User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Too many sacks - horrible blocking AI
Page:
 
mogs01gt
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Originally posted by mogs01gt

The only reason to keep raising strength and ignoring agility is to pad your Pancake stats. The Pancake SA needs to be on both Pass and Run blocking or removed from the game. If you want to keep pancakes, then there needs to be a stat that shows the number of sacks allowed by an offensive linemen
60 agility is pathetic for a RT. The tackles on the team I am on, both have strength above 80 and no pass blocking SAs. They have been giving up 5+ sacks a game.

The only reason to have strength above 80 is to have an OT built like a real OT!!!
OTs are typically some of the strongest players in the NFL. I gaurantee they do much better in the 225 bench rep test compared to peers than the cone drills or short shuttle drills.

and they are also agile for their size but who cares about NFL we are talking about GLB where DE's have 80 agilty when they reach level 35. Stop with this whole comparign NFL to GLB thing.

Originally posted by Lohengrin
Originally posted by mogs01gt

The only reason to keep raising strength and ignoring agility is to pad your Pancake stats. The Pancake SA needs to be on both Pass and Run blocking or removed from the game. If you want to keep pancakes, then there needs to be a stat that shows the number of sacks allowed by an offensive linemen
60 agility is pathetic for a RT. The tackles on the team I am on, both have strength above 80 and no pass blocking SAs. They have been giving up 5+ sacks a game.

This is a straw-man argument that has no bearing on this issue, and I don't understand why people keep bringing it up. Most people who are building pass-blocking OTs could care less about pancakes; stop projecting your own obsession with statistics on others

dude shut up man, you sound like a pissed off teenager. Intelligent people bring it up because its the truth.

Last edited Dec 5, 2008 13:14:26
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
Originally posted by Rage Kinard

Originally posted by Mat McBriar


Just swap out strength for blocking and you'll do fine. You don't need more than soft capped agility, just 90 blocking.


Not if you are ROT and facing a very well built speed DE. I'm at 94 blocking and 57 agility on my ROT now so that he is effective for the time being. I'm going to take agility up to at least 61, however, because the DEs are only going to be adding more agility, speed, first step, shed block, and tunnel vision and I can't use protect SA.


There are other SAs that will help you. My OT is a ROT as well, and he's only given up a few sacks all year (due to the TE bump bug)


Your OT is on a team where the starting QB has been sacked over 70 times. I suspect the LDE is just getting beaten to the sack by other players.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=249466
Last edited Dec 5, 2008 13:19:31
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Also, strength is very important for OTs.

It's all of the folks who think that there is a single "silver bullet" to winning in GLB that create the opportunity for so many mismatches.

Build a good football player and you will be successful.
Last edited Dec 5, 2008 13:19:05
 
rickg15
offline
Link
 
If you are going to compare GLB to the NFL, then you should realize that pancake blocks are QUITE RARE in the NFL. No matter how small and agile defensive linemen are, they just don't get knocked to the ground very often. The only stat for linemen right now is pancakes, and so you assume that you should get 3 or 4 per game. That's crazy. If an NFL OT got 16 pancake blocks in a season that would be quite impressive I think.
 
Lohengrin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mogs01gt

dude shut up man, you sound like a pissed off teenager. Intelligent people bring it up because its the truth.



From straw man to ad-hominem attacks, nice. I really have no idea how pancakes keep factoring into this, the issue is the number of sacks OTs are now giving up compared to last season. Pancakes is a straw-man argument based on no evidence other than people's own intuition. This is the issue:

S6 sacks >>> S5 sacks

What has changed that made caused such a drastic increase in sacks? I still maintain that offensive lines didn't just begin to suck after one off-season.


 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rickg15
If you are going to compare GLB to the NFL, then you should realize that pancake blocks are QUITE RARE in the NFL. No matter how small and agile defensive linemen are, they just don't get knocked to the ground very often. The only stat for linemen right now is pancakes, and so you assume that you should get 3 or 4 per game. That's crazy. If an NFL OT got 16 pancake blocks in a season that would be quite impressive I think.


Nobody's saying a GLB offensive lineman should be getting more pancakes. However, I gaurantee you that even Dwight Freeney and Jason Taylor have a lot more strength than the way GLB DEs are being built. Also, if teams played safeties up on the LOS against O-linemen, there might be a few more pancakes in the NFL.


The comparison to the NFL is because it is the highest level of football. We can compare it to any level of football you want. If the purpose of this game is to try and become a realistic football sim, then the most effective builds for those positions should micmick the most effective players IRL.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Lohengrin
Originally posted by mogs01gt


dude shut up man, you sound like a pissed off teenager. Intelligent people bring it up because its the truth.



From straw man to ad-hominem attacks, nice. I really have no idea how pancakes keep factoring into this, the issue is the number of sacks OTs are now giving up compared to last season. Pancakes is a straw-man argument based on no evidence other than people's own intuition. This is the issue:

S6 sacks >>> S5 sacks

What has changed that made caused such a drastic increase in sacks? I still maintain that offensive lines didn't just begin to suck after one off-season.




Actually it is more DEs started taking all their equipment out of strength and putting it into either agility or speed and mimicking the other successful DEs. They are typically 50 strength and around 160 - 180 speed + agility with significant points in tunnel vision, first step, and or shed block. Now they at least have to have 40+ vision as well. The top DEs have actually seen their sack totals drop so that they will only get 115-125 sacks instead of 150-200.

 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Also, strength is very important for OTs.

It's all of the folks who think that there is a single "silver bullet" to winning in GLB that create the opportunity for so many mismatches.

Build a good football player and you will be successful.


I believe that an OT with 85 strength, 75 blocking, and 60 agility would be a good football player IRL, but that player will suck in GLB.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Originally posted by tautology

Also, strength is very important for OTs.

It's all of the folks who think that there is a single "silver bullet" to winning in GLB that create the opportunity for so many mismatches.

Build a good football player and you will be successful.


I believe that an OT with 85 strength, 75 blocking, and 60 agility would be a good football player IRL, but that player will suck in GLB.


Well, it's a little bit of a pointless argument...comes down to what you think skill levels in GLB represent in real life....that player would be good, but would he be good enough to slow down a very fast and agile DE? Maybe not, since he needs more technique. Would he be good compared to a player with less strength but better technique? Again, maybe not.

Regardless, the real issue we are seeing is that the means for building successful DEs in a particular style became widely known and emulated, while the means for building a successful OT have been far less publicly known. You are obviously doing your part to reverse that trend...I guess someone must have clued you in
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by Rage Kinard

Originally posted by tautology


Also, strength is very important for OTs.

It's all of the folks who think that there is a single "silver bullet" to winning in GLB that create the opportunity for so many mismatches.

Build a good football player and you will be successful.


I believe that an OT with 85 strength, 75 blocking, and 60 agility would be a good football player IRL, but that player will suck in GLB.


Well, it's a little bit of a pointless argument...comes down to what you think skill levels in GLB represent in real life....that player would be good, but would he be good enough to slow down a very fast and agile DE? Maybe not, since he needs more technique. Would he be good compared to a player with less strength but better technique? Again, maybe not.

Regardless, the real issue we are seeing is that the means for building successful DEs in a particular style became widely known and emulated, while the means for building a successful OT have been far less publicly known. You are obviously doing your part to reverse that trend...I guess someone must have clued you in


And I thank that someone very much. Although I'm only trying to give away part of the secret he told me rather than the whole thing. I want to see the sack numbers come down so games aren't decided on an inability to stop a DE, not stop sacks all toghether.

 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnerhero
Bullshit, a team I OC for matched up EVEN with the last two teams we faced, and in each game our OT's got slaughtered by their DEs...on BOTH sides. So my QB had enough time to hike the football, and take one step before he had either the LDE, the RDE, or both DEs sacking him...every pass play, almost.

Against equal competition, OTs get smoked...because they - for some UNKNOWN reason - now need speed to match up with a DE.


Dick. But he's right. Your builds probably suck.
 
sxewesley
offline
Link
 
I must be playing an entirely different game then the rest of you. I thought sacks were out of control LAST season. Our DEs sack totals are down 50% this season, in the same league.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sxewesley
I must be playing an entirely different game then the rest of you. I thought sacks were out of control LAST season. Our DEs sack totals are down 50% this season, in the same league.



Those complaining things are worse this year are just now going up against the super DEs which there are more of now. They didn't have to start adjusting their OTs last season. There are also others in leagues where they haven't faced the super DEs yet who aren't listening to the advice of those who have. They will be complaining about it next season.
 
rehash
offline
Link
 
Last edited Dec 5, 2008 21:41:19
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Here is a DE with 97 sacks.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=433515

Here is a well built LOT
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=157318

Result
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=273285

Since boosting, my OT hasn't given up a single sack in games or scrimmages (7-8 games).

So what is the problem?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.