User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Cbucks
offline
Link
 
The slaves who were caught in the north, weren't the caught by slave catchers from the south or were those northerners? I think it was just southerner slave catchers, which the south didn't put that law out for capturing slaves until.....I can't remember

I'm also pretty sure there weren't any slaves in the north, because they're labeled as the free states and the south states were labeled the slave states.

I know, that was a major reason the Civil War started, and was going on after the formation of the U.S. all the states wanted to go off on their own, but there were others who wanted to keep the federal government. But that was ripple upon the Civil War.


I do realize that Lee was against slavery, and I'm pretty sure it's common knowledge that he only joined the South, because Virginia seceded from the Union. Though West Virginia didn't really secede, I mean yes they seceded from Virginia, but they stated with the Union, which they were originally apart of.

Secession can be good for the right reasons, but then again secession can be bad for the wrong reasons. I feel the southerner secession was bad because they were leaving because they were angry with the north, who didn't have the same goals as them. The South was farmers, and rich plantation owners, and the north was bankers, manufacturers. The plantation owners relied on slavery for their industry, which may have not been the main reason for the war, but in the public it is probably the most known reason for the war. But, it can be proven that the north didn't care that much about slavery (only the abolitionists), which goes along the lines of WWII, the Holocaust had been going on for a while, and England and France didn't go to war with Germany until Germany attacked Poland.

I mean yes he should have pride in his ancestors who fought and died. I just can't support the Confederate Flag because the first thing that comes to my mind when I see that flag is the institution of slavery.
 
redneckjake
offline
Link
 
See.....the funny thing about the whole idea of not supporting the Confederate Flags because of slavery, is that the Confederate flag represented a country that existed for 4 years. The Stars and Stripes......our U.S. flag represents a country that has been around for over 2 centuries. A country that stood for slavery for 100 years. So, how does your argument have a valid point? You say the Confederacy was a foreign nation......the U.S. is a foreign nation to this land, taken from the original inhabitants. Being labeled a "Free" state did not mean a state didn't allow or have slavery......it's a fact that the Northern states very much depended on slaves. Maybe not as much as the southern plantations, but they had them. And if you just HAVE to be against the Confederate flag, the one I fly was the BATTLE flag.....it was flown in battle to distinguish the Confederates from the Union boys. It didn't fly over the Confederate Capital as the National flag. It was a representation of the good men who fought for the southern side......so if you want to hate a flag based on slavery, hate the American flag and the Confederate national flag, but not the one that, regardless of what any jaded blind to history fools think, represents ONLY the men who fought.
 
masheen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cbucks
The slaves who were caught in the north, weren't the caught by slave catchers from the south or were those northerners? I think it was just southerner slave catchers, which the south didn't put that law out for capturing slaves until.....I can't remember

I'm also pretty sure there weren't any slaves in the north, because they're labeled as the free states and the south states were labeled the slave states.

I know, that was a major reason the Civil War started, and was going on after the formation of the U.S. all the states wanted to go off on their own, but there were others who wanted to keep the federal government. But that was ripple upon the Civil War.


I do realize that Lee was against slavery, and I'm pretty sure it's common knowledge that he only joined the South, because Virginia seceded from the Union. Though West Virginia didn't really secede, I mean yes they seceded from Virginia, but they stated with the Union, which they were originally apart of.

Secession can be good for the right reasons, but then again secession can be bad for the wrong reasons. I feel the southerner secession was bad because they were leaving because they were angry with the north, who didn't have the same goals as them. The South was farmers, and rich plantation owners, and the north was bankers, manufacturers. The plantation owners relied on slavery for their industry, which may have not been the main reason for the war, but in the public it is probably the most known reason for the war. But, it can be proven that the north didn't care that much about slavery (only the abolitionists), which goes along the lines of WWII, the Holocaust had been going on for a while, and England and France didn't go to war with Germany until Germany attacked Poland.

I mean yes he should have pride in his ancestors who fought and died. I just can't support the Confederate Flag because the first thing that comes to my mind when I see that flag is the institution of slavery.


It was a totally different atmosphere in those days. The South was fighting for stronger state government and weaker federal government. And again, in those days, people identified with their state of birth more than being an American citizen. You talk about secession being good in some cases and bad in others. That's obvious, but who decides when it was good or bad? At the time, the Southerners believed they were right and had the right to secede. And yes, West Virginia seceded from Virginia, that's how they stayed in the Union. Same thing almost happened in Western Kentucky and Western Tennessee. Didn't happen because Tennessee seceded, which left the Southern leaning Kentuckians on their own. Did you know Kentucky actually declared Neutrality in the Civil War, and only joined the North when invaded by the Confederacy at Columbus, Kentucky? Slavery wasn't abolished in the north, there was just no demand for slave labor. Labor in the north was provided by immigrant workers in the factories. If Northerners were so opposed to slavery, they should have mandated that slaves that made it to Northern states were free. Did they? No. Matter of fact, one way they tried to resolve slavery was sending all slaves back to Africa (Liberia) and only at the end of the Civil War did they pass the 13th amendment.
 
jdpbernal
offline
Link
 
Wow! I never thought that I could take history and law lessons on a thread created by Bloodtown!!!
Keep it up guys!

 
corycipra
offline
Link
 
lol
 
Cbucks
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by redneckjake
See.....the funny thing about the whole idea of not supporting the Confederate Flags because of slavery, is that the Confederate flag represented a country that existed for 4 years. The Stars and Stripes......our U.S. flag represents a country that has been around for over 2 centuries. A country that stood for slavery for 100 years. So, how does your argument have a valid point? You say the Confederacy was a foreign nation......the U.S. is a foreign nation to this land, taken from the original inhabitants. Being labeled a "Free" state did not mean a state didn't allow or have slavery......it's a fact that the Northern states very much depended on slaves. Maybe not as much as the southern plantations, but they had them. And if you just HAVE to be against the Confederate flag, the one I fly was the BATTLE flag.....it was flown in battle to distinguish the Confederates from the Union boys. It didn't fly over the Confederate Capital as the National flag. It was a representation of the good men who fought for the southern side......so if you want to hate a flag based on slavery, hate the American flag and the Confederate national flag, but not the one that, regardless of what any jaded blind to history fools think, represents ONLY the men who fought.


The Civil War started because Lincoln went into office who was against the EXPANSION OF SLAVERY beyond the states that already had slavery, that was clearly a start to end slavery. Thus the Southern States seceded because the Union was going against what they wanted, SLAVERY.

Yes you could say that the United States stood for slavery, but I'm pretty sure slaves were only owned by the rich, and mostly by people in the SOUTH. As I've said before the northerners were bankers manufacturers ,etc, they did NOT NEED SLAVES. Yes "Free" state did meant there were no slaves, they either PROHIBITED OR BANNED slavery in the FREE STATES. No the North didn't greatly rely on slaves, like i said those were the manufacturers who relied on immigrants from Germany and Ireland for work instead. You could say that the North relied on slavery for the cotton produced by the South, but then again they were openly against it, there were LITTLE OR NO slaves in the north. Most of the slaves were in the SOUTH.

" It was a representation of the good men who fought for the southern side" Men who fought for the southern side which was for Slavery. They didn't have to fight for the south, they could have easily gone and fought for the North. Even after the Civil War, during the Civil Rights movement most of the hate and attacks on African Americans were in the SOUTH. You keep trying to put it back on the North, well they didn't stop slavery until...the North was openly against slavery and most northern states either PROHIBITED OR BANNED slavery.

One more thing, say your ancestors were Nazi Soldiers who fought for a nation that killed over 10 million people(i think, this is including everyone they killed not just the jewish people). Would openly support the Nazi Battleflag or the Swastika for the so called brave soldiers who fought for their country. FUCK NO, those men fought for a country based on killing a helpless minority, they knew what was going on and they could have been like the other germans who tried to assassinate Hitler.
 
corycipra
offline
Link
 
Blah Blah Blah this is getting old and not even worth reading anymore, where is bloodtown? I bet he has something smart to say.
 
Cbucks
offline
Link
 
you'd think by now he want to chip in
 
redneckjake
offline
Link
 
Yeah, I don't even care anymore.......this whole thing has got really old. The fact is, regardless of what anyone else thinks or says I am 75% Native American and was raised in that culture...hence the name "redneck"jake (I'm not a hillbilly countrified white boy), and since my ancestors fought under that flag I will always fly it. I'm sure slavery sucked for the black man, but it's never been a big deal to me....Natives often didn't even get the privilege of being enslaved. Its a flag....what it means to me may be different than what it is to you, and thats just fine. Its nice to argue with people smarter than Bloodtown, but everyone has their own opinion. Different cultures look at history in different ways, so I can't say I'm right but I know how I feel about the past.
 
Cbucks
offline
Link
 
And that's why we live in the United States of America. You can believe what you want, say what you want, (most of the time).
 
maddvirus
offline
Link
 
And I missed all the enjoyable convos all season long...damn
 
redneckjake
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cbucks
And that's why we live in the United States of America. You can believe what you want, say what you want, (most of the time).


Yeah....."most of the time" as you say. Since Bush's whole "freedom listening" thing, eavesdropping on terrorists though.......is the gov't reading the goallineblitz.com forums, gathering evidence against us all? Maybe the Secret Service busted Bloodtown's door down and he's being tortured at this very moment for being a wannabe. Spooky to think about! Lol........just joking, Mr. President!
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.