User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Not enough fumbling?
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by TheBosnian
Originally posted by fallingmercury

Originally posted by ripper12


blind side sack should be 33% fumble chance imo


We still have DEs (and some DTs) on track for ~60 sacks. That's already extraordinarily powerful. Do you really want them to get 20+ forced fumbles on top of that?


Yeah that's the problem... Players' find ways to (what I would call-) "exploit" certain things in the game & use it. (DEs getting that insane of a number of sacks... Hard to do other things for Bort; like calculate a better FF formula.


IMO the solution wasn't to nerf DEs. It was to upgrade blocking pathing and options for the blocking back(s) and O-line.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by fallingmercury

No way, that's way too many.

What does a SS get, about 80 tackles per year? What you're suggesting is that the player would force a fumble a whopping 10% or more of his tackles. That would be insane, especially if there were multiple fumble-forcers on the same team.

IMO, you want GLB to be like basketball.

The number is unimportant tbh. The point is consistency, some type of repeatable outcome (however many times it gets repeated is up to "realism").


Since it's not "consistent" or "repeatable" in real football, even with big-hitters....

I think when people start to think they're "entitled" to one FF every other game or whatever, that's a major problem.
Last edited Jan 11, 2009 23:10:54
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Since it's not "consistent" or "repeatable" in real football, even with big-hitters....

Sure it is. Go look at the top 20 names in FF leaders in the NFL over the past 3 or so seasons, you're going to see a large number of the same names come up (provided they were healthy that season, of c.).
 
Link
 
Yeah and there are a ton of names that pop up just once in those lists.


How many force fumbles in 10%-15% of their tackles?
Last edited Jan 11, 2009 23:23:06
 
sully
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by zroeder
who cares. i mean really is this really what we are complaining about now. as long as there are turnovers what does it matter if its INT's or fumbles


Originally posted by Second Goalie
Oh no my fake ego for my fake football player will be deflated if I don't get 15 FF a game. All the other fake football player owners will see my stats and make fun of me.


Congratulations on completely missing the point of the thread and contributing nothing to the discussion.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by fallingmercury

Since it's not "consistent" or "repeatable" in real football, even with big-hitters....

Sure it is. Go look at the top 20 names in FF leaders in the NFL over the past 3 or so seasons, you're going to see a large number of the same names come up (provided they were healthy that season, of c.).


Here are this year's NFL top tacklers and their FF's:

D'Quell Jackson: 154 tackles, 0 FF, 0%
Patrick Willis: 141 tackles, 1 FF, .7%
John Beason: 138 tackles, 0 FF, 0%
Barrett Ruud: 137 tackles, 0 FF, 0%
Kirk Morrison: 135 tackles, 2 FF, 1.5%

Surely most of these guys have the "equivalent" of Big Hit (etc), right? Patrick Willis?

Ultra-elite Pro-Bowler James Harrison had 7 in 101 tackles, just shy of 7%. The most a SS had was 3. And you think your GLB SS should net 7-10 FF?

In a number of recent years we've seen NFL seasons where no player (at any position) forced more than three.
Last edited Jan 11, 2009 23:44:47
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Yeah and there are a ton of names that pop up just once in those lists.


How many force fumbles in 10%-15% of their tackles?

The hike up to 7-10 was, as I mentioned, due to loldots. Stats are inflated across the board, and don't correlate 1:1 with any type of realistic values, so that's why the number was high. But, again, the actual number is unimportant, whether it be on 10% or 4% of tackles, the point is that it's somewhat consistent/repeatable. As in, I'm assuming if you ran the numbers on the top 20 FF guys every season in the NFL/NCAA what have you, there'd be some relatively consistent percentages.

Originally posted by fallingmercury
Here are this year's NFL top tacklers and their FF's:

D'Quell Jackson: 154 tackles, 0 FF, 0%
Patrick Willis: 141 tackles, 1 FF, .7%
John Beason: 138 tackles, 0 FF, 0%
Barrett Ruud: 137 tackles, 0 FF, 0%
Kirk Morrison: 135 tackles, 2 FF, 1.5%

Surely most of these guys have the "equivalent" of Big Hit (etc), right? Patrick Willis?

Probably not, actually. Searching for a GLB equivalent, those would be your steady tacklers on wrap-up, looking to make the stop and not force fumbles. Willis seems like a prototypical GLB linebacker, a ton of speed/agility, not much in the way of strength, etc.

James Harrison, on the other hand, seems like the type of player that's impossible to replicate in GLB. Sure, you can build one "like" him, but I guarantee you wouldn't approach a 7% FF mark. Again, my LB, for his career, is forcing a fumble on 3% of his tackles, and really has no business doing so, with sub-40 strength/tackling.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by fallingmercury

Yeah and there are a ton of names that pop up just once in those lists.


How many force fumbles in 10%-15% of their tackles?

The hike up to 7-10 was, as I mentioned, due to loldots. Stats are inflated across the board, and don't correlate 1:1 with any type of realistic values, so that's why the number was high. But, again, the actual number is unimportant, whether it be on 10% or 4% of tackles, the point is that it's somewhat consistent/repeatable. As in, I'm assuming if you ran the numbers on the top 20 FF guys every season in the NFL/NCAA what have you, there'd be some relatively consistent percentages.

Originally posted by fallingmercury

Here are this year's NFL top tacklers and their FF's:

D'Quell Jackson: 154 tackles, 0 FF, 0%
Patrick Willis: 141 tackles, 1 FF, .7%
John Beason: 138 tackles, 0 FF, 0%
Barrett Ruud: 137 tackles, 0 FF, 0%
Kirk Morrison: 135 tackles, 2 FF, 1.5%

Surely most of these guys have the "equivalent" of Big Hit (etc), right? Patrick Willis?

Probably not, actually. Searching for a GLB equivalent, those would be your steady tacklers on wrap-up, looking to make the stop and not force fumbles. Willis seems like a prototypical GLB linebacker, a ton of speed/agility, not much in the way of strength, etc.

James Harrison, on the other hand, seems like the type of player that's impossible to replicate in GLB. Sure, you can build one "like" him, but I guarantee you wouldn't approach a 7% FF mark. Again, my LB, for his career, is forcing a fumble on 3% of his tackles, and really has no business doing so, with sub-40 strength/tackling.



Lol... Dude... of course if you listed the top-20 FF guys every season it would have the same names. That's because you'd have one or two guys forcing 4-5 fumbles, an eleven-way tie for 3 FFs, and a thirty-six way tie for 2 FFs. So your top 20 list ends up being like 50 names long.

You don't watch Patrick Willis much, do you?

But yeah, your LB probably does deserve 3% FF rate based on the number of gutted/weakling teams you've probably faced over his years.
Last edited Jan 12, 2009 00:00:59
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Lol... Dude... of course if you listed the top-20 FF guys every season it would have the same names. That's because you'd have one or two guys forcing 4-5 fumbles, an eleven-way tie for 3 FFs, and a thirty-six way tie for 2 FFs. So your top 20 list ends up being like 50 names long.

Huh? I said 20 guys, which would mean twenty people, not the 858275897245897485 that tied for 20th. My entire point was that, of the top FFers every season, I'm willing to bet that both the same people come up quite often in that list of 20 (in any given 3-5 season span), and that the %s of fumbles forced per number of tackles remains relatively consistent (the whole point being that, yes, one can consistently force fumbles).

Originally posted by fallingmercury

You don't watch Patrick Willis much, do you?

Unfortunately, yes. I'm a Seahawks fan, so I get to see way more of him than I want to. Like when he picked off a Hasselbeck throw and outran the entire team 86 yards to the endzone. GLB != NFL, obv., and of course Willis is strong, etc., but he's known for being a sideline-to-sideline/tackling machine type, which would equate to a high speed/agility GLB LB.

Originally posted by fallingmercury

But yeah, your LB probably does deserve 3% FF rate based on the number of gutted/weakling teams you've probably faced over his years.

That would make sense, if his FF rate didn't jump up to 5.7% in the playoffs (4 FFs on 70 career tackles).
 
pestface
offline
Link
 
I think most good defenses don't invest a whole ton of points in tackling/strength, mainly because off SP limitations. Players with 90 tackling/70 strength would probably force fumbles at a seemingly broken rate, but those players would also be extremely ineffective at playing defense.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
I wouldn't mind seeing a few more fumbles overall, tbh, especially since a lot of people have gimpy carrying ability. I don't think right now is the best time to toy with it though, because honestly I think if more defenders had higher tackling skill (and I don't mean ~50), we'd see more fumbles anyway. That would be the point to getting tackling skill near 100, imo.
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
Omg.
 
Livestrong
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I wouldn't mind seeing a few more fumbles overall, tbh, especially since a lot of people have gimpy carrying ability. I don't think right now is the best time to toy with it though, because honestly I think if more defenders had higher tackling skill (and I don't mean ~50), we'd see more fumbles anyway. That would be the point to getting tackling skill near 100, imo.


pffft right. how would you know?







zing
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
I'm gonna 3rd cap tackling right now, i'm serious.
 
Dr.Zoidberg
offline
Link
 
Needs moar fumbles
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.