User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > A way to allow for users to have some say over height at creation, while adding dynamic weight change and doing away with the "Reroll" method of generating starting attributes
Page:
 
the doors1
offline
Link
 
yea but there should be restrcitions. Like no 7' 6" Wr that weights 325 lbs and runs a 4.3 40
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by the doors1
yea but there should be restrcitions. Like no 7' 6" Wr that weights 325 lbs and runs a 4.3 40


Did you look at the chart? No position comes anywhere near that height.

While I don't think weight should limit speed, it should most deifnitely limit acceleration, the ability to change direction and the amount of stamina it takes to maintain that top speed.
 
BellyCheck
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by BellyCheck

I stopped in on the thread b/c I've got a ridiculously light LB... but shouldn't strength get you a weight gain over time? I would say it should probably, to be realistic, go from your "birth" as a draftee through the fill-out process. If you think of a kid coming out of college, as he hits the weight room you can often get weight up, over several seasons, 20 lbs of muscle mass. I don't think it makes sense that through working out your guy will gain more than that, but why not make 3 points of added strength equal to 1 pound of weight, up to a max of 20 lbs? So up to your first 60 *natural* strength points added (i.e., not equipment points), you can add weight. Cap it at 300 (if you ask me,) because your seriously heavy lineman types are more likely to need to lose non-lean mass (blubber) than pump up their weight through lifting.

I hope this wasn't discussed along the way along with the original suggestion. I read about a page then realized we were on exactly the same page, but different paragraphs.

Belly

Edit - or relate it to ONLY strength points gained through training, and make it a pound per point.


You will still gain weight as your strength exceeds your stamina by more and more, effectively achieving the same thing


I think you're much more invested in the initial roll; correct me if I'm wrong. It looks like the suggestion is thought through in terms of tradeoffs. So far so good.

But moving forward there is absolutely no realism-based reason for someone who gains muscle mass through lifting, to lose stamina, particularly if said player is putting in road work as well. You end up rewarding low stamina and making a class of player who enjoys weight advantages but gets tired easily. This is not always the case, in fact, once you're past linemen it seems unlikely to ever be the case. Improving my stamina should not make me lose weight unless I'm lardy to begin with... if I'm lean and lifting, as I'd argue is the model for anybody in the secondary, receivers, and backs -- as well as many linebackers -- this would not be what I would expect. Terrell Owens or David Boston did not lose weight when they packed on muscle, but did not have to lose their stamina as a result. Thigh muscles are heavier than cottage cheese.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by BellyCheck
Originally posted by drifter

Originally posted by BellyCheck


I stopped in on the thread b/c I've got a ridiculously light LB... but shouldn't strength get you a weight gain over time? I would say it should probably, to be realistic, go from your "birth" as a draftee through the fill-out process. If you think of a kid coming out of college, as he hits the weight room you can often get weight up, over several seasons, 20 lbs of muscle mass. I don't think it makes sense that through working out your guy will gain more than that, but why not make 3 points of added strength equal to 1 pound of weight, up to a max of 20 lbs? So up to your first 60 *natural* strength points added (i.e., not equipment points), you can add weight. Cap it at 300 (if you ask me,) because your seriously heavy lineman types are more likely to need to lose non-lean mass (blubber) than pump up their weight through lifting.

I hope this wasn't discussed along the way along with the original suggestion. I read about a page then realized we were on exactly the same page, but different paragraphs.

Belly

Edit - or relate it to ONLY strength points gained through training, and make it a pound per point.


You will still gain weight as your strength exceeds your stamina by more and more, effectively achieving the same thing


I think you're much more invested in the initial roll; correct me if I'm wrong. It looks like the suggestion is thought through in terms of tradeoffs. So far so good.

But moving forward there is absolutely no realism-based reason for someone who gains muscle mass through lifting, to lose stamina, particularly if said player is putting in road work as well. You end up rewarding low stamina and making a class of player who enjoys weight advantages but gets tired easily. This is not always the case, in fact, once you're past linemen it seems unlikely to ever be the case. Improving my stamina should not make me lose weight unless I'm lardy to begin with... if I'm lean and lifting, as I'd argue is the model for anybody in the secondary, receivers, and backs -- as well as many linebackers -- this would not be what I would expect. Terrell Owens or David Boston did not lose weight when they packed on muscle, but did not have to lose their stamina as a result. Thigh muscles are heavier than cottage cheese.


That's a good point...
 
tokas87
offline
Link
 
It's a good idea but if you let people customize their player eventually there's going to be a perfected formula for each position and everyone's players are going to be the same
 
skau
offline
Link
 
just let us choose the Height/Weight..

I dont care about the effect.. just hate seing a HB over 6'0 and under 200 Lbs
 
Minarets36
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tokas87
It's a good idea but if you let people customize their player eventually there's going to be a perfected formula for each position and everyone's players are going to be the same


That's the one thing I worry about when thinking about replacing the roll feature.
 
Hugestballs
offline
Link
 
+1, height and weight are important in football, they should be important in GLB.

I think everyone is pretty ambivalent about the rerolling thing because the scripts have gotten pretty mature at this point, so they're basically putting the points wherever they want anyways.
 
Kazmo
offline
Link
 
This is a great idea!

did I just epicly bump this? my bad
 
Gongadan
offline
Link
 
Something along these lines really does need to be implemented.

1) Assigning points instead of rolling: This would be far less frustrating for players, would mean that it would be realistic to make characters using a browser other than Firefox, and would SIGNIFICANTLY reduce server load on day 31 of the season.

2) Height: If we give both advantages and disadvantages to being taller and to being shorter, I think we should start people at the league average and then let them spend points to go up or down. Getting shorter and gaining points would lead to some goofy min-maxing for a lot of positions where being short is perceived to be an advantage or unimportant.

3) Weight: I disagree with the way you're calculating weight as a ratio of STR/STA related to 3*height. I like the idea, I just disagree with the formula. First, Ht*3 is a straight-line function; an average-build 6'7" guy is a hell of a lot more than 30 pounds heavier than an average build 5'9" guy. Second, early in a center's career, many players will jack up the STR to 60 without spending many, if any, points on STA. That would lead to some pretty extreme weights until the stamina came back in line. For this part, I think an additive formula related to str, stamina and agility would work better.

Here is a possible formula we could use related to Ht^2. This is only an example, could be tweaked a lot:
Weight = Height * Height / 26 * (1+MODIFIER)
MODIFIER = (STR * 3 - STA - AGI) / 300

So for examples:
The base weight for a 5'10" player would be about 188 lb. (Ht*3 yields 210)
The base weight for a 6'0" player would be about 199 lb. (Ht*3 yields 216)
The base weight for a 6'3" player would be about 216 lb. (Ht*3 yields 225)
The base weight for a 6'7" player would be about 240 lb. (Ht*3 yields 237)

So figure a bulky center with 90 STR, 40 AGI, 45 STA: MODIFIER would be (270 - 40 - 50)/300 = 0.6. If he was 6'3", that would be yield a weight of about 346.

Now look at a lean WR with 40 STR, 80 AGI, 45 STA: MODIFIER would be (120 - 80 - 45)/300 = -0.3. If he was 6'3", that would yield about 212lbs.

We could play around with the formula some more, but using Height squared (or even cubed) in the formula for weight would probably yield more realistic results, and having some sort of factor based on STR-STA (and maybe AGI) instead of STR/STA would keep the more extreme builds from having wildly unrealistic results.

4) Instead of using points to affect Height, we could always leave a roller in for that. Or just let people pick. To be honest, though, I'd support my #2 or even your idea for how to develop height more than leaving in a roller.
 
MessorLord
offline
Link
 
I like this they should make height and weight a factor as far as play goes.
 
KCChiefsMan
offline
Link
 
I kind of like it, but a lot of super slow builders would make a team of everyone really tall and heavy and be able to really dominate later on.
 
Gongadan
offline
Link
 
Well, as he stated, weight would be controlled by stats. You could modify your height at character creation, but it would cost you some points (so you'd always be a few SPs behind other players at your level) and height probably shouldn't be such a huge factor that a 6'5" receiver will dominate a 6'2" receiver of otherwise equivalent stats.
 
MessorLord
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gongadan
Well, as he stated, weight would be controlled by stats. You could modify your height at character creation, but it would cost you some points (so you'd always be a few SPs behind other players at your level) and height probably shouldn't be such a huge factor that a 6'5" receiver will dominate a 6'2" receiver of otherwise equivalent stats.


More like tall receivers dominate the short corners and safeties
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Seems pretty implemented to me...locking and de-epicing.
Edited by pottsman on Dec 5, 2009 14:12:48
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.