting to stritctly counter power builds this was bound to happen, now it's time for the offense to catch up. I'm really getting tired of the def getting nerfed down while the offense gets a free ride to super human seasons.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
The defense did not catch up, driftinggrifter. Bort changed the sim and nerfed powerbacks because there was a problem with how the sim handled the running game.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
The defense did not catch up, driftinggrifter. Bort changed the sim and nerfed powerbacks because there was a problem with how the sim handled the running game.


Nope, what he did do was add in a repeat play penalty for the stong I exploit. Other than that, the defense has caught up, especially with people not going the route of attribute VA's anymore and going with the situational ones. BLPP, one that you linked up in your example, is proof of that. Up until this season, I have had to try and gameplan against them and they have never really had much of a problem cuz their builds are just that good. Same with any top ranked Pro team.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter
Nope, what he did do was add in a repeat play penalty for the stong I exploit. Other than that, the defense has caught up

Seriously, dude, the more you post all you do is to highlight how clueless you are. No, the repeated play penalty was not the only thing that Bort did to nerf powerbacks. He also decreased the effectiveness of their SAs, raised the balance modifier to make it harder to break more tackles after breaking a first, and many other changes. You don't know what you're talking about regarding the powerback problem and you don't know what you're talking about regarding the current fumbling problem. You're clueless and you keep proving that, so stop embarrassing yourself and just stop posting. Haven't you heard the old saying that it's better to keep your mouth shut and let people think you're ignorant than open your mouth and prove it? You keep proving it over and over again like your mission in life is to make sure everyone knows just how clueless you are.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Originally posted by Bort




Originally posted by Originally posted by itsme4





I don't mind that there are more fumbles but we got no kind of advanced warning before the season.

unless I'm missing something in the changelog.


That's because the meta game changed, not the code. Fumble ability was the same last season, and some players did get quite a few FF's last season, if they built for it.

Tons more people are going with +FF stuff for their defenders than ever before this season, in large part due to the +FF va being more attractive than the +tackle one. It's a bandwagon thing. One guy has success, somebody sees it, copies it, and everyone else does it too. Combine that with ball carriers not getting +15% carrying from VA's and a repeat play penalty which is likely to give you problems when you run the same play multiple times, and the scales turn a bit to where offensive players who were not prepared start feeling it.
Last edited May 1, 2009 08:36:46
 
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by driftinggrifter

Nope, what he did do was add in a repeat play penalty for the stong I exploit. Other than that, the defense has caught up

Seriously, dude, the more you post all you do is to highlight how clueless you are. No, the repeated play penalty was not the only thing that Bort did to nerf powerbacks. He also decreased the effectiveness of their SAs, raised the balance modifier to make it harder to break more tackles after breaking a first, and many other changes. You don't know what you're talking about regarding the powerback problem and you don't know what you're talking about regarding the current fumbling problem. You're clueless and you keep proving that, so stop embarrassing yourself and just stop posting. Haven't you heard the old saying that it's better to keep your mouth shut and let people think you're ignorant than open your mouth and prove it? You keep proving it over and over again like your mission in life is to make sure everyone knows just how clueless you are.


Take your own advice imo and read the quote above. I got plenty more quotes from the almight bort, and I'm sure I will take his word about his game over yours.
 
Link
 
Which goes back to being a build problem.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Originally posted by Bort




Originally posted by Originally posted by Deathblade





Originally posted by Originally posted by Gyuri1






Originally posted by Originally posted by JCJayhawk







Please just leave it the way it is. Let those that need to put more points into carrying and strength do so. This is not a problem for those that have built correctly


If you need lots of strength to prevent multiple fumbles a game, then there will be no more elusive builds. I guess that's ok if it's what people want, but it's what the result would be.



Bort said Carrying is more important than Strength...and I don't think it is a sin to have a player whose sole purpose is to carry the football required to invest in a skill that helps them carry the football. More than first capping it obviously.


100% agree.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by kretchfoop

Multiple fumble games happen in the NFL.

Rarely. No HB in NFL history has ever fumbled five times in a game, and no HB has ever had more than 15 in a season. A fairly significant percentage of HBs in GLB have already exceeded the first and are on pace to obliterate the second.

This is really an easy fix. If experiencing a turnover has no effect on the likelihood of experiencing another turnover, then you don't get these cascade effects and at that point turnover probability actually would be determined by builds.


And how many have had 800+ yard games or 10,000 yard seasons or 12 touchdown games? To compare this to the NFL in this respect and not ask for realism in the other area of a running backs game is ludicrous. It is also ridiculous for morale to have NO EFFECT - why bother with confidence at all? Yeah, yeah, he had 60 confidence. Like I said, turn up the importance of confidence in stopping the cascade, but your suggestion is not something I agree with.



 
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
Originally posted by jdbolick

Originally posted by kretchfoop


Multiple fumble games happen in the NFL.

Rarely. No HB in NFL history has ever fumbled five times in a game, and no HB has ever had more than 15 in a season. A fairly significant percentage of HBs in GLB have already exceeded the first and are on pace to obliterate the second.

This is really an easy fix. If experiencing a turnover has no effect on the likelihood of experiencing another turnover, then you don't get these cascade effects and at that point turnover probability actually would be determined by builds.


And how many have had 800+ yard games or 10,000 yard seasons or 12 touchdown games? To compare this to the NFL in this respect and not ask for realism in the other area of a running backs game is ludicrous. It is also ridiculous for morale to have NO EFFECT - why bother with confidence at all? Yeah, yeah, he had 60 confidence. Like I said, turn up the importance of confidence in stopping the cascade, but your suggestion is not something I agree with.





Check his HB stats for the past few seasons and you will see he averaged 18+ ypc one season and over 7 ypc two other seasons and had a 51 td season as well. Over inflated stats are only good for the offense but if the defense gets overinflated stats ie Sacks and FF's then the sim needs to be fixed
/sigh.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
jdbolick and Tans...a match made in heaven
 
tonylieu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter

Check his HB stats for the past few seasons and you will see he averaged 18+ ypc one season and over 7 ypc two other seasons and had a 51 td season as well. ...
/sigh.


Because in his twisted mind, it rarely that a HB fumbled 5 times in a game, but surely it's a common occurrence that a HB had 18+ ypc. I always try not to call people names on public forums, but hell there's always exception, What a %#$$@!!!!
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.