User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > ReProgram the Simulation - Redo The Game
Page:
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JDaniels127
Originally posted by GG

Possibly the only way for the "GLB" concept to reach its potential is if the rights to the game are sold for a good enough amount of money to please the current owners, so that the new mob totally overhauled the existing code, frameworks, systems, attributes, and devoted their larger time/money/programmer-resources into it----into genuinely making the game better by doing whatever it takes to correct the problems.



Disagree with commercialism aspect.


I mean, Bort is a one-man operation, and probably tires of the whole game, knowing his limitations to what he can do and also how his "nice guy" approach has allowed the game to become an exploit cookie-cutter deathtrap.

Some bigger group, with actual team of programmers, would have more balls and inclination to overhaul it because that would be the reason why they would hypothetically buy the game from Bort/DD. Because they see the potential and where it's being held back, and would therefore invest whatever it takes to fix it so that it DID reach its potential.
 
ThaOutlaw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Originally posted by JDaniels127

Originally posted by GG


Possibly the only way for the "GLB" concept to reach its potential is if the rights to the game are sold for a good enough amount of money to please the current owners, so that the new mob totally overhauled the existing code, frameworks, systems, attributes, and devoted their larger time/money/programmer-resources into it----into genuinely making the game better by doing whatever it takes to correct the problems.



Disagree with commercialism aspect.


I mean, Bort is a one-man operation, and probably tires of the whole game, knowing his limitations to what he can do and also how his "nice guy" approach has allowed the game to become an exploit cookie-cutter deathtrap.

Some bigger group, with actual team of programmers, would have more balls and inclination to overhaul it because that would be the reason why they would hypothetically buy the game from Bort/DD. Because they see the potential and where it's being held back, and would therefore invest whatever it takes to fix it so that it DID reach its potential.


If said big company wanted to do that, why not just build their own? Seems easier to me. Not hard to advertise for either.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
There would be elements of the code, things that Bort has done, that would be unique, or that are evidence of how it can work. Ie, you're buying the code not just the game.

However, they would sit down, reverse engineer it, and totally new minds would re-do it all where it needs to be re-done.

Also, it doesnt necessarily have to be a big company like Yahoo or ESPN. Just some group of programmers or small-time EXISTING game developers.

Whoever it was, they would re-do it, is my point.
Last edited Jan 12, 2009 01:36:08
 
ThaOutlaw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
There would be elements of the code, things that Bort has done, that would be unique, or that are evidence of how it can work. Ie, you're buying the code not just the game.

However, they would sit down, reverse engineer it, and totally new minds would re-do it all where it needs to be re-done.

Also, it doesnt necessarily have to be a big company like Yahoo or ESPN. Just some group of programmers or small-time EXISTING game developers.

Whoever it was, they would re-do it, is my point.


Ah ok, I see what you are saying.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Because it's bort's baby, and bort has a certain limitation and tolerance, then the game is held back, band-aided along.
But if you had a little bigger enterprise, like say 4 devs who already are game developers in some capacity, IF they bought it they would buy it because they saw the potential and WHERE it's being held back----so to buy it theyd re-do it because the way it is now is crippling its potential due to the current devs/admins limitations/attitude.
Last edited Jan 12, 2009 01:38:40
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Anyway, you see what im saying.
 
SwagOnLock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JDaniels127
Originally posted by GG

Originally posted by JDaniels127


Originally posted by GG



Possibly the only way for the "GLB" concept to reach its potential is if the rights to the game are sold for a good enough amount of money to please the current owners, so that the new mob totally overhauled the existing code, frameworks, systems, attributes, and devoted their larger time/money/programmer-resources into it----into genuinely making the game better by doing whatever it takes to correct the problems.



Disagree with commercialism aspect.


I mean, Bort is a one-man operation, and probably tires of the whole game, knowing his limitations to what he can do and also how his "nice guy" approach has allowed the game to become an exploit cookie-cutter deathtrap.

Some bigger group, with actual team of programmers, would have more balls and inclination to overhaul it because that would be the reason why they would hypothetically buy the game from Bort/DD. Because they see the potential and where it's being held back, and would therefore invest whatever it takes to fix it so that it DID reach its potential.


If said big company wanted to do that, why not just build their own? Seems easier to me. Not hard to advertise for either.


Built-in userbase doesn't hurt.
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
1) Fix the SIM.
2) Test it on end of life players so we know it works through season 10.
3) Leave it the F--- alone.

I've been complaining for many seasons that we don't have press coverage. That we need zone blitzes and stunts. I've changed my mind. Every time Bort tries to make this game more complex or add features he screws it up. I have no doubt that he never tested the effects of the season 7 SIM updates along with what would happen when he rolled out veteran abilities. We're back to where we were season 3 where anyone with a marginally decent defense can play pass defense all game and not even worry about stopping the run. We're back to the point where only a few really well built HB's in any league are able to consistently run the ball, so everyone has to throw.

It's not fun to own a team anymore. Every new season rolls around and I'm not excited about new features. I'm wondering how Bort managed to shove it up my arse as an owner this season. Which players on my team will need all new equipment so they're effective again. Which offensive and defensive strategies we've been using for seasons will suddenly suck. Which exploitive new builds will be putting up stupid numbers so I have to try to see if I can get anyone on my team to those numbers. Etc.

I'd be happier to have season 6's SIM back. It had it's bugs, but it was balanced. People complained they couldn't stop the run but I saw A LOT of games in Pro level leagues where two decent teams played and the average ypc was under 3 for both teams. Overall, when teams of equal talent met we ended up with NCAA type numbers. They might have been a little inflated compared to the NFL averages, but I still maintain that the average GLB user isn't going to be happy with NFL numbers. Nobody wants to drop 7000FP into a lvl 40+ WR signed as the #4 guy on their team so that receiver can have a 350 yard and 2 TD season. Last season if you were playing a team you were slightly better than you'd get 4-5ypc instead of the NFL average closer to 4. Passing completion percentages were often a little high, but the results were good enough. Sure sometimes we'd get WAC type scores and offensive shootouts, and sometimes we'd get Big10 type games where neither team put up 20 points or 300 yards of offense. But at least running the ball was possible as an offensive strategy, and for the most part things were good. This season is the season I've been the least happy with Bort and the game, and my team is undefeated. We spent 4 seasons building ourselves as a run-first team, and we're now seeing our running game held to less than 4ypc by teams that will be lucky to win 4 games who play pass defense all game.

And don't blame builds. If the answer here is that elusive back builds that have excelled for 6 seasons are suddenly unrealistic and should be nerfed to crap, that suddenly they should expect to see their average ypc drop by 2-3ypc, that's BS. The reality is that this wasn't really even a nerf. It's just the result of making a bunch of changes all at once with no idea what the result would be.

Last edited Jan 12, 2009 01:49:54
 
GG
offline
Link
 
I say season 1 and 2 were the best sims in the sense of balance. There were bugs back then like how players always ran out of bounds instead of running for the endzone, and stuff like that, but the level of parity and competitiveness in the game was good.

Obviously there were exploits waiting to be exploited, but at the time, the sim was uncomplicated. Nowadays there's a ton of added bonuses and special things like break tackle bonuses and deflect pass bonuses and knocking people down bonuses etc etc, that just makes the sim impossible to play and terribly uncompetitive build vs build.

You have to have like the exact same builds and SP allocations and VAs etc just to have a chance at anything. You cant even employ any variation in tactics or builds in any way whatsoever because there's a certain specific way that works. Like how you just stack the box in cover 1 335, and blitz the SS/RLB, how you play nothing but man, all speed/agility max, etc. Basically there's no use to tactics, no use to using any other plays from the playbook, just run the strong-i off-tackle, and those certain few pass plays. No use for zone or coverage long or this or that, no use to building any other types of builds for any player but max speed/agility, etc etc. How you buy this and that VA only. Etc.

All this touted "a real way for player differentiation" etc is BS and anyone who thought so at the time was stupid. This game at its foundation is all about exploitive extreme builds, one way of doing stuff, and so VAs and SAs and EQT and anything else in the game is gonna emphasize and exasperate that more.

The game, like I said, took the WRONG fork in the road. It's fubar'd.

Last edited Jan 12, 2009 02:24:26
 
SwagOnLock
offline
Link
 
How do we get Bort's attention, though? How do you get through to a guy who is making money off the current system, and has a ravenous customer base that will disagree with what you and I are saying until the day they die?

GG this isn't a knock to you, but you've made that last post there in a hundred other threads. It is put eloquently every time, and gets truer as the seasons wear on, but you have BEEN saying this for quite some time now. I'm sort of at a loss at this point.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
What this game should do is overhaul, and REMOVE all the BS like bonus-applied SAs, VAs, EQT, etc. Just make it attribute vs attribute. Create more attributes, deepen that whole attribute system. And when you include something like SAs, they have to be only SKILL-specific things. Like giving you the ability to take a one-handed catch. Not giving you a percentage chance to take a one-handed catch, and then boosting the percentage chance of that by stacking it with more SPs. The SAs being free-form, and all just skill-specific, would make the journey of that first created player more real as they learn and acquire new skills (SAs).

You place an emphasis on tactics, not levels. You implement more interactive features for players and owners.....players---training modules that are actually interactive, you have to do wonderlic tests and click the mouse to catch balls etc. While for owners they have like socio-economic RPG elements that affect their team and finances. While for coaches they have play creation modules that is completely customizable.

And as the whole point of GLB is to be a 10 season decline, then by the 10th season, all that stuff should be more than enough for a players lifetime and an agents sense of interactivity with GLB. Enough for them to come back and play more and more BECAUSE every game is parity-driven, real-like dynamics and stats, scores, etc. And bringing back the "watch the live game" mode that was fun for groups of people to enjoy.

Removing all the tedium too of a thousand mouse-clicks to have to do anything. And all the laborious AI interface percentages. And the website has all the basic forum and PM/email/chat tools that a lot still havent been implemented during season 1 suggestions.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SwagOnLock
How do we get Bort's attention, though? How do you get through to a guy who is making money off the current system, and has a ravenous customer base that will disagree with what you and I are saying until the day they die?

GG this isn't a knock to you, but you've made that last post there in a hundred other threads. It is put eloquently every time, and gets truer as the seasons wear on, but you have BEEN saying this for quite some time now. I'm sort of at a loss at this point.


Ive been saying all this stuff since season 2/3. I saw all this that's transpired back then. But was mocked by mods/admin and other agents. Not all. But most. Every suggestion Ive ever put here has been genuine. Not anarchist. They may not be good, but the intention of them was always based on bettering the game. Over time, hundreds and thousands of people have seen it too and all made suggestions for the same reasons etc. Many people here resist and whine because they want the status quo to remain. So you end up with a ratio of agents who pay money who DONT want change, and complain and maybe even threaten devs/admin. And you have a ratio of agents who pay money who DO want change, and while they dont threaten, they do what they do----which is bit by bit leave the game, throw their arms up. And GLB owners/devs often are their own worst enemy because they reject the big important overhauls and visions of the game that are for the long-term better, or just to avoid legal action or just to avoid having "unhappy" customers who are enjoying the exploitive cookie-cutter deathtrap, or because they foster exploits and giving favors to friends, or they poorly manage the whole thing, and customer service, or they want to just keep cashing in with the littlest effort (programming), or whatever.

It's that bunch of maddenites who play 10 seasons of franchise mode and win 160-0 every game on easy mode, and HAVE TO go 16-0 every season otherwise they reboot the game so they dont have a loss against their name. Or when they play people online they have to log out of the game to avoid a defeat etc. Those types of people ruined all FPS games thru spawn-camping, and they ruin games like madden online, or texas-holdem poker during the early X360 days, and they ruin GLB, etc. And whilever GLB doesnt show the balls to fix the game properly (overhaul) on account of appeasing all these types of people and the other whiners for "it's my turn to be a good team in season 7 dont you dare ruin it for me".
Last edited Jan 12, 2009 02:44:45
 
SwagOnLock
offline
Link
 
That's all true. And I'm one of the people who has been on your side of things for a while now. But again, where do we go from here? How do we get Bort to actually listen? I only want to force the issue because you are so on point and so capable of expressing this sentiment, and I'm sorry to see you "waste" it in the 20th pages of threads that nobody is even reading.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
If anyone, agent or admin/dev thinks this game isnt fubar'd or that things arent as bad as what some people may say.....they're in denial. As much denial as those fans of teams like the Raiders or whomever who always think every new season something will change for the better, or that things are functional instead of dysfunctional.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SwagOnLock
That's all true. And I'm one of the people who has been on your side of things for a while now. But again, where do we go from here? How do we get Bort to actually listen? I only want to force the issue because you are so on point and so capable of expressing this sentiment, and I'm sorry to see you "waste" it in the 20th pages of threads that nobody is even reading.


Threads like this fall on deaf ears because admin/devs disagree. And there'll be that bunch of rent-a-crowd fanboys to come in and tell us we're stupid or whining or to "go make your own game".....as tho them saying that somehow invalidates the fubar state of this game. Especially when deep down they all know it and whine amongst themselves in their own team forums or in other boards they go to.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.