User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > General Discussion > Music > What is it with your fetish in thinking that if they can't perform live, you shouldn't listen to them?
Page:
 
Joshua1207
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by krisdaschwab912
I haven't heard all of their studio recordings, but the ones I've heard (roughly 10-15 songs) is quite hit or miss, mostly the latter.


Probably heard their later stuff then.. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=li30NxCsJ7w This song is awesome, from their Lonesome Crowded West album. (older album, made in like 1998?)
Last edited Apr 22, 2009 21:57:19
 
LoveGoose
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks
Originally posted by eb45

Originally posted by Goose the Redeemer


The Mona Lisa is a picture of a face and nothing more. There is not really any deeper, intrinsic meaning to the painting. It's pretty devoid of a real artistic statement too, yet it's considered the greatest work of visual art ever.


Except it's the mystery behind that deeper, intrinsic meaning, including whether or not it exists that makes it the greatest work of visual art ever.

Also, I will now only answer to "lollable douchehead".


Goose is a robot. He doesn't comprehend art and human emotion or any correlation between the two.


Whaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa????????????

Why do you think I want my first kiss to be framed in a flowery meadow with the spring breeze blowing through our hair as the out of body view spins around us in our loving grasp, lighted by a magenta sunset in the distance?

Because I comprehend the correlation between art and human emotion.
Last edited Apr 22, 2009 22:05:12
 
LoveGoose
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by krisdaschwab912
Also, Goose, what the fuck is with your username? LoveGoose sounds even trollier than Goose The Redeemer. It's like Bernie Madoff trying to change his name; we'll still know who you are.


Goose the Redeemer was a bad name from a religious perspective. It was making a false Idol of myself.

LoveGoose is nice because I believe love is very important and is something we should all strive to understand and share. Also, from a subconscious state, seeing "LoveGoose" over and over might eventually trick your brain into telling you to love Goose.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by LoveGoose
Originally posted by krisdaschwab912

Also, Goose, what the fuck is with your username? LoveGoose sounds even trollier than Goose The Redeemer. It's like Bernie Madoff trying to change his name; we'll still know who you are.


Goose the Redeemer was a bad name from a religious perspective. It was making a false Idol of myself.

LoveGoose is nice because I believe love is very important and is something we should all strive to understand and share. Also, from a subconscious state, seeing "LoveGoose" over and over might eventually trick your brain into telling you to love Goose.


no.
 
Link
 
there's just something better about a band that can play their music great live
that's better then a band that is bad live but has good albums...
 
LoveGoose
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rjk16
Originally posted by LoveGoose
LoveGoose is nice because I believe love is very important and is something we should all strive to understand and share. Also, from a subconscious state, seeing "LoveGoose" over and over might eventually trick your brain into telling you to love Goose.
no.


Don't think of a black cat.

You thought of one eh?

That's because "think of a black cat" was in there.
 
Joshua1207
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by LoveGoose
Originally posted by rjk16

Originally posted by LoveGoose

LoveGoose is nice because I believe love is very important and is something we should all strive to understand and share. Also, from a subconscious state, seeing "LoveGoose" over and over might eventually trick your brain into telling you to love Goose.
no.


Don't think of a black cat.

You thought of one eh?

That's because "think of a black cat" was in there.


LoveGoose is a weird name though. I won't love you, Goose
 
Excl
offline
Link
 
No point in having a favorite band that you never get to see
 
Chris LeDoux
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks
Originally posted by Goose the Redeemer

Originally posted by Joshua1207


Modest Mouse preforms better live. They need more live albums lol.


The best of the best usually perform better live because of the emotion they transcend. Prince, Bon Jovi, Garth Brooks. They're all better live, but this is obviously an elite of the elite thing.

The reasoning behind it is that the version which the record label or whoever wants to release in studio is what it is, but it's not perfect or grandiose. These guys can go out there and do better than what was allowed or preferred in studio. Throw on the crowds and emotion like Bones is talking about and you can see how it's possible.


Not true at all. Sometimes the best live performances come from unknown bands. And lol at Garth Brooks transcending emotion.


He's actually pretty damn good live. Took a page out of Chris LeDoux's book, without totally ripping him off. I wish I'd made it to his 2007 concerts in KC, the video of that is just amazing.
 
LoveGoose
offline
Link
 
PRJ apparently doesn't think songs about unanswered prayers, coming to acceptance of a broken heart or making passionate love to a lonely widow are emotional. Rather PRJ lives off the emotion one can only feel from skanking, breaking people's arms in a mosh, skateboarding and "being hardcore."
 
Bushido Zin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gracehoper
Originally posted by Bushido Zin

separating art from artist is a futile, stupid effort that only serves to diminish both.


Separating art from artist is the only possible way to have any discourse on art.


maybe if you suck ass at it, but you kill art by putting it in a vacuum
 
Gracehoper
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bushido Zin

maybe if you suck ass at it


Really? This is what you got, "if you suck ass at it"? I suspect that you already know that all modern art criticism (even the theories that demand to put art in a certain context like Marxist theory or New Historicism) have the separation of art and artist at their fundament. If not you just need to read up on the last 90 years of art theory (starting with formalism and onwards).

 
DDJSoDope :3
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by LoveGoose
Originally posted by rjk16

Originally posted by LoveGoose

LoveGoose is nice because I believe love is very important and is something we should all strive to understand and share. Also, from a subconscious state, seeing "LoveGoose" over and over might eventually trick your brain into telling you to love Goose.
no.


Don't think of a black cat.

You thought of one eh?

That's because "think of a black cat" was in there.


I didn't.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by LoveGoose
PRJ apparently doesn't think songs about unanswered prayers, coming to acceptance of a broken heart or making passionate love to a lonely widow are emotional. Rather PRJ lives off the emotion one can only feel from skanking, breaking people's arms in a mosh, skateboarding and "being hardcore."


What's your point?
 
EmpYllek
offline
Link
 
Goose you really want to know why?

Listen to Knights of Cydonia by Muse. Studio is kind of meh. Live is just incredible. After doing that if you dont agree with me then youre obviously trolling.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.