User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Solution to Test Server Issue - Please do not Delete/Lock - Serious Idea
Page:
 
James1985
offline
Link
 
^^^^^
That post shows you....THERE IS NO ADVATAGE. It is Impossible to tell.
Last edited Feb 15, 2009 20:26:09
 
Diamonddog
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dmfa41
"Silly Beta, tests are for kids!"

Even if this happened - full test server access - I don't think I would use it. Kinda kills the fun of the game for me, in my opinion.


Shit, I don't have the time to do it...
 
GG
offline
Link
 
I only just read about ServerGate. Still trying to read thru the other threads.

Re-specing is a must now. Just one thing that ought to be done just to heal, and then as others suggested, carrying forward with transparency, listing the Testers and making public the results of all testing etc.
Last edited Feb 15, 2009 21:02:17
 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by James1985
^^^^^
That post shows you....THERE IS NO ADVATAGE. It is Impossible to tell.


James, this thread is not the thread where we are discussing 'if there is an advantage' to being on the test server, that is the other thread with 187 pages..

If you want to debate whether or not there is an advantage of being on the test server etc... Please go there and do it...
there are plenty of people who agree and disagree with you, and if you read the last 20-30 pages (or any 20-30 pages in a row actually) , as well as the OP you will get an idea of the sentiment

This thread is to discuss my solution to this perceived problem of test servers.

If you truly feel there is no advantage of being on the test server, than my 'solution' (the topic of this thread) should not in any way bother you, you should support it...as more testers would be better...and being on a testing server (according to you) leads to no changes or gain of knowledge...

If you have any input on SPECIFICALLY the idea of allowing all users access to the test server, feel free to post here...

If you don't like the idea, state why....If you are in favor, state why....etc....

Last edited Feb 15, 2009 21:11:35
 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
I only just read about ServerGate. Still trying to read thru the other threads.

Re-specing is a must now. Just one thing that ought to be done just to heal, and then as others suggested, carrying forward with transparency, listing the Testers and making public the results of all testing etc.


Thanks for the comment GG, but please try and keep this thread to JUST the idea of allowing everyone access to the test servers (or not) and whether or not you are in favor of it and why...etc..

I would love to hear your opinion on it...
 
The Tempest
offline
Link
 
My suggestion is that everyone stops complaining about everything. Never in my life have I heard so many people whine, about something that is minuscule as this.

 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Tempest
My suggestion is that everyone stops complaining about everything. Never in my life have I heard so many people whine, about something that is minuscule as this.



Actually this isnt a complaint thread....I am not complaining here, I am making a suggestion to get rid of all of the complaining actually...(and I think it would work!)

I would love to know whether or not you think my idea would accomplish this, rather than have you come in and derail the topic..(with your hypocritical complaining about people who complain, i might add)

Thanks.
Last edited Feb 15, 2009 21:10:21
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mantis7
Originally posted by GG

I only just read about ServerGate. Still trying to read thru the other threads.

Re-specing is a must now. Just one thing that ought to be done just to heal, and then as others suggested, carrying forward with transparency, listing the Testers and making public the results of all testing etc.


Thanks for the comment GG, but please try and keep this thread to JUST the idea of allowing everyone access to the test servers (or not) and whether or not you are in favor of it and why...etc..

I would love to hear your opinion on it...


Imo....

Everyone should be given access to it. Just like other MMO's do.

I can understand the idea to continue allowing a handful access and having some documentation/results made public to show everyone, because of the notion the testers are looking for bugs, but I still dont find that a trustable situation (especially after the scandal itself, how it had to be leaked before GLB admitted it). Also, making certain info public or having testers just "test certain things they're told to test" isnt even going to really help de-bug and de-exploit the game. Tens of thousands of people have tens of thousands more ways/ideas than a handful of Testers.

So, full access to all people. Especially too that this isnt the first scandal of admin/Bort allowing certain few people in the know to cheat the rest of the community. So an effort has to be made then to turn all those scandals around by allowing people full access to Test Servers.

With everyone having full access, you can STILL have a certain group of people assigned as Lead Testers, who will do exactly what Bort wants them to do, de-bug and de-exploit specific things, and provide feedback back to Bort and a Forum just for Test Server discussions that all other agents can read thru, and put their own feedback in.

Example....the BUGS board would actually become the Test Server Feedback board where everyone can provide feedback, report on problems etc. Like it was originally supposed to be for under this false notion that we're all testers with full transparency.
Last edited Feb 15, 2009 21:23:12
 
eve999
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mantis7
Originally posted by eve999

Ok. It was suggested that everyone should have access and I will debate why that won't likely happen.

<...snip rest of post>



I don't frankly care about your opinion of the likelihood of it happening..I do value your opinion (if you have one) of why it should or should not happen....and so far I have not heard one single good reason from anyone of why this isn't the most perfect, beautiful solution to this issue.


My post explained the reason of why it shouldn't happen. Because there's no value in it. Because that's not how testing works. There is not one single reason why the general population needs to be on the test server. "Because we want to be there" doesn't count as a reason. In any case it's time for bed.
 
The Tempest
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mantis7

Actually this isnt a complaint thread....I am not complaining here, I am making a suggestion to get rid of all of the complaining actually...(and I think it would work!)

I would love to know whether or not you think my idea would accomplish this, rather than have you come in and derail the topic..(with your hypocritical complaining about people who complain, i might add)

Thanks.


No, the easiest solution would be to ban those that use exploits like it states in the TOS. Since these people were hand picked by the administrators it wouldn't be difficult to find those that exploit the system.

I am not complaining, It was a statement to grow up.
 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by eve999
There is not one single reason why the general population needs to be on the test server. "Because we want to be there" doesn't count as a reason. In any case it's time for bed.


The reason is because in many people's minds being on the test server gives an unfair advantage to those who have the access..

For 100+ pages of discussion on that topic, and the reason I came up with this thread, please see the debate here:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2071720

If you truly think there is no unfair advantage to being on the test server, that thread is the place to go debate it.
 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Tempest
No, the easiest solution would be to ban those that use exploits like it states in the TOS. Since these people were hand picked by the administrators it wouldn't be difficult to find those that exploit the system.

I am not complaining, It was a statement to grow up.


Yes, you were complaining about people who complain, which was incredibly funny.

And i don't know if you have read the huge thread here that discusses the testing server and whether or not using it is an unfair advantage (an exploit in your words) but that thread is here:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2071720

It has well over 1000 posts, check it out..

If you don't think that being on the test server is inherently an unfair advantage, please go to that thread and make your case, as this thread is not for that topic, thanks.

As for banning testers, I don't think that is a very good solution. There have been people who want that to happen, they want testers to be a seperate community....But I think that is wrong...No one is as qualified to test this game as the people who play it, so having a rule that stated something like 'if you are a tester, you cant own/gm a team' etc would be the wrong way to do it IMHO...I Think my solution of allowing Everyone some kind of limited access (everyone with equal access) is a much more elegant, and superior solution.

Thanks for your valuable input though.

 
James1985
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mantis7
Originally posted by James1985

^^^^^
That post shows you....THERE IS NO ADVATAGE. It is Impossible to tell.


James, this thread is not the thread where we are discussing 'if there is an advantage' to being on the test server, that is the other thread with 187 pages..

If you want to debate whether or not there is an advantage of being on the test server etc... Please go there and do it...
there are plenty of people who agree and disagree with you, and if you read the last 20-30 pages (or any 20-30 pages in a row actually) , as well as the OP you will get an idea of the sentiment

This thread is to discuss my solution to this perceived problem of test servers.

If you truly feel there is no advantage of being on the test server, than my 'solution' (the topic of this thread) should not in any way bother you, you should support it...as more testers would be better...and being on a testing server (according to you) leads to no changes or gain of knowledge...

If you have any input on SPECIFICALLY the idea of allowing all users access to the test server, feel free to post here...

If you don't like the idea, state why....If you are in favor, state why....etc....



Fine then....

For the topic of this thread....NO!! WAY!!
 
Link
 
TEST SERVERS ARE FOR PEOPLE WHO REGULATE THIS GAME, NOT EVERY IDIOT THAT WANTS TO MAKE A "PLAYER" THAT WILL DOMINATE A RPG. THIS IS HOW THEY MAKE MONEY, THEY NEED TO TEST THINGS SO MOST OF THE GLITCHS GET ERASED. STOP WHINING, I DON'T UNDERSTAND WHY PEOPLE THINK THEY'RE SO POWERFUL THAT THEY CAN REQUEST USING THE TESTERS. IT'S FOR ADMINS AND MODS AND BORT AND DD ONLY!!!
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Personally, I don't think it is necessary to give every user access to all of the functionality of the test server as long as every user gets access to all the information on the test server. Meaning: the general population of GLB doesn't need to be able to actually run the tests, as long as they can see all of the results of all of the tests.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.