User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
mavdaddy22
offline
Link
 
my point exactly.. lol... weve geared down the use of the wr screen to where we only run it about 4 or 5 times a game... i didnt even notice its dominance with the right personel until about half way thru the season..
 
mavdaddy22
offline
Link
 
but thanks for showing off the speed and strength of my wr's! lol... but you can clearly see that wen its run on the short side of the field it is WAY less effective
 
superpunk
offline
Link
 
Something has to be done with the pathing of the CBs.They can't just continually smack into each other leaving the FS to make the tackle 12 yards downfield. If your CB has good vision, agility and speed, he should be able to read that and cut under. Or the WR needs to block the interior CB, leaving the outside corner 1 on 1 against the WR.
 
mavdaddy22
offline
Link
 
true... i think if you see a team that runs it a lot, and you know the down and distance that they normally run it, then just try to make sure that you stay in base defense on the play, the wr can maybe pick 2 cbs but he cant pick a LB.. im sure the issue has come up to bort at some point and hopefully will be fixed.. however my qb's rating may not be 139.9 next year tho... lol
 
missnlife
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by superpunk
Something has to be done with the pathing of the CBs.They can't just continually smack into each other leaving the FS to make the tackle 12 yards downfield. If your CB has good vision, agility and speed, he should be able to read that and cut under. Or the WR needs to block the interior CB, leaving the outside corner 1 on 1 against the WR.


I'm dying to see one of those screens get picked off and taken to the house.
 
DavidD458
offline
Link
 
I sorta agree with the diminishing returns, but it doesn't fix everything.

In power football, if you can't stop a team running, you can't stop a team running. A lot of times, defenses KNOW what play is coming (I-form, majority of the time it's up the middle) but it doesn't mean they can stop it, or are any more likely to stop it later in the game.

SB Screen CAN be stopped (sometimes). Is it too strong right now? Yes. By a LOT? Not really. If you put 2 CBs over there, you won't stop it too often. But it's the same thing in an NFL game, if you have two CBs over there for a WR screen, it's a 1 on 1 for a CB to make a tackle against a WR. CBs with 20 strength, 30 tackling would definitely miss some tackles there, and it'd be a TD.

But I digress-- I agree it's a little too powerful, but its your defenses job to stop it. You can't just ignore it. But the main argument for it -- BOTH teams can run the play. It's not like only underdogs can call a WR screen, anyone can. Fight fire with fire and it evens out. I know it's not the best answer on earth, but hey, it's the truth.

tl;dr: Yeah it's too strong, but teams that have 2 CBs over their shouldn't be complaining; the ones with 3 CBs definitely have an argument.
 
Klydon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DavidD458
I sorta agree with the diminishing returns, but it doesn't fix everything.

In power football, if you can't stop a team running, you can't stop a team running. A lot of times, defenses KNOW what play is coming (I-form, majority of the time it's up the middle) but it doesn't mean they can stop it, or are any more likely to stop it later in the game.

SB Screen CAN be stopped (sometimes). Is it too strong right now? Yes. By a LOT? Not really. If you put 2 CBs over there, you won't stop it too often. But it's the same thing in an NFL game, if you have two CBs over there for a WR screen, it's a 1 on 1 for a CB to make a tackle against a WR. CBs with 20 strength, 30 tackling would definitely miss some tackles there, and it'd be a TD.

But I digress-- I agree it's a little too powerful, but its your defenses job to stop it. You can't just ignore it. But the main argument for it -- BOTH teams can run the play. It's not like only underdogs can call a WR screen, anyone can. Fight fire with fire and it evens out. I know it's not the best answer on earth, but hey, it's the truth.

tl;dr: Yeah it's too strong, but teams that have 2 CBs over their shouldn't be complaining; the ones with 3 CBs definitely have an argument.


It might be a bit strong right now, but if left alone, defenses will adapt tactics and builds to deal with it.

There is a history of stuff like this that is the latest fad and eventually folks figure it out (pitch plays anyone?).

The other thing is not all offense can run it effectively. (Again, have to have the right builds, etc).

At its very basics, offense vs defense is sort of like rock, paper, scissors. If the defense guesses right, you should be screwed in most cases. If they don't, then you should have some success in most cases.

The very best teams can beat you in more than one way and the very best teams can stop you in more than one way as well. The really good offensive teams present a defense with all sorts of issues because they don't really know what the offense has in mind for that particular game.
Last edited Dec 18, 2008 17:12:18
 
missnlife
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Klydon
Originally posted by DavidD458

I sorta agree with the diminishing returns, but it doesn't fix everything.

In power football, if you can't stop a team running, you can't stop a team running. A lot of times, defenses KNOW what play is coming (I-form, majority of the time it's up the middle) but it doesn't mean they can stop it, or are any more likely to stop it later in the game.

SB Screen CAN be stopped (sometimes). Is it too strong right now? Yes. By a LOT? Not really. If you put 2 CBs over there, you won't stop it too often. But it's the same thing in an NFL game, if you have two CBs over there for a WR screen, it's a 1 on 1 for a CB to make a tackle against a WR. CBs with 20 strength, 30 tackling would definitely miss some tackles there, and it'd be a TD.

But I digress-- I agree it's a little too powerful, but its your defenses job to stop it. You can't just ignore it. But the main argument for it -- BOTH teams can run the play. It's not like only underdogs can call a WR screen, anyone can. Fight fire with fire and it evens out. I know it's not the best answer on earth, but hey, it's the truth.

tl;dr: Yeah it's too strong, but teams that have 2 CBs over their shouldn't be complaining; the ones with 3 CBs definitely have an argument.


It might be a bit strong right now, but if left alone, defenses will adapt tactics and builds to deal with it.

There is a history of stuff like this that is the latest fad and eventually folks figure it out (pitch plays anyone?).

The other thing is not all offense can run it effectively. (Again, have to have the right builds, etc).

At its very basics, offense vs defense is sort of like rock, paper, scissors. If the defense guesses right, you should be screwed in most cases. If they don't, then you should have some success in most cases.

The very best teams can beat you in more than one way and the very best teams can stop you in more than one way as well. The really good offensive teams present a defense with all sorts of issues because they don't really know what the offense has in mind for that particular game.


The overall issue with the WR screen really isn't the play itself. There are plays already in existence to stop it. Unfortunately, they won't stop it every time because the real issue with the play is the blocking ability of the guy at WR3, regardless of Str or Blk attributes.

If I were to run the WR screen for an entire game against a team that was running a known stop to the play for an entire game...I guarantee you there would still be a number of plays where the WR3 took on 2 CBs(and occasionally a FS), to spring WR1 for 10-15 yards, maybe more.

Until the pursuit pathing for CBs is fixed, or blocking becomes more about Blocking than Strength, the issue will persist...regardless of defenses created to stop it.
 
mirob
offline
Link
 
The HB screen is kinda dirty too:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=231901&pbp_id=9326710
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=231847&pbp_id=8043718
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=231916&pbp_id=10594134
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=280234&pbp_id=13039573
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=231868&pbp_id=7424413
 
mavdaddy22
offline
Link
 
did anybody happen to watch the carolina game from last week??? well from about the 25 yd line, carolina runs a wr screen where steve smith was on the outside, and the inside wr blocked smith's man, and the inside cb got picked and caught up in between and smith walked in for a TD... just like GLB.
 
chef17
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mavdaddy22
did anybody happen to watch the carolina game from last week??? well from about the 25 yd line, carolina runs a wr screen where steve smith was on the outside, and the inside wr blocked smith's man, and the inside cb got picked and caught up in between and smith walked in for a TD... just like GLB.


But Smith is a beast.
 
ruleslawyer
offline
Link
 
Moose is huge and oldschool, with more points in STR/Block than 30/20 imo. I did see the play though
Last edited Dec 21, 2008 13:36:00
 
GmanV2
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mavdaddy22
did anybody happen to watch the carolina game from last week??? well from about the 25 yd line, carolina runs a wr screen where steve smith was on the outside, and the inside wr blocked smith's man, and the inside cb got picked and caught up in between and smith walked in for a TD... just like GLB.


Didn't get to see it as AFN wasn't showing that game on the channel we get here in Iraq, however, since it applies to GLB, just curious, how many times did they run that screen?

5? 10? 15? Only being a little sarcastic here, and there wasn't a 3rd player blocked was there? That's what the fuss has been about with the WR screen. Not the screen itself, but a WR taking 3 guys out of the play, and teams running the screen relentlessly all game long b/c of it.
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
I'm waiting for a NFL Game where someone drives a car through the hole on a Singleback HB Slam (a la GLB)
 
mavdaddy22
offline
Link
 
im not saying the play is fair.... all im saying is that we were all talking about it and then carolina ran the SAME screen and scored a TD where steve smith was untouched thats all
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.