User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Promotion/Demotion at the end of the off-season and the problems associated with it - need ideas
Page:
 
REDAZZ
offline
Link
 
I still think that new team owners should start at a "bottom tier" league. The cream will rise to the top. A well ran team will succeed and be promoted as the team level increases. Why should a team that is being started over be placed against teams already rolling along and at a higher level?

Designate when purchasing a team weather you're starting from scratch or continuing from where another owner left off. If you're slow building, you shouldn't be playing teams leveled 2-3 times the one you are starting.

As a team's level increases, the high up the league class you move.
 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
would it be possible to create a game wide restructuring - utilizing the tech already in place for the waiting list for buying teams?


it would have to be fleshed out just a little (i've never seen it since i've owned a team since before it existed)

people would choose either:

- i don't want my team moved
- move me to a capped league (and wipe roster/stadium)
- move me to a different part of the world into a 'level appropriate' division with the following priorities (and force them to rank ALL zones)
* 1st choice - South America
* 2nd choice - Canada
* 3rd choice - USA
* 4th choice - Africa
etc
etc
etc

You would need to find a way to incorporate 'seniority' into it - so that a team that is already in South America gets to stay in south america before a team that's never been in south america can get moved there...(hope that makes sense) - so; if you are currently in South America; and want to stay in South America - you will - UNLESS you have chosen that you want to become a capped team and there aren't any in South America (i'm not sure)

Also - seniority would play in the restructure as well - pretend that everyone want to be moved to South America - obviously everyone can't go there - so that list of people would have to be sorted - First by team owner seniority - if you've owned a team for 6 seasons; you get moved there ahead of someone who's owned a team 5 seasons. As a secondary sort - maybe you give priority to teams who've recently won a league championship; then a conference championship; then record from this past season (or just use your current promotion script for this 2nd step)

Then you would have a massive re-shuffle - just like the old days when teams were handed out...this would include reshuffling divisions to some degree - but only in extreme cases:
- all CPU teams; or teams who are significantly outlevelled AND finished in the bottom half of the conference get moved down

There would be some black and white rules - if your team made the playoffs - you can NOT be moved down - but could be moved up. To sort out who moves up - you would probably use the system you've already got in place.


Beyond the fact that this might be impossible to program - or might take too long to program; so couldn't be a solution for this offseason - what are the problems with it?

edit: added what happens to high demand areas
Last edited Dec 18, 2008 07:54:47
 
nthomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Jed

Basically, do whatever you think is going to work the best and figure no matter what, it's going to be unfair to someone and that person will unfortunately just have to deal with it.


Seems like last season's version worked well enough, minus the team swaps. The main problems were:

1) teams selling after day 40 - I'm less worried about that one because teams are sold all the time and there's not much we can do about it
2) "I forgot" expired teams that were moved to the bottom and then the owner comes back and wants his team back. Now he's stuck at the bottom of the ladder even if he was 16-0 in a pro league and won the title. We've given a bit more warning this season, though, with the alert on the team page, so maybe that won't be as much of an issue.


Why "minus the team swaps"? I think that worked great, at least for EE. Maybe not allow teams to jump from EE A to SA pro, but moving up or down one level in your region, provided you find a trading partner, will only help keep parity in each league. That in turn will lead to more close games, more interest in each and every game, and more long-term committed players. I don't see the down-side.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by TxSteve
would it be possible to create a game wide restructuring - utilizing the tech already in place for the waiting list for buying teams?


it would have to be fleshed out just a little (i've never seen it since i've owned a team since before it existed)

people would choose either:

- i don't want my team moved
- move me to a capped league (and wipe roster/stadium)
- move me to a different part of the world into a 'level appropriate' division with the following priorities (and force them to rank ALL zones)
* 1st choice - South America
* 2nd choice - Canada
* 3rd choice - USA
* 4th choice - Africa
etc
etc
etc

You would need to find a way to incorporate 'seniority' into it - so that a team that is already in South America gets to stay in south america before a team that's never been in south america can get moved there...(hope that makes sense) - so; if you are currently in South America; and want to stay in South America - you will - UNLESS you have chosen that you want to become a capped team and there aren't any in South America (i'm not sure)

Then you would have a massive re-shuffle - just like the old days when teams were handed out...this would include reshuffling divisions to some degree - but only in extreme cases:
- all CPU teams; or teams who are significantly outlevelled AND finished in the bottom half of the conference get moved down

There would be some black and white rules - if your team made the playoffs - you can NOT be moved down - but could be moved up. To sort out who moves up - you would probably use the system you've already got in place.


Beyond the fact that this might be impossible to program - or might take too long to program; so couldn't be a solution for this offseason - what are the problems with it?


I really like this tx
 
Intimnasc
offline
Link
 
One idea that has come up in the past and I personnaly like is allow teams that promote to boost to the median level of the league. This way they are not thrown immediately into a league where they are giving up 3-6 levels. Being more competitive will keep more people interested.
 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Intimnasc
One idea that has come up in the past and I personnaly like is allow teams that promote to boost to the median level of the league. This way they are not thrown immediately into a league where they are giving up 3-6 levels. Being more competitive will keep more people interested.



The problem there is - I sign with a team about to be promoted to a non cap league; from a cap league - just to take advantage of the extra boosts...and then i get released; or traded; or whatever so i can go to the league of my choice...can be easily exploited (even though i like the concept)
Last edited Dec 18, 2008 08:00:37
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Intimnasc
One idea that has come up in the past and I personnaly like is allow teams that promote to boost to the median level of the league. This way they are not thrown immediately into a league where they are giving up 3-6 levels. Being more competitive will keep more people interested.


I like it as well, but yeah what tx said
 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
i find it interesting that there is so little discussion here - BUT - when bort announces what he is doing - there will be 400 pages of complaints within 3 hours.
 
keithj
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TxSteve
i find it interesting that there is so little discussion here - BUT - when bort announces what he is doing - there will be 400 pages of complaints within 3 hours.

Probably because Bort posted it in the suggestion forum. Not many people come here unless they have a suggestion.
 
Link
 
this thread started at like 2 am central standard time(my time zone and it is 9:12 am here on a thursday, so all the day shift people are hurriedly doing there work so that after lunch they can pretend to work while they glb
 
ZachG650
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jared
Originally posted by TxSteve

would it be possible to create a game wide restructuring - utilizing the tech already in place for the waiting list for buying teams?


it would have to be fleshed out just a little (i've never seen it since i've owned a team since before it existed)

people would choose either:

- i don't want my team moved
- move me to a capped league (and wipe roster/stadium)
- move me to a different part of the world into a 'level appropriate' division with the following priorities (and force them to rank ALL zones)
* 1st choice - South America
* 2nd choice - Canada
* 3rd choice - USA
* 4th choice - Africa
etc
etc
etc

You would need to find a way to incorporate 'seniority' into it - so that a team that is already in South America gets to stay in south america before a team that's never been in south america can get moved there...(hope that makes sense) - so; if you are currently in South America; and want to stay in South America - you will - UNLESS you have chosen that you want to become a capped team and there aren't any in South America (i'm not sure)

Then you would have a massive re-shuffle - just like the old days when teams were handed out...this would include reshuffling divisions to some degree - but only in extreme cases:
- all CPU teams; or teams who are significantly outlevelled AND finished in the bottom half of the conference get moved down

There would be some black and white rules - if your team made the playoffs - you can NOT be moved down - but could be moved up. To sort out who moves up - you would probably use the system you've already got in place.


Beyond the fact that this might be impossible to program - or might take too long to program; so couldn't be a solution for this offseason - what are the problems with it?


I really like this tx


yes me too
 
43Hitman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TxSteve
if owners 'forget' and lose their team....even after receiving an alert; etc....then that sucks..but it is just too bad..


people in this game (forum mainly) don't seem to take much responsibility for their actions...that's not going to change until you and the mods make them accountable for their actions..


with the alerts that get sent out....there is no real reason for people to forget..

unless they have gone inactive; etc for some small period of time..maybe an alert should be sent out 40 days prior to team ownership expiring; 30 days prior; 20 days prior; 15 days prior; 10 days prior; and 5; 4; 3; 2; 1....then at least they'd have no excuse


QFT..If you own a team you should be accountable for that team period.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by keithj
Originally posted by TxSteve

i find it interesting that there is so little discussion here - BUT - when bort announces what he is doing - there will be 400 pages of complaints within 3 hours.

Probably because Bort posted it in the suggestion forum. Not many people come here unless they have a suggestion.


totally not true
 
MikeV99
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Ok, so I set up this up based on a suggestion last season:

Instead of processing all promotions/relegations at the start of day 41 and moving all the teams then and there, process it and "flag" the teams who will be moving, and keep doing so each day as teams get sold throughout the offseason. Teams flagged to move up out of the capped leagues get to sign players at their new league's cap. Then at the end of offseason, you move all the teams. Sounds simple enough, right?

I started thinking about it, though, and there are two potential problems with it:

1) Let's say a team a team expires. We flag it, and flag all the teams below to move up. The team owner contacts support and says "Ooops! I forgot to renew my team!" or "I wanted to transfer to my GM" or whatever. Now there is one less team flagged to move down, so one of the "fringe" capped teams is now un-flagged. Problem is: they've been able to recruit above the cap, and now they're not moving. Hrm.

2) Let's say the next season starts on the day after day 45. A team gets sold on day 45. Now somebody gets flagged to move up and literally has less than a day to recruit and prepare for their new league. That doesn't sound fun.

The only thing I've been able to come up with is to do promotion/relegation on day 42, to allow for dealing with people selling teams late or failing team renewals. Then have a roster freeze on day 41 so nobody gets an "unfair advantage" towards recruiting. Sounds like a waste of a day though.

Ideas? Thoughts?


Make it Real simple, The teams that are moving up b/c they are the best in the division, and replacing the two teams that are the worst in the division, REGARDLESS of who else is bought, sold, disbanded etc.....

Those two teams moving up, get the right to recruit at the new leagues level cap..

Other teams getting bumped up due to non-performance reasons (Sales, Dibanding, forgetting to renew, etc...) They do not get to recruit at a higher level..

I know it isn't perfect, but that way you can eliminate the problems with teams not having time to recruit or teams recruiting and then staying put....
 
bruiser 1234
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ZachG650
Originally posted by jared

Originally posted by TxSteve


would it be possible to create a game wide restructuring - utilizing the tech already in place for the waiting list for buying teams?


it would have to be fleshed out just a little (i've never seen it since i've owned a team since before it existed)

people would choose either:

- i don't want my team moved
- move me to a capped league (and wipe roster/stadium)
- move me to a different part of the world into a 'level appropriate' division with the following priorities (and force them to rank ALL zones)
* 1st choice - South America
* 2nd choice - Canada
* 3rd choice - USA
* 4th choice - Africa
etc
etc
etc

You would need to find a way to incorporate 'seniority' into it - so that a team that is already in South America gets to stay in south america before a team that's never been in south america can get moved there...(hope that makes sense) - so; if you are currently in South America; and want to stay in South America - you will - UNLESS you have chosen that you want to become a capped team and there aren't any in South America (i'm not sure)

Then you would have a massive re-shuffle - just like the old days when teams were handed out...this would include reshuffling divisions to some degree - but only in extreme cases:
- all CPU teams; or teams who are significantly outlevelled AND finished in the bottom half of the conference get moved down

There would be some black and white rules - if your team made the playoffs - you can NOT be moved down - but could be moved up. To sort out who moves up - you would probably use the system you've already got in place.


Beyond the fact that this might be impossible to program - or might take too long to program; so couldn't be a solution for this offseason - what are the problems with it?


I really like this tx


yes me too


+1
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.