User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Forced fumbles on RBs - a thing of the past?
Page:
 
RIP Al Davis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by expandingman
I have a level 14 HB and I have not given his carrying a single point (it's 14.3 right now)...he has never fumbled


thaz messed up!
 
csull36
offline
Link
 
At the very least, I would say fumbles need to happen more consistently. If you have a LB with very high strength and tackling and 5-10 points in monster hit and 10-15 in power tackler, you should at least have a few forced fumbles this season.

I have 2 LBers with those stats, and they have 0 FFs between them. My RBs meanwhile, have not fumbled a single time! I have 4 HBs, none of them with high carrying, and 0 fumbles. Meanwhile, my strength oriented, monster hit LBs have 0 FFs. In my opinion, this does not reflect reality at all and something needs to be adjusted.

My QB also has 0 fumbles. I have players with double digit sacks who have not forced a single fumble. If we want this game to be realistic we need to increase the occurrence of forced fumbles when a QB is sacked. As of right now, it is completely unrealistic, and any points spent in any of the power tackling type SAs or VAs or strength is a complete waste.

This is part of the reason why we see so many speed oriented cookie cutter builds on defense.
 
csull36
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kira
Originally posted by expandingman

I have a level 14 HB and I have not given his carrying a single point (it's 14.3 right now)...he has never fumbled


thaz messed up!


1,100+ yards, 16 TDs. 0 fumbles. He has 12 carrying. Pee Wee team, but still...
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1128505

Last edited Jan 19, 2009 09:37:57
 
wallysmith
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

VA's like motivational speaker (though it's not very much of a morale bonus per play, I guess it could make a difference over the course of a game) and some of the avoid fumble type ones might have something to do with it as well - those are fairly popular choices after track star and quick.


Bort, as someone in this thread suggested earlier, would it be possible to run a large number of sims with Motivational Speaker activated and a control group with it off? I'm willing to bet that on average you would see a lot more fumbles in the set of games with it off.

When VA's first came out, MS was absolutely one of those skills that a team MUST have. It was too easy to ask the K or P to invest 10 points in it and not have to sacrifice or direct a build towards it. The fact that it said "only one motivational speaker can be activated per play" prevent random bench agents from investing in it, and the fact that it fires on every play made it logical for only K or P to invest in it.

If you find that MS is truly this unbalancing, then it would be an easy fix to the code; just lessen the number of times it fires (say every other or every third play), and the number of players it affects (say the lowest morale player and 3-8 other random players). It would still be a skill that every team would absolutely need to have without completely unbalancing the sim towards ballcarriers. Note that this would also help break the ability of powerbacks to run up obscene amounts of broken tackles since they won't have the morale to make as many successful rolls.
 
whoshotjr
offline
Link
 
I'll just add that my CB KR hasn't fumbled in about 200 return attempts now (Seasons5-7). In Seasons 3&4 he fumbled 12 times in about 250 return attempts.

It didn't seem like increasing STR/CAR actually helped avoid fumbles in my case, it was more switching to elusive from combo that seemed to do the trick.
 
wallysmith
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wallysmith

Bort, as someone in this thread suggested earlier


Bort, actually the suggestion came from this thread:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1894548

Also note that on the third page I have listed the top powerbacks from random leagues and all show the same trends: fumbles are way down while broken tackles are way up.
 
wallysmith
offline
Link
 
bump for GLB relevance
 
EagleOtto
offline
Link
 
Fumbles have become a rarity, last season, I was used to seeing on average 3 fumbles a game.
This season I haven't seen one critical fumble that cost a game for any of my GM'd teams.
 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by csull36
At the very least, I would say fumbles need to happen more consistently. If you have a LB with very high strength and tackling and 5-10 points in monster hit and 10-15 in power tackler, you should at least have a few forced fumbles this season.

I have 2 LBers with those stats, and they have 0 FFs between them. My RBs meanwhile, have not fumbled a single time! I have 4 HBs, none of them with high carrying, and 0 fumbles. Meanwhile, my strength oriented, monster hit LBs have 0 FFs. In my opinion, this does not reflect reality at all and something needs to be adjusted.

My QB also has 0 fumbles. I have players with double digit sacks who have not forced a single fumble. If we want this game to be realistic we need to increase the occurrence of forced fumbles when a QB is sacked. As of right now, it is completely unrealistic, and any points spent in any of the power tackling type SAs or VAs or strength is a complete waste.

This is part of the reason why we see so many speed oriented cookie cutter builds on defense.


this makes so much sense-- why does no one listen
 
Link
 
Forced Fumbles Should happen more often in GLB

The reason for this is the majority of player builds are low carrying. I know people bitch when they start to fumble but the only attributes that really seem to matter right now are speed and agility. They are so overpowering currently that what works at pro levels and is considered to be a "Good" build is just high speed/agility. There should be more than one way to have a successful team and more than one build type that can succeed. Bort did not intend for speed/agility to be all that matters and if changes are not made he should just change the player skills page to only have those two skills.

What about Tackling? So just have 50 tackling and play on wrap up and you are good. I know of a player build that has 69 tackling and even against gutted teams that guy doesn't get fumbles. The only fumbles that typically occur on on returns when a CB is the return guy. Currently the thought is you need a high speed impact to cause a fumble. When looking at fumble's that do occur that seems to be the case. Have your fastest dot collide with a dot.

Bort needs to just make the change, and spell it out to us - What Causes Fumbles. Or let everyone know that Season 8 if you don't have better carrying you will fumble when someone with high tackling hits you. This is a Beta so change should be expected. Typically there is 1 FF per game in the nfl.

In the 2008 season the average was 15.68 FF per team on the season. That is the NFL. You would not see players with 20-30 carrying (GLB). We have lots of people in the Pro's with that....obviously why worry about it if bort doesn't make it an issue. We also have TONS of defensive players with 50 tackling....same thing...why worry about it if bort doesn't make it an issue.

Bort needs to stop worrying about pleasing the masses and just make the game how he thinks it should be made. He obviously wants to strive for some type of player build balance with multiple ways to have a successful build....so do it. Ignore these bitchy little kids.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by csull36

This is part of the reason why we see so many speed oriented cookie cutter builds on defense.



You mean there are other skills besides speed and agility?
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by csull36


This is part of the reason why we see so many speed oriented cookie cutter builds on defense.



You mean there are other skills besides speed and agility?

no way
 
csull36
offline
Link
 
The problem is not just the rate of occurance of FFs, which seems to be unusually low, but the lack of a direct correlation between player builds and forced fumbles. A LB with high strength and fumble causing SAs/VAs should actually force a fumble now and then, but there seems to be no correlation at all between a players build and a FF...
 
Titus Pullo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Titus Pullo
Originally posted by Bort

tackle quality (which has to be decent to allow a FF check in the first place)


That part right their may be the problem. I see FFs occur quite often in the NFL when the defender attacks the ball rather then the ball carrier. Thus the quality of the tackle is very low since the chance the defenders move of actually tackling the ball carrier is very low. However since he focued on slapping the ball out the ball comes loose and a fumble occurs.

Just watch some fumbling highlights and you will see what I am talking about. The ball carrier is running with the ball not hugged close (high carry skill) to his chest but out away from the body (low carry skill) and a defender who has little to no chance to making a tackle instead just dives at the exposed ball and knocks it lose (low strenght). Most QBs fumbles occur in this way as well since the ball is being held out in a throwing position and not secured very well. A pass rusher may miss the QB who side steps him, but he still is able to grab the arm or hit the ball as he flies by and cause a fumble. So the idea that tackle quality has to be high before a fumble can occur is incorrect. Eliminate that and you may see everything else work itself out.



Good Post. You reading this stuff Bort?
 
oronis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by csull36
The problem is not just the rate of occurance of FFs, which seems to be unusually low, but the lack of a direct correlation between player builds and forced fumbles. A LB with high strength and fumble causing SAs/VAs should actually force a fumble now and then, but there seems to be no correlation at all between a players build and a FF...


Not just that, we need logic for people to attempt to force a fumble when they have other defenders in the area to make the tackle if they fail at the fumble and/or tackle. A LB with nobody behind him won't try to force a fumble; he'll make sure he has that guy wrapped up. However, if that same LB breaks into the backfield, why not try to force that fumble on the QB or RB? You see it all the time with that hammer-swing arm the LBs throw when tackling midfield.

There needs to be logic, wrap-up / normal / FF settings need to be revisited, and the whole tackling quality being related to fumbling needs to be revisited. They are two completely separate actions.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.