User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Free for All > I can haz refund??
Page:
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1

Or crappy builds. Come on gart, I know what your LBs look like.


Heh, as of midway through last season.

If over 70/70 strength/tackling BASE isn't good enough to give up less than 4 yards on almost every SI slam, well then...

Refund please!
 
Mr. Me2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gart888
Originally posted by silenthatred

Originally posted by Gart888


I disagree.

In any case, there should be a system in place that punishes teams for doing the same thing over and over again, so the whole falling forward for extra yards thing being overpowered should be a moot point.

To deal with the cheese issue, he'll tone down the run blocking and the falling forward to the point where passing is much more effective. Next season we'll see teams running a handful of pass plays 90+% of the time.

Fix the core issue Bort, not just this season's favorite way to exploit the core issue.


So basically what we are saying is, make the casual leagues the John Madden style pick your play from a pre-created playbook, and then with real teams, create your own from scratch with the play creators? As a DC, I'd have no problem with that.


Huh? I wasn't saying that at all. (I don't think)

What i'm trying to say is that teams should be rewarded for using large playbooks by punishing teams for using smaller ones.

In the current system using 3 plays is just as effective as 30 (see: Monmouth Evil Monkeys).


So play recognition.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by silenthatred
Originally posted by islander1

Originally posted by Gart888


Also, if he really is admitting that the current cheese running is his fault and not ours, doesn't that make us at least somewhat entitled to a refund?


clicked for compensation.

although by my interpretation, cheese doesn't imply exploit. It just means he finally admits that maybe letting teams run the same play 40 times + in a game is something he should fix. I mean no one called the single back slam or strong I OT spamming cheese.

oh wait.

bottom line is, if you have a run defense worth a crap, you can stop the strong I. Don't believe me?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=455350
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=455018

Cincinnati = high quality defense. We only got 3 yards a carry against them.


3ypc isn't bad. That's about where the bar is. If you are at 3ypc or better running, factoring in sacks and other TFLs, you probably had a decent day. And in both of those games, Cincinnati still lost. Not only that, both games had a +100 yard rusher, one was even +250. Not exactly what I would call stopping anything.


let's see. They lost to the best team in the game in OT.
They also barely lost to us. I'd say that's proof nothing is broken now. At least no more broken then the past 5 seasons where everyone said things were 'so glorious'.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gart888
Originally posted by islander1


Or crappy builds. Come on gart, I know what your LBs look like.


Heh, as of midway through last season.

If over 70/70 strength/tackling BASE isn't good enough to give up less than 4 yards on almost every SI slam, well then...

Refund please!


70 stamina too, right?
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by silenthatred
Originally posted by Gart888

Originally posted by silenthatred


Originally posted by Gart888



I disagree.

In any case, there should be a system in place that punishes teams for doing the same thing over and over again, so the whole falling forward for extra yards thing being overpowered should be a moot point.

To deal with the cheese issue, he'll tone down the run blocking and the falling forward to the point where passing is much more effective. Next season we'll see teams running a handful of pass plays 90+% of the time.

Fix the core issue Bort, not just this season's favorite way to exploit the core issue.


So basically what we are saying is, make the casual leagues the John Madden style pick your play from a pre-created playbook, and then with real teams, create your own from scratch with the play creators? As a DC, I'd have no problem with that.


Huh? I wasn't saying that at all. (I don't think)

What i'm trying to say is that teams should be rewarded for using large playbooks by punishing teams for using smaller ones.

In the current system using 3 plays is just as effective as 30 (see: Monmouth Evil Monkeys).


So play recognition.


If coded properly, yup.
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by Gart888

Originally posted by islander1



Or crappy builds. Come on gart, I know what your LBs look like.


Heh, as of midway through last season.

If over 70/70 strength/tackling BASE isn't good enough to give up less than 4 yards on almost every SI slam, well then...

Refund please!


70 stamina too, right?


Nah, they're only around the first cap in stamina, but they always end their games at 90+ so i don't think that's the issue.

Maybe LBs can get a special play intensity setting of:
Extra Hard - Don't suck dick while on the playing field, but use up even more energy.
 
Mr. Me2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ravenwood
Originally posted by silenthatred

An exploit only becomes an exploit when exploited.


Stopped reading right there. I suppose ebola only becomes dangerous once it's a pandemic?


No, the proper comparison to ebola would be a disease. It's a disease weather it's a pandemic or not. If there was a gentlemen's agreement not to run the SI slam 90% of the time between two teams, lets just pick Dryden and Halifax, and say they didn't do it to each other repeatedly, would there be an exploit? Sure it is there, but it's harmless if not being used repeatedly. I don't think there is a time when ebola is anywhere and harmless when used only slightly.
 
Ravenwood
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by silenthatred
Originally posted by Ravenwood

Originally posted by silenthatred


An exploit only becomes an exploit when exploited.


Stopped reading right there. I suppose ebola only becomes dangerous once it's a pandemic?


No, the proper comparison to ebola would be a disease. It's a disease weather it's a pandemic or not. If there was a gentlemen's agreement not to run the SI slam 90% of the time between two teams, lets just pick Dryden and Halifax, and say they didn't do it to each other repeatedly, would there be an exploit? Sure it is there, but it's harmless if not being used repeatedly. I don't think there is a time when ebola is anywhere and harmless when used only slightly.


Fundamentally, you and I agree, and I believe we're both on the same side of this debate. But realistically, you are expecting a bunch of 14-year olds who are consumed with the "win at all costs" attitude to act like gentlemen. Unfortunately, that's simply not going to happen.
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by silenthatred
Originally posted by Ravenwood

Originally posted by silenthatred


An exploit only becomes an exploit when exploited.


Stopped reading right there. I suppose ebola only becomes dangerous once it's a pandemic?


No, the proper comparison to ebola would be a disease. It's a disease weather it's a pandemic or not. If there was a gentlemen's agreement not to run the SI slam 90% of the time between two teams, lets just pick Dryden and Halifax, and say they didn't do it to each other repeatedly, would there be an exploit? Sure it is there, but it's harmless if not being used repeatedly. I don't think there is a time when ebola is anywhere and harmless when used only slightly.


So... you're blaming the agents morals and not the state of the sim? >_>
 
Mr. Me2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by silenthatred

Originally posted by islander1


Originally posted by Gart888



Also, if he really is admitting that the current cheese running is his fault and not ours, doesn't that make us at least somewhat entitled to a refund?


clicked for compensation.

although by my interpretation, cheese doesn't imply exploit. It just means he finally admits that maybe letting teams run the same play 40 times + in a game is something he should fix. I mean no one called the single back slam or strong I OT spamming cheese.

oh wait.

bottom line is, if you have a run defense worth a crap, you can stop the strong I. Don't believe me?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=455350
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=455018

Cincinnati = high quality defense. We only got 3 yards a carry against them.


3ypc isn't bad. That's about where the bar is. If you are at 3ypc or better running, factoring in sacks and other TFLs, you probably had a decent day. And in both of those games, Cincinnati still lost. Not only that, both games had a +100 yard rusher, one was even +250. Not exactly what I would call stopping anything.


let's see. They lost to the best team in the game in OT.
They also barely lost to us. I'd say that's proof nothing is broken now. At least no more broken then the past 5 seasons where everyone said things were 'so glorious'.


That just means they can almost SI slam at MEM's level, but aren't quite there yet. Giving up 265 yards rushing in a game period, let a lot to one player, is not stopping the run as you said. Letting one player run for 100 yard vs. you in real football, your chances of winning go down unless you can do the same or better. If you give up over 200+ on the ground to one or more players, you can pretty much count on losing.
 
Lazer Noble
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ravenwood
Originally posted by silenthatred

An exploit only becomes an exploit when exploited.


Stopped reading right there. I suppose ebola only becomes dangerous once it's a pandemic?


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aX6XMIldkRU
 
Mr. Me2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gart888
Originally posted by silenthatred

Originally posted by Ravenwood


Originally posted by silenthatred



An exploit only becomes an exploit when exploited.


Stopped reading right there. I suppose ebola only becomes dangerous once it's a pandemic?


No, the proper comparison to ebola would be a disease. It's a disease weather it's a pandemic or not. If there was a gentlemen's agreement not to run the SI slam 90% of the time between two teams, lets just pick Dryden and Halifax, and say they didn't do it to each other repeatedly, would there be an exploit? Sure it is there, but it's harmless if not being used repeatedly. I don't think there is a time when ebola is anywhere and harmless when used only slightly.


So... you're blaming the agents morals and not the state of the sim? >_>


Nope, that would be blaming them both.
 
Mr. Me2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gart888
Originally posted by silenthatred

Originally posted by Gart888


Originally posted by silenthatred



Originally posted by Gart888




I disagree.

In any case, there should be a system in place that punishes teams for doing the same thing over and over again, so the whole falling forward for extra yards thing being overpowered should be a moot point.

To deal with the cheese issue, he'll tone down the run blocking and the falling forward to the point where passing is much more effective. Next season we'll see teams running a handful of pass plays 90+% of the time.

Fix the core issue Bort, not just this season's favorite way to exploit the core issue.


So basically what we are saying is, make the casual leagues the John Madden style pick your play from a pre-created playbook, and then with real teams, create your own from scratch with the play creators? As a DC, I'd have no problem with that.


Huh? I wasn't saying that at all. (I don't think)

What i'm trying to say is that teams should be rewarded for using large playbooks by punishing teams for using smaller ones.

In the current system using 3 plays is just as effective as 30 (see: Monmouth Evil Monkeys).


So play recognition.


If coded properly, yup.


I'd like that. I'd also like custom playbooks only.
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by silenthatred
Originally posted by Gart888

Originally posted by silenthatred


Originally posted by Ravenwood



Originally posted by silenthatred




An exploit only becomes an exploit when exploited.


Stopped reading right there. I suppose ebola only becomes dangerous once it's a pandemic?


No, the proper comparison to ebola would be a disease. It's a disease weather it's a pandemic or not. If there was a gentlemen's agreement not to run the SI slam 90% of the time between two teams, lets just pick Dryden and Halifax, and say they didn't do it to each other repeatedly, would there be an exploit? Sure it is there, but it's harmless if not being used repeatedly. I don't think there is a time when ebola is anywhere and harmless when used only slightly.


So... you're blaming the agents morals and not the state of the sim? >_>


Nope, that would be blaming them both.


Right, and i'd like a system in place where agents aren't at fault for running the best game plan available to them. Having people who want to win at all costs policing themselves is ridiculous.

When two of the top teams in a good pro league have to agreed to use Basic AI, full playbooks and preset run %s to actually get a decent sim, you know things aren't working as intended.

Season 8 refund please.
 
Mr. Me2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gart888
Originally posted by silenthatred

Originally posted by Gart888


Originally posted by silenthatred



Originally posted by Ravenwood




Originally posted by silenthatred





An exploit only becomes an exploit when exploited.


Stopped reading right there. I suppose ebola only becomes dangerous once it's a pandemic?


No, the proper comparison to ebola would be a disease. It's a disease weather it's a pandemic or not. If there was a gentlemen's agreement not to run the SI slam 90% of the time between two teams, lets just pick Dryden and Halifax, and say they didn't do it to each other repeatedly, would there be an exploit? Sure it is there, but it's harmless if not being used repeatedly. I don't think there is a time when ebola is anywhere and harmless when used only slightly.


So... you're blaming the agents morals and not the state of the sim? >_>


Nope, that would be blaming them both.


Right, and i'd like a system in place where agents aren't at fault for running the best game plan available to them. Having people who want to win at all costs policing themselves is ridiculous.

When two of the top teams in a good pro league have to agreed to use Basic AI, full playbooks and preset run %s to actually get a decent sim, you know things aren't working as intended.

Season 8 refund please.


I'd love that too. I agree the inmates are running the asylum, and it's the situation they were put in that allowed this to happen. Expecting them to police themselves is ridiculous. But they are not without blame.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.