User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Ilok
offline
Link
 
Tebow will not have a first round grade and shouldn't go pro. His throwing motion is horrible. and rivals Vince Young as one of the worst I've seen out of the best college QBs. Also it hurts Tebow how many good QBs are going to be in this draft.
 
DangerClose
offline
Link
 
I agree, he's a GOD at Florida now, and would be even bigger if he came back another season, and you're right, too many "classic" NFL-types coming out this year,..and yeah, we got ol' VY here in Tennessee, imho, he's never gonna be what they thought he would be,..
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ilok
Tebow will not have a first round grade and shouldn't go pro. His throwing motion is horrible. and rivals Vince Young as one of the worst I've seen out of the best college QBs. Also it hurts Tebow how many good QBs are going to be in this draft.


Tebow's throwing motion will need to be fixed so he'll need to sit for AT LEAST 1 season in the NFL, however even VY's motion wasn't worse than Byron Leftwich's 5 second wind up.
Last edited Jan 9, 2009 14:42:56
 
Ilok
offline
Link
 
Both Young and Tebow are accurate and make generally smart decisions, and my assessment has nothing to do with their running ability, but that damn wind up throwing motion has never and will never work in the NFL. It takes both of them almost a full second when they start their motion to when they release it. It works in college football because for the most part college secondaries are watered down and even though pro secondaries for the most part aren't shut down, you get safeties a full second to react, it's going to turn out badly.

Leftwich is a totally different animal as the only thing he brings to the game is his throwing and he isn't what I'd call a good NFL QB and is definitely considered a first round bust. You realize he never threw more than 15 TDs in a season, only completed over 60% of his passes 1 season and lost his starting role after three seasons? Leftwich is a great example why Tebow will not be a NFL QB regardless of if he sit or not. If your throwing motion is completely jacked up in college, it's not going to be any better in the pros and if he completely changes his motions, it changes his release, velocity and timing so he'll be a totally new QB when you finish, one with no college experience. You'll be better off converting a RB to be a passer.
 
ChicagoTRS
offline
Link
 
Tebow will be fortunate if he can find an NFL team to draft him as a QB...
 
Ilok
offline
Link
 
oh and it's hard to compare Leftwich's 5 second wind up to Young's 6 foot stride side arm throw. At least Leftwich's release point was over 6 foot, where Young's was around the 5'8" mark. Young literally had to throw through defenders.

Tebow is more comparable to Leftwich though.
 
jloescher3
offline
Link
 
If tebow goes pro, the only team that i think would possibly draft him as a QB would be Jax since hes a local hero. more than likely though hed convert into a FB or TE (if he has hands) much like Randle El, Matt Jones, and Seneca Wallace are now WRs.
 
Ilok
offline
Link
 
plenty of teams will draft him as a QB, just like teams took a chance on Leftwich and Vince Young. There is a big difference between Tebow and Randle El, Matt Jones and Seneca Wallace. Tebow is one of the most successful college QBs ever, where if you combine those threes careers you still don't have a Tebow.

Tebow is raw material and plenty of teams take chances on those types of players. Sure there are a bunch of bust, but when you do find a gem the pay off is massive, the latest being Flacco (which is still pending since 1 seasons doesn't make a career.)
 
MeauxJeaux
offline
Link
 
He would make one hell of a TE. I don't care if he's a mascot, i'm just ready for him to go.
 
jloescher3
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ilok
plenty of teams will draft him as a QB, just like teams took a chance on Leftwich and Vince Young. There is a big difference between Tebow and Randle El, Matt Jones and Seneca Wallace. Tebow is one of the most successful college QBs ever, where if you combine those threes careers you still don't have a Tebow.

Tebow is raw material and plenty of teams take chances on those types of players. Sure there are a bunch of bust, but when you do find a gem the pay off is massive, the latest being Flacco (which is still pending since 1 seasons doesn't make a career.)


he lacks accuracy in the deep ball, which has been proven that youll fail in the nfl if you dont have it. in that regard hes almost exaclty like randle el, jones, and wallace.

also tebows running ability w/o the option will be squashed in the pros and the Dlineman and LBs of the NFL. hell be taken 3rd rd earliest.... and if that early to a team wholl draft him in a different position. as a qb he falls to 5th rd most likely. as you put it hes a great college qb.
 
jloescher3
offline
Link
 
oh and teams learn from mistakes like VY and Leftwich..... they wont draft similar players as highly any more.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jloescher3
Originally posted by Ilok

plenty of teams will draft him as a QB, just like teams took a chance on Leftwich and Vince Young. There is a big difference between Tebow and Randle El, Matt Jones and Seneca Wallace. Tebow is one of the most successful college QBs ever, where if you combine those threes careers you still don't have a Tebow.

Tebow is raw material and plenty of teams take chances on those types of players. Sure there are a bunch of bust, but when you do find a gem the pay off is massive, the latest being Flacco (which is still pending since 1 seasons doesn't make a career.)


he lacks accuracy in the deep ball, which has been proven that youll fail in the nfl if you dont have it. in that regard hes almost exaclty like randle el, jones, and wallace.

also tebows running ability w/o the option will be squashed in the pros and the Dlineman and LBs of the NFL. hell be taken 3rd rd earliest.... and if that early to a team wholl draft him in a different position. as a qb he falls to 5th rd most likely. as you put it hes a great college qb.


First of all, Tebow throws a very good deep ball...his biggest problem is his release and footwork which can be fixed by the right QB coach. 2nd of all, Tom Brady's deep ball is not very good and yet he's one of the best QBs in the NFL. You don't need a great deep ball. Tebow is 6'3 250, tough as nails and the dude is fucking strong...he won't get squashed by anyone. He just played a defense with multiple NFL DLs on it and did well. He's a good runner even without the option and can run on pass plays if nothing is there but the most important thing is that he's a PASS FIRST QB unlike Vick.

 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jloescher3
oh and teams learn from mistakes like VY and Leftwich..... they wont draft similar players as highly any more.


1. He won't come out this season.
2. He'll likely be a 2nd-4th round pick next season.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.