User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Oceania > Oceania AAA Leagues > AAA - "SDT S.C.O.R.E"
Page:
 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HaplosDog
What I find weird about these rankings is that they're too objective. Maybe it's because mine are way more subjective, but some strange stuff happens when it's only about numbers. For example, Avondell's Raiders pull off the upset over BDC, yet BDC moves up one spot while the Raiders stay put.


Welcome to college football!
 
HaplosDog
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by McGruffHawk
Originally posted by HaplosDog

What I find weird about these rankings is that they're too objective. Maybe it's because mine are way more subjective, but some strange stuff happens when it's only about numbers. For example, Avondell's Raiders pull off the upset over BDC, yet BDC moves up one spot while the Raiders stay put.


Welcome to college football!


I don't follow college football very much but, if you're referring to the BCS ranking system, my understanding is that a good portion of it is somewhat subjective. I.E. the AP poll and the coaches' poll.
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HaplosDog
What I find weird about these rankings is that they're too objective. Maybe it's because mine are way more subjective, but some strange stuff happens when it's only about numbers. For example, Avondell's Raiders pull off the upset over BDC, yet BDC moves up one spot while the Raiders stay put.


Yeah, it's weird to see some of the shifts and they're often in direct conflict with expectations, at a glance at least. We're now at a point in the season that we could think of including some kind of "last five games" or "current streak" factor to add some weight to recent trends. :shrug:
 
HaplosDog
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnit643
Originally posted by HaplosDog

What I find weird about these rankings is that they're too objective. Maybe it's because mine are way more subjective, but some strange stuff happens when it's only about numbers. For example, Avondell's Raiders pull off the upset over BDC, yet BDC moves up one spot while the Raiders stay put.


Yeah, it's weird to see some of the shifts and they're often in direct conflict with expectations, at a glance at least. We're now at a point in the season that we could think of including some kind of "last five games" or "current streak" factor to add some weight to recent trends. :shrug:


That's a good idea. I actually do something like that in my rankings, in a subjective, non-numerical kind of way.
 
shutd0wn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HaplosDog
What I find weird about these rankings is that they're too objective. Maybe it's because mine are way more subjective, but some strange stuff happens when it's only about numbers. For example, Avondell's Raiders pull off the upset over BDC, yet BDC moves up one spot while the Raiders stay put.


Go here: http://www.sysfx.org/GLB/rank.php

This will show you who a team beat / lost to and what their WIN % is.

Its a simple concept, I dont why so many people are having a hard time understanding it.

The Raiders did get credit for their win over the BDC. But look who else they beat, losing teams. The BDC BEAT two teams over .500. They've beat teams with better records.

That is what the rankings are based off of. WHO YOU BEAT and WHO YOU LOST TO. It will adjust as teams win and lose. The BDC beat the Gold Coast Crocs. If the Gold Coast Crocs continue to win games, that win will become more and more important to the BDC in the rankings system, as it should. If BDC continues to lose games it will continue to hurt the Gold Coast Crocs because they lost to a losing team. It throws the upset factor in there which alot of ranking systems ignore.

This is why teams will move up even when losing a game. Thats why when people lose to the Mustangs they dont move down. Thats why when people beat the Fiji Storm or District 5 Ducks they dont move up.
Last edited May 12, 2008 19:11:31
 
shutd0wn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wannaknow147

Yeah i guess that could work out.
Even tho, does that really count higher then a loss?


Its all relative. Just because a team wins, regardless of how crappy their opponent was, doesnt automatically mean they should jump substantially in the rankings. That makes actually makes less sense.

The ranking system does not put the past behind you and allow you to jump because of 1 win. It still remembers the teams you lost too and the teams you beat. It will continue to factor them based on their current record into your overall ranking.
 
HaplosDog
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shutd0wn
Originally posted by HaplosDog

What I find weird about these rankings is that they're too objective. Maybe it's because mine are way more subjective, but some strange stuff happens when it's only about numbers. For example, Avondell's Raiders pull off the upset over BDC, yet BDC moves up one spot while the Raiders stay put.


Go here: http://www.sysfx.org/GLB/rank.php

This will show you who a team beat / lost to and what their WIN % is.

Its a simple concept, I dont why so many people are having a hard time understanding it.

The Raiders did get credit for their win over the BDC. But look who else they beat, losing teams. The BDC BEAT two teams over .500. They've beat teams with better records.

That is what the rankings are based off of. WHO YOU BEAT and WHO YOU LOST TO. It will adjust as teams win and lose. The BDC beat the Gold Coast Crocs. If the Gold Coast Crocs continue to win games, that win will become more and more important BDC in the rankings system, as it should. If BDC continues to lose games it will continue to hurt the Gold Coast Crocs because they lost to a losing team.

This is why teams will move up even when losing a game. Thats why when people lose to the Mustangs they dont move down. Thats why when people beat the Fiji Storm or District 5 Ducks they dont move up.


Hey, hold your horses there. I do understand the system. I was just pointing out some odd results of it when earlier games are given as much weight as recent games.
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HaplosDog
Originally posted by shutd0wn

Originally posted by HaplosDog


What I find weird about these rankings is that they're too objective. Maybe it's because mine are way more subjective, but some strange stuff happens when it's only about numbers. For example, Avondell's Raiders pull off the upset over BDC, yet BDC moves up one spot while the Raiders stay put.


Go here: http://www.sysfx.org/GLB/rank.php

This will show you who a team beat / lost to and what their WIN % is.

Its a simple concept, I dont why so many people are having a hard time understanding it.

The Raiders did get credit for their win over the BDC. But look who else they beat, losing teams. The BDC BEAT two teams over .500. They've beat teams with better records.

That is what the rankings are based off of. WHO YOU BEAT and WHO YOU LOST TO. It will adjust as teams win and lose. The BDC beat the Gold Coast Crocs. If the Gold Coast Crocs continue to win games, that win will become more and more important BDC in the rankings system, as it should. If BDC continues to lose games it will continue to hurt the Gold Coast Crocs because they lost to a losing team.

This is why teams will move up even when losing a game. Thats why when people lose to the Mustangs they dont move down. Thats why when people beat the Fiji Storm or District 5 Ducks they dont move up.


Hey, hold your horses there. I do understand the system. I was just pointing out some odd results of it when earlier games are given as much weight as recent games.


I agree.

It doesn't account for when a majority of any single team decides to boost their players. For example, if 75% of my team opted to not boost until Week 8, then our games before Week 8 against teams who had already boosted cannot be realistically compared to our last couple games.
 
shutd0wn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lukin83
I agree.

It doesn't account for when a majority of any single team decides to boost their players. For example, if 75% of my team opted to not boost until Week 8, then our games before Week 8 against teams who had already boosted cannot be realistically compared to our last couple games.


That doesnt make sense at all. So if your team doesnt win until Week 8 or lose to a divisional opponent before then do those not matter either? If two teams tie for the 8th spot of the playoffs, its decided by the H2H matchup. What if that game happened during week 1. It will matter....every game matters.

All teams get better, all players get better. Just because you're a better team now than 2 weeks ago, does not discredit the fact who you won or lost to in the meantime. It definitely wont matter when it comes to deciding who gets into the playoffs and who doesnt, so why should it matter here?
 
Carpy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lukin83


I agree.

It doesn't account for when a majority of any single team decides to boost their players. For example, if 75% of my team opted to not boost until Week 8, then our games before Week 8 against teams who had already boosted cannot be realistically compared to our last couple games.


Levels are over-rated big time.

The majority of games are won and lost by game-planning, scouting and strategy.
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shutd0wn
Originally posted by lukin83

I agree.

It doesn't account for when a majority of any single team decides to boost their players. For example, if 75% of my team opted to not boost until Week 8, then our games before Week 8 against teams who had already boosted cannot be realistically compared to our last couple games.


That doesnt make sense at all. So if your team doesnt win until Week 8 or lose to a divisional opponent before then do those not matter either? If two teams tie for the 8th spot of the playoffs, its decided by the H2H matchup. What if that game happened during week 1. It will matter....every game matters.

All teams get better, all players get better. Just because you're a better team now than 2 weeks ago, does not discredit the fact who you won or lost to in the meantime. It definitely wont matter when it comes to deciding who gets into the playoffs and who doesnt, so why should it matter here?


So, for example, let's say FFLW waited until Week 8 to boost and Sth Queensland boosted right away. Sth Queensland beats FFLW Week 4 with superior players (since they already boosted). Now that FFLW has "caught up" by boosting, they are still the inferior team? I am not discrediting the earlier games. Sth Queensland won that game Week 4, so mad props to them. I don't know if they boosted early or not, nor do I know when and if all of our players have boosted. I am just using this as an example.

I know there is no 100% accurate way of determining this. I am just using boosting as an example of what Haplos is saying. I appreciate what you bring and I love reading this thread every week. I was simply agreeing with Haplos that the earlier games being weighted the same as later games makes for some odd results.
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Carpy
Originally posted by lukin83



I agree.

It doesn't account for when a majority of any single team decides to boost their players. For example, if 75% of my team opted to not boost until Week 8, then our games before Week 8 against teams who had already boosted cannot be realistically compared to our last couple games.


Levels are over-rated big time.

The majority of games are won and lost by game-planning, scouting and strategy.


Believe me. I know that is what is important, but an edge is an edge. Leveling certainly increases the chances of bringing home the W.
 
shutd0wn
offline
Link
 
http://www.sysfx.org/GLB/rank.php

I added a new section to show you the overall records of teams they beat and teams they lost to.

You can see the teams ranked higher have defeated teams with more victories are ranked higher than teams who have defeated weaker opponents.

You can also see in BDC's case, there are a few teams who are ranked higher that have played weaker opponents. That is because BDC lost to Barossa Grapestompers, a losing team. It hurts their rankings because according to the standings it was a definite upset.
 
shutd0wn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lukin83

So, for example, let's say FFLW waited until Week 8 to boost and Sth Queensland boosted right away. Sth Queensland beats FFLW Week 4 with superior players (since they already boosted). Now that FFLW has "caught up" by boosting, they are still the inferior team? I am not discrediting the earlier games. Sth Queensland won that game Week 4, so mad props to them. I don't know if they boosted early or not, nor do I know when and if all of our players have boosted. I am just using this as an example.


There is no real way to gauge any of that. Regardless of what a team looks like on paper, how awesome they possibly can be, all the matters is WINS and LOSSES. You either win, or lose. If that loss keeps you out of the playoffs, then it doesnt matter how great your team is now does it? If they beat you while you were weak, in every aspect of this game they're going to wreak the benefits. They have the H2H over you regardless of how you look at it.

We lost to a team we were clearly better than, but were simply out game planned. There are so many factors that can be played into W's and L's, the only way you can even get a decent scope on it is what happens after the fact.

I know people will say "Our record doesnt resemble how good we really are", and if you look at teams like the Raiders, that could very well be the case. But when it comes to Playoffs and A Championship, only 1 thing matters. Who Wins and who Loses.
 
Staden
offline
Link
 
i like your method the most shutdown (maybe cause our SQ Crushers rank high on it). i like that it takes strength of schedule into account. i think that that is overlooked in most cases and more often ignored by winning teams.
great job to all you rankers though.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.