User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > The fix for powerbacks.... without taking away from their abilities
Page:
 
Scoot
offline
Link
 
i'm in enough power back threads - fix your defense.

as for the OP's point to missed tackles from behind i'm in full support of this. bort hasnt figured out how to make the defenders take real angles so everything is chase. without defenders taking realistic angles, a tweak needs to be made to assume so ... the back needs to be slowed and made easier to tackle for several ticks to compensate.

the big thing with chasing IMO is pushing a player out of bounds. i'm not sure bort's measurements but if a player is near the sideline, some of these missed tackles should go to [out of bounds - tackle ********].
 
jktooley
offline
Link
 
+1 Scoot.
 
Grimareaper
offline
Link
 
+1 I like this idea I think the idea is good and I have two HBs
Last edited Jan 16, 2009 12:23:42
 
Hans Hammer
offline
Link
 
+1 again
 
Raid
offline
Link
 
Tackles from behind should throw off balance more and it should slow the back down, but to be more likely to make the tackle?

you ever tried to drag someone down from behind that is bigger and stronger than you? your main gial in that situation is to slow him down and hope for more people to get there. but if the powerback still rolls a great roll and the tackle just isn't there it shouldn't be that big an issue.

 
jktooley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Atatakakunai
Tackles from behind should throw off balance more and it should slow the back down, but to be more likely to make the tackle?

you ever tried to drag someone down from behind that is bigger and stronger than you? your main gial in that situation is to slow him down and hope for more people to get there. but if the powerback still rolls a great roll and the tackle just isn't there it shouldn't be that big an issue.



It's not that tough to drag down somebody bigger than you from behind IMO... If you can get into their legs, they're going down.
 
Skoll Wolfrun
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jktooley
Originally posted by Atatakakunai

Tackles from behind should throw off balance more and it should slow the back down, but to be more likely to make the tackle?

you ever tried to drag someone down from behind that is bigger and stronger than you? your main gial in that situation is to slow him down and hope for more people to get there. but if the powerback still rolls a great roll and the tackle just isn't there it shouldn't be that big an issue.



It's not that tough to drag down somebody bigger than you from behind IMO... If you can get into their legs, they're going down.


QFT, I was small in HS football but had good basics. Tackling from behind is not difficult if you are willing to take their cleats in the chest.
Last edited Jan 16, 2009 14:02:00
 
Raid
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Skoll Wolfrun
Originally posted by jktooley

Originally posted by Atatakakunai


Tackles from behind should throw off balance more and it should slow the back down, but to be more likely to make the tackle?

you ever tried to drag someone down from behind that is bigger and stronger than you? your main gial in that situation is to slow him down and hope for more people to get there. but if the powerback still rolls a great roll and the tackle just isn't there it shouldn't be that big an issue.



It's not that tough to drag down somebody bigger than you from behind IMO... If you can get into their legs, they're going down.


QFT, I was small in HS football but had good basics. Tackling from behind is not difficult if you are willing to take their cleats in the chest.


you seriously think it's easy to drag them down? I always had problems doing anything but tripping them up, kicked in the faceguard a couple times as well. especially if the guy notices you coming.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
The "fix" for power backs without taking away from their abilities is for LB's to move eq to and put SP's in Tackling and Strength.

It's also the realistic solution.
 
al0x
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
The "fix" for power backs without taking away from their abilities is for LB's to move eq to and put SP's in Tackling and Strength.

It's also the realistic solution.


This exactly, I haven't read the whole thread, but powerbacks only need fixing because every defensive player is pure speed and agility. Its the same with the DE vs OT, DEs didn't need nerfing, OTs needed to adapt.
 
Skvan
offline
Link
 
nothing needs to be nerf'd or even changed. Agents need to adjust their builds to cope with how it is. Half the missed tackles are because LB's are still being told to set power tackles etc and they do not have the tackling skill to pull it off against powerbacks. They need to either pump str and tackling and or change their tackling settings
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by alex2544
Originally posted by Ken1

The "fix" for power backs without taking away from their abilities is for LB's to move eq to and put SP's in Tackling and Strength.

It's also the realistic solution.


This exactly, I haven't read the whole thread, but powerbacks only need fixing because every defensive player is pure speed and agility. Its the same with the DE vs OT, DEs didn't need nerfing, OTs needed to adapt.


I disagree about DE/OT because the level of Speed that OT's need (they actually still need it; the big difference is that the vast majority now have it) was unrealistic for a player who at most should realistically have Speed as his 5th-6th highest stat, behind Blocking, Strength, Agility, Vision, and maybe Confidence.

But let's not turn this into a DE/OT thread.
 
al0x
offline
Link
 
No, thats a different subject.

Back to the thread, its easy to tell when you are playing a powerback, give your LBs money to buy strength and tackling equip when you play one.
 
this_guy1015
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mathias82
All I want is one season. One season of being better then the elusive HB its all I ask. But because all this whinning has almost reached Bort critical mass nerf. I doupt I get that.


lol they already are better. mainly after you pass the first hit their gone.
 
Dianwei32
offline
Link
 
I would be fine with increaing the chance to be tackled from behind, so long as the HB gets a simlar increase in the chance to fight out extra yards against against the defender.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.