User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Say "ROLB" "RILB" "MLB" "LILB" and "LOLB" on replays
Page:
 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
why not:

LO LI RI RO
(left outside; left inside; right inside; right outside)
and

LB MB RB

(left backer; middle backer; right backer)
 
TrojanMan
offline
Link
 
Inafterepic
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TxSteve
why not:

LO LI RI RO
(left outside; left inside; right inside; right outside)
and

LB MB RB

(left backer; middle backer; right backer)


Because LB (left) and RB (right) are not very correct if a team is playing the TE on the left instead of the right. The idea is that in GLB you would specify WLB MLB SLB so that the SLB will be a certain type of player playing the strong side wherever it is.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by GG

If Bort gives the go-ahead for these updates I would be most happy to do the player dots with their new names.

This would also help agents learn more about the game etc imo.


Yeah, I'd need some new dots.

There would be no easy way at the moment to differentiate between 3-4 LOLB and 4-3 WLB, though, so we'd pretty much just need a LOLB/ROLB/MLB/RILB/LILB dot.


Ok give me 20 minutes and I'll email them to you. Sorry what was the email address again?
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
goallineblitz@gmail.com
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Cheers
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Sent.
Let me know if you want any changes/improvements.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Got it - I'll take a look in a bit.

Edit: Looks good - I'll test 'em out and see how they work.
Last edited Dec 17, 2008 16:13:00
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Thanks Bort. Will keep an eye on a game replay to see if they're in.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Thanks Bort. Will keep an eye on a game replay to see if they're in.


They work fine with the current replays.

I'll probably upload with all the new design stuff for next season.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Any chance of having the WRs (dots and depth chart) changed to "FL", "SE", and "SL"?

Because FLanker is specific for speedy WRs playing off the LOS to avoid jamming, Split End for your bigger WRs who face a lot of jamming. And so WR-3 WR-4 and WR-5 becomes SL-1, SL-2, SL-3.

The official terms for WRs are those, not WR, and because those positions allow more detailed planning by OC's with their depth charts and recruiting.
Last edited Dec 18, 2008 05:27:07
 
Plax_Are_Meth
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Any chance of having the WRs (dots and depth chart) changed to "FL", "SE", and "SL"?

Because FLanker is specific for speedy WRs playing off the LOS to avoid jamming, Split End for your bigger WRs who face a lot of jamming.


Originally posted by GG


FL (flanker) takes up the strong side (most commonly) and is up on the LOS.



Make up your mind.

I clearly believe their LOS alignment all depends on where the TE is at.
And slot receivers can line up on the LOS on the strong side, with both the SE and FL off the LOS.

I think it would start getting too complicated. Best leave it at "WR". It's the most common label for receivers today. And I have yet to hear commentators use the real terms for them yet, except for slot receiver.
I also don't think jamming has been implemented in the game yet anyways.

Last edited Dec 18, 2008 05:37:31
 
GG
offline
Link
 
That bit you quoted was a typo. My brain was in 50 places at once at the time. But thanks for pointing it out so i could go back and correct it. To your points...


It's not that difficult for anyone on GLB to grasp, regardless if they have in depth football knowledge or not. Surely people know that WR is just some generic term, but the actual positions are Flanker, Split End and Slot, and they are intended to play different roles. Seeing as GLB runs very basic offense etc, then it will work well here calling them FL, SE, SL, as the playbooks we have are very small, basic, and standard---where the QB is always right-handed, the TE is most often on the right, and therefore the Flanker on the strongside suited for right-handed QBs. Etc.

The stuff you mention about Slots, and how they can line up left or right, on or off the LOS, or how the #1 WR can often play from the slot, or flanker, etc, is all true, but it's not important in GLB because all the plays we have are very basic and standardized, no motions or different alignments of formations, etc.

Commentators who are former players do use Flanker, Split End in their commentary. Or when someone like Jaws breaks-down a play for the viewer. Coaches and players and analysts will call them by their proper names. It's better for people who play GLB also to learn aspects of the game itself by playing GLB. The importance of the difference between FL and SE is not something that ever disappears from the jargon.

Jamming hasnt been implemented, but Im pretty sure i read Bort saying it would be soon or soon enough. Seeing as it will come in, then having FL, SE, SL will naturally work with that.

Last edited Dec 18, 2008 06:47:45
 
cwarenda
offline
Link
 
+ 1
 
Plax_Are_Meth
offline
Link
 
I concur. I just think implementing the SE-FL-SL now when we have no real decision on alignment with the current playbook and AI would be over complicating things.
It would be best to work from the ground up, so yeah, the real receiving names would be good once the AI is more flexible positioning wise.
This could also lead to letting DC's choose which WR the CB should stick to during the whole game, IE: the fastest CB will always matchup against the designated flanker throughout the whole game, instead of just matching up against whoever is put in "WR1".


+1
Last edited Dec 18, 2008 09:33:36
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.