User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > The new section in awards tab
Page:
 
MrMoose
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tater15

Looks like Borts formula takes into account the quality of competition. Inflated stats against bad teams don't seem to count for very much.

Thats a very good thing


So if one team happens to draw a bad interconference opponent and another gets a mediocre one, the guy that drew the bad interconference opponent is penalized in the MVP race?

Also, both teams were even scouting bar wise. Is it fair to penalize my player for being on a good team, or to penalize the rest of the players for being on a good team?

Maybe we shouldn't count the first game of a season, and just count the 15 games within the conference. Since everyone would get to play the bad teams and the good teams, all the stats would count.
 
ufshowboat
I has 7 titles
offline
Link
 
I wish there was a penalty for playing gutted teams... As it stands right now, all the people on the leaderboard have 500 rushing yards.... 11 punt return touchdowns... etc. etc.

Is it hard to completely remove the impact of playing a gutted team? Like games with victories of 50 or 100 points don't count in the formula?

2-3 teams got to play gutted teams and padded stats for the non-conference game, the rest of the teams had a good game and much lower stats of course...

What about mid season gut jobs? Half the league benefits, the other half gets punished....

Why not just take this entire impact out?

Don't get me wrong here.... I love the idea of an MVP race... Its just not going to mean anything if the 255-0 games count for anything at all.... What would stop somebody from going 100% pass or run for their gut games to get their QB / RB more stats... the exploiters will get trophies while others are punished....

Good Luck with this Bort... Great idea... but needs to be implemented better..
 
Jotnar
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mrmattregan
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player_awards.pl?player_id=698657

my qb is #1 in all of the qb spots, yet didn't make the conference mvp race...

Sorry to say, the mvp race is BROKE!


yeah, kinda weird how the MVP race is calculated. Another RB in in y players conference today had the following numbers:

15 attempts/80 yards 1 rec/56.5 yards 3 TDs between the two, and returns

My RB is #2

17 attempts.492 yards 0 receptions 8 TDs no returns

My QB is #3 with better stats than the first RB as well

The first guy lost by 15 points, my team won by 138 points.

So is it setup like the way fame is gained and you get shit for having a blowout? If that is the case then thats bullshit. If it goes on stats, then the difference is apples and oranges here. But when I look at the top 10 its the same shit, some guy on a losing team with low #s is in there. Even my #2 RB had better #s then the rest of these guys, and my #3 RB should be up there too because he had similar #s and did returns.

If you have to be on a bad team to get the MVP award, then you better go back to the drawing board with that formula. Although I know this isnt NFL, but Tom Brady got the MVP when the pats went 16-0, wasnt some scrub on the shitty dolphins. Was Calvin Johnson in the running this year for the MVP in the NFL on the 0-16 lions, not that I know of. Seems to me this MVP is being calculated more on value to team, than actual performance. Even looking at other leagues I have teams in the same theory looks true as well, close wins or loss = mvp votes. Just because a team blows someone out, why should their players get less consideration for an mvp? Just as I said with the Brady example above, the pats ran the score all year and he still got MVP.

from wiki

In sports, a Most Valuable Player (MVP) award is an honor typically bestowed upon the best performing player or players on a specific team, in an entire league, or for a particular contest or series of contests.

Since you are giving league wide MVP awards, doesnt that nulify the team aspect of the definition?




 
ufshowboat
I has 7 titles
offline
Link
 
Oh geez... I see now that there are people who think their numbers actually mean something when they play crappy teams... I guess I understand now why Bort can't exclude these numbers.... people will just complain like the guy above me... "My guy has 1000 yards against a gutted team... why is he not in 1st place!"

So I understand Bort.. You have to deal with that crap... So you're screwed either way
Last edited Apr 25, 2009 21:55:04
 
Jotnar
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ufshowboat
Oh geez... I see now that there are people who think their numbers actually mean something when they play crappy teams... I guess I understand now why Bort can't exclude these numbers.... people will just complain like the guy above me... "My guy has 1000 yards against a gutted team... why is he not in 1st place!"

So I understand Bort.. You have to deal with that crap... So you're screwed either way


We didnt play a gutted team, infact it didnt have a single cpu player, or under leveled player on. It was fucking peewee, so shouldnt everyone be on an even playing field, especially on day 1? Are my players punished because the other team cant gameplan?
 
ufshowboat
I has 7 titles
offline
Link
 
Didn't see that it was pee-wee... waste of time to even talk about
 
blazzinken
offline
Link
 
I think this a great new addition!

Sure has nothing to do with the sim, but its cool to be able to compare to other players
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkus Black


Aww. I miss that little fucker.

You seem like you have a real chip on your shoulder tonight!

I bet your a fan of one of those Shit NFL Teams who has never won a Superbowl, and you realize this year will be no different.
 
Jotnar
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ufshowboat
Didn't see that it was pee-wee... waste of time to even talk about


regardless of whether peewee is a waste of time, doesnt answer to anything I originally stated. Everyone starts remotely even in peewee, aside from cpu teams, it is all relative to higher leagues. Yet when MVP consideration comes in someone who had a close game gets more consideration than someone who had a blowout. Like I said is it our players fault that the opponent cant gameplan pr builds their players like shit?

Maybe if the system cant take in the difference between cpu, gutted, and low level teams, then it shouldnt be implemented. These MVP awards havent even been handed out, and I am already bitching. How is it going to work, are they handed out at the end of the season, to carry over to the next?
 
outus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Eagles_84
What does zero for rank mean? My punter is ranked 0 for conference all punter special teams. http://goallineblitz.com/game/player_awards.pl?player_id=1317591


lol 0. Take the hint?

Also, your build is open.

--

http://goallineblitz.com/game/league.pl?league_id=87&conference_id=173

One SS has 11 tackles, 5 PDs and 9 FFums. The other one has 6 tackles, 2 PDs and 2 FFums. Guess which is on the D MVP list. Curious.



 
ink43
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player_awards.pl?player_id=798084

explain? my guy is number one in rankings but is like 11 levels down from other guys?
 
marcaodl
offline
Link
 
does cupcakes count?

kinda hard to get a good global ranking, when you compare with guyz playing lower leagues.
 
GmanV2
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jotnar
Originally posted by ufshowboat

Oh geez... I see now that there are people who think their numbers actually mean something when they play crappy teams... I guess I understand now why Bort can't exclude these numbers.... people will just complain like the guy above me... "My guy has 1000 yards against a gutted team... why is he not in 1st place!"

So I understand Bort.. You have to deal with that crap... So you're screwed either way


We didnt play a gutted team, infact it didnt have a single cpu player, or under leveled player on. It was fucking peewee, so shouldnt everyone be on an even playing field, especially on day 1? Are my players punished because the other team cant gameplan?


And didn't build their lvl 1s on day 32? to get 18 extra days of training? Whatever dude.

I like the MVPs, something is better than nothing.

Guppy suggested that the stats of games versus the playoff teams count, that way you drop the bottom tier teams off the race, I think it'd be a great solution honestly.
 
jamz
offline
Link
 
This MVP system will crush Epeens everywhere.

Buyer beware.
 
mjpol2000
offline
Link
 
Okay what are the difference between the first three boxes and second three boxes?
Are the first three your standing in the conference as a whole and the second three how you stand against all of the players at your position? If so cool.
One other question, what if you have a zero? My punter is 15-15-0.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player_awards.pl?player_id=1099449
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.