User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Suggestion to slow down gutting and killing teams
Page:
 
seorang
offline
Link
 
And if you read the line immediately after the notion you quoted, I also said those who do come back will generally be better owners than the first time they did it.

These penalties will not stop the gutting the first time. It just slows it down the 2nd/3rd/nth time, if any. Still will not overcome the GM/owner loophole.
Last edited Jan 11, 2009 10:40:20
 
Link
 
I did read it and also don't agree with that line either. There are more crappy owners in this game than people are willing to admit. And they don't just 'go away'
 
Gheemony
offline
Link
 
+1 - let's slow the gutting of teams. I think teams should be scarcer so as to improve owner quality.
 
hambone77us
offline
Link
 
if people have issues they should be able to get with a mod i like the idea because maybe it would make a better playing atmosphere.
 
Skoll Wolfrun
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Diamonddog
I think you shouldn't be able to own a team for a full season, after you abandon a team in the previous season.

Too many owners run teams that do quite well, and then get promoted, and then are not headed for another 13-3 season, so they give up the team 3 or 4 games in, and start a new one the following season.

Maybe if they had to sit out the next season as an owner, they might not be so eager to just throw the team on the trash heap.

(can't wait to see what kind of trolls this brings out of the woodwork)


+2
While I can understand family issues/money becoming an issue for running a team, the owner/player needs to know that dropping teams part way into a season drops them from running a team (if the rule goes in).
Personally, at least 2 season minimum from another ownership.
 
Papapoud
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jared
I got one this season(gutted team) most high level guys wouldn't sign because they looked at the 1-15 for the season 6 standings and not the chemistry grace period right undreneath it, anyway we are massively underleveled and at a complete disadvantage with a reset stadium, but that isn't going to make me sell my team, I will take my lumps and with all the hardwork, and the good group of agents I've collected we'll be alright in a few seasons


Originally posted by evel66
Being a guy that got a gutted team from an owner that "gave" up I say you lose the right to own a team period.

I spend 3 ours a day trying to recruit and that is to get middle to high teen players to join me in a league that has every team at 24-30 players.

It sucks. I am willing to spend the money and take the time to build but hard to get guys to believe you.

John Evans


i am in the same boat and think many are as well, if teams are sold or whatever why can't bort put noobs together in a league so it stays competitive? usa#1-#6 vets and usa#7-#8 new owners, might make it more fun for everyone.

but i agree with the original topic, i am seriously out-leveled but i feel i have an obligation to my guys and will try to compete as best i can.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Papapoud
Originally posted by jared

I got one this season(gutted team) most high level guys wouldn't sign because they looked at the 1-15 for the season 6 standings and not the chemistry grace period right undreneath it, anyway we are massively underleveled and at a complete disadvantage with a reset stadium, but that isn't going to make me sell my team, I will take my lumps and with all the hardwork, and the good group of agents I've collected we'll be alright in a few seasons


Originally posted by evel66

Being a guy that got a gutted team from an owner that "gave" up I say you lose the right to own a team period.

I spend 3 ours a day trying to recruit and that is to get middle to high teen players to join me in a league that has every team at 24-30 players.

It sucks. I am willing to spend the money and take the time to build but hard to get guys to believe you.

John Evans


i am in the same boat and think many are as well, if teams are sold or whatever why can't bort put noobs together in a league so it stays competitive? usa#1-#6 vets and usa#7-#8 new owners, might make it more fun for everyone.

but i agree with the original topic, i am seriously out-leveled but i feel i have an obligation to my guys and will try to compete as best i can.


Exactly, it took me 3 seasons to put a competitive team on the field (this is our third season), in our first game, we got destroyed every game, I inherited my team with 0 players on the roster. The problem with getting a gutted team is that it disallows you, severely, to even concern yourself much of the time with builds because it's hard enough to field a 40 man team in the first place.

I do, in full honesty agree, that people who continually gut, then sell their team, shouldn't have the option to get another one.

But worst case scenario, like someone else mentioned, they should not be allowed to get one for a few seasons. Because at least then, they'd have some time to figure out how to be a proper owner and maybe next time, they'd do it right.
 
atom871
offline
Link
 
The problem is universal player mobility. A player can move anywhere he wants to go when his contract expires. Generally, this involves a player moving to a team with someone he knows.

Trades are also universal. If you could only trade within your league, that would reduce the number of trades as well.

I say once a player signs with a team, he should stay in that league. Research your options and remain in that league. It would do wonders for recruiting, parity, gutting and collusion. It would also allow for implementation of a drafting system from the d-leagues.

Take the NFL for example, if a player chooses to leave the NFL, how many options does he have? CFL? NFL Europe (nope, scratch that one...) Not many choices are there?

 
Papapoud
offline
Link
 
sounds like a good concept but then anyone who has been around glb for a while starts trying to get into usa and the rest are left with fewer and fewer available players/agents. i can't count the number of times a good recruit went with a lesser team than my own to be in usa. and i don't have a great team.

i don't think that would solve the problem, but could be a great idea for another thread. we would still have separation in each region and still have owners that don't understand people pay to play this game and they take out the enjoyment factor when they dump players, mostly unknowingly. and ruin the game for many.
 
didymus
offline
Link
 
Anyone who supports this thread...

Clearly has no idea what a pain in the ass it is for an uncapped team to start over with level one players.

It screws the entire conference that they are in.

GLB should encourage teams that are in the position to start over to sell their team and buy an expansion team.
 
atom871
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by didymus
Anyone who supports this thread...

Clearly has no idea what a pain in the ass it is for an uncapped team to start over with level one players.

It screws the entire conference that they are in.

GLB should encourage teams that are in the position to start over to sell their team and buy an expansion team.


Why? The end result will be the same. Except now, you will have a new team owner in your conference who may or may not know how to run a team.
Last edited Jan 12, 2009 07:34:27
 
AuburnBlue
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by atom871

...

I say once a player signs with a team, he should stay in that league. Research your options and remain in that league. It would do wonders for recruiting, parity, gutting and collusion. It would also allow for implementation of a drafting system from the d-leagues.

Take the NFL for example, if a player chooses to leave the NFL, how many options does he have? CFL? NFL Europe (nope, scratch that one...) Not many choices are there?



-1 (that's MINUS 1, negative, disagree)

Players in the NFL (or any other league) can go anywhere they want when their contact ends. Look at Warren Moon and Doug Flutie and Hershel Walker as perfect illustrations. Flutie AND Walker started out in the USFL, under your rule that's where their careers would have ended. Flutie next goes into the NFL where he bombed. He then went to the CFL and became a superstar. He threw for something like 45,000 yards and was an MVP 6(?) times! THEN he came back to the NFL and finished with a career winning record. Walker's USFL and NFL records speak for themselves. Warren Moon was a superstar in Canada and then became the highest paid player in the NFL and went tot he Pro Bowl 9 times. He also had something like 50,000 yards passing in just his NFL career.

Short answer, blocking where a player can go when their contract expires is a stupid suggestion and has no basis in reality.
Last edited Jan 12, 2009 09:21:59
 
AuburnBlue
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Skoll Wolfrun
Originally posted by Diamonddog

I think you shouldn't be able to own a team for a full season, after you abandon a team in the previous season.

Too many owners run teams that do quite well, and then get promoted, and then are not headed for another 13-3 season, so they give up the team 3 or 4 games in, and start a new one the following season.

Maybe if they had to sit out the next season as an owner, they might not be so eager to just throw the team on the trash heap.

(can't wait to see what kind of trolls this brings out of the woodwork)


+2
While I can understand family issues/money becoming an issue for running a team, the owner/player needs to know that dropping teams part way into a season drops them from running a team (if the rule goes in).
Personally, at least 2 season minimum from another ownership.


+1 Agree!
 
Link
 
Originally posted by didymus
Anyone who supports this thread...

Clearly has no idea what a pain in the ass it is for an uncapped team to start over with level one players.

It screws the entire conference that they are in.

GLB should encourage teams that are in the position to start over to sell their team and buy an expansion team.


BULL SHIT!

I got my team in season 5. You know how many players were on it? GUess.. you're right if you guessed a # BETWEEN -1 and 1. 0 players. 0 stadium upgrades, very little money.

I had to build from scratch and even I think this is a good idea. So don't sit here, with all due respect, and claim that the only people that support disallowing people to sell teams are the people doing it. What sense does that even make?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by AuburnBlue
Originally posted by atom871


...

I say once a player signs with a team, he should stay in that league. Research your options and remain in that league. It would do wonders for recruiting, parity, gutting and collusion. It would also allow for implementation of a drafting system from the d-leagues.

Take the NFL for example, if a player chooses to leave the NFL, how many options does he have? CFL? NFL Europe (nope, scratch that one...) Not many choices are there?



-1 (that's MINUS 1, negative, disagree)

Players in the NFL (or any other league) can go anywhere they want when their contact ends. Look at Warren Moon and Doug Flutie and Hershel Walker as perfect illustrations. Flutie AND Walker started out in the USFL, under your rule that's where their careers would have ended. Flutie next goes into the NFL where he bombed. He then went to the CFL and became a superstar. He threw for something like 45,000 yards and was an MVP 6(?) times! THEN he came back to the NFL and finished with a career winning record. Walker's USFL and NFL records speak for themselves. Warren Moon was a superstar in Canada and then became the highest paid player in the NFL and went tot he Pro Bowl 9 times. He also had something like 50,000 yards passing in just his NFL career.

Short answer, blocking where a player can go when their contract expires is a stupid suggestion and has no basis in reality.


As far as players go, there needs to be more incentive to signing long term deals imo.

When it comes to trades, how about a 'player veto option'? Give the Players an alert, and allow them to VETO the trade within 24 hr. of its existance. This DOES admittingly slow down the trade process, and probably calls for a slightly longer off season, but it allows the players some control over where they get traded. It also may encourage the majority of owners to go about trading people in the proper manner.

When it comes to contracts, implementing team captain ideas, among others, like jersey sales, etc. may help, little by little encourage long term deals.

What about changing up chemistry a little? Make it so when you sign a SOLID player, you get + chemistry, not just negative. Perhaps + overall but a - O or D chem. Just a thought.


As far as gutted teams, there's no way to completely eliminate them, but here's some thoughts..

Stop supporting farm teams, Put a VERY THIN limit on how many players one agent can have on a single team, and Make Penalties for selling your team.

These things, won't completely eliminate it, but give STRONG Discouragement toward it.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.