User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > timeout bug - why are we calling timeout in the dying minutes when the score is tied?
Page:
 
PaqMarq11
makes sense
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by craw33

Dear PaqMarq11

I am curious to what you would have done?
We will assume you did not use your Timeout after they picked up the first down on 3rd and 2.
So they have no timeouts you have 3 timeouts.
They have 1st and 10 at your 38 with the clock running at the 1:43 Mark. They are looking at a 55 Yard Field Goal From Here.

If I am the OC I am in no big hurry. I like my chances of getting at least 4 more yards to get into field goal range and 1:43 on the clock.

I think the real problem is that you have to set up your AI to kick a Field Goal with 40 seconds or you are risking not kicking one.

Your team should have never gotten the ball back in real football. If you are not going to use timeouts.






Not worth trying to use logic here, the OP is illogical


do you know football, even? try tennis.

sim would try and make a play, try a fg, or run out of time.

so why give them TIME. time is on our side (we can't lose). time is against their side (to win).

use logic, scace. you have a brain for a reason

 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Even with no timeouts, over 1:40 seconds is plenty of time to get a number of plays off in an effort to get closer.
 
lunchbox6186
offline
Link
 
Time is no way on your side R tard. There was just under two minutes. Go turn on a football game and see how many plays you can get off even without timeouts.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PaqMarq11
Originally posted by SCACE

Originally posted by craw33


Dear PaqMarq11

I am curious to what you would have done?
We will assume you did not use your Timeout after they picked up the first down on 3rd and 2.
So they have no timeouts you have 3 timeouts.
They have 1st and 10 at your 38 with the clock running at the 1:43 Mark. They are looking at a 55 Yard Field Goal From Here.

If I am the OC I am in no big hurry. I like my chances of getting at least 4 more yards to get into field goal range and 1:43 on the clock.

I think the real problem is that you have to set up your AI to kick a Field Goal with 40 seconds or you are risking not kicking one.

Your team should have never gotten the ball back in real football. If you are not going to use timeouts.






Not worth trying to use logic here, the OP is illogical


do you know football, even? try tennis.

sim would try and make a play, try a fg, or run out of time.

so why give them TIME. time is on our side (we can't lose). time is against their side (to win).

use logic, scace. you have a brain for a reason



It is becoming quite clear you don't have one, or if you do have one, it rates between the IQ levels required to do repetitive manual labour and to make correct change from a $10 bill.
 
PaqMarq11
makes sense
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lunchbox6186
i hardly consider 1:45 to be Little time when they have to move 5 yards


so why give them more time by calling a timeout?

so if you were the coach you would call a timeout? even though you know the score is tied?

 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PaqMarq11
Originally posted by lunchbox6186

i hardly consider 1:45 to be Little time when they have to move 5 yards


so why give them more time by calling a timeout?

so if you were the coach you would call a timeout? even though you know the score is tied?



If I felt my defense could hold them up and get the ball back, I'd consider it to leave my offense enough time on the clock to do something. I wouldn't have called the 2nd and 3rd though after watching their HB gash my defense.

Regardless, you aren't getting a re-sim, no matter how much you whine, and you need to work on your rushing D, which as mentioned had more holes than swiss cheese in the final minutes.
 
lunchbox6186
offline
Link
 
You gotta understand you werent doing it to give them more time, you were doing it to save time for your Offense. It was almost certain they would score from their field posisiton so you needed to save as much time as possible for your O to move down the field to try to tie it. Doesnt matter how many timeouts you have if you get the ball back with 3 seconds on the clock
 
PaqMarq11
makes sense
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by PaqMarq11

Originally posted by SCACE


Originally posted by craw33



Dear PaqMarq11

I am curious to what you would have done?
We will assume you did not use your Timeout after they picked up the first down on 3rd and 2.
So they have no timeouts you have 3 timeouts.
They have 1st and 10 at your 38 with the clock running at the 1:43 Mark. They are looking at a 55 Yard Field Goal From Here.

If I am the OC I am in no big hurry. I like my chances of getting at least 4 more yards to get into field goal range and 1:43 on the clock.

I think the real problem is that you have to set up your AI to kick a Field Goal with 40 seconds or you are risking not kicking one.

Your team should have never gotten the ball back in real football. If you are not going to use timeouts.






Not worth trying to use logic here, the OP is illogical


do you know football, even? try tennis.

sim would try and make a play, try a fg, or run out of time.

so why give them TIME. time is on our side (we can't lose). time is against their side (to win).

use logic, scace. you have a brain for a reason



It is becoming quite clear you don't have one, or if you do have one, it rates between the IQ levels required to do repetitive manual labour and to make correct change from a $10 bill.


because you don't know football, you resort to attacking me.

i posted this here so people with football knowledge can take a look at it. something i can't say for you. don't blame me if you are getting confused. it's in the genes.

back to the topic: football logic, defensive coordinators, head coaches won't call a timeout at that point when the score is tied.

 
PaqMarq11
makes sense
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lunchbox6186
You gotta understand you werent doing it to give them more time, you were doing it to save time for your Offense. It was almost certain they would score from their field posisiton so you needed to save as much time as possible for your O to move down the field to try to tie it. Doesnt matter how many timeouts you have if you get the ball back with 3 seconds on the clock


almost certain?

a 55-56 yarder almost certain?

at that point we can't lose. the score is tied.

you are in the defense, you are trying not to lose. at that time you don't know yet that you will give up yards or the fg.

 
PaqMarq11
makes sense
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by PaqMarq11

Originally posted by lunchbox6186


i hardly consider 1:45 to be Little time when they have to move 5 yards


so why give them more time by calling a timeout?

so if you were the coach you would call a timeout? even though you know the score is tied?



If I felt my defense could hold them up and get the ball back, I'd consider it to leave my offense enough time on the clock to do something. I wouldn't have called the 2nd and 3rd though after watching their HB gash my defense.

Regardless, you aren't getting a re-sim, no matter how much you whine, and you need to work on your rushing D, which as mentioned had more holes than swiss cheese in the final minutes.


even you said it. you wouldn't call the timeout.

are you going to settle for that? and not have it corrected? you won't say there is a bug?

Last edited Nov 27, 2008 15:48:28
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
PM - you were the one that started with insults. Don't come out of the closet if you aren't prepared to get flamed, or whatever the saying is.

As for me, I play to win, I don't play "not to lose".

Regardless, you have no clue what you are talking about and you're whining like a child in the grocery store when mommy won't buy him a candy bar.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PaqMarq11
Originally posted by SCACE

Originally posted by PaqMarq11


Originally posted by lunchbox6186



i hardly consider 1:45 to be Little time when they have to move 5 yards


so why give them more time by calling a timeout?

so if you were the coach you would call a timeout? even though you know the score is tied?



If I felt my defense could hold them up and get the ball back, I'd consider it to leave my offense enough time on the clock to do something. I wouldn't have called the 2nd and 3rd though after watching their HB gash my defense.

Regardless, you aren't getting a re-sim, no matter how much you whine, and you need to work on your rushing D, which as mentioned had more holes than swiss cheese in the final minutes.


even you said it. you wouldn't call the timeout.

are you going to settle for that? and not have it corrected? you won't say there is a bug?



I said I'd consider calling the 1st one when you were on the 38 yard line. After the 8.5 yard gain, I wouldn't call another timeout.

And, as I have mentioned, Bort is working on this, but it takes time to get the logic right. He is aware of the issues surrounding timeout logic and is trying to correct it. If you can't accept that, that's your own problem.
 
lunchbox6186
offline
Link
 
IM done with this thread. And i cant beleive i tried to help out a fudgepacker fan. Especially living in MN
 
PaqMarq11
makes sense
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by PaqMarq11

Originally posted by SCACE


Originally posted by PaqMarq11



Originally posted by lunchbox6186




i hardly consider 1:45 to be Little time when they have to move 5 yards


so why give them more time by calling a timeout?

so if you were the coach you would call a timeout? even though you know the score is tied?



If I felt my defense could hold them up and get the ball back, I'd consider it to leave my offense enough time on the clock to do something. I wouldn't have called the 2nd and 3rd though after watching their HB gash my defense.

Regardless, you aren't getting a re-sim, no matter how much you whine, and you need to work on your rushing D, which as mentioned had more holes than swiss cheese in the final minutes.


even you said it. you wouldn't call the timeout.

are you going to settle for that? and not have it corrected? you won't say there is a bug?



I said I'd consider calling the 1st one when you were on the 38 yard line. After the 8.5 yard gain, I wouldn't call another timeout.

And, as I have mentioned, Bort is working on this, but it takes time to get the logic right. He is aware of the issues surrounding timeout logic and is trying to correct it. If you can't accept that, that's your own problem.


i insulted you? hmmm...you might want to review the thread.

if bort is trying to correct it, it means it's buggy (thanks in advance bort for looking into this).

if your game got "bugged" wouldn't you want a re-sim? i don't even know the history of re-simming (success rate). i'm asking if it can be considered.

what is it to you? does it really bother you that much?

we have scrimm all the time. i'll gladly put up the flex if a re-sim will need that. i'll pay for mine and for the other team. just to get a sim that is not bugged

 
PaqMarq11
makes sense
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lunchbox6186
IM done with this thread. And i cant beleive i tried to help out a fudgepacker fan. Especially living in MN


lol

thanks for dropping by

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.