User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Teams Attempting to Exploit the System
Page:
 
drewsky
offline
Link
 
As an OC who doesn't spam the same play repeatedly, I don't like this suggestion. We do not have absolute authority on which play the sim is going to pick each down. If I have my AI set to 20% strong pitch right, there is a chance that the sim will pick that play 5,6,7 times in a row. It's not probable, but it could happen. Why should my team be penalized because the AI randomly selects the same play multiple times in a row?
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drewsky
As an OC who doesn't spam the same play repeatedly, I don't like this suggestion. We do not have absolute authority on which play the sim is going to pick each down. If I have my AI set to 20% strong pitch right, there is a chance that the sim will pick that play 5,6,7 times in a row. It's not probable, but it could happen. Why should my team be penalized because the AI randomly selects the same play multiple times in a row?


Because

a) That's highly unlikely to happen to you,

b) If it did happen, regardless of the reason it happened, it would be unrealistic for it to work out for you,

c) Preventing and giving out realistic negative consequences (opponent Vision increased against the play) for spamming the same play is extremely important to keep the game realistic and fun (What if half the teams found a play that worked well for them and used only that, switching off which play from game to game? Would that make for fun games to watch?), and

d) It will limit the damage if a play is ever added to the game that works unrealistically well.
 
Colin Mochrie
offline
Link
 
I like the player memory idea.
 
jsiegesm
offline
Link
 
Instead of just giving a plus to vision each time the same play was run, could we also give the D also got a corresponding MINUS to vision when a different play was run from the same formation (to simulate the D jumping the wrong play)?

I'm thinking of the Broncos . . . run left, run left, run left, and now the bootleg rgy pcidy is wide open because the whole D jumps left.
 
buckeyes33
offline
Link
 
eh...i don't really like your numbers and exactly what you said, but i have something along the lines of it. i think if a team runs a play 2 times in a row, the defense gets a 10% boost on the next play. if the team runs a play 5 times in a row, the defense should get a 50% boost on the next play(s). every play they run in a row, they defense should get a 5% bonus, unless it hits 2 or 5. does that make sense?

cause in real life, if you run a running play and get 5-6 yards, and you attempt that same exact run play the next play, the defense is prepared and most of the time the offense gets stopped for a loss.

if you disagree with me, saying that that does not happen, then you have no football knowledge whatsoever.
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
I am all for some type of vision bonus for the defense in these instances...but again it can't be implemented until we have 4-5 plays of each type out of each formation. As I mentioned before if I can scout and find a weakness in an opposing defense currently there might only be one play choice for an inside run out of certain formations (or a TE pass, etc.) If that is the play I need to run to exploit your defensive flaw then I shouldn't be penalized for the fact that there aren't 4-5 different inside runs out of the single back formation. If you want to add additional plays then we can start talking about requiring diversity in playcalling.
 
Ilok
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Buckeyes33
eh...i don't really like your numbers and exactly what you said, but i have something along the lines of it. i think if a team runs a play 2 times in a row, the defense gets a 10% boost on the next play. if the team runs a play 5 times in a row, the defense should get a 50% boost on the next play(s). every play they run in a row, they defense should get a 5% bonus, unless it hits 2 or 5. does that make sense?

cause in real life, if you run a running play and get 5-6 yards, and you attempt that same exact run play the next play, the defense is prepared and most of the time the offense gets stopped for a loss.

if you disagree with me, saying that that does not happen, then you have no football knowledge whatsoever.


same with teams that blitz 100% of the time, or a defense that blitzes the same person every time or runs the same coverage scheme over and over again.

If Ray Lewis blitzed 100% of the time when a team lines up in 3 wide single back, he would not be too effective. If champ Baily blitzed 100% of the time in either 5 wide sets of 3 wide shotgun, he would not be too effective. If Reggie White or Dwight Freeny pushed an outside rush every time, they would not be too effective. If you disagree with me, you have no football knowledge whatsoever.

This is a completely stupid idea that comes up way too much. If a team runs the same play over and over again, it would be a good thing for a DC. Just put 1 output that stops that play and crush the team. If a team only runs 1 play out of each formation, it should be very easy for you to crush that team.

Do some freaking scouting already. You want GLB to do all the work for you. If defenses automatically adjusted what skill do we really need as GMs and Owners. It would make this game like Fantasy Football. Every year, the league is won through the draft/off season and nothing else matters.

If I see a team always run cover 2 while blitzing the ROLB every time the opponent lines up in single back, hell yeah I'm going to use the hell out of the WR screen. It's called scouting. Use it people.

There is just not enough effective plays in each formation to penalize a team for using the same play. I have 5 good WRs. I love to use 5 wide sets because of this. I took out the hail mary and all the QB runs. That gives me 3 plays out of that formation to use. My team will be heavily penalized because of it. There is like 2 effective passes out of shotgun, 1 effective pass out of strong I, like 3 plays total out of weak I.

A defense has unlimited amount of plays they can use, being able to use 4-3 3-4 4-2 nickel 3-3 nickel cover 0 cover 1 cover 2 cover 3 cover 4 and blitzing 1 2 3 4 5 or 6 players and being able to blitz from all kinds of positions, or blitz no one at all. Still most teams only use 2 or 3 plays against a certain formation and if they find 1 play that is very very effective against a certain formation they run it 100% of the time. That's exactly what the OP is complaining about, just substitute defense for offense.

There are good owners and bad owners, good gms and bad gms. If you get beat cause a team runs a play 5 times in a row, obviously you are a bad one.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by rbedgood
I am all for some type of vision bonus for the defense in these
instances...but again it can't be implemented until we have 4-5 plays
of each type out of each formation. As I mentioned before if I can
scout and find a weakness in an opposing defense currently there might
only be one play choice for an inside run out of certain formations (or
a TE pass, etc.) If that is the play I need to run to exploit your
defensive flaw then I shouldn't be penalized for the fact that there
aren't 4-5 different inside runs out of the single back formation. If
you want to add additional plays then we can start talking about
requiring diversity in playcalling.


True. Once there are bonuses given to the defense for certain circumstances then it will be "exploited", the only thing that will stop that from happening is a good selection of plays from every formation. That way - it gets back to what football is about- playcalling. ( you can have the biggest, baddest players on GLB but if ur playcalling sucks you shouldn't win-unless ur playing cupcake teams which is a whole other topic...)
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drewsky
As an OC who doesn't spam the same play repeatedly, I don't like this suggestion. We do not have absolute authority on which play the sim is going to pick each down. If I have my AI set to 20% strong pitch right, there is a chance that the sim will pick that play 5,6,7 times in a row. It's not probable, but it could happen. Why should my team be penalized because the AI randomly selects the same play multiple times in a row?


Actually, you do have some authority on which play the SIM will pick. Here's how you do it.

1. Remove all outside runs from the playbook except the Power-I off-tackle.
2. Call an outside run every play.

What will come up? Power-I off-tackle every play.
 
ozzfan1317
offline
Link
 
I like the Idea but with much smaller numbers like a 2% boost to vision on repititious plays.
 
PaqMarq11
makes sense
offline
Link
 
sending this back to page 1
 
5STAR
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PaqMarq11
sending this back to page 1


Good idea!

This thread shows which people are to stupid to figure out how to stop a 1 play offense....

I wish we played more of them because a team with 1 play = easy win
 
Link
 
Originally posted by jared
I also think a minimum amount of plays from each formation in the playbook would help curtail this, if they don't have the minimum required plays in the playbook they can't used advanced AI. that would be a really simple solution


This won't solve anything.

Any good OC can call specific plays from the entire default playbook.
 
PaqMarq11
makes sense
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 5STAR
Originally posted by PaqMarq11

sending this back to page 1


Good idea!

This thread shows which people are to stupid to figure out how to stop a 1 play offense....

I wish we played more of them because a team with 1 play = easy win


to stupid?

or too stupid?

i guess you have to revisit the word.

you are the greatest, man! your team is the greatest!

 
beeve17
offline
Link
 
and if the team stops running the same play, does the boost eliminate?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.