User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > nfratami says: Endorsements - There Needs to Be More Than 1 Given Per Position
Page:
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Drago

Again, until how the lottery balls are selected gets released - you have no idea wtf you're talking about.


I do have any idea wtf I'm talking about, and I've supported it, do you really think that bort is going to release a system where the top fame guy gets 1000 chances and the bottom guy gets 1. No he won't for the same reason he has mention that in early seasons he didn't want to have different income for teams in diff leagues (class action threats).

Originally posted by Drago

Also, who cares if my #5 LB gets the piece - maybe it will make him my new #1 LB.


Yeah, you're right the equipment is going to make a lvl 35 backup linebacker better than a lvl 45 starter. Do you use any logic when you think or do you just figure out an argument and go with it?

Originally posted by Drago

Finally - there will be around 20 pieces of equipment released across the league. There are 32 teams in each league. The point isn't to make the majority of the league happy - the point is each time has a decent enough shot to land one piece of equipment per team.


Haha what?

So 20 pieces over 32 teams gives you 62.5% of teams with a piece, and that is if there are no double ups, which there will be. If you are assuming that the chance is widespread then you too agree that my first assumption on the lottery is correct./

I love how you can make assumptions like this but I can't.

You want to discuss how even if a team gets a piece, that it will most likely go to someone that doesn't matter?

Originally posted by Drago

This is an all-or-nothing implement. It's not designed to make the masses happy. Most likely it will be a topic of discussion and excitement in your team forum about a teammate... who is not you.


Thank you for supporting my point. In order for GLB to be successful in the long run, you need to make the masses happy. Time should not be spent on stuff that isn't for the greater good.

We'll see if teams are excited when their 5th string linebacker who never posts, doesn't check in, and barely exists wins the lone LB piece for the league with his 300 fame and 10 tackles.
 
Link
 
Ok lets get back to the OP, what does everyone think about the 3-per conference per position idea?? Good/Bad More/Less?
 
77racing
offline
Link
 
GET THIS IN EPIC suggestions ASAP
 
Link
 
Originally posted by nfratami
Originally posted by Drago

Originally posted by nfratami


Originally posted by Drago



Does anyone even know the formula for determining who gets the most "ping pong balls" in the lottery? We know it's tied into fame, but we don't know how big it's tied into fame.

I don't like the idea of multiple items... takes away from the greatness of winning the lottery. It's also supposed to serve as an incentive to play in the correct leagues for your level and achieve more fame...


Originally posted by nfratami



Originally posted by MrMoose




Where has it been said that 1 fame = 1 ticket in the lottery? Everyone keeps saying this, but I don't recall ever seeing an official bort posting on it.


We have to act on logical assumptions just like we have to on everything in this game.

To be honest how else could it be done.

There could be a complex equation that for every point you are over the league average or median in fame that you receive more entries in the lottery, but this would still result in a very low percentage chance of you winning an item because there are a lot of players with high/comparable fame to the highest people in leagues.


In all, you pretty much don't understand the concept, there is such a low chance to get an item that it won't deter any smart individual when picking their leagues. The lack of veteran XP is the item in place that will cause people to pick proper leagues.


In all, you don't know shit. Has the formula for how the pieces have been picked been released yet?


Wow, I provided the only logical other way it could be done, a way that still will result in the same outcome and I don't know shit.

You haven't provided any logical argument, you just say "you don't know the formula".

Well, none of us know any formulas, so any time you receive build advice I assume you tell the person "you don't know shit".


You need to understand that your argument is, "More than 1 person should get a piece."

I disagree with this wholeheartedly. I'd rather have no one get a piece - than more than one person getting a piece.

It's one thing to give a bonus to an individual on a certain team - it's another thing to give half the league a bonus.

As far as the formula for getting the piece - you don't have any idea how it is calculated. Say that out loud to yourself.

You may have presented one or two "logical" ways on how it should work. That doesn't mean those are the only logical ways the piece will be distributed. For you to try to tell me, "You don't understand the concept..." is more or less a crock of shit. I understand YOUR concept - and I think it's shit. Deal with it.
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Chaka
Originally posted by Jack Del Rio

Well, you don't know the formula. It doesn't mean random ass guesses mean anything. For all you know it isn't a drawing from this big fame-pool, what if fame is ranked and then the leader is awarded like a 10x chance, the second place awarded a 5x chance, 3rd place awarded a 4x chance, etc. etc?
Random useless speculation and you're trying to push for change. A little less trying to get your threads to have many pages, and a little more use your fucking head.




Thanks for always coming in and being a dick Del Rio, I have stated in other posts why we don't think bort will do it that way.

EVERY POST ON GAME THEORY IS SPECULATION, WE DON'T KNOW ANY FORMULAS. Quit using widespread facts as arguments simply because you think they are effective.

This is a discussion based on the fact that endorsements are said to be on a lottery.

The formula isn't even the main point, how about this...

Originally posted by nfratami


So 20 pieces over 32 teams gives you 62.5% of teams with a piece, and that is if there are no double ups, which there will be. If you are assuming that the chance is widespread then you too agree that my first assumption on the lottery is correct./

I love how you can make assumptions like this but I can't.

You want to discuss how even if a team gets a piece, that it will most likely go to someone that doesn't matter?
.


Honestly, Del Rio we don't need you in here flaming, we are having a discussion about endorsements and GLB. Maybe it will even lead to bort coming in and hinting about the formula. If I am wrong so be it, but it is a bit hypocritical to come in here and tell me I don't know shit about the formula when you don't know shit either.
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Clinton Esquire

You need to understand that your argument is, "More than 1 person should get a piece."

I disagree with this wholeheartedly. I'd rather have no one get a piece - than more than one person getting a piece.

It's one thing to give a bonus to an individual on a certain team - it's another thing to give half the league a bonus.

As far as the formula for getting the piece - you don't have any idea how it is calculated. Say that out loud to yourself.

You may have presented one or two "logical" ways on how it should work. That doesn't mean those are the only logical ways the piece will be distributed. For you to try to tell me, "You don't understand the concept..." is more or less a crock of shit. I understand YOUR concept - and I think it's shit. Deal with it.


Seriously, you people need to come the fuck down.

Originally posted by nfratami

Endorsements are said to be done in a lottery system. I assume it will work as in the equation below.


I said I was assuming, that is all, it is a discussion and a suggestion, everything in GLB is based on assumptions.

I'm not asking for half the league to get a bonus? I said maybe 5 per position, that was what this discussion was for? Maybe 2 per position? 5 WR getting equipment is not a large percentage of the league, prob approx 1/32nd of the league. And if the 5th piece awarded isn't that great, what is the big deal, it pleases the masses and doesn't provide a huge advantage.

Thanks for the kind words.
 
Link
 
We're not talking about giving half the league an endorsement... 3 per position / per conference isn't too much to ask for imo.
As for the way it's calculated... I can already tell you (no I don't know precisely, just an educated guess) that with only 1 piece per position per league, that one piece MOST LIKELY will NOT go to anyone really deserves it. ie; a 3rd string LB with a poor build, on a "so-so" team will get it . You see VERY few(if any?) crap players in real life NFL football get endorsements, why would we want crappy players to get em 90% of the time in GLB?

*edit* holy crap , nfratami u type alot faster than I do, LoL ! by the time I got this done in response to Clinton Esquire you'd already posted 2...
Last edited Feb 15, 2009 12:24:59
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VladtheImpaler1
Ok lets get back to the OP, what does everyone think about the 3-per conference per position idea?? Good/Bad More/Less?


I like the idea of separating conferences though, they are already like different leagues as it is.

I think it would maybe need fine tuning, probably based on position population.

1 QB per conference
1 HB per conference
2 WR per conference

etc.
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VladtheImpaler1
We're not talking about giving half the league an endorsement... 3 per position / per conference isn't too much to ask for imo.
As for the way it's calculated... I can already tell you (no I don't know precisely, just an educated guess) that with only 1 piece per position per league, that one piece MOST LIKELY will NOT go to anyone really deserves it. ie; a 3rd string LB with a poor build, on a "so-so" team will get it . You see VERY few(if any?) crap players in real life NFL football get endorsements, why would we want crappy players to get em 90% of the time in GLB?


don't waste your time responding to them

we don't know the formula, either do they

we can't make assumptions and have discussion based on the formula, but they can tell us that our assumptions aren't warranted
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
i'd like to ask the mods if the people attacking me with curse words in this thread are being dealt with in the same manner as me when i "attack" people
 
rowyho
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nfratami
Originally posted by VladtheImpaler1

Ok lets get back to the OP, what does everyone think about the 3-per conference per position idea?? Good/Bad More/Less?


I like the idea of separating conferences though, they are already like different leagues as it is.

I think it would maybe need fine tuning, probably based on position population.

1 QB per conference
1 HB per conference
2 WR per conference

etc.


This is what I was just going to say. It should be based on how many starters there are at each position on an average team. So:

1 QB
1 RB
1 FB
1 TE
2 WR
1 C
2 G
2 T

2 DE
2 DT
3 LB
2 CB
1 SS
1 FS

1 K
1 P

All per conference. Sound good? Great.
Last edited Feb 15, 2009 12:31:34
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jack Del Rio
A little less trying to get your threads to have many pages, and a little more use your fucking head.


I would think that taking the time to note all the bad suggestions from a season and then posting it would serve little purpose that to get your thread to have many pages and gain some recognition.
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rowyho
Originally posted by nfratami

Originally posted by VladtheImpaler1


Ok lets get back to the OP, what does everyone think about the 3-per conference per position idea?? Good/Bad More/Less?


I like the idea of separating conferences though, they are already like different leagues as it is.

I think it would maybe need fine tuning, probably based on position population.

1 QB per conference
1 HB per conference
2 WR per conference

etc.


This is what I was just going to say. It should be based on how many starters there are at each position on an average team. So:

1 QB
1 RB
1 FB
1 TE
2 WR
1 C
2 G
2 T

2 DE
2 DT
3 LB
2 CB
1 SS
1 FS

1 K
1 P

All per conference. Sound good? Great.


I like it the only thing I might switch is to 1G and 1T, simple because they aren't glamor positions and that would make sense to me.
 
Alpha Q
offline
Link
 
So far the best idea that has come out of this discussion is putting the names of the winners of the lottery on the league page.
 
Vagrant God
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 77racing
GET THIS IN EPIC suggestions ASAP


 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.