damn bort just tell them it was windy...thats what i told my owner when he bitched about my completion rate
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > UGLY GAME 4s - We think something is wrong with the passing in the sims
UK_Giant_Steve
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
QB pass quality was adjusted slightly downward last night. Combined with the recent chemistry updates and stamina effects, it could contribute to some lower completions %'s or dropped passes.
I have to ask this, though: didn't you find it odd that even Lv 5-6 QB's were consistently passing for 80+%? Payton Manning's career passing pct is 64%. I would say he's a bit higher than lv 10.
If you get a chance Bort, check out all these plays from the game I posted earlier, it really looks odd to me:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=1780266
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=1781076
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=1781361
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=1781393
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=1781679
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=1782123
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=1782153
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=1782746
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=1783575
That's not all the deflections from my QB in this game, but these were the ones that looked the most dubious. Then the opposing QB, with a MUCH lower passing bar rating did much better than my guy.
By the way, if it is an accuracy tweak, then fair enough, but this is a guy with 50+ throwing, 45ish vision and 38 or so strength... Not to mention a bunch of points in the pocket passer tree, so shall we abandon the passing game until our QB's hit 80+ in those catagories?
But, you are right about weaker QB's coming in and performing just as well as the number 1 guys.
QB pass quality was adjusted slightly downward last night. Combined with the recent chemistry updates and stamina effects, it could contribute to some lower completions %'s or dropped passes.
I have to ask this, though: didn't you find it odd that even Lv 5-6 QB's were consistently passing for 80+%? Payton Manning's career passing pct is 64%. I would say he's a bit higher than lv 10.
If you get a chance Bort, check out all these plays from the game I posted earlier, it really looks odd to me:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=1780266
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=1781076
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=1781361
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=1781393
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=1781679
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=1782123
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=1782153
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=1782746
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=1783575
That's not all the deflections from my QB in this game, but these were the ones that looked the most dubious. Then the opposing QB, with a MUCH lower passing bar rating did much better than my guy.
By the way, if it is an accuracy tweak, then fair enough, but this is a guy with 50+ throwing, 45ish vision and 38 or so strength... Not to mention a bunch of points in the pocket passer tree, so shall we abandon the passing game until our QB's hit 80+ in those catagories?
But, you are right about weaker QB's coming in and performing just as well as the number 1 guys.
Zeke0123
offline
offline
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=10776 2 pretty evenly matched teams...40% ??
Boble
offline
offline
Originally posted by Zeke0123
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=107762 pretty evenly matched teams...40% ??
This is just awful, has nothing to do with football, check the code, such a change changes every aspect of this wonderful game, usually stats in Football are not compiled by the individual strength, but by a difference in strengths between two teams, a bad QB can still complete 80% of the passes, if the other team has no pass defense at all, a LVL 2 QB against a LVL 2 defense should get about the same numbers than a LVL 12 guy goin against a LVL 12 defense.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=107762 pretty evenly matched teams...40% ??
This is just awful, has nothing to do with football, check the code, such a change changes every aspect of this wonderful game, usually stats in Football are not compiled by the individual strength, but by a difference in strengths between two teams, a bad QB can still complete 80% of the passes, if the other team has no pass defense at all, a LVL 2 QB against a LVL 2 defense should get about the same numbers than a LVL 12 guy goin against a LVL 12 defense.
bigtisme
offline
offline
Originally posted by Boble
a LVL 2 QB against a LVL 2 defense should get about the same numbers than a LVL 12 guy goin against a LVL 12 defense.
nah...thats like saying 2 even peewee teams should have the same comp percent as two evenly matched college football teams.
Thats just not the way GLB works.
a LVL 2 QB against a LVL 2 defense should get about the same numbers than a LVL 12 guy goin against a LVL 12 defense.
nah...thats like saying 2 even peewee teams should have the same comp percent as two evenly matched college football teams.
Thats just not the way GLB works.
Sonny Walker
offline
offline
Originally posted by bigtisme
Originally posted by Boble
a LVL 2 QB against a LVL 2 defense should get about the same numbers than a LVL 12 guy goin against a LVL 12 defense.
nah...thats like saying 2 even peewee teams should have the same comp percent as two evenly matched college football teams.
Thats just not the way GLB works.
certainly not - but I wonder why anyone completing 15% or less of passes would continue to pass...
and even if the average passing completions for ~ lvl 5 QBs drops to 30% (which is fine, if that's what Bort & team want), it doesn't explain why several run-heavy teams started gunslinging like crazy when it went against their chosen tactics and against what would help them win games.
Originally posted by Boble
a LVL 2 QB against a LVL 2 defense should get about the same numbers than a LVL 12 guy goin against a LVL 12 defense.
nah...thats like saying 2 even peewee teams should have the same comp percent as two evenly matched college football teams.
Thats just not the way GLB works.
certainly not - but I wonder why anyone completing 15% or less of passes would continue to pass...
and even if the average passing completions for ~ lvl 5 QBs drops to 30% (which is fine, if that's what Bort & team want), it doesn't explain why several run-heavy teams started gunslinging like crazy when it went against their chosen tactics and against what would help them win games.
dead_poet
offline
offline
Originally posted by Boble
Originally posted by Zeke0123
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=107762pretty evenly matched teams...40% ??
This is just awful, has nothing to do with football, check the code, such a change changes every aspect of this wonderful game, usually stats in Football are not compiled by the individual strength, but by a difference in strengths between two teams, a bad QB can still complete 80% of the passes, if the other team has no pass defense at all, a LVL 2 QB against a LVL 2 defense should get about the same numbers than a LVL 12 guy goin against a LVL 12 defense.
I agree. High school QBs can complete 60% or more of their passes. It's based on talent and the strength of the competition. Obviously if a level 4 QB (or a high school QB) was going against a level 14 secondary (or a bunch of division I college players), his completion percentage should and would be lower (just like it has been in this game). I don't see how making everybody's QBs (and receivers) worse makes the game any more real.
Originally posted by Zeke0123
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=107762pretty evenly matched teams...40% ??
This is just awful, has nothing to do with football, check the code, such a change changes every aspect of this wonderful game, usually stats in Football are not compiled by the individual strength, but by a difference in strengths between two teams, a bad QB can still complete 80% of the passes, if the other team has no pass defense at all, a LVL 2 QB against a LVL 2 defense should get about the same numbers than a LVL 12 guy goin against a LVL 12 defense.
I agree. High school QBs can complete 60% or more of their passes. It's based on talent and the strength of the competition. Obviously if a level 4 QB (or a high school QB) was going against a level 14 secondary (or a bunch of division I college players), his completion percentage should and would be lower (just like it has been in this game). I don't see how making everybody's QBs (and receivers) worse makes the game any more real.
Last edited May 2, 2008 15:29:52
Originally posted by Sonny Walker
Originally posted by bigtisme
Originally posted by Boble
a LVL 2 QB against a LVL 2 defense should get about the same numbers than a LVL 12 guy goin against a LVL 12 defense.
nah...thats like saying 2 even peewee teams should have the same comp percent as two evenly matched college football teams.
Thats just not the way GLB works.
certainly not - but I wonder why anyone completing 15% or less of passes would continue to pass...
and even if the average passing completions for ~ lvl 5 QBs drops to 30% (which is fine, if that's what Bort & team want), it doesn't explain why several run-heavy teams started gunslinging like crazy when it went against their chosen tactics and against what would help them win games.
And it still dosent explain how the higest level QB in the game threw for barely 40%
Originally posted by bigtisme
Originally posted by Boble
a LVL 2 QB against a LVL 2 defense should get about the same numbers than a LVL 12 guy goin against a LVL 12 defense.
nah...thats like saying 2 even peewee teams should have the same comp percent as two evenly matched college football teams.
Thats just not the way GLB works.
certainly not - but I wonder why anyone completing 15% or less of passes would continue to pass...
and even if the average passing completions for ~ lvl 5 QBs drops to 30% (which is fine, if that's what Bort & team want), it doesn't explain why several run-heavy teams started gunslinging like crazy when it went against their chosen tactics and against what would help them win games.
And it still dosent explain how the higest level QB in the game threw for barely 40%
sunder B
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
QB pass quality was adjusted slightly downward last night. Combined with the recent chemistry updates and stamina effects, it could contribute to some lower completions %'s or dropped passes.
I have to ask this, though: didn't you find it odd that even Lv 5-6 QB's were consistently passing for 80+%? Payton Manning's career passing pct is 64%. I would say he's a bit higher than lv 10.
That is a seriously flawed analysis. These leagues are set up as weighted leagues It is pefectly reasonable to expect a lvl 6 QB to have a decent completion rate when he is throwing against lvl 4 DB's and no pass rush.
Should a lvl 6 QB be a monster in AAA or Pro? Heck no, but A Qb's performance depend a lot on the level of his competition. I have seen pop warner or High School QB's with outrageous stats, but it is always because they are superior to their competition. I have seen High School QB's throw for 300 + yards and 60% or 70% plus passing against weaker schools. They'd get killed against college Defenses. It's all relative.
We can't all be wrong with our concerns can we?
QB pass quality was adjusted slightly downward last night. Combined with the recent chemistry updates and stamina effects, it could contribute to some lower completions %'s or dropped passes.
I have to ask this, though: didn't you find it odd that even Lv 5-6 QB's were consistently passing for 80+%? Payton Manning's career passing pct is 64%. I would say he's a bit higher than lv 10.
That is a seriously flawed analysis. These leagues are set up as weighted leagues It is pefectly reasonable to expect a lvl 6 QB to have a decent completion rate when he is throwing against lvl 4 DB's and no pass rush.
Should a lvl 6 QB be a monster in AAA or Pro? Heck no, but A Qb's performance depend a lot on the level of his competition. I have seen pop warner or High School QB's with outrageous stats, but it is always because they are superior to their competition. I have seen High School QB's throw for 300 + yards and 60% or 70% plus passing against weaker schools. They'd get killed against college Defenses. It's all relative.
We can't all be wrong with our concerns can we?
rj414
offline
offline
i undertsand downgrading pass quality - but a level 9 throwing to a 10 and 9 wr, and a 13 te, against a defense with 2 4 lbs and a 4 cb - 18/63? Come on Bort. And yes, it is entirely possible for an inexperienced qb to throw 80 percent. Those games were the exception, not the rule.
Sonny Walker
offline
offline
Originally posted by Sonny Walker
certainly not - but I wonder why anyone completing 15% or less of passes would continue to pass...
and even if the average passing completions for ~ lvl 5 QBs drops to 30% (which is fine, if that's what Bort & team want), it doesn't explain why several run-heavy teams started gunslinging like crazy when it went against their chosen tactics and against what would help them win games.
oops, I see this is being addressed in a separate thread
certainly not - but I wonder why anyone completing 15% or less of passes would continue to pass...
and even if the average passing completions for ~ lvl 5 QBs drops to 30% (which is fine, if that's what Bort & team want), it doesn't explain why several run-heavy teams started gunslinging like crazy when it went against their chosen tactics and against what would help them win games.
oops, I see this is being addressed in a separate thread
dead_poet
offline
offline
Originally posted by Sonny Walker
Originally posted by Sonny Walker
certainly not - but I wonder why anyone completing 15% or less of passes would continue to pass...
and even if the average passing completions for ~ lvl 5 QBs drops to 30% (which is fine, if that's what Bort & team want), it doesn't explain why several run-heavy teams started gunslinging like crazy when it went against their chosen tactics and against what would help them win games.
oops, I see this is being addressed in a separate thread
Link?
Originally posted by Sonny Walker
certainly not - but I wonder why anyone completing 15% or less of passes would continue to pass...
and even if the average passing completions for ~ lvl 5 QBs drops to 30% (which is fine, if that's what Bort & team want), it doesn't explain why several run-heavy teams started gunslinging like crazy when it went against their chosen tactics and against what would help them win games.
oops, I see this is being addressed in a separate thread
Link?
Boble
offline
offline
I'm so upset, i can't even adress, the sim was pretty good concerning passing and running balance, I can hardly understand, why such a dropoff, it was even, that the Y/A where still pretty low compared to real football, and long passes already had big incomp. factors, but why make short passes more difficult, they are not, if the WR is open, he is open, and even a kid can catch a ball when open.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























