epic me please
Forum > Suggestions > Players adapting to overused plays
I haven't read the whole thread but I like the idea with one caveat. Play action fakes get implemented so that the bonus for reading the same play over and over is also a correlating penalty on a pass play.
Intimnasc
offline
offline
I like the post. Haven't read all the replies but the original idea is on track with maybe a few tweaks.
Argonut
offline
offline
Would it not be easy for teams with competent OC's to run a bunch of "same plays" to start a game and then change it all up the final 3 quarters? A defense that (automatically) reacts to a certain formation would get killed once the passing starts (or runs to the left in Strong I)
And how about teams that can stop those plays now? (ie: WR screen) They have a D that can stop the play but when the other team uses it a lot to start a game ... the sim engine sees the play and makes changes to the D to be like the sim thinks it should be and not what the successful DC designed.
Then there would be tons of threads from DC's about how the D isn't reacting to the reaction and the game stinks.
I do like the idea in principle
And how about teams that can stop those plays now? (ie: WR screen) They have a D that can stop the play but when the other team uses it a lot to start a game ... the sim engine sees the play and makes changes to the D to be like the sim thinks it should be and not what the successful DC designed.
Then there would be tons of threads from DC's about how the D isn't reacting to the reaction and the game stinks.
I do like the idea in principle
23yrwej
offline
offline
Originally posted by Argonut
Would it not be easy for teams with competent OC's to run a bunch of "same plays" to start a game and then change it all up the final 3 quarters? A defense that (automatically) reacts to a certain formation would get killed once the passing starts (or runs to the left in Strong I)
And how about teams that can stop those plays now? (ie: WR screen) They have a D that can stop the play but when the other team uses it a lot to start a game ... the sim engine sees the play and makes changes to the D to be like the sim thinks it should be and not what the successful DC designed.
Then there would be tons of threads from DC's about how the D isn't reacting to the reaction and the game stinks.
I do like the idea in principle
That's the strategy of it. To trick the defense and that's why you need higher vision so they react faster to the change. The WR Screen isn't one of the bad ones, the strong I offtackle last year was terribly hard to stop. It wouldn't change the play, the players would know it was coming no matter what defensive play was run and react faster as well as try to get in position to stop it but if it's a different play, they can get burned. The nature of the strategy behind it.
Originally posted by Peacesells
I haven't read the whole thread but I like the idea with one caveat. Play action fakes get implemented so that the bonus for reading the same play over and over is also a correlating penalty on a pass play.
I agree with this.
Would it not be easy for teams with competent OC's to run a bunch of "same plays" to start a game and then change it all up the final 3 quarters? A defense that (automatically) reacts to a certain formation would get killed once the passing starts (or runs to the left in Strong I)
And how about teams that can stop those plays now? (ie: WR screen) They have a D that can stop the play but when the other team uses it a lot to start a game ... the sim engine sees the play and makes changes to the D to be like the sim thinks it should be and not what the successful DC designed.
Then there would be tons of threads from DC's about how the D isn't reacting to the reaction and the game stinks.
I do like the idea in principle
That's the strategy of it. To trick the defense and that's why you need higher vision so they react faster to the change. The WR Screen isn't one of the bad ones, the strong I offtackle last year was terribly hard to stop. It wouldn't change the play, the players would know it was coming no matter what defensive play was run and react faster as well as try to get in position to stop it but if it's a different play, they can get burned. The nature of the strategy behind it.
Originally posted by Peacesells
I haven't read the whole thread but I like the idea with one caveat. Play action fakes get implemented so that the bonus for reading the same play over and over is also a correlating penalty on a pass play.
I agree with this.
bmedders
offline
offline
Originally posted by Argonut
Would it not be easy for teams with competent OC's to run a bunch of "same plays" to start a game and then change it all up the final 3 quarters? A defense that (automatically) reacts to a certain formation would get killed once the passing starts (or runs to the left in Strong I)
And how about teams that can stop those plays now? (ie: WR screen) They have a D that can stop the play but when the other team uses it a lot to start a game ... the sim engine sees the play and makes changes to the D to be like the sim thinks it should be and not what the successful DC designed.
Then there would be tons of threads from DC's about how the D isn't reacting to the reaction and the game stinks.
I do like the idea in principle
This is a good idea. Maybe it should only be if a D call fails - and maybe that's a setting DCs can tweak as to defining it (running play over 5 yards, complete pass, etc) and DCs can set it to if the play fails X amount let the players settings tweak it.
Would it not be easy for teams with competent OC's to run a bunch of "same plays" to start a game and then change it all up the final 3 quarters? A defense that (automatically) reacts to a certain formation would get killed once the passing starts (or runs to the left in Strong I)
And how about teams that can stop those plays now? (ie: WR screen) They have a D that can stop the play but when the other team uses it a lot to start a game ... the sim engine sees the play and makes changes to the D to be like the sim thinks it should be and not what the successful DC designed.
Then there would be tons of threads from DC's about how the D isn't reacting to the reaction and the game stinks.
I do like the idea in principle
This is a good idea. Maybe it should only be if a D call fails - and maybe that's a setting DCs can tweak as to defining it (running play over 5 yards, complete pass, etc) and DCs can set it to if the play fails X amount let the players settings tweak it.
23yrwej
offline
offline
Originally posted by bmedders
Originally posted by Argonut
Would it not be easy for teams with competent OC's to run a bunch of "same plays" to start a game and then change it all up the final 3 quarters? A defense that (automatically) reacts to a certain formation would get killed once the passing starts (or runs to the left in Strong I)
And how about teams that can stop those plays now? (ie: WR screen) They have a D that can stop the play but when the other team uses it a lot to start a game ... the sim engine sees the play and makes changes to the D to be like the sim thinks it should be and not what the successful DC designed.
Then there would be tons of threads from DC's about how the D isn't reacting to the reaction and the game stinks.
I do like the idea in principle
This is a good idea. Maybe it should only be if a D call fails - and maybe that's a setting DCs can tweak as to defining it (running play over 5 yards, complete pass, etc) and DCs can set it to if the play fails X amount let the players settings tweak it.
I can see that happening.
Originally posted by Argonut
Would it not be easy for teams with competent OC's to run a bunch of "same plays" to start a game and then change it all up the final 3 quarters? A defense that (automatically) reacts to a certain formation would get killed once the passing starts (or runs to the left in Strong I)
And how about teams that can stop those plays now? (ie: WR screen) They have a D that can stop the play but when the other team uses it a lot to start a game ... the sim engine sees the play and makes changes to the D to be like the sim thinks it should be and not what the successful DC designed.
Then there would be tons of threads from DC's about how the D isn't reacting to the reaction and the game stinks.
I do like the idea in principle
This is a good idea. Maybe it should only be if a D call fails - and maybe that's a setting DCs can tweak as to defining it (running play over 5 yards, complete pass, etc) and DCs can set it to if the play fails X amount let the players settings tweak it.
I can see that happening.
sleepyfool
offline
offline
this sounds good, one thing I would like to see added to this is an additional tactics option where we can set how quickly/slowly the player takes the risk of adapting to the play. Vision is nice to do this, but I'd rather have the option in the individual tactics. This way, we continue to have control over whether the player does this. Don't get me wrong, I think vision should have a big part in this, its just that I would rather have it so that as soon as the player starts to recognize the pattern (his vision affecting this), he then has the option (set through individual tactics) to act on this quickly, or to slowly act on it (i.e. playing it safe in case in the next quarter, or next series, the tactics change).
Spirer
offline
offline
I think a counter for the number of times a play has been called would be easy to code. Then you could assign a tiny bonus to play reading after a few repeats, increasing that exponentially to a moderate bonus after a lot of calls, say 30, and then continue on to a huge bonus say after 50 times.
This would help prevent the 1 play games, which might detract from the game.
This would help prevent the 1 play games, which might detract from the game.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























