User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Repetitive plays: More it's run, more likely the defensive is to stop it.
Page:
 
BansheeTime
offline
Link
 
Just 2 days ago, a team ran the Strong I HB Slam for an entire drive. Sure, we scouted and knew what was coming, but that doesn't help my little dots on defense. The offense is already powerful enough; this would help the defense to matchup against those gameplanners who use overpowered exploit plays to try and win. I'm all for winning, and if using your running game will get you there, then I'm all for it. Running the same play over and over because you know your opponent physically cannot stop it is just disrespectful.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
First of all, before this could be implemented, the playbooks would need to get a little bigger but my thought was that there needs to be a penalty to running the same play 40+ times a game.

My thoughts on a solution would be say a Offense Runs a Strong I right play 10 times in a row(just an example), well on the 11th play the defense would shift right and have the players in position to stuff it just like NFL teams do. They might also get a boost to attributes mattering on how many times in a play has been run.

I was thinking this would be a good team because it would stop teams from running the same play over and over again because it's an exploit and add strategy to GLB. Some teams might purposely try to run the same play over and over again to get the shift so they could comeback with a play to the other side...this would also give teams a reason to run the ball left. Teams rarely run it left, by having teams shift right, they could get big yards doing a run to the left side after quite a few right side runs. If anyone else have something to add on or a great idea on how to stop this problem, go oh ahead. What do you guys think?
 
aliuking
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by aliuking

I don't like the idea much at all because it isn't like we have a lot to choose from when it comes to offensive plays

That is just nonsense. If people run the same crap over and over, it's because they choose to. Most of my offensive AI has 8+ inputs per situation, meaning I don't even know what our offense is going to run. There are plenty of plays to choose from, some are just more commonly used than others.


There isn't many plays period from each formation, that is what I am talking about. And even less plays with teams that are strong against certain formations. Especially if you want to run the ball. Now if you scout a team and see that a team struggles with a certain formation then I don't see the problem of using that formation. I don't mind guarding against extreme overuse (every play) but if you see that it works and is mixing it in with other plays, it would be wrong to penalize a team for that.
 
Menamino
offline
Link
 
So is there any progress on this? I didn't see this thread because it was buried on this page, so I made my own suggestions thread in the main forum which was of course immediately locked: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2320174

I think the idea of a vision bonus after 10 or 15 versions of the same play being run is absolutely necessary. I don't like the idea of it altering the team's AI to better defend the play though. That takes actual gameplanning out of the equation.

I set up our defensive playbook at the beginning of this season to be diverse and have 3 or 4 plays to defend every formation/situation. The main idea being that there may be one offensive play that beats one of my defensive plays, but then 2 of the other defensive plays would beat that offensive play, and so on. Basically meaning that one team couldn't run the same play all game and be consistently successful.

That of course has been murdered by the strong I hb slam abuse this season, which can't be consistently stopped by anything. So in the thread I posted, near the bottom I suggested that for the same PASS play 10-15+ times, the defense would get a +vision bonus, and for the same RUN play 10-15% times, the defense would get a +block shedding boost.

That doesn't alter the AI at all, yet makes the individual players better equipped to stop the same exact play they've seen 60 times in a game rather than act just as dumbfounded as the first time.

I see this thread has been open a week, has there been any progress made? We have mods who lock threads within a minute of them being made but can't make critical game updates that are ruining the game for thousands over the course of a month?
 
Xar
offline
Link
 
Problem being, if you did this offences could exploit knowing full well there would be no penalty for 2 plays and on the 3rd the D sets up to stop that play and you play from the same formation but different play and absolutely screw the D.
 
whitewolf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Menamino

I see this thread has been open a week, has there been any progress made? We have mods who lock threads within a minute of them being made but can't make critical game updates that are ruining the game for thousands over the course of a month?


Easy there, killer. The mods don't make game updates, that's pretty much just Bort. And do you really expect a major sim update to happen in 7 days? If you do, I think you need to realign your expectations. At best, I would expect something like this to be put in over the offseason. And the thread was locked appropriately, there is no reason to have multiple threads saying the same thing, especially when this one is already in Epic.
Last edited Mar 19, 2009 23:25:02
 
Menamino
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xar
Problem being, if you did this offences could exploit knowing full well there would be no penalty for 2 plays and on the 3rd the D sets up to stop that play and you play from the same formation but different play and absolutely screw the D.


Well that's why a straight up attribute bonus would be the best way to solve it. No actual altering of the team's AI, just a boost to the individual players.

Originally posted by
Easy there, killer. The mods don't make game updates, that's pretty much just Bort. And do you really expect a major sim update to happen in 7 days? If you do, I think you need to realign your expectations. At best, I would expect something like this to be put in over the offseason. And the thread was locked appropriately, there is no reason to have multiple threads saying the same thing, especially when this one is already in Epic.


I know, it's just that when we have so many people testing this game, for the apparent "good of the game", I'd like to see in season results and changes much faster than in the past. We already had drastic midseason changes this season, especially to the passing game, which were much needed and well done. Why can't we make this change as well?

Take for example my team's most recent game. We won by the way, so this isn't sour grapes, it's just an example of why this game is losing luster for many and fast: http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=375355

That team runs strong I hb inside all game every game, and everyone knows it. We set up our strong I defense to never respect the pass, to blitz both safeties almost all the time, and for our entire DL to be STR heavy and focused on stopping the run. I know these guys, I like them, and we've been in the same league for multiple seasons. But I also know they've never beaten us in the past and we have a distinct talent advantage. So taking all of that into account, the result of them running 60 strong I HB slams when we knew they were coming: 250.5 yards, 4.2 YPC, 41 points.

There's something seriously wrong with that. And for that reason, I don't think you'd find any sane person who would complain about a change like the ones suggested in this thread being implemented before the playoffs this season.
 
Xar
offline
Link
 
Dive For Yardage. That is why they do well every play.
 
jktooley
offline
Link
 
Not going to read through all of this.... But the idea I had....

run 10 times - +5% attribute boost across the board for defense when facing that play again

run 20 Times - +10% attribute boost across the board for defense when facing that play again

run 30 Times - +20% attribute boost across the board for defense when facing that play again....
 
Xar
offline
Link
 
Offense can fool defense. It's part of the game. Run Strong I all day, you can still have 6 different plays, rushes and passes. The defense can only guess by formation and situation.

Say a team runs Strong I HB Slam 10 times, the Defense gets a +5% bonus to that play. Offense lines up again in Strong I, defense thinks its a HB Slam, but it's actually a TE Out. TE is free as dogs balls and takes it to the house. Defense gets screwed by assuming a play. And that is all an offense has to do.

You would have to make the attribute cover all plays from that formation, which really limits the offense. The main idea of having multiple plays from one set is to trick the defense. Take this away, and you then have no variety for the offense. Otherwise, you have a defense which is so switched on to one play from one formation, it gets raped if another play from that formation is played out.
Last edited Mar 20, 2009 18:29:34
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Menamino
I don't think you'd find any sane person who would complain about a change like the ones suggested in this thread being implemented before the playoffs this season.


I seriously laughed at this. You must not understand the userbase at all.
 
Randy03Texags
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jktooley
Not going to read through all of this.... But the idea I had....

run 10 times - +5% attribute boost across the board for defense when facing that play again

run 20 Times - +10% attribute boost across the board for defense when facing that play again

run 30 Times - +20% attribute boost across the board for defense when facing that play again....


Yep thats close to what I think as well .. you need a +% all attributes as a scaling factor

It could be a +1% per time the play is run, that would be reasonable, you could run it 10 times and not notice a difference, but by 30 times, you would likely really notice, would it be too late by then? Thats a good question.

If you really wanted to force people to open up their playbooks .. a +2% per incident would work I figure that would amount to

5 times = 10%
10 times = 20%
20 times = 40% (I figure that would cut this crap out real quick)
30 times = 60% bonus
40 times = 80% bonus (doubt it would get this far then, only out of fear if anything)
 
buckeyes33
offline
Link
 
i would like this:

ran 5 times in a row- +10% vision, +5% speed
ran 10 times in a row- +25% vision, +10% speed, +10% agility, +5% tackling
ran 20 times in a row- +50% vision, +25% speed, +25% agility, +20% tackling
ran 50 times in a row- +100% vision, +50% speed, +50% agility, +50% tackling, +10% to every other attribute including punting


if you can't stop that play by then, you should just put your head down. especially with the +10% to punting
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Still think a flat increase to attributes is a dumb way to go about it.
 
wessimo
offline
Link
 

At the very least, D vision should increase significantly after the same play is run 5-10 times.

Great idea, make it happen.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.