User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Um, isn't it against the rules to gut a team?
Page:
 
LiveWire
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by LiveWire

Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader


Originally posted by LiveWire



Originally posted by Awesomus_Prime




couldn't find a GM or a Coordinator? Hmm, I've seen a few people make posts looking for one or the other, and they get a ton of "I will do it" posts.


He wanted to keep it in house, to people who knew the team, had been there from the start of the season. It's his choice who he wants in it, and if no one on the team cared enough to step up why should he care enough to keep it. I don't understand you people, a few weeks ago you wanted him dead. Now, he left and you want him... back? Which is it? Staying or going? You can't have your cake and eat it too!




Speaking for myself, I'd like players to honor contracts, owner to honor commitments, and all involved to settle their disputes OUTSIDE of any current season. That's the only way for it to be fair for all involved.


If people WANT to be released, and on good terms, isn't that honoring the person? Situtations change, the players wanted release, let them go. Sometimes you have to let go of that which you love the most.



Uh, no. The LEAGUE (and the leagues of those who got a fresh batch of players) were all adversely affected by the owner's abdication of his commitment. This isn't that hard--if you're not prepared to own a team for an entire season, DON'T START A NEW SEASON.



What if his life situation changed, unforseen circumstances? Should he be obligated to a GAME to neglect real life situations to complete a "commitment" to a game? What if he has cancer, and has to have Chemo? You do not know this, you didn't even bother to find out. Instead, like the rest of the blind sheep wandering through this pasture, you chose to believe the worst.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Icespyder
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

Originally posted by LiveWire


Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader



Originally posted by LiveWire




Originally posted by Awesomus_Prime





couldn't find a GM or a Coordinator? Hmm, I've seen a few people make posts looking for one or the other, and they get a ton of "I will do it" posts.


He wanted to keep it in house, to people who knew the team, had been there from the start of the season. It's his choice who he wants in it, and if no one on the team cared enough to step up why should he care enough to keep it. I don't understand you people, a few weeks ago you wanted him dead. Now, he left and you want him... back? Which is it? Staying or going? You can't have your cake and eat it too!




Speaking for myself, I'd like players to honor contracts, owner to honor commitments, and all involved to settle their disputes OUTSIDE of any current season. That's the only way for it to be fair for all involved.


If people WANT to be released, and on good terms, isn't that honoring the person? Situtations change, the players wanted release, let them go. Sometimes you have to let go of that which you love the most.



Uh, no. The LEAGUE (and the leagues of those who got a fresh batch of players) were all adversely affected by the owner's abdication of his commitment. This isn't that hard--if you're not prepared to own a team for an entire season, DON'T START A NEW SEASON.



Life changes, I'm sure you are aware of that. The admins feel the same way, since they allow teams to be sold back.



What is "allowed" doesn't always equal what is "honorable", nor what is "right". This team should have been internally managed and kept intact for the remainder of the current season--anything beyond that is after-the-fact rationalization rather than justification.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by LiveWire
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

Originally posted by LiveWire


Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader



Originally posted by LiveWire




Originally posted by Awesomus_Prime





couldn't find a GM or a Coordinator? Hmm, I've seen a few people make posts looking for one or the other, and they get a ton of "I will do it" posts.


He wanted to keep it in house, to people who knew the team, had been there from the start of the season. It's his choice who he wants in it, and if no one on the team cared enough to step up why should he care enough to keep it. I don't understand you people, a few weeks ago you wanted him dead. Now, he left and you want him... back? Which is it? Staying or going? You can't have your cake and eat it too!




Speaking for myself, I'd like players to honor contracts, owner to honor commitments, and all involved to settle their disputes OUTSIDE of any current season. That's the only way for it to be fair for all involved.


If people WANT to be released, and on good terms, isn't that honoring the person? Situtations change, the players wanted release, let them go. Sometimes you have to let go of that which you love the most.



Uh, no. The LEAGUE (and the leagues of those who got a fresh batch of players) were all adversely affected by the owner's abdication of his commitment. This isn't that hard--if you're not prepared to own a team for an entire season, DON'T START A NEW SEASON.



What if his life situation changed, unforseen circumstances? Should he be obligated to a GAME to neglect real life situations to complete a "commitment" to a game? What if he has cancer, and has to have Chemo? You do not know this, you didn't even bother to find out. Instead, like the rest of the blind sheep wandering through this pasture, you chose to believe the worst.



That was sillier than your earlier posts--congrats.

 
FBGProfessor
offline
Link
 
This is the same as in fantasy football where a player dumps all their good guys into Free Agency and gives up mid-season. It destroys the balance of the league. And there are only two reasons to explain it:
a) absolute and stupid ignorance; if you don't have time to run the team find a GM who does (easy to do by posting on the public forums) or SELL the team to someone who does have the time and interest.
b) What you really wanted was to get your good players off of this team and to other teams that you own or GM or have players and you decided it was cheaper and easier to buy the team and then move everyone (and let everyone else go, which of course they would want to do). This avoids the need to offer a comparable trade value and saves your team the need to give players or money to get your guys. For the cost of 1000 FP if there are quite a few players involved it is a good deal.

Congratulations--you jobbed the system but please don't act like we are bad for calling you on it.
 
LiveWire
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by Icespyder

Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader


Originally posted by LiveWire



Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader




Originally posted by LiveWire





Originally posted by Awesomus_Prime






couldn't find a GM or a Coordinator? Hmm, I've seen a few people make posts looking for one or the other, and they get a ton of "I will do it" posts.


He wanted to keep it in house, to people who knew the team, had been there from the start of the season. It's his choice who he wants in it, and if no one on the team cared enough to step up why should he care enough to keep it. I don't understand you people, a few weeks ago you wanted him dead. Now, he left and you want him... back? Which is it? Staying or going? You can't have your cake and eat it too!




Speaking for myself, I'd like players to honor contracts, owner to honor commitments, and all involved to settle their disputes OUTSIDE of any current season. That's the only way for it to be fair for all involved.


If people WANT to be released, and on good terms, isn't that honoring the person? Situtations change, the players wanted release, let them go. Sometimes you have to let go of that which you love the most.



Uh, no. The LEAGUE (and the leagues of those who got a fresh batch of players) were all adversely affected by the owner's abdication of his commitment. This isn't that hard--if you're not prepared to own a team for an entire season, DON'T START A NEW SEASON.



Life changes, I'm sure you are aware of that. The admins feel the same way, since they allow teams to be sold back.



What is "allowed" doesn't always equal what is "honorable", nor what is "right". This team should have been internally managed and kept intact for the remainder of the current season--anything beyond that is after-the-fact rationalization rather than justification.


Honor on the internet? Honor to people who show no respect? Honor to people who would draw blood over a game? Why? WHAT IF HE HAS CANCER?!? THINK OF THE CANCER!
 
LiveWire
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FBGProfessor
This is the same as in fantasy football where a player dumps all their good guys into Free Agency and gives up mid-season. It destroys the balance of the league. And there are only two reasons to explain it:
a) absolute and stupid ignorance; if you don't have time to run the team find a GM who does (easy to do by posting on the public forums) or SELL the team to someone who does have the time and interest.
b) What you really wanted was to get your good players off of this team and to other teams that you own or GM or have players and you decided it was cheaper and easier to buy the team and then move everyone (and let everyone else go, which of course they would want to do). This avoids the need to offer a comparable trade value and saves your team the need to give players or money to get your guys. For the cost of 1000 FP if there are quite a few players involved it is a good deal.

Congratulations--you jobbed the system but please don't act like we are bad for calling you on it.


You are bad and you should feel bad. I hope you have nightmares tonight.
 
FBGProfessor
offline
Link
 
This is a total red herring. DID he have cancer? What circumstances changed? Did cancer forbid him from selling the team to a competent owner? Did cancer forbid him from finding a GM?

Originally posted by LiveWire
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

Originally posted by LiveWire


Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader



Originally posted by LiveWire




Originally posted by Awesomus_Prime





couldn't find a GM or a Coordinator? Hmm, I've seen a few people make posts looking for one or the other, and they get a ton of "I will do it" posts.


He wanted to keep it in house, to people who knew the team, had been there from the start of the season. It's his choice who he wants in it, and if no one on the team cared enough to step up why should he care enough to keep it. I don't understand you people, a few weeks ago you wanted him dead. Now, he left and you want him... back? Which is it? Staying or going? You can't have your cake and eat it too!




Speaking for myself, I'd like players to honor contracts, owner to honor commitments, and all involved to settle their disputes OUTSIDE of any current season. That's the only way for it to be fair for all involved.


If people WANT to be released, and on good terms, isn't that honoring the person? Situtations change, the players wanted release, let them go. Sometimes you have to let go of that which you love the most.



Uh, no. The LEAGUE (and the leagues of those who got a fresh batch of players) were all adversely affected by the owner's abdication of his commitment. This isn't that hard--if you're not prepared to own a team for an entire season, DON'T START A NEW SEASON.



What if his life situation changed, unforseen circumstances? Should he be obligated to a GAME to neglect real life situations to complete a "commitment" to a game? What if he has cancer, and has to have Chemo? You do not know this, you didn't even bother to find out. Instead, like the rest of the blind sheep wandering through this pasture, you chose to believe the worst.


 
Icespyder
offline
Link
 
I even asked of the validity of the move before I made in the Gutting/Collusion thread found in Announcements. I got no response from everyone that is so upset in here. If you felt so strongly about the issue, a response would have been nice instead you go on crying over nothing.

I gave the new owner plenty of time to fill up the roster again, as soon as I contacted him about the team opening I told him that most players would probably not stay with the team.
 
LiveWire
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FBGProfessor
This is a total red herring. DID he have cancer? What circumstances changed? Did cancer forbid him from selling the team to a competent owner? Did cancer forbid him from finding a GM?

Originally posted by LiveWire

Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader


Originally posted by LiveWire



Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader




Originally posted by LiveWire





Originally posted by Awesomus_Prime






couldn't find a GM or a Coordinator? Hmm, I've seen a few people make posts looking for one or the other, and they get a ton of "I will do it" posts.


He wanted to keep it in house, to people who knew the team, had been there from the start of the season. It's his choice who he wants in it, and if no one on the team cared enough to step up why should he care enough to keep it. I don't understand you people, a few weeks ago you wanted him dead. Now, he left and you want him... back? Which is it? Staying or going? You can't have your cake and eat it too!




Speaking for myself, I'd like players to honor contracts, owner to honor commitments, and all involved to settle their disputes OUTSIDE of any current season. That's the only way for it to be fair for all involved.


If people WANT to be released, and on good terms, isn't that honoring the person? Situtations change, the players wanted release, let them go. Sometimes you have to let go of that which you love the most.



Uh, no. The LEAGUE (and the leagues of those who got a fresh batch of players) were all adversely affected by the owner's abdication of his commitment. This isn't that hard--if you're not prepared to own a team for an entire season, DON'T START A NEW SEASON.



What if his life situation changed, unforseen circumstances? Should he be obligated to a GAME to neglect real life situations to complete a "commitment" to a game? What if he has cancer, and has to have Chemo? You do not know this, you didn't even bother to find out. Instead, like the rest of the blind sheep wandering through this pasture, you chose to believe the worst.




Why does the fish have to be herring, and why must it be red. This is not red herring, it's a striped bass. The walleye has afflicted his pond and the blue gill no longer swim as strong. The minnows flee in fear and the the muskee's rule supreme.
 
Tigerbait0307
offline
Link
 
I think i'm more or a blind bat just looking for blood. Yeah I dont wander pastures I wander the night.


Hey when you get off the soap box can I use it.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Icespyder
I even asked of the validity of the move before I made in the Gutting/Collusion thread found in Announcements. I got no response from everyone that is so upset in here. If you felt so strongly about the issue, a response would have been nice instead you go on crying over nothing.

I gave the new owner plenty of time to fill up the roster again, as soon as I contacted him about the team opening I told him that most players would probably not stay with the team.



Again, that's not even close to a valid justification for throwing that team's LEAGUE and the leagues that the players defected to into chaos. Try as you might and you will not find a valid justification for abdicating one's commitments.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Icespyder

I gave the new owner plenty of time to fill up the roster again, as soon as I contacted him about the team opening I told him that most players would probably not stay with the team.



Exactly how much time was there between you telling him about the team and him taking it?

 
FBGProfessor
offline
Link
 
Cutting a bunch of players to move them to other teams is pretty obviously the definition of "gutting". Did you give the owner the off season? What do you mean "plenty of time"? Are you the guy with cancer? What was the reason for cutting your players and your friend's players? Why didn't you trade for them?
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Ug, this got much worse since I posted.

1) STOP USING NESTED QUOTES. Take the time to delete some stuff out of your quotes.

2) I don't care what your thoughts are on people selling teams, on people releasing players just before selling teams, or how any of this relates to a board game. If you don't have anything related to this topic: that being the potential of any sort of cheating and any info that can help solve this issue one way or the other, DO NOT POST.

If you want to talk about those other topics, go to another thread or, if one doesn't exist, create one and debate away.

3) Owners are not obligated to keep a team for one second longer than they would like, whether it throws the balance of the league a bit out of whack or not. It's no worse than if LdT got injured 7 games into the season after averaging close to 200 yards and 2 TDs a game. The NFL isn't going to say "wait, we have to keep things balanced, no more games till he gets better or it's not fair to the teams the Chargers already played!" Things happen, teams/leagues change.

In conclusion, cut it out or I'm locking the thread
 
FBGProfessor
offline
Link
 
Obviously you have nothing intelligent to say to justify yourself so you resort to absurdities.Originally posted by FBGProfessor
I'm a dumbass who likes nested quotes


Last edited May 7, 2008 14:23:12
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.