User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Europe East > Myself and some of the guys from season 7's EEBBB expansion started a forum to keep track of the best overalls to start off expansion seasons.
Page:
 
Kenshinzen
online
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Back on topic, like I said scouting report bars are not the best determiner of who the best team is. They can give you a rough estimate as a 45 is going to be better than a 30...but just because someone has a 45 doesn't mean they are better built than a 42 because certain things aren't taken into consideration by the bars or effect the bars less.(like a strength DE boosts the bar A LOT more then a speed DE)


Agreed with that. A team with 45 overall is not always better than a team with 42 overall but almost most of the times is better than one with 36-39.

 
aird88
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by aird88

OMG, everyone needs to just chill out, it's just a game. It's supposed to be fun, but when agents starting getting all emotional and crying it makes me not want to play with you guys. Please people grow up and lets stop talking about stupid crap and talk about the good things in life, like the Mayhem walking away with the league championship trophy this season.


I'm taking my ball and going home.


Back on topic, like I said scouting report bars are not the best determiner of who the best team is. They can give you a rough estimate as a 45 is going to be better than a 30...but just because someone has a 45 doesn't mean they are better built than a 42 because certain things aren't taken into consideration by the bars or effect the bars less.(like a strength DE boosts the bar A LOT more then a speed DE)


Correct my point exactly. Thank you much and Godzirra you were the one straying away from topic. What do you think Godzirra, do you think that scouting bars are determined by the type of build of player or not?
 
Godzirra
offline
Link
 
I do, and I think they definitely determined by the type of build. And for the most part you can tell the type of build from them... I.E. speed or possession receivers. And unless someone has a hundred SA's or 0 SA's at lvl 40, they are a pretty good indication of build quality. Jrry32 is correct when he says that bars don't take into account SA's. But you have to say "on the average" you can go by scouting bars to judge builds. There is a span for each overall so a player at a 51 overall, could be better than another at 51. You can dump a few levels worth of points into stats and still not move the scouting bar. So there is a grey area. But again, bars under "normal" circumstances are a pretty good indication of how a player is built and how well a player is built.

A couple points before the usual ahole trolls come around..

1. I said "usual" circumstances.
2. I'm talking player scouting bars... NOT team scouting bars.

Just my opinion... which has been pretty accurate for me in the past.
Last edited Feb 22, 2009 07:46:43
 
aird88
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Godzirra
I do, and I think they definitely determined by the type of build. And for the most part you can tell the type of build from them... I.E. speed or possession receivers. And unless someone has a hundred SA's or 0 SA's at lvl 40, they are a pretty good indication of build quality. Jrry32 is correct when he says that bars don't take into account SA's. But you have to say "on the average" you can go by scouting bars to judge builds. There is a span for each overall so a player at a 51 overall, could be better than another at 51. You can dump a few levels worth of points into stats and still not move the scouting bar. So there is a grey area. But again, bars under "normal" circumstances are a pretty good indication of how a player is built and how well a player is built.

A couple points before the usual ahole trolls come around..

1. I said "usual" circumstances.
2. I'm talking player scouting bars... NOT team scouting bars.

Just my opinion... which has been pretty accurate for me in the past.


With offensive lineman who have more agility than strength such as most OTs will have lower blocking bars than those with more strength. So a lower bar means better pass protection and a higher bar means more run blocking skill because higher strength means more pancakes and higher agility allows you to pickup the speedy DEs and those quick OLBs.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Godzirra
I do, and I think they definitely determined by the type of build. And for the most part you can tell the type of build from them... I.E. speed or possession receivers. And unless someone has a hundred SA's or 0 SA's at lvl 40, they are a pretty good indication of build quality. Jrry32 is correct when he says that bars don't take into account SA's. But you have to say "on the average" you can go by scouting bars to judge builds. There is a span for each overall so a player at a 51 overall, could be better than another at 51. You can dump a few levels worth of points into stats and still not move the scouting bar. So there is a grey area. But again, bars under "normal" circumstances are a pretty good indication of how a player is built and how well a player is built.

A couple points before the usual ahole trolls come around..

1. I said "usual" circumstances.
2. I'm talking player scouting bars... NOT team scouting bars.

Just my opinion... which has been pretty accurate for me in the past.


Agreed for the most part but don't forget eq. I had a WR with a 60 receiving bar and like a 54 carrying bar last year which makes you think, he's a possesion guy...well with eq. he was actually more of a speedster so if people know how to use eq. then they can manipulate the bars. But yes, as a whole they are a decent determiner of what type of player a guy is.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by aird88
Originally posted by Godzirra

I do, and I think they definitely determined by the type of build. And for the most part you can tell the type of build from them... I.E. speed or possession receivers. And unless someone has a hundred SA's or 0 SA's at lvl 40, they are a pretty good indication of build quality. Jrry32 is correct when he says that bars don't take into account SA's. But you have to say "on the average" you can go by scouting bars to judge builds. There is a span for each overall so a player at a 51 overall, could be better than another at 51. You can dump a few levels worth of points into stats and still not move the scouting bar. So there is a grey area. But again, bars under "normal" circumstances are a pretty good indication of how a player is built and how well a player is built.

A couple points before the usual ahole trolls come around..

1. I said "usual" circumstances.
2. I'm talking player scouting bars... NOT team scouting bars.

Just my opinion... which has been pretty accurate for me in the past.


With offensive lineman who have more agility than strength such as most OTs will have lower blocking bars than those with more strength. So a lower bar means better pass protection and a higher bar means more run blocking skill because higher strength means more pancakes and higher agility allows you to pickup the speedy DEs and those quick OLBs.


Usually yes but not always, it goes back to the eq. thing I was talking about:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=142505
63 blocking bar...but Tarik is one of GLB's best PASS Blockers.
 
Air18
offline
Link
 
Ratings mean nothing.
 
aird88
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by aird88

Originally posted by Godzirra


I do, and I think they definitely determined by the type of build. And for the most part you can tell the type of build from them... I.E. speed or possession receivers. And unless someone has a hundred SA's or 0 SA's at lvl 40, they are a pretty good indication of build quality. Jrry32 is correct when he says that bars don't take into account SA's. But you have to say "on the average" you can go by scouting bars to judge builds. There is a span for each overall so a player at a 51 overall, could be better than another at 51. You can dump a few levels worth of points into stats and still not move the scouting bar. So there is a grey area. But again, bars under "normal" circumstances are a pretty good indication of how a player is built and how well a player is built.

A couple points before the usual ahole trolls come around..

1. I said "usual" circumstances.
2. I'm talking player scouting bars... NOT team scouting bars.

Just my opinion... which has been pretty accurate for me in the past.


With offensive lineman who have more agility than strength such as most OTs will have lower blocking bars than those with more strength. So a lower bar means better pass protection and a higher bar means more run blocking skill because higher strength means more pancakes and higher agility allows you to pickup the speedy DEs and those quick OLBs.


Usually yes but not always, it goes back to the eq. thing I was talking about:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=142505
63 blocking bar...but Tarik is one of GLB's best PASS Blockers.


He is almost level 50. Of course his bar is going to be that high. Actually that is somewhat average for a decently built player.. My level 16 OT has a blocking bar of 51 already. If your blocking bar was any lower than 63 then I would say he was a crappy built OT. I agree with equipment to an extent, but that is only good at later levels. Right now equipment won't give as much of a boost as it does at level 48. So it rarely makes a difference.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by aird88
Originally posted by jrry32

Originally posted by aird88


Originally posted by Godzirra



I do, and I think they definitely determined by the type of build. And for the most part you can tell the type of build from them... I.E. speed or possession receivers. And unless someone has a hundred SA's or 0 SA's at lvl 40, they are a pretty good indication of build quality. Jrry32 is correct when he says that bars don't take into account SA's. But you have to say "on the average" you can go by scouting bars to judge builds. There is a span for each overall so a player at a 51 overall, could be better than another at 51. You can dump a few levels worth of points into stats and still not move the scouting bar. So there is a grey area. But again, bars under "normal" circumstances are a pretty good indication of how a player is built and how well a player is built.

A couple points before the usual ahole trolls come around..

1. I said "usual" circumstances.
2. I'm talking player scouting bars... NOT team scouting bars.

Just my opinion... which has been pretty accurate for me in the past.


With offensive lineman who have more agility than strength such as most OTs will have lower blocking bars than those with more strength. So a lower bar means better pass protection and a higher bar means more run blocking skill because higher strength means more pancakes and higher agility allows you to pickup the speedy DEs and those quick OLBs.


Usually yes but not always, it goes back to the eq. thing I was talking about:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=142505
63 blocking bar...but Tarik is one of GLB's best PASS Blockers.


He is almost level 50. Of course his bar is going to be that high. Actually that is somewhat average for a decently built player.. My level 16 OT has a blocking bar of 51 already. If your blocking bar was any lower than 63 then I would say he was a crappy built OT. I agree with equipment to an extent, but that is only good at later levels. Right now equipment won't give as much of a boost as it does at level 48. So it rarely makes a difference.


LOL at you saying my build is average. Your level 16 OT has a blocking bar 51, let me guess he has no speed or agility.(I am estimating a speed of 12 and agility at 16)

 
madet0rder
offline
Link
 
Scouting bars mean nothing tbh.
 
Godzirra
offline
Link
 
They don't mean "nothing" if you know what you are looking at.

They may not mean "everything"... but the definitely mean "something". And anyone that thinks they mean "nothing" is clueless.

There actually private forums dedicated to the "reading" of scouting bars... and the formulas that make them up. If a person thinks they mean "nothing" then they are not a good judge of players and probably shouldn't scout.

Even Jrry32 who says scouting bars don't mean everything, responded to aird88 a couple posts ago about a blocking bar for a level 16 being at 51... must have speed of 12 and agility of 16.

How did he do this? By rolling a 20 sided dice? By reading his wifes palm? No, it was he has a pretty decent idea of what bars should look like for certain level players.

So anyone that thinks bars mean "nothing" suffers from rectal-cranial inversion.

Nuff said on this subject, because you can lead a horse to water... but you can't make him get his head out of his butt.
Last edited Feb 22, 2009 20:29:38
 
aird88
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by aird88

Originally posted by jrry32


Originally posted by aird88



Originally posted by Godzirra




I do, and I think they definitely determined by the type of build. And for the most part you can tell the type of build from them... I.E. speed or possession receivers. And unless someone has a hundred SA's or 0 SA's at lvl 40, they are a pretty good indication of build quality. Jrry32 is correct when he says that bars don't take into account SA's. But you have to say "on the average" you can go by scouting bars to judge builds. There is a span for each overall so a player at a 51 overall, could be better than another at 51. You can dump a few levels worth of points into stats and still not move the scouting bar. So there is a grey area. But again, bars under "normal" circumstances are a pretty good indication of how a player is built and how well a player is built.

A couple points before the usual ahole trolls come around..

1. I said "usual" circumstances.
2. I'm talking player scouting bars... NOT team scouting bars.

Just my opinion... which has been pretty accurate for me in the past.


With offensive lineman who have more agility than strength such as most OTs will have lower blocking bars than those with more strength. So a lower bar means better pass protection and a higher bar means more run blocking skill because higher strength means more pancakes and higher agility allows you to pickup the speedy DEs and those quick OLBs.


Usually yes but not always, it goes back to the eq. thing I was talking about:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=142505
63 blocking bar...but Tarik is one of GLB's best PASS Blockers.


He is almost level 50. Of course his bar is going to be that high. Actually that is somewhat average for a decently built player.. My level 16 OT has a blocking bar of 51 already. If your blocking bar was any lower than 63 then I would say he was a crappy built OT. I agree with equipment to an extent, but that is only good at later levels. Right now equipment won't give as much of a boost as it does at level 48. So it rarely makes a difference.


LOL at you saying my build is average. Your level 16 OT has a blocking bar 51, let me guess he has no speed or agility.(I am estimating a speed of 12 and agility at 16)



Actually he has a lot higher agility than that, but I can't tell you for the games sake. Lets just say that he is well equiped
 
madet0rder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Godzirra
They don't mean "nothing" if you know what you are looking at.

They may not mean "everything"... but the definitely mean "something". And anyone that thinks they mean "nothing" is clueless.

There actually private forums dedicated to the "reading" of scouting bars... and the formulas that make them up. If a person thinks they mean "nothing" then they are not a good judge of players and probably shouldn't scout.

Even Jrry32 who says scouting bars don't mean everything, responded to aird88 a couple posts ago about a blocking bar for a level 16 being at 51... must have speed of 12 and agility of 16.

How did he do this? By rolling a 20 sided dice? By reading his wifes palm? No, it was he has a pretty decent idea of what bars should look like for certain level players.

So anyone that thinks bars mean "nothing" suffers from rectal-cranial inversion.

Nuff said on this subject, because you can lead a horse to water... but you can't make him get his head out of his butt.


Calm down sir, it was a joke.
 
cowtesticles2001
udder pressure
offline
Link
 
........lol....
 
Godzirra
offline
Link
 
I am calm. Just because I respond to someone that doesn't agree with me, doesn't mean I'm not calm. So don't get sand in your vagina.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.