User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > I don't think slow build works as well as you think.
Page:
 
RandomBeast
offline
Link
 
ITT: Deathblade teaches class.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oban14

OK, so let's say I'm building a tackle and I want his strength to be at 68 naturally. You're saying I should train strength/blocking until I have enough SP and a high enough strength level to get to 48. Then I should train blocking, but any points I get I should dump back into strength


This.
 
xeef
offline
Link
 
What I think is hillarious is there *IS* so much difference in opinion as to what slowbuilding actually is.

I think 8 or so different strategies got lumped together into one and people here (and other places) bicker about what is and isnt the proper way to "slow build" when most of the "slowbuild" methods are speed build methods.
 
JeffSteele
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by oban14


Exactly. Clearly it won't get you the most well rounded player, but if you want someone highly specialized (say a super fast TE, or a TE who only blocks) there may be some benefit.


fwiw, a player with ONLY one attribute and nothing else even touched will fail miserably.
not if they're kicking, punting or blocking.

i might concede the blocking, but you really only do 4 stats for blockers anyway (blk-agi-str-vis) that have auto-bonus (remember spd has no auto-bonus) so it's not harm in softcap2/3 on blk before softcaps on the other three. almost all other positions, though, have at least 5 or 6 stats that need to be fleshed out (mainly b/c they get spd auto-bonus)
 
TheGreatPuma
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jjj1dog

ok, that's what i like to do. our team's been told not to use skill pts till much further down the road though.


Your team has gotten some VERY poor advice.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by oban14


Exactly. Clearly it won't get you the most well rounded player, but if you want someone highly specialized (say a super fast TE, or a TE who only blocks) there may be some benefit.


fwiw, a player with ONLY one attribute and nothing else even touched will fail miserably.


I'm not talking about that. This is something I'm actually pursuing and calling combo-building.

I'm building twin TEs - one I want to have strength and blocking to the third or fourth cap as well as all equipment. I'm going to train up vision, agility, so-so speed, and basically build him like a tackle.

The second one is going to be all speed, agility, catching, with vision and jumping. Sound familiar?

One will be used on passing plays, the other on running plays. I'm trying to determine if it would be better value to just cap at 48 and let the auto boosts go or save up to 61 or 68 and then let it go from there.


 
kuaggie
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ChicagoTRS

"Slow building does not work well if you have no clue what you are doing"


cosign, lol
 
Link
 
Originally posted by kuaggie
Originally posted by ChicagoTRS


"Slow building does not work well if you have no clue what you are doing"


cosign, lol


In fairness, I'm trying to learn. I'm not saying what I'm doing has any strategic advantage, but I do believe the potential is there.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oban14

One will be used on passing plays, the other on running plays. I'm trying to determine if it would be better value to just cap at 48 and let the auto boosts go or save up to 61 or 68 and then let it go from there.


Saving up for 61 or 68 gains nothing...

You will still need to train other attributes, so you won't be losing out on any training value.
 
drakeborn
offline
Link
 
Use the player builder to test your different strategies, oban14 (yummy Scotch btw). For one of my new specialized players, I found I do actually get an advantage by saving SPs and training until I could hit the 3:1 cap rather than the usual slowbuild way of hitting 48 all at once and then continuing. Granted, the difference was only 1.7 SPs saved, but it was still a better.
 
TheGreatPuma
offline
Link
 
Deathblades advice has been spot on here.

The only time I disagree is saying that you should always cap ASAP. That's not always true. Sometimes it doesn't buy you much to cap at certain levels.

Take a WR for instance. Their natural gains are .33 SP per level for a primary. So at level 3 he has enough to cap speed, say 23.66 speed with 25 SP. Two options: Cap or Wait to level 4:

Cap at level 3, spend all 25 SP: speed = 48.66
level 4 speed = 48.99, with 5 SP

Wait, train speed up another point, cap at level 4:
Level 3 speed: 23.66
Level 4 speed: 24.99 + 24 SP = 48.99 + 6 SP

So by training a bit more and waiting a level to cap you saved yourself one SP. It could be argued that the training you spend on Speed from level 3 to 4 could have been spent elsewhere as well, so the benefit isn't necessarily a full SP, but I think you get the point.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drakeborn
Use the player builder to test your different strategies, oban14 (yummy Scotch btw). For one of my new specialized players, I found I do actually get an advantage by saving SPs and training until I could hit the 3:1 cap rather than the usual slowbuild way of hitting 48 all at once and then continuing. Granted, the difference was only 1.7 SPs saved, but it was still a better.


If players could get by with only one attribute...sure. But since you will HAVE to train other attributes anyway, you may as well benefit from from both training and level up bonuses, rather than just pick the most beneficial one.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheGreatPuma
Deathblades advice has been spot on here.

The only time I disagree is saying that you should always cap ASAP. That's not always true. Sometimes it doesn't buy you much to cap at certain levels.

Take a WR for instance. Their natural gains are .33 SP per level for a primary. So at level 3 he has enough to cap speed, say 23.66 speed with 25 SP. Two options: Cap or Wait to level 4:

Cap at level 3, spend all 25 SP: speed = 48.66
level 4 speed = 48.99, with 5 SP

Wait, train speed up another point, cap at level 4:
Level 3 speed: 23.66
Level 4 speed: 24.99 + 24 SP = 48.99 + 6 SP

So by training a bit more and waiting a level to cap you saved yourself one SP. It could be argued that the training you spend on Speed from level 3 to 4 could have been spent elsewhere as well, so the benefit isn't necessarily a full SP, but I think you get the point.


Or you could train it to 90%+, then cap it, then finish training it, for an extra SP.
 
GMathiasf
offline
Link
 
This is SP Hoarding, not slow-building.
 
drakeborn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by drakeborn

Use the player builder to test your different strategies, oban14 (yummy Scotch btw). For one of my new specialized players, I found I do actually get an advantage by saving SPs and training until I could hit the 3:1 cap rather than the usual slowbuild way of hitting 48 all at once and then continuing. Granted, the difference was only 1.7 SPs saved, but it was still a better.


If players could get by with only one attribute...sure. But since you will HAVE to train other attributes anyway, you may as well benefit from from both training and level up bonuses, rather than just pick the most beneficial one.


Oh, I agree. This build in particular is a highly specialized experiment.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.