User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > NERF THE FUMBLES NOW!!!
Page:
 
taurran
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Gyuri1

Originally posted by Phantom_Opera


If the guys have more then 70 in both str & carry and at least 5 in cover up are they fumbling?


So there shouldn't be speed/elusive HBs in GLB? Good to know.

By the way, the complaint here, as far as I can tell, isn't that his guys fumbled some, it's that they fumbled 10+ times in a game with HBs that have over 60 strength/60 carrying. No one thinks that's a little overpowered?

By the way, as satisfying as "fix your build" is to say, particularly when the power HBs were shouting it from the rooftops last season, it is a little disingenuous (especially for those <cough> jrry <cough> who should know that there are times in this game where there is no realistic fix to certain builds) when Bort previously changed the sim to increase the amount of fumbles due to your whining in the past (when he buffed Monster/Big Hit).


Except gyuri, the only RB of mine who has fumbling problems is my Elusive RB who has 30 strength so that's understandable.


Elusive backs are fucked either way they go. Reason being, if you have more than 60 carrying on your elusive back, you'll get run down by every defensive back in the game as you're most likely lacking in other important areas.

Closing speed is ridiculous. You've really got to have 110+ speed to make long breakaways nowadays.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by taurran
Originally posted by jrry32

Originally posted by Gyuri1


Originally posted by Phantom_Opera



If the guys have more then 70 in both str & carry and at least 5 in cover up are they fumbling?


So there shouldn't be speed/elusive HBs in GLB? Good to know.

By the way, the complaint here, as far as I can tell, isn't that his guys fumbled some, it's that they fumbled 10+ times in a game with HBs that have over 60 strength/60 carrying. No one thinks that's a little overpowered?

By the way, as satisfying as "fix your build" is to say, particularly when the power HBs were shouting it from the rooftops last season, it is a little disingenuous (especially for those <cough> jrry <cough> who should know that there are times in this game where there is no realistic fix to certain builds) when Bort previously changed the sim to increase the amount of fumbles due to your whining in the past (when he buffed Monster/Big Hit).


Except gyuri, the only RB of mine who has fumbling problems is my Elusive RB who has 30 strength so that's understandable.


Elusive backs are fucked either way they go. Reason being, if you have more than 60 carrying on your elusive back, you'll get run down by every defensive back in the game as you're most likely lacking in other important areas.

Closing speed is ridiculous. You've really got to have 110+ speed to make long breakaways nowadays.


Meh not really. My Elusive RB could have 60 carrying after 2 level ups and would still have 100+ speed and 90+ agility.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
Originally posted by Phantom_Opera

If the guys have more then 70 in both str & carry and at least 5 in cover up are they fumbling?


So there shouldn't be speed/elusive HBs in GLB? Good to know.

By the way, the complaint here, as far as I can tell, isn't that his guys fumbled some, it's that they fumbled 10+ times in a game with HBs that have over 60 strength/60 carrying. No one thinks that's a little overpowered?

By the way, as satisfying as "fix your build" is to say, particularly when the power HBs were shouting it from the rooftops last season, it is a little disingenuous (especially for those <cough> jrry <cough> who should know that there are times in this game where there is no realistic fix to certain builds) when Bort previously changed the sim to increase the amount of fumbles due to your whining in the past (when he buffed Monster/Big Hit).


Thank you! Somebody has common sense here! I have no problem w/ an increase in fumbles, but not such a drastic one that's completely unrealistic.
 
Phantom_Opera
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
Originally posted by Phantom_Opera

If the guys have more then 70 in both str & carry and at least 5 in cover up are they fumbling?


So there shouldn't be speed/elusive HBs in GLB? Good to know.

By the way, the complaint here, as far as I can tell, isn't that his guys fumbled some, it's that they fumbled 10+ times in a game with HBs that have over 60 strength/60 carrying. No one thinks that's a little overpowered?

By the way, as satisfying as "fix your build" is to say, particularly when the power HBs were shouting it from the rooftops last season, it is a little disingenuous (especially for those <cough> jrry <cough> who should know that there are times in this game where there is no realistic fix to certain builds) when Bort previously changed the sim to increase the amount of fumbles due to your whining in the past (when he buffed Monster/Big Hit).


OK whatever. Just saying I wouldn't freakout about my HB's fumbling if they played against my LB's. I had one of my LB's create 3 consecutive fumbles on KO's all were return for a TD. Something we as a team are gunning for. We changed our EQ and VA's to try and strip the ball.

Actually we started this in the middle of last season, and we are not stopping now. This is our commitment.
Last edited Apr 26, 2009 10:47:00
 
Jason Cash
offline
Link
 
Linebackers have been pumping strength and tackling for 2 season now.. ever since Powerbacks came around and gang tackling didnt work. My LInebackers is sitting on 70 strength and 60 tackling
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Phantom_Opera
Originally posted by Gyuri1

Originally posted by Phantom_Opera


If the guys have more then 70 in both str & carry and at least 5 in cover up are they fumbling?


So there shouldn't be speed/elusive HBs in GLB? Good to know.

By the way, the complaint here, as far as I can tell, isn't that his guys fumbled some, it's that they fumbled 10+ times in a game with HBs that have over 60 strength/60 carrying. No one thinks that's a little overpowered?

By the way, as satisfying as "fix your build" is to say, particularly when the power HBs were shouting it from the rooftops last season, it is a little disingenuous (especially for those <cough> jrry <cough> who should know that there are times in this game where there is no realistic fix to certain builds) when Bort previously changed the sim to increase the amount of fumbles due to your whining in the past (when he buffed Monster/Big Hit).


OK whatever. Just saying I wouldn't freakout about my HB's fumbling if they played against my LB's. I had one of my LB's create 3 consecutive fumbles on KO's all were return for a TD. Something we as a team are gunning for. We changed our EQ and VA's to try and strip the ball.


Yeah because that's normal in football. :rollseyes:
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Painmaker
FWIW, I'll admit that the fumble distribution may have swung too far to the other side of reasonable behavior... seems like a lot of the time when the sim has a "minor" adjustment, some pretty big effects are seen in game results. I think a lot of that may just be because folks need to adjust (equipment, team AI, player tactics, long-term builds, etc) from previously extreme setups, which takes a few games to figure out -- typically 10-12 weeks of the season before the community as a whole figures out how to adapt.


I agree with this (particularly the guardrail to guardrail swings that the sim undergoes with theoretically minor changes), and I expect that Mr. Reliable will become much more attractive for HBs. Though if the only fix to keep multiple fumbles from happening is triple capped strength/carrying and half-filled Cover UP, then I think there is a problem.
 
player66
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jason Cash
Linebackers have been pumping strength and tackling for 2 season now.. ever since Powerbacks came around and gang tackling didnt work. My LInebackers is sitting on 70 strength and 60 tackling


people had this in past seasons and it did nothing that is why lots of D players went for speed, because having high strength really did not cause fumbles. Like poot said a few pages back carrying needs to be the deciding factor in fumbles not strength.
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Also, if the fumbling is going to continue as is, then Bort really ought to have a fair catch option for returners.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
Originally posted by Painmaker

FWIW, I'll admit that the fumble distribution may have swung too far to the other side of reasonable behavior... seems like a lot of the time when the sim has a "minor" adjustment, some pretty big effects are seen in game results. I think a lot of that may just be because folks need to adjust (equipment, team AI, player tactics, long-term builds, etc) from previously extreme setups, which takes a few games to figure out -- typically 10-12 weeks of the season before the community as a whole figures out how to adapt.


I agree with this (particularly the guardrail to guardrail swings that the sim undergoes with theoretically minor changes), and I expect that Mr. Reliable will become much more attractive for HBs. Though if the only fix to keep multiple fumbles from happening is triple capped strength/carrying and half-filled Cover UP, then I think there is a problem.


I think the biggest problem is when bort buffed the monster tackle, I don't think he could forsee that all those seasons of pumping strength and tackling would allow most Defenders to go to power tackling and kill RBs, KRs and PRs.
 
player66
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
Also, if the fumbling is going to continue as is, then Bort really ought to have a fair catch option for returners.


he does, not KOR but punt yes. not an option but they can do it
Last edited Apr 26, 2009 10:50:14
 
Phantom_Opera
offline
Link
 
Yeah some defenses to play to strip the ball. I am out of here. Your team fumbled, I am trying to tell you how to fight back. You will still fumble if all you want to do is whine. It happened to us, we learned from it, applied what we learned on both sides of the ball. Things are getting much better on both sides of the ball for now. I am sure we will still have a few fumbles. GLB isn't just about speed anymore, it is now about strength.

I am out.
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
I think the biggest problem is when bort buffed the monster tackle, I don't think he could forsee that all those seasons of pumping strength and tackling would allow most Defenders to go to power tackling and kill RBs, KRs and PRs.


I agree with this, too, and it was the point I was trying to make in my first post. I think this situation is very similar to what happened with OTs, when Bort made changes to the sim to try and create the results he wanted when builds were already being adjusted. After the builds were properly adjusted, Bort's previous changes became overpowered. This is why the "fix your build" argument has some validity to me, but once Bort has already intervened, fixing the builds may require too much work and lead to a single path for builds where there should be at least a little variety.

 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by player66
Originally posted by Gyuri1

Also, if the fumbling is going to continue as is, then Bort really ought to have a fair catch option for returners.


he does, not KOR but punt yes. not an option but they can do it


I meant something on the individual tactics page so that they could choose to make fair catches more often in particular games/circumstances.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
Originally posted by jrry32

I think the biggest problem is when bort buffed the monster tackle, I don't think he could forsee that all those seasons of pumping strength and tackling would allow most Defenders to go to power tackling and kill RBs, KRs and PRs.


I agree with this, too, and it was the point I was trying to make in my first post. I think this situation is very similar to what happened with OTs, when Bort made changes to the sim to try and create the results he wanted when builds were already being adjusted. After the builds were properly adjusted, Bort's previous changes became overpowered. This is why the "fix your build" argument has some validity to me, but once Bort has already intervened, fixing the builds may require too much work and lead to a single path for builds where there should be at least a little variety.



I guess that's true but I don't want him to make fumbles non existant again.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.