User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Saris
As far as just making the tackle, I'd say a ponderate average of str/tackle/agi/vis should come into play. Otherwise the secondary could have major issues taking down power backs. BUT, a defenders strength and tackling should decide how many additional "dragging" yards a powerback can tack on after contact.

So a corner without exceptional str/tackle would still be able to bring down a powerback, although he'd probably get dragged for a couple yards and his odds of getting his tackle broken would be higher, just not game breakingly so.


THATS BECAUSE POWER BACKS 1v1 AGAINST A FREAKING CORNER BACK AND SAFETY WIN 9 outta 10 freaking times. How many times do you remember Deion taking down Big runningbacks??? 0!!! THats becasue there bult to cover wr, not take out dudes with 100 strength.
 
Welsh76
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by iMan
Originally posted by Welsh76

I would guess it varies depending on the position of the player and the type of tackle he would adopt, my guess would be:

Defensive Line: 70 strength / 60 tackling
Linebackers: 60 strength / 50 tackling
Cornerbacks: 40 strength / 40 tackling

All set to 'Wrap-up' of course.


that makes absolutely no sense
it should be reversed.
its easier to stop the RB before he gets started (near the LOS) then after he gets started (secondary level)


The point is that defensive line players would work on strength/tackling more than linebackers, who would also work on strength/tackling more than the defensive backs.

You can't have defensive backs putting all their points into strength & tackling because he'll also need a lot in confidence when the WR just burns right past him because he doesn't have the speed/agility to keep up.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
I still think power tackling should be more effective against power rushers...

I mean, power rushers charge into people to break tackles. Power tackling misses more often because they get side-stepped. Missing tackles against powerbacks because of being on power tackling makes no sense...


This makes sense to me.
 
swoosh22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by WestbrookFTW
Originally posted by swoosh22

If we are going to have to make players have 70+ str and tackling that is going to give the offenses a huge advantage in this game which I already think they have.

How can a CB/SS/FS have that much in str and tackle when they need speed/agility/vision 70+ as well to cover WRs and not get faked by the QB.


For a CB, you are tackling for the most part WRs. You should have around 48 tackling and 35 strength to bring them down. That isn't that hard...

Now, if WRs stopped going SPEED SPEED SPEED AGILITY, and went carrying/strength, you could have the dominate, possession WRs that are tough to bring down.


This is just going to create a bunch of players in the secondary with a lot of 60's in stats. Which will give speed WRs a dominate advantage.
 
JSSynister
offline
Link
 
Logically speaking, I feel that tackling should be a lot more important to making a tackle stick than strength.

But a defender with say 60ish tackling and only 30 strength may be able to make most tackles, the ball carrier should be able to get a couple more yards out of the play.

Basicly IM saying strength shouldnt be the major factor in making a successful tackle, only your ability to cancel out a ball carriers momentum.

And on the other side of the coin, a 70+ strength defender with only 30ish tackling may be able to lay a big hit and slow down a defender but would more likely fail to COMPLETE the tackle.
 
TuNice
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpride59
Originally posted by Saris

As far as just making the tackle, I'd say a ponderate average of str/tackle/agi/vis should come into play. Otherwise the secondary could have major issues taking down power backs. BUT, a defenders strength and tackling should decide how many additional "dragging" yards a powerback can tack on after contact.

So a corner without exceptional str/tackle would still be able to bring down a powerback, although he'd probably get dragged for a couple yards and his odds of getting his tackle broken would be higher, just not game breakingly so.


THATS BECAUSE POWER BACKS 1v1 AGAINST A FREAKING CORNER BACK AND SAFETY WIN 9 outta 10 freaking times. How many times do you remember Deion taking down Big runningbacks??? 0!!! THats becasue there bult to cover wr, not take out dudes with 100 strength.


Deion sanders also never WANTED to make a tackle and openly admitted that. All he tried to do was push people out of bounds at the most. Often times when CBs are facing larger RBs they will dive at their ankles anyway.
 
BartRock
offline
Link
 
I think in the open field, 150 combined speed/tackling/strength should do the trick at least half the time, because it doesn't have to be a head to head, textbook tackle. He just has to get enough of the guy to get him on the ground.
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
This entire argument you guys are making "what about my cover corner he cant tackle its not fair" is totally hillarious. YOu should never be able to tackle a 100 strength hb one on one, mb slow down, and then he gets tackled by someone else. YOU CANNOT MAKE A TACKLE VS 100 strength runningbacks if you are a cover corner.
 
boondocksaint
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by Deathblade

I still think power tackling should be more effective against power rushers...

I mean, power rushers charge into people to break tackles. Power tackling misses more often because they get side-stepped. Missing tackles against powerbacks because of being on power tackling makes no sense...


This makes sense to me.


I'll agree here as well.
 
TuNice
offline
Link
 
The tackling attribute should be the skill of being able to successfully making a tackle. Strength should be an amplifier to how HARD you can make a tackle
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JSSynister
Logically speaking, I feel that tackling should be a lot more important to making a tackle stick than strength.

But a defender with say 60ish tackling and only 30 strength may be able to make most tackles, the ball carrier should be able to get a couple more yards out of the play.

Basicly IM saying strength shouldnt be the major factor in making a successful tackle, only your ability to cancel out a ball carriers momentum.

And on the other side of the coin, a 70+ strength defender with only 30ish tackling may be able to lay a big hit and slow down a defender but would more likely fail to COMPLETE the tackle.


Good post. That makes sense.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
I know Bort would like to have us toss out a wide range of guesses, but I'm less concerned about a magic number than I am the tales that I keep reading where LBs and CBs have tackling and strength in the 30s and yet consistenly going a couple of games in a row without missing a tackle. That just doesn't ring right to me.


That's kinda why I'm asking this, Larry. People complain about missing tackles, but missing 3-4 tackles in a game vs one of these guys when you have 30 strength and 40 tackling and aren't running full speed with your 90 spd/agility doesn't really seem that out of line to me, even with "wrap up" settings.

I mean, you don't want power backs to be the end-all build, but you want to make their skills worthwhile as well, so a tiny weak CB doesn't take him down every time.
 
iMan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Welsh76
Originally posted by iMan

Originally posted by Welsh76


I would guess it varies depending on the position of the player and the type of tackle he would adopt, my guess would be:

Defensive Line: 70 strength / 60 tackling
Linebackers: 60 strength / 50 tackling
Cornerbacks: 40 strength / 40 tackling

All set to 'Wrap-up' of course.


that makes absolutely no sense
it should be reversed.
its easier to stop the RB before he gets started (near the LOS) then after he gets started (secondary level)


The point is that defensive line players would work on strength/tackling more than linebackers, who would also work on strength/tackling more than the defensive backs.

You can't have defensive backs putting all their points into strength & tackling because he'll also need a lot in confidence when the WR just burns right past him because he doesn't have the speed/agility to keep up.


DL dont work on tackling more than linebacker
as a guy that plays both IRL, LB practice much more on the tackling (whether it is heads up or at an angle)
DL work a lot on footword
 
billthekill
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by Deathblade

I still think power tackling should be more effective against power rushers...

I mean, power rushers charge into people to break tackles. Power tackling misses more often because they get side-stepped. Missing tackles against powerbacks because of being on power tackling makes no sense...


This makes sense to me.


+1

 
Link
 
Seriously, at least 85-90% of the carrier's strength and the same for carrying. Why? Even a 190 lb. CB can tackle a 245+ lb RB. The variable is the 10 Power Through as not all backs will have it. So, is just the defensive players tackling ability alone or does their strength+tackling both come into play. It just depends on how the attributes add together to make a well-rounded player that will not only stop the run but have the agility to play the pass .

Actual numbers:
RB - 100 str + 70 carrying + 60 speed/agility + 10 SA + 15 VA = 255 points

So I would say 85-90% of 255 = 216-229; A defensive player of which should be Strength, Tackling, Agility + any SA/VA .
Last edited Dec 29, 2008 19:09:07
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.