I hate the BCS and have always backed a playoff...and I don't really want to get too involved in this argument/discussion. All I have to say though, is if you believe Utah would have drilled Ohio State OR possibly even beaten Texas..then you should just go watch the Utah/TCU game. Utah was extremely lucky to win that one as TCU missed two 4th quarter field goals.
Utah is a very good team but to make a blanket statement that they would drill or beat any other team based upon their performance against an Alabama team that was missing its best offensive lineman(hence the increased amount of sacks by the Utah defensive) is not a smart thing to say. Now, does one offensive lineman make a game...NO and I truly believe Utah was probably better than Alabama...but...I don't think Utah beats USC, Florida, Oklahoma, Texas or Ohio State(maybe Ohio State
) I think Utah could make a game of any of those match ups, I just don't think they are a better team than those listed above.
To the person who said Oklahoma was clearly the better school...go see a doctor. Texas beats Oklahoma on a neutral field by 10(i believe it was) and loses to Tech in Lubbock on a last second play by probably the best receiver on the field and probably one of the best in college ball this year. Yes Oklahoma drilled Tech...at home where they should win. So again..to say Oklahoma was CLEARLY better is just dumb. It was a terrible situation for all the schools to be in but what made it worse is the way the Big 12 handles their tiebreakers. Allowing BCS standings to determine a conference champion is insane.
anyway, have a wonderful day guys.
edit: Wish to God we could have a damn playoff so we wouldn't have to have these kinds of discussions. I would love to see those top teams..inluding Utah play each other!!
Utah is a very good team but to make a blanket statement that they would drill or beat any other team based upon their performance against an Alabama team that was missing its best offensive lineman(hence the increased amount of sacks by the Utah defensive) is not a smart thing to say. Now, does one offensive lineman make a game...NO and I truly believe Utah was probably better than Alabama...but...I don't think Utah beats USC, Florida, Oklahoma, Texas or Ohio State(maybe Ohio State
) I think Utah could make a game of any of those match ups, I just don't think they are a better team than those listed above.To the person who said Oklahoma was clearly the better school...go see a doctor. Texas beats Oklahoma on a neutral field by 10(i believe it was) and loses to Tech in Lubbock on a last second play by probably the best receiver on the field and probably one of the best in college ball this year. Yes Oklahoma drilled Tech...at home where they should win. So again..to say Oklahoma was CLEARLY better is just dumb. It was a terrible situation for all the schools to be in but what made it worse is the way the Big 12 handles their tiebreakers. Allowing BCS standings to determine a conference champion is insane.
anyway, have a wonderful day guys.
edit: Wish to God we could have a damn playoff so we wouldn't have to have these kinds of discussions. I would love to see those top teams..inluding Utah play each other!!
Last edited Jan 9, 2009 16:53:27





























