User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > A real fix to speed
Page:
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by czman
Originally posted by Guppy, Inc



Stop
letting the exploit hounds drive the game. If their players arent well
balanced, they should suck and its their own fault. This game cant
survive if it attempts to allow everyone to be a stud.


Agreed. Specialization is OK if there is a negative equal to the positive.

The problem is when by only using one stat a player is able to do all things well.


I agree...sort of.

But I also agree with the OP that Strength is underimportant in GLB. I think the game was developed with Strength very much undervalued relative to Speed, and Speed overvalued relative to everything.

I'd have to agree for the most part that Speed/Agility based linemen running around OT's would be okay if they had a negative, I'd also say that it should have to be much more Agility based to work. Not even getting blocked at all shouldn't happen.

Then with very high Agility and Shed Block he can usually shed the blocks, and on very rare occasions through Speed and Agility avoid them.

But, any contact with someone much stronger than you should be a bigger stamina hit (with other things taking slightly less Stamina to compensate as Stamina is balanced), and on a running play, the undersized DE should be Pancaked regularly, and Pancakes should really drain morale and energy of the defender.
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I'm seeing a trend: "Don't nerf my build! Nerf the other guy's build!"


You're just now noticing?
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Modok
I think most people will be open to changes if they come at a gradual rate. The changes that get under people's skin are these:

1) Changes coming in mid-season after ALOT of people have already used their boosts.

2) Changes made that completely make some builds obsolete or ineffective.

3)
Changes that are too strong out of the gate. I think if everyone was
told that, "Hey, we are going to up the importance of tackling
gradually over the season, prepare yourself," things may be received in
a better light.


No to all three restrictions.

1) The only case where this has any merit is if the change doesn't obviously reflect real life football better, period (so, if, say, he decreased the importance of Vision in avoiding drops, that wouldn't be obvious, so there'd be a point there; if he makes D-Linemen have Strength, anyone who built a weak D-Lineman knew he was using an exploit. Period. May they burn.)

It's best, I think, if people start thinking in terms of making realistic football players and realize they'd better or they'll be nerfed. Never wait until the end of the season unless it's very fast approaching.

2) Some builds should be ineffective, and shouldn't be propped up just because some people exploited unrealistic sim features that allowed them to be effective.

3) No, you balance things immediately. It isn't even a help, really, to do it slowly (as he did with the importance of Stamina) as I couldn't test different sub-out levels in the preseason.

A big note is:

If you build realistic football players, your players never get hurt significantly compared to others at their position when Bort makes changes. The solution is to build realistic football players.
 
czman
offline
Link
 
Maybe if changes were explained a few weeks before they went live it might help.

I also think instead of giving people free re-specs Bort should just allow people to sell back gear at purchased value anytime he does major changes. This would allow people to have gear fixes to builds until they can get the SP needed to fix their player.
 
Thunder39
offline
Link
 
I've noticed this year that my power FB (who I recently retired to start over as a slow build) was breaking 6-7 tackles a run against guys who had 20 tackle (this was BBB league so bear with me) Strength isn't neccessarily important at this point I understand, but tackling has to come into the equation also. Maybe a guy with high tackling will always make the tackle, but he gets dragged for a couple yards because he isn't strong enough to pull down a power back. Conversely, if a guy with huge strength but low tackling hits a guy, there's a chance he might bounce the guy back but not make the tackle, or lay the guy out completely, or just miss altogether (because he has terrible tackling form). Just a thought.
 
Link
 
This isn't moved to epic yet?
 
Dianwei32
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter
This isn't moved to epic yet?


Seriously, this suggestion and the Weight Classes suggestion (in my opinion) need to be moved to the Epic Suggestions subforum.

The weight classes suggestion may be too controversial ATM, but this suggestion definitely deserves Epic recognition.
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kavadas
Originally posted by Bort

I have tried to increase the value of strength and tackling, etc, in the past. All I get in return is 100 bug threads about how players miss too many tackles, because everyone's 20 tackling CB is god's gift to GLB.

Maybe I just need to let those go, but I also don't want to see power backs get 50 ypc all the time.

I'd like to add bump coverage for sure at some point, which would require strength for sure.


See, where you're going wrong is by giving a shit about a bunch of people with retarded builds while neglecting the basic game design itself.

So I guess you have to make the choice of:
a)Making the game less retarded; or
b)Keep yo moniez from people who put the retard in GLB.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

This is why I personally think Bort doesn't do dick or really cares about speed/agility owning this entire game. If he changed the attributes to be less absurd 90% of the builds in this game would be obsolete over night and the forums would erupt in the ultimate QQ fest from 'tards like Flames54 crying about how his all speed WR is getting pancaked at the line every single play. Or all of the morons crying about how power runners are all of the sudden obliterating defenses because they (the defense) lack the strength needed to deal with that type of player. It would take multiple seasons for defensive player builds to adjust to this kind of change; ergo it will never happen. Why do you think power runners were recently nerfed and that ridiculous "line of scrimmage" slowdown was added?

It was a retarded fix that doesn't even begin to address the root of anything.

Bort never gives any change he makes in this game time to correct itself. If he fixes strength to work properly and you get all of the QQ threads about defenses he'll just change it back. What's even more sad is that I'm certain he realizes it could take seasons before attribute balance manifests itself through changes because builds are permanent. If Bort actually cared about BETA TESTING THIS BETA GAME he would just give us the respecs so we could, oh, I don't know, BETA TEST THIS BETA PRODUCT. Instead we pay him for the "privilege" of beta testing and when he actually needs to fix something we paralyze him (and the game).

That's why after 6 six seasons this isn't fixed nor will it ever be fixed. Fixing it would cost Bort $$$.

That's why this game will never work properly.


All my players are now typically build the same way unless they are a lineman. Speed and agility.

If you roll a LB you will be presented with this thread that basically tells all LB's that strength and tackling are secondaries that you don't really have to worry about with the wrap up tackling option. http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1031209

I actually soft capped strength first on my MLB since it made sense plus I was tired of building every guy the same way.

Ignore the vocal minority and make the changes that are for the game and would please the majority of the player base.
 
Dianwei32
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo


All my players are now typically build the same way unless they are a lineman. Speed and agility.

If you roll a LB you will be presented with this thread that basically tells all LB's that strength and tackling are secondaries that you don't really have to worry about with the wrap up tackling option. http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1031209

I actually soft capped strength first on my MLB since it made sense plus I was tired of building every guy the same way.

Ignore the vocal minority and make the changes that are for the game and would please the majority of the player base.


When you have a thread that tells all LB to max Speed/Agility and essentially ignore Strength/Tackling, something is horribly wrong.

Please Bort, fix Strength. Ignore the few squeaky wheels and do it, it's what's best for GLB as a whole.
Last edited Nov 25, 2008 19:16:42
 
Jason Cash
offline
Link
 
meh..build a realistic player and you dont have anything to worry about. My LB is fast, agile and has very high vision an is capped in tackling. I havent seen ANY nerfed effects on him. Cash has consistently played competitivly
 
Vinceable
offline
Link
 
speed doesn't need fixing.
 
Dianwei32
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vinceable
speed doesn't need fixing.


Speed itself does not need a direct fix, but other attributes need to be made more important since most of the competitive LBs/CBs can play extremely well by just dumping all their SP into Speed/Agility and ignoring Strength/Tackling.
 
Mr_Victor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sturge
I agree with a post made earlier. Only make major changes in the offseason. I would then allow EVERYONE (since its beta) to completely reassign their skill points to adjust to the changes during the offseason. Once the season starts stats are locked down.

I think it would eliminate a lot of the complaining and allows everyone to see the true effects of the changes right away.


I like this idea
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Bort:

Stick to your guns a little more...let the players develop towards the game, don't "pander" the game towards the players.

On the other hand, small tweaks from season to season keep things vibrant, as new trends and player types develop from the changes.

No more significant mid-season changes though, PLEASE!

Mid-season should be for fixing bugs and exploits, and for extremely mild tweaks.

The game is great, btw
 
Dianwei32
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mr_Victor
Originally posted by sturge

I agree with a post made earlier. Only make major changes in the offseason. I would then allow EVERYONE (since its beta) to completely reassign their skill points to adjust to the changes during the offseason. Once the season starts stats are locked down.

I think it would eliminate a lot of the complaining and allows everyone to see the true effects of the changes right away.


I like this idea


No, no no no. No respecs. If you built a player based on having super high Speed/Agility and you only have 20 Strength and 30 Tackling, then you get to pay the price in getting run over until you can get Strength and Tackling up to par.

Instead of offering do-overs to people who built crappy players, Bort should give out an announcement that Strength/Tackling will be more important next season, allowing players to spend any more SP they get from leveing/boosting on Strength and Tackling. Come next season, the people who ignored the warnings will get run over by Power HBs and they will have no one to blame but themselves.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.