And most of the sack numbers you guys are pulling from your asses are from LAST YEAR. The sim is MUCH DIFFERENT this year, yet you are still complaining. Did you guys notice the difference?
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Please stop posting that DE's are to strong
Rage Kinard
offline
offline
Originally posted by berzerkerusmc
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Here is something to consider
There is a DE that got 60 sacks in 1 game last season. Now admittedly that was a huge mismatch game against low level players. However that equates to
A HB getting 6,000 yards in one game.
I don't think and entire offense has gotten over 2,000 yards in one game let alone a single HB.
A QB throwing for 13,500 yards in a single game.
Would love to hear the boards after that one.
So a sack is = to a HB getting 100 yards? WTF?
Of course it is. Check records. 20 sacks = great season for defensive player. It hasn't happened very often. 2,000 yards rushing or 4,500 yards passing is an equivalent benchmark to a 20 sack season.
RBs average over 5.0 yards per carry more than defensive players get over 20 sacks.
WRs get 100 catches per season more than defensive players get over 20 sacks.
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Here is something to consider
There is a DE that got 60 sacks in 1 game last season. Now admittedly that was a huge mismatch game against low level players. However that equates to
A HB getting 6,000 yards in one game.
I don't think and entire offense has gotten over 2,000 yards in one game let alone a single HB.
A QB throwing for 13,500 yards in a single game.
Would love to hear the boards after that one.
So a sack is = to a HB getting 100 yards? WTF?
Of course it is. Check records. 20 sacks = great season for defensive player. It hasn't happened very often. 2,000 yards rushing or 4,500 yards passing is an equivalent benchmark to a 20 sack season.
RBs average over 5.0 yards per carry more than defensive players get over 20 sacks.
WRs get 100 catches per season more than defensive players get over 20 sacks.
SteelersInsider
offline
offline
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Here is something to consider
There is a DE that got 60 sacks in 1 game last season. Now admittedly that was a huge mismatch game against low level players. However that equates to
A HB getting 6,000 yards in one game.
I don't think an entire offense has gotten over 2,000 yards in one game let alone a single HB.
A QB throwing for 13,500 yards in a single game.
Would love to hear the boards after that one.
P.S. NFL rules don't prohibit double teaming a DE. If they did, sack numbers would be MUCH MUCH higher. There were no way to keep the HB or TE in during season 5, but now there is. Sacks will be WAY WAY down just from that alone.
Here is something to consider
There is a DE that got 60 sacks in 1 game last season. Now admittedly that was a huge mismatch game against low level players. However that equates to
A HB getting 6,000 yards in one game.
I don't think an entire offense has gotten over 2,000 yards in one game let alone a single HB.
A QB throwing for 13,500 yards in a single game.
Would love to hear the boards after that one.
P.S. NFL rules don't prohibit double teaming a DE. If they did, sack numbers would be MUCH MUCH higher. There were no way to keep the HB or TE in during season 5, but now there is. Sacks will be WAY WAY down just from that alone.
Warlock
offline
offline
DE vs OT needs to be changed from the current system, because it isn't working. I've said this in many threads on the subject already. These plays need to engage (no matter the builds involved), the main problem is that once they engage the system is broken. Although the current system, where players are running around one another is also broken.
In the 8 years that I played contact football, I've never run around an OT completely untouched (or had a DE run around me completely untouched), I played both RDE and LT. I've been beat on the outside and have beaten people on the outside, but guess what... it wasn't always a sack either (in-fact it was still less than half the time). Another issue is that in order to get that huge jump on the outside edge, you're taking yourself out of the play (if it happens to be a run or the QB steps up into the pocket).
Adjustments need to be made to the swims/rips/bull-rush/etc... all of the linemen need to engage first, the player that wins the battle, breaks the block and makes the play (well has the opportunity anyways).
Pathing should be pretty standard... only changing on stunts, reads and shifts. The true difference should be what happens once the individual battles begin.
Right now, DEs are dominating. Once OTs adjust, DEs will be hurting worse than the OTs are. I don't want to see this happen, some may consider it whining or whatever, but it's actually wanting to see a fair system put into play. So that the balance doesn't swing at the smallest of adjustments.
In the 8 years that I played contact football, I've never run around an OT completely untouched (or had a DE run around me completely untouched), I played both RDE and LT. I've been beat on the outside and have beaten people on the outside, but guess what... it wasn't always a sack either (in-fact it was still less than half the time). Another issue is that in order to get that huge jump on the outside edge, you're taking yourself out of the play (if it happens to be a run or the QB steps up into the pocket).
Adjustments need to be made to the swims/rips/bull-rush/etc... all of the linemen need to engage first, the player that wins the battle, breaks the block and makes the play (well has the opportunity anyways).
Pathing should be pretty standard... only changing on stunts, reads and shifts. The true difference should be what happens once the individual battles begin.
Right now, DEs are dominating. Once OTs adjust, DEs will be hurting worse than the OTs are. I don't want to see this happen, some may consider it whining or whatever, but it's actually wanting to see a fair system put into play. So that the balance doesn't swing at the smallest of adjustments.
berzerkerusmc
offline
offline
I don't know why everyone compares this to the NFL stat wise. The talent level is not nearly as balanced as in the NFL. Hell it's not even as balanced as most of college football.
Rage Kinard
offline
offline
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Here is something to consider
There is a DE that got 60 sacks in 1 game last season. Now admittedly that was a huge mismatch game against low level players. However that equates to
A HB getting 6,000 yards in one game.
I don't think an entire offense has gotten over 2,000 yards in one game let alone a single HB.
A QB throwing for 13,500 yards in a single game.
Would love to hear the boards after that one.
P.S. NFL rules don't prohibit double teaming a DE. If they did, sack numbers would be MUCH MUCH higher. There were no way to keep the HB or TE in during season 5, but now there is. Sacks will be WAY WAY down just from that alone.
I guess you haven't seen the plays where the DEs are not only running around the OTs, but around the HBs and FBs staying in to block as well.
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Here is something to consider
There is a DE that got 60 sacks in 1 game last season. Now admittedly that was a huge mismatch game against low level players. However that equates to
A HB getting 6,000 yards in one game.
I don't think an entire offense has gotten over 2,000 yards in one game let alone a single HB.
A QB throwing for 13,500 yards in a single game.
Would love to hear the boards after that one.
P.S. NFL rules don't prohibit double teaming a DE. If they did, sack numbers would be MUCH MUCH higher. There were no way to keep the HB or TE in during season 5, but now there is. Sacks will be WAY WAY down just from that alone.
I guess you haven't seen the plays where the DEs are not only running around the OTs, but around the HBs and FBs staying in to block as well.
SteelersInsider
offline
offline
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Here is something to consider
There is a DE that got 60 sacks in 1 game last season. Now admittedly that was a huge mismatch game against low level players. However that equates to
A HB getting 6,000 yards in one game.
I don't think an entire offense has gotten over 2,000 yards in one game let alone a single HB.
A QB throwing for 13,500 yards in a single game.
Would love to hear the boards after that one.
P.S. NFL rules don't prohibit double teaming a DE. If they did, sack numbers would be MUCH MUCH higher. There were no way to keep the HB or TE in during season 5, but now there is. Sacks will be WAY WAY down just from that alone.
I guess you haven't seen the plays where the DEs are not only running around the OTs, but around the HBs and FBs staying in to block as well.
does that ever happen it real life?
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Here is something to consider
There is a DE that got 60 sacks in 1 game last season. Now admittedly that was a huge mismatch game against low level players. However that equates to
A HB getting 6,000 yards in one game.
I don't think an entire offense has gotten over 2,000 yards in one game let alone a single HB.
A QB throwing for 13,500 yards in a single game.
Would love to hear the boards after that one.
P.S. NFL rules don't prohibit double teaming a DE. If they did, sack numbers would be MUCH MUCH higher. There were no way to keep the HB or TE in during season 5, but now there is. Sacks will be WAY WAY down just from that alone.
I guess you haven't seen the plays where the DEs are not only running around the OTs, but around the HBs and FBs staying in to block as well.
does that ever happen it real life?
berzerkerusmc
offline
offline
Well just think how many more sacks there would be in real life if a QB just dropped back and hardly ever moved to buy himself extra time, or could not throw the ball away? Does the QB in the sim actually have an option to just throw the ball away?
SteelersInsider
offline
offline
Originally posted by berzerkerusmc
I don't know why everyone compares this to the NFL stat wise. The talent level is not nearly as balanced as in the NFL. Hell it's not even as balanced as most of college football.
This is the main reason. Correct. There are more "real life" football players than the small number in this game. Imagine if they cut all the worst builds and only kept enough GLB players to field ~250 teams like college football or 32 teams like the NFL. I think the games would be extremely close and there would be very realistic numbers.
The weird numbers come in when huge mismatches occur. 60-70% of the sacks last year were against CPU and gutted teams in my league. Without the CPU games, I think we would have had 3 players over 28 sacks. That's isn't bad. The RB and TE staying in to block would have limited the best DE's to under 30 sacks even if no changes were made at all in the OT/DE interaction.
I don't know why everyone compares this to the NFL stat wise. The talent level is not nearly as balanced as in the NFL. Hell it's not even as balanced as most of college football.
This is the main reason. Correct. There are more "real life" football players than the small number in this game. Imagine if they cut all the worst builds and only kept enough GLB players to field ~250 teams like college football or 32 teams like the NFL. I think the games would be extremely close and there would be very realistic numbers.
The weird numbers come in when huge mismatches occur. 60-70% of the sacks last year were against CPU and gutted teams in my league. Without the CPU games, I think we would have had 3 players over 28 sacks. That's isn't bad. The RB and TE staying in to block would have limited the best DE's to under 30 sacks even if no changes were made at all in the OT/DE interaction.
SteelersInsider
offline
offline
Originally posted by berzerkerusmc
Well just think how many more sacks there would be in real life if a QB just dropped back and hardly ever moved to buy himself extra time, or could not throw the ball away? Does the QB in the sim actually have an option to just throw the ball away?
no he doesn't. Another excellent point.
Well just think how many more sacks there would be in real life if a QB just dropped back and hardly ever moved to buy himself extra time, or could not throw the ball away? Does the QB in the sim actually have an option to just throw the ball away?
no he doesn't. Another excellent point.
Warlock
offline
offline
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Originally posted by Warlock
You're crazy with those numbers... In college, I used to run a 4.6 forty at 230 lbs and being 19 years old. I ran a 6.06 a couple of summers ago at 31 years old and 295lbs (I had the fastest time out of the OL on my semi-pro team)... the fastest player on my team ran a 4.9 forty. This includes a ton of young males in their prime and in good shape.
Very few people (in the grand scheme of life) run under a 6 sec forty. Most athletes will, but there are many who can't break 5 secs.
I don't know where you grew up or went to HS, but I went to a small HS where roughly 40% of the males in the HS played football. Not a single person on the football team ran over a 5.4. I ran a 4.8 and was too slow to play a speed position at the HS level.
I guess I've been around the military too much as well, because I don't know many men who can not run under a 5.5 40. Heck, I'm 38 6-0 220 and out of shape and I can still run under a 5.5.
I'm ex-military... soldiers run all the time. Besides, there's a good number of shitbirds in the service, so I'm sure there's more than a handful that can't run those times. I had my PT badge and have run two miles in 10:30, so yes there are many Soldiers in good shape (but I was in my prime at the time as well, 22 years old).
My point is that, on a semi-pro team full of guys who played at all different levels... the fastest time was a 4.9 forty. Ages ran from 19 to 38 as well. Good forty times are more about technique than speed anyways. Put it this way, the professional trainers that our owner hired for our combine, were impressed that I ran a 6.06, they said that it was a pretty good time for a 300lb'er. I beat the other 300lb'ers by a full half second (both of which were younger). I went against a DE who ran a 4.3 forty that year... he had 2 sacks, not 12. I also pancaked his ass when he tried to block me on an INT, so bad in-fact (he went vertical after running into me), that his own Coach told me "nice hit" after the game.
Originally posted by Warlock
You're crazy with those numbers... In college, I used to run a 4.6 forty at 230 lbs and being 19 years old. I ran a 6.06 a couple of summers ago at 31 years old and 295lbs (I had the fastest time out of the OL on my semi-pro team)... the fastest player on my team ran a 4.9 forty. This includes a ton of young males in their prime and in good shape.
Very few people (in the grand scheme of life) run under a 6 sec forty. Most athletes will, but there are many who can't break 5 secs.
I don't know where you grew up or went to HS, but I went to a small HS where roughly 40% of the males in the HS played football. Not a single person on the football team ran over a 5.4. I ran a 4.8 and was too slow to play a speed position at the HS level.
I guess I've been around the military too much as well, because I don't know many men who can not run under a 5.5 40. Heck, I'm 38 6-0 220 and out of shape and I can still run under a 5.5.
I'm ex-military... soldiers run all the time. Besides, there's a good number of shitbirds in the service, so I'm sure there's more than a handful that can't run those times. I had my PT badge and have run two miles in 10:30, so yes there are many Soldiers in good shape (but I was in my prime at the time as well, 22 years old).
My point is that, on a semi-pro team full of guys who played at all different levels... the fastest time was a 4.9 forty. Ages ran from 19 to 38 as well. Good forty times are more about technique than speed anyways. Put it this way, the professional trainers that our owner hired for our combine, were impressed that I ran a 6.06, they said that it was a pretty good time for a 300lb'er. I beat the other 300lb'ers by a full half second (both of which were younger). I went against a DE who ran a 4.3 forty that year... he had 2 sacks, not 12. I also pancaked his ass when he tried to block me on an INT, so bad in-fact (he went vertical after running into me), that his own Coach told me "nice hit" after the game.
Rage Kinard
offline
offline
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Here is something to consider
There is a DE that got 60 sacks in 1 game last season. Now admittedly that was a huge mismatch game against low level players. However that equates to
A HB getting 6,000 yards in one game.
I don't think an entire offense has gotten over 2,000 yards in one game let alone a single HB.
A QB throwing for 13,500 yards in a single game.
Would love to hear the boards after that one.
P.S. NFL rules don't prohibit double teaming a DE. If they did, sack numbers would be MUCH MUCH higher. There were no way to keep the HB or TE in during season 5, but now there is. Sacks will be WAY WAY down just from that alone.
Hasn't hurt TJ KING
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player_game_log.pl?player_id=105403
Or Julius Dee
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player_game_log.pl?player_id=123897
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Here is something to consider
There is a DE that got 60 sacks in 1 game last season. Now admittedly that was a huge mismatch game against low level players. However that equates to
A HB getting 6,000 yards in one game.
I don't think an entire offense has gotten over 2,000 yards in one game let alone a single HB.
A QB throwing for 13,500 yards in a single game.
Would love to hear the boards after that one.
P.S. NFL rules don't prohibit double teaming a DE. If they did, sack numbers would be MUCH MUCH higher. There were no way to keep the HB or TE in during season 5, but now there is. Sacks will be WAY WAY down just from that alone.
Hasn't hurt TJ KING
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player_game_log.pl?player_id=105403
Or Julius Dee
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player_game_log.pl?player_id=123897
sling
offline
offline
Originally posted by Billsman
MY LOT never has a problem with DE's, strong bull rushers or fast agile ones.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=294014
Yeah and posting a closed build like that just absolutely proves your point.
MY LOT never has a problem with DE's, strong bull rushers or fast agile ones.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=294014
Yeah and posting a closed build like that just absolutely proves your point.
Last edited Nov 15, 2008 06:37:04
Rage Kinard
offline
offline
Originally posted by Warlock
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Originally posted by Warlock
You're crazy with those numbers... In college, I used to run a 4.6 forty at 230 lbs and being 19 years old. I ran a 6.06 a couple of summers ago at 31 years old and 295lbs (I had the fastest time out of the OL on my semi-pro team)... the fastest player on my team ran a 4.9 forty. This includes a ton of young males in their prime and in good shape.
Very few people (in the grand scheme of life) run under a 6 sec forty. Most athletes will, but there are many who can't break 5 secs.
I don't know where you grew up or went to HS, but I went to a small HS where roughly 40% of the males in the HS played football. Not a single person on the football team ran over a 5.4. I ran a 4.8 and was too slow to play a speed position at the HS level.
I guess I've been around the military too much as well, because I don't know many men who can not run under a 5.5 40. Heck, I'm 38 6-0 220 and out of shape and I can still run under a 5.5.
I'm ex-military... soldiers run all the time. Besides, there's a good number of shitbirds in the service, so I'm sure there's more than a handful that can't run those times. I had my PT badge and have run two miles in 10:30, so yes there are many Soldiers in good shape (but I was in my prime at the time as well, 22 years old).
My point is that, on a semi-pro team full of guys who played at all different levels... the fastest time was a 4.9 forty. Ages ran from 19 to 38 as well. Good forty times are more about technique than speed anyways. Put it this way, the professional trainers that our owner hired for our combine, were impressed that I ran a 6.06, they said that it was a pretty good time for a 300lb'er. I beat the other 300lb'ers by a full half second (both of which were younger). I went against a DE who ran a 4.3 forty that year... he had 2 sacks, not 12. I also pancaked his ass when he tried to block me on an INT, so bad in-fact (he went vertical after running into me), that his own Coach told me "nice hit" after the game.
I guess I should have said males under 35 who are under 300 lbs and in shape. 10:30 is a great time for 2 miles. I was USMC and 20:25 was my best time for 3 miles. I probably could have gotten 2 miles under 12, but don't think I could have come close to a 10:30.
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Originally posted by Warlock
You're crazy with those numbers... In college, I used to run a 4.6 forty at 230 lbs and being 19 years old. I ran a 6.06 a couple of summers ago at 31 years old and 295lbs (I had the fastest time out of the OL on my semi-pro team)... the fastest player on my team ran a 4.9 forty. This includes a ton of young males in their prime and in good shape.
Very few people (in the grand scheme of life) run under a 6 sec forty. Most athletes will, but there are many who can't break 5 secs.
I don't know where you grew up or went to HS, but I went to a small HS where roughly 40% of the males in the HS played football. Not a single person on the football team ran over a 5.4. I ran a 4.8 and was too slow to play a speed position at the HS level.
I guess I've been around the military too much as well, because I don't know many men who can not run under a 5.5 40. Heck, I'm 38 6-0 220 and out of shape and I can still run under a 5.5.
I'm ex-military... soldiers run all the time. Besides, there's a good number of shitbirds in the service, so I'm sure there's more than a handful that can't run those times. I had my PT badge and have run two miles in 10:30, so yes there are many Soldiers in good shape (but I was in my prime at the time as well, 22 years old).
My point is that, on a semi-pro team full of guys who played at all different levels... the fastest time was a 4.9 forty. Ages ran from 19 to 38 as well. Good forty times are more about technique than speed anyways. Put it this way, the professional trainers that our owner hired for our combine, were impressed that I ran a 6.06, they said that it was a pretty good time for a 300lb'er. I beat the other 300lb'ers by a full half second (both of which were younger). I went against a DE who ran a 4.3 forty that year... he had 2 sacks, not 12. I also pancaked his ass when he tried to block me on an INT, so bad in-fact (he went vertical after running into me), that his own Coach told me "nice hit" after the game.
I guess I should have said males under 35 who are under 300 lbs and in shape. 10:30 is a great time for 2 miles. I was USMC and 20:25 was my best time for 3 miles. I probably could have gotten 2 miles under 12, but don't think I could have come close to a 10:30.
Rage Kinard
offline
offline
All I can say is if you think you have the OTs that can stop any DE ask Bort to match them up against Julius Dee and TJ King in testing and post results of how many hurries and/or sacks the DEs got on 30 pass plays.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























