User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Special Teamer Ability does NOT apply to Punters-Kickers-Returners
Page:
 
BansheeTime
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by Bort

how is kos/krs ambiguous? There is a kos/krs depth chart slot.


Bort: It is not completely ambiguous if you live and breathe the game and know the charts backwards and forwards.

It IS ambiguous if you compare the Special teamer description to other descriptions (which specifically preclude returners for instance).

It is also misleading in that it starts by speaking to special teams as a whole rather than referring specifically to depth charts, and it is not unreasonable to think KRS= Kick Return squad, which would normally include the Returner in general parlance.

Either way, thanks for your attention to this


+1 to Bort, and if you don't know the positions at level 25, it's your fault for not paying attention.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
I suppose I could include KR/PR in the special teamer ability, since there is no "return man" ability (though I have plans to add that one, but I'm waiting on our designer to send me the template for the buttons). It would mean there would be no reason to add a "return man" ability.

The intent of the ability was for it to be only for the guys blocking and tackling, mainly because KR/PR already has an SA related to it.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BansheeTime
Originally posted by Shalubis

Parse these two VP explanations having to do with special teams and tell me that there aren't distinct differences that would lead you to believe that Special Teamer includes all special teamers. Check it out:

Distance Runner
Playing on kickoffs can take a lot out of you. Each level of Distance Runner lessens this player's energy usage on kickoffs and punts by 5%, except when playing KR/PR.

Special Teamer
Special teams is 1/3 of the game. Each level of Special Teamer gives a +1% bonus to all attributes when playing on KOS or KRS.


Distance runner specifically includes and exclusionary clause, "except when playing KR/PR" and Special Teamer does not. The difference between the two makes it clear that Special Teamer would in fact include all players on KOS/KRS and not just those on the KOS/KRS depth chart.


The first one just generalizes a group, and then takes a position out of it. The 2nd one specifies a specific position. I don't understand what you guys want other than somebody to do it for you.


A close reading and fairly deep knowledge of the mechanics of the GLB-specific depth chart are required to make this distinction. It is not unreasonable for a Kicker or Returner to think that it might apply to them if they are not a GM and familiar with the difference between the GLB charts and the common designations used in actual football.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I suppose I could include KR/PR in the special teamer ability, since there is no "return man" ability (though I have plans to add that one, but I'm waiting on our designer to send me the template for the buttons). It would mean there would be no reason to add a "return man" ability.

The intent of the ability was for it to be only for the guys blocking and tackling, mainly because KR/PR already has an SA related to it.


I think applying to the Returner would be fine mechanic-wise...my main point is that the description could be a little more clear if you don't make that change...
 
BansheeTime
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by BansheeTime

Originally posted by Shalubis


Parse these two VP explanations having to do with special teams and tell me that there aren't distinct differences that would lead you to believe that Special Teamer includes all special teamers. Check it out:

Distance Runner
Playing on kickoffs can take a lot out of you. Each level of Distance Runner lessens this player's energy usage on kickoffs and punts by 5%, except when playing KR/PR.

Special Teamer
Special teams is 1/3 of the game. Each level of Special Teamer gives a +1% bonus to all attributes when playing on KOS or KRS.


Distance runner specifically includes and exclusionary clause, "except when playing KR/PR" and Special Teamer does not. The difference between the two makes it clear that Special Teamer would in fact include all players on KOS/KRS and not just those on the KOS/KRS depth chart.


The first one just generalizes a group, and then takes a position out of it. The 2nd one specifies a specific position. I don't understand what you guys want other than somebody to do it for you.


A close reading and fairly deep knowledge of the mechanics of the GLB-specific depth chart are required to make this distinction. It is not unreasonable for a Kicker or Returner to think that it might apply to them if they are not a GM and familiar with the difference between the GLB charts and the common designations used in actual football.


It's not an SA for level 1 players entering the game, it's a VA for players who are supposed to have some knowledge of the game, i.e. a "veteran".
 
Santah
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
how is kos/krs ambiguous? There is a kos/krs depth chart slot.


Your description doesn't contain the words "depth chart". Plus the other skill for specials specifically mentioned it didn't apply to KR/PR.
Last edited Dec 27, 2008 17:00:28
 
BansheeTime
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BansheeTime
Originally posted by Shalubis

Parse these two VP explanations having to do with special teams and tell me that there aren't distinct differences that would lead you to believe that Special Teamer includes all special teamers. Check it out:

Distance Runner
Playing on kickoffs can take a lot out of you. Each level of Distance Runner lessens this player's energy usage on kickoffs and punts by 5%, except when playing KR/PR.

Special Teamer
Special teams is 1/3 of the game. Each level of Special Teamer gives a +1% bonus to all attributes when playing on KOS or KRS.


Distance runner specifically includes and exclusionary clause, "except when playing KR/PR" and Special Teamer does not. The difference between the two makes it clear that Special Teamer would in fact include all players on KOS/KRS and not just those on the KOS/KRS depth chart.


The first one just generalizes a group, and then takes a position out of it. The 2nd one specifies a specific position. I don't understand what you guys want other than somebody to do it for you.


 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BansheeTime
Originally posted by tautology

Originally posted by BansheeTime


Originally posted by Shalubis



Parse these two VP explanations having to do with special teams and tell me that there aren't distinct differences that would lead you to believe that Special Teamer includes all special teamers. Check it out:

Distance Runner
Playing on kickoffs can take a lot out of you. Each level of Distance Runner lessens this player's energy usage on kickoffs and punts by 5%, except when playing KR/PR.

Special Teamer
Special teams is 1/3 of the game. Each level of Special Teamer gives a +1% bonus to all attributes when playing on KOS or KRS.


Distance runner specifically includes and exclusionary clause, "except when playing KR/PR" and Special Teamer does not. The difference between the two makes it clear that Special Teamer would in fact include all players on KOS/KRS and not just those on the KOS/KRS depth chart.


The first one just generalizes a group, and then takes a position out of it. The 2nd one specifies a specific position. I don't understand what you guys want other than somebody to do it for you.


A close reading and fairly deep knowledge of the mechanics of the GLB-specific depth chart are required to make this distinction. It is not unreasonable for a Kicker or Returner to think that it might apply to them if they are not a GM and familiar with the difference between the GLB charts and the common designations used in actual football.


It's not an SA for level 1 players entering the game, it's a VA for players who are supposed to have some knowledge of the game, i.e. a "veteran".


I hear what you are saying, but why would you make an argument to maintain a description that is unclear unless you indeed have a clear undertsanding on these mechanical distinctions in the game? What about folks for whom English is not their first language? The descritions could use more clarity and consistency in their application to the skills.

Seems simple enough to me.

Edit: and nice work quoting yourself, btw
Last edited Dec 27, 2008 16:59:51
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BansheeTime
Originally posted by BansheeTime

Originally posted by Shalubis


Parse these two VP explanations having to do with special teams and tell me that there aren't distinct differences that would lead you to believe that Special Teamer includes all special teamers. Check it out:

Distance Runner
Playing on kickoffs can take a lot out of you. Each level of Distance Runner lessens this player's energy usage on kickoffs and punts by 5%, except when playing KR/PR.

Special Teamer
Special teams is 1/3 of the game. Each level of Special Teamer gives a +1% bonus to all attributes when playing on KOS or KRS.


Distance runner specifically includes and exclusionary clause, "except when playing KR/PR" and Special Teamer does not. The difference between the two makes it clear that Special Teamer would in fact include all players on KOS/KRS and not just those on the KOS/KRS depth chart.


The first one just generalizes a group, and then takes a position out of it. The 2nd one specifies a specific position. I don't understand what you guys want other than somebody to do it for you.




By the way, you seem to have an awfully thorough understanding for someone whose first player was created a couple days ago, and has no veteran points at all...congrats on that I guess?
Last edited Dec 27, 2008 17:03:25
 
atm490
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I suppose I could include KR/PR in the special teamer ability, since there is no "return man" ability (though I have plans to add that one, but I'm waiting on our designer to send me the template for the buttons). It would mean there would be no reason to add a "return man" ability.

The intent of the ability was for it to be only for the guys blocking and tackling, mainly because KR/PR already has an SA related to it.


What about kickers and punters? They also tackle, so shouldn't it apply to them as well?

Personally - I didn't read KOS / KRS to mean "the KOS / KRS depth chart" - I read it to mean "players that play on kick offs and punts". Naturally, I put (only 2) points in the ability because I thought it would help my kicker. Maybe I'm an idiot, maybe not. Either way, if you decide now to apply the skill to KR and PR, you should also apply it to kickers and punters too.
 
BansheeTime
offline
Link
 
I have no problem with changing it for people who have yet to spend their points because they are confused what it does. I do, however, have a problem with people who probably spent their VXP within the first 5 minutes of being online. What about people who spend their XP on SAs too early? Of course, everybody just tells them to reroll, but it's the same concept. Nobody gives them a chance if they keep that player.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BansheeTime
I have no problem with changing it for people who have yet to spend their points because they are confused what it does. I do, however, have a problem with people who probably spent their VXP within the first 5 minutes of being online. What about people who spend their XP on SAs too early? Of course, everybody just tells them to reroll, but it's the same concept. Nobody gives them a chance if they keep that player.


How do you know so much about vet points...you have no players over level 5? Are you really such a careful reader?
 
ozzfan1317
offline
Link
 
I agree +1
 
Mithra
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by BansheeTime

I have no problem with changing it for people who have yet to spend their points because they are confused what it does. I do, however, have a problem with people who probably spent their VXP within the first 5 minutes of being online. What about people who spend their XP on SAs too early? Of course, everybody just tells them to reroll, but it's the same concept. Nobody gives them a chance if they keep that player.


How do you know so much about vet points...you have no players over level 5? Are you really such a careful reader?


So, taut, are you going to spend the rest of this thread checking to see what players every one has, and then dismissing the ideas and opinions of those without old enough players? Grow up.
 
BansheeTime
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by BansheeTime

I have no problem with changing it for people who have yet to spend their points because they are confused what it does. I do, however, have a problem with people who probably spent their VXP within the first 5 minutes of being online. What about people who spend their XP on SAs too early? Of course, everybody just tells them to reroll, but it's the same concept. Nobody gives them a chance if they keep that player.


How do you know so much about vet points...you have no players over level 5? Are you really such a careful reader?


I just read FAQs so I'm atleast the slightest bit informed when everybody starts talking about 'em.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.